It was such a pleasure working with Bake My Day for our wedding cake! Our wedding was originally set to take place on 4/25/20 however with that being in the thick of Covid we were forced to postpone until May 15th, 2021. Bake My Day was so understanding and quick to change our date with no fuss! I came in with a unique vision for our cake and they executed it perfectly! On top of wonderful service, the cake flavors were all so delicious and the best part is you can taste them all without an appointment and even gave enough samples for our kids! We had rave reviews from our guests on the cake both taste and looks! 10 out of 10 would recommend Bake My Day!

We had MANY people tell us our wedding cupcakes were the best they've had! The ladies working there are so friendly and really helped pull my cake design together!

Hiring Bake My Day was one of the best decisions we made during the wedding planning process. First, we were told we could just stop in to sample some of their flavors - we didn't have to make an appointment. Then they brought out FULL SIZE cupcakes for us to try - the flavors were heavenly, especially the Amaretto! We ended up picking Amaretto, Lemon, Carrot, Vanilla, S'mores and Red Velvet. The staff were very easy to work with! I worked with one of the owners Katie the most and she was so sweet! I had a very particular thing I wanted with a small 2-tier cake and she made it happen. The week before the wedding I just had to drop off my cake topper and platter for the cake and they did the rest! The cake and cupcakes were so delicious! And everyone was raving about them! I would hire them again in a heartbeat!!

Katie at Bake My Day was wonderful from the start. She listened to my requests and accepted inspiration from photos that I showed her. I can’t tell you the amount of people who said “this is the best cake I’ve ever had.” The flavor and design were top notch! Highly highly recommended for weddings, birthdays, parties, or just because it’s Tuesday! :)

Bake my day was so great to work with! They allowed us to sample all of the flavors, which were all delicious! They were also very reasonably priced!

We looked at a few bakeries in the area. One actually wanted us to pay for a tasting. At Bake My Day, they were friendly the second we walked in the door. They let us sample each flavor and encouraged more samples if we wanted. Their vanilla cake was amazing! I was surprised by how delicious a simple vanilla cake could be.

I brought in two photos, one of a three tiered cake and one from my grandmother's wedding cake. They did an amazing job of combining the two and making them in our wedding colors. They matched the buttercream frosting to our bridesmaid dresses and I brought in the ribbon and cake topper and our florist delivered the flowers right to the bakery.

They have so many flavors and they are all delicious!

They are the most affordable in Green Bay and were so great to work with.

We got so many compliments on how good the cake was and where we got the cake.

Worth every penny!

We were very pleased with how our cake turned out. We asked for a 3 tier square cake with butter cream frosting. However, we wanted the frosting to be smooth so that it had a fondant look. I dropped off ribbon and flowers to be placed on the cake and told them to place them how they'd like. They did a fantastic job and I got so many compliments on how great our cake looked.

Our cake was made to serve 225 people and it only cost us a grand total of $370 (there was a $50 fee added on originally that you got back when you brought back the cake board). In addition to the 3 tier cake, we had a sheet cake in the back.

The one thing I loved about their cakes was the different flavors you could have. Every wedding I've gone to has had lemon poppyseed, white, chocolate, etc. We ended up choosing orange, cherry, and amaretto. Every single flavor was absolutely awesome, specifically the cherry. I would highly recommend it!

This cake was absolutely to die for! Great taste. Great service. Joan was so easy to work with and very helpful when deciding how big of a cake to get based upon the guest list! Reasonable prices for such a delicious product! Thank you!

THE MOST DELICIOUS, MOIST, YUMMY CAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED. THE ICING WAS SMOOTH AS SILK.