About
Make your next event AMAZING with Amazing Cakes of Indy. We pride ourselves in making beautiful & great tasting cakes. We specialize in spectacular Wedding & Custom Cakes, as well as Birthdays, Baby Showers etc. You can also stop in and get some of your favorite flavored Cupcakes Available Daily. Check out our Menu For the latest Flavors & Specials.
Vendors you may like
See other vendors that are popular with couples right now
Reviews of Amazing Cakes of Indy
4.1 out of 5 rating
4.1
Good
15 reviews
Recommended by 82% of couples
Lauren Sent on 10/27/2014
5 out of 5 rating
Our cake was not only beautiful, but it was so scrumptious!!! We can't wait to have more on our anniversary (or most likely before since it is so good!)! :)
User1780127 Sent on 08/25/2014
5 out of 5 rating
Wonderful! Millie met us for a cake tasting and brought out 8 different flavors of cake for us to try. All of them were delicious but we picked a lemon cake with strawberry filling. Great price and great service
Lisa Sent on 07/23/2013
5 out of 5 rating
Millie is an artist and the flavor is insane! I tried her tequila rose cake at the Scottish Rite Cathedral Bridal Show and forgot which vendor she was. My bridesmaids called around to every cake vendor for a month until they found the only one that makes tequila rose. This cake is beyond any flavor you would think.
In the end we had Tequila Rose, Rum, Tiramisu and White Chocolate with raspberry filling. All of them were delicious and we could not say which was the best. She delivered all the way to Anderson for minimal cost. Worth every penny to have her do your cake!
In the end we had Tequila Rose, Rum, Tiramisu and White Chocolate with raspberry filling. All of them were delicious and we could not say which was the best. She delivered all the way to Anderson for minimal cost. Worth every penny to have her do your cake!
Mandi Sent on 06/30/2009
5 out of 5 rating
Amazing Cakes did a great job on our wedding cakes. We wanted a little bit of a non traditional style without going to the cost of fondant and they did a great job of turning our vision into reality. Not to mention all the compliments we got on how delicious the cake was! I can't wait to try it again on our anniversary!!
Christina Sent on 09/06/2008
5 out of 5 rating
The cake was BEAUTIFUL!!! It was 4 layers and had different cakes on each layer. Had different designs and topped with real red rose petals. Totally pulled off my dream cake!! I loved it, it was delicious and everyone else loved it too!!!
Becca Sent on 02/20/2008
5 out of 5 rating
My sister used Millie's cake for her wedding and had a wonderful experience, so I used her and was just as satisfied. Her cake is wonderful (especially the white chocolate flavor) and she is very sweet. She is willing to work with your specific needs, I simply drew what I wanted on a sheet of paper and she created the perfect cake for me! It was spectacular, really. I would highly recommend her to anyone!
Rachel Sent on 10/13/2012
4.8 out of 5 rating
I first got introduced to Millie's amazing cakes many years ago when I came across her booth at a bridal show I was working at. I sampled her chocolate cake with mint filling and white icing and knew then and there that would be my wedding cake! Three years later when I introduced my fiance to the delicious cake he was sold as well. We decided to go with a small 6inch round cake for us to cut into and then a variety of cupcakes for the guests, of course our cake and one of the cupcake options was the chocolate cake with mint filling and white icing. Millie accommodating two additional tastings for us, as there were so many wonderful choices it took me awhile to decide our two other cupcake flavors. I always wanted to have more unique set up with the cupcakes vs. the traditional cupcake tower but due to time constraints we went with one of their towers at the last minute. They used a beautiful square brass tower that just added to the elegance of our reception. I'm sure we'll be getting more cakes from Millie down the road for future special events!
Krystal Sent on 09/27/2010
4.8 out of 5 rating
Amazing Cakes of Indy did a great job on my wedding cake. I had to change my cake half way through and they were very easy to work with. My cake looked great at the wedding and everyone raved on how delicious it was. My only concern was the price. It was a little more expensive for what I thought I was getting. However, everything turned out great. I would definitely recommend them to anyone.
Tiffanie Sent on 04/17/2008
4.8 out of 5 rating
We received a cake to feed 200 people for $450. What a great deal! The cake was delicious & still great after a year (the top layer). They had a great selection of designs or they could make whatever your imagination had dreamed up! Loved them!
Marianna Sent on 09/18/2008
4.5 out of 5 rating
They were just amazing!!!!! They let me design the cake and they were very accommodating. Just make sure you have a big enough box to take the top part of the cake at home with you!!!!!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
15
Explore other vendors in your area
Find the most recommended vendors and Couples' Choice Award winners.
See vendors