Yummy Goodness Catering Co. Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
Featured
![Leesa]()
Leesa Sent on 06/19/2024Yummy Goodness is exactly right!
Yummy Goodness Catering were such pros, and we are so happy we chose them to cater our daughter’s wedding day. From the very beginning, they made the whole experience so easy, working with my daughter and her fiancé to create a custom menu of their favorite foods. They were so helpful throughout the planning process and were so patient with us when we kept changing up the menu! And most importantly the food was just exceptional, so delicious we even had guests making a point to let us know. We highly recommend them to anyone looking for a top-notch catering company for their wedding! -
![David]()
David Sent on 09/23/2025Cocktail-Style Wedding Feast
Our wedding day was perfect, and Yummy Goodness Catering played an enormous part in that success. Serving more than 150 guests at an outdoor wedding with only rented ovens to work with and food stations open for a full two hours is no easy feat, yet everything ran seamlessly. Our guests are still raving about the quality of the food, the friendliness of the staff, and the beauty of the setup.
The food displays were jaw-dropping. The tables, decorated with risers, fresh herbs, fruit, and plants, looked like something out of a magazine. And the food tasted equally spectacular. Each dish seemed to have its own fan club, but some stand outs were the crispy endive, tomato pie bites, beef tenderloin crostini, bacon-wrapped shrimp, and entire mezze spread. The giant seafood paella, meanwhile, was a showstopper, a dish that not only tasted incredible but looked like a centerpiece.
The attention to detail elevated everything. Lavender, mint, and rosemary on the tables were not only beautiful but worked as natural bug repellents, which made all the difference for an outdoor summer wedding. The team also kept tables spotless throughout the evening, and we never once noticed pests being an issue.
The bar was equally impressive. On a summer evening, they kept drinks cold and ice plentiful. The bar itself was beautifully set up, the bartenders were quick and engaging, and we hardly ever saw a line. The addition of the fresh juicer was a nice touch, and our guests who discovered the fresh-squeezed orange crushes are still talking about them.
Most importantly, we always felt like everything was under control. Being able to hand over all food and drink responsibilities and simply enjoy our day was one of the greatest gifts. We cannot thank Yummy Goodness Catering enough and will think of them first for every future celebration. -
-
![Sophie]()
Sophie Sent on 06/19/2024BEST wedding food ever
Yummy goodness is amazing to work with. From the food tasting to the actual wedding day, I loved it. We even changed a part of the menu a month or so before the wedding and they were super flexible and accommodating. Our menu was brisket and chicken and waffles, with potato wedges, salad, and more. It was so good. They also sent us home with a ton of leftovers which we enjoyed the entire week after. They took amazing care of us and I will forever reccomend them to friends and family. -
![Emily]()
Emily Sent on 06/18/2023Yummy Greatness
I recommend Yummy Goodness for EVERYTHING. Every event, party, random Tuesday evening. Lori and chef Kellie and all of the staff were absolutely wonderful. From the first contact all the way through the day-of, Lori was extremely kind, patient and responsive. The tasting was fantastic. We were supposed to have four people there, but life happens, so it wound up being only my mom and me. We ate well, and then Lori brought out trays for us to take the leftovers home to those who couldn't make it. We all ate well for days. Lori was helpful in taking care of all the little changes and additions to the menu. She was great in advising about rentals for plates, glassware, silverware and other necessities.
We also used them for our bar/alcohol service. It was so nice to have them insured and ABC licensed. They worked with us on signature drinks for the cocktail hour and with the beer selection we wanted.
Lori and Rhonda from Hunt Club Farm worked well together and met on their own to decide the layouts and locations for food, bar and staging.
I wish I could go back and attend as a guest. As the bride, I didn't get to partake in the cocktail hour because we were taking pictures. The dinner was wonderful.
The one suggestion I would make would be to cut the chicken breasts in the Cordon Bleu in half or thirds. They were GIGANTIC! Usually that would be fantastic, but for a buffet, it was a little unwieldy. It would also be nice to have a mini cocktail snack table for the wedding party at the main photograph site. We didn't get to partake in any of the cocktail snacks except when the photographer brought some of the candied bacon over for tasting. It would be a nice touch and easy to put together. -
-
![Kaila]()
Kaila Sent on 10/08/2022The name says it all!
The Yummy Goodness Catering literally has the perfect name because it is a whole lot of Yummy Goodness but they are so much more than their food. My husband and I got married last week to the day in the middle of a nor'easter. Leading up to the day I think everyone was a little nervous about the weather and if the wedding was going to be able to take place. Yummy Goodness reached out to me to check in and make sure that I was doing okay, they reassured me that inside or out the day would be beautiful and they would be there to feed our guests. Thankfully the weather was perfect and our guests got to enjoy the most amazing food we have eaten outside together as planned. We went with the Tuscan Wedding menu with some changes to fit our needs and I can't recommend it enough! Our guests are still talking about it and we have enjoyed leftovers every day this week! -
Emily Sent on 10/27/2021
DELICIOUS food, great service!
This is the best wedding food I've ever had.... and my guests are still raving about it! We hired Yummy Goodness for our small, intimate beach wedding with 25 people total. We had them drop off the food and served ourselves, buffet-style.
They were incredible to work with throughout the whole process. We had an initial phone call with them before we hired them to discuss our ideas, have our questions answered, and get their ideas/professional opinions. They were so incredibly nice, had great suggestions, and it all was for a reasonable price. They checked in with us before the wedding, and were able to adjust our menu and headcount a few weeks before.
The food was absolutely delicious, and there was plenty of food for everyone - even some leftovers. I HIGHLY recommend them to anyone who wants their guests to be talking about their food months after the wedding! :) -
-
![Alexis]()
Alexis Sent on 01/02/2020Delicious!
People raved about the food well after the wedding!Yummy Goodness Catering Co.'s reply:
Thank you so much! We really enjoyed meeting you and making your day special! Our staff works hard to make sure all of our couples have the wedding they have always dreamed of! -Chef Kelly -
![Kristin]()
Kristin Sent on 10/11/2019Food will change your life!
Truly an amazing staff, food was out of this world, could not have been luckier with our selection of caterer's! #blessed #nomnom -
Jamie Sent on 08/13/2019
Perfect food, perfect service!
I want to host another event just so I can hire Yummy Goodness again!!
Kelly, Lori, and the whole crew made our rehearsal dinner/Korean wedding ceremony an absolutely perfect event! The team was incredibly professional, organized, and delightfully creative from the planning process all the way through the event. My husband and I wanted to have a mix of American and Korean food, and Kelly and her team came up with a delicious and unique menu including kimchi chicken and waffles, fried chicken baos, family style crispy pork belly, grilled short rib lettuce wraps, and an ice cream sundae bar — plus tons more, no one went hungry! All of our guests absolutely loved the food and are still talking about it!
On top of all of this, the best part about Yummy Goodness is their super fun and attentive staff that made sure my husband and I were happy and all of our guests had a wonderful time. It definitely shows through their impeccable work that they enjoy working together! Would definitely recommend for your next event. -
-
![Nancy]()
Nancy Sent on 11/07/2018Outstanding caterer
From start to finish, outstanding, professional service. The food was incredible and the staff was very responsive to our needs. Our guests raved about the food and I would recommend Yummy Goodness for any of your catering needs. -
![Karen]()
Karen Sent on 04/10/2017Yummy Goodness did an outstanding job for our Sandbridge wedding in March. Staff were attentive to our guests and the food was delicious! Guests have been raving about the food and said it is the best they have had at a wedding. The presentation was like out of a magazine. Lori was so helpful when deciding on food selection for our special day. The Brisket is a must! -
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 05/09/2023Wonderful Service with delicious food
I loved the professionalism and dedication Yummy Goodness portrayed during my beach wedding. The food, specifically the flank steak, guests were raving about to me. I also appreciate the staff cleaning up and packing away our food for us. The bartender also was super nice and funny! He did a great job with keeping the drinks flowing and providing a good time.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?