Wild Flour NYC Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Colin]()
Colin Sent on 06/28/2025You MUST Book Gina!!
We loved working with Gina for our wedding cake! From the moment we stepped foot into Wild Flour for our tasting she made us feel like we were at home. She would not rest to make sure we tried every option that we wanted to find not just one but three perfect cake options that captured our day. Our wedding cake was not only moist and delicious but truly BEAUTIFUL!! Gina was able to make some nut free and gluten free cake slices for family members with allergies. We cannot thank you enough Gina for making our day so sweet!! -
![Gary]()
Gary Sent on 05/13/2025Best. Wedding. Cake. Ever.
We loved working with Gina at Wild Flour -- the tasting was fun and informative, the process was very easy, the cake turned out GORGEOUS, and most importantly, it was really really really tasty. Gina converted me from a wedding cake skeptic to a wedding cake BELIEVER. People were all abuzz about it, and even asking for Wild Flour's contact so they could get the same exact cake made. We did a combo of her champagne vanilla and champagne dark chocolate, then an assortment of other tasty goodies. The cake was definitely one of the highlights of our wedding, and we're so grateful Gina sent our guests off so sweetly. -
-
![Alejandro]()
Alejandro Sent on 10/17/2024The best cake
We are in absolute BLISS. That was the wedding of our dreams. We are so thankful to you for your attention to detail and incredible creation of the cake. It was DELICIOUS and we have so much in our house. The guests were RAVING about it. And it was GORGEOUSSSS -
![Ellie]()
Ellie Sent on 12/05/2023Dream cake!!
Gina is absolutely incredible! I loved her sunny personality and creativity when I first met her during the tasting (yum!) but she truly wowed me when I saw the actual result of our planning. When the wait staff brought in the cake, I literally gasped because it was everything I dreamed of!! The design, the positioning of our toppers, the golden accent—everything was simply perfect! And needless to say, it tasted sooooo good!! If you’re still choosing a baker, don’t even hesitate—Wildflour is your go-to! Thank you so much, Gina, for making our special day even more special! ♥️ -
-
![Jess & Doug Guerra]()
Jessica Sent on 06/23/2022Vanilla champagne and sparkling rosé cake wedding cake perfection
The wedding cake that Gina at Wild Flour NYC made for our May 13th wedding at MyMoon was by far the best wedding cake I have ever had in my life -- and I am not just saying that because it was our wedding! From our first tasting, I knew that Gina was a true cake visionary. She made us a vanilla champagne and sparkling rosé cake with lemon buttercream, coated with a thin layer of honey lavender buttercream on the outside (naked cake style). Perfection. My husband and I were delighted to have some extra cake to take home after the wedding, and we've been treating ourselves to slices on special occasions since the wedding. Thank you so much Gina, especially for being so flexible and compassionate after we had to reschedule the wedding not once, but three times, due to COVID! -
-
Desiree Sent on 01/26/2022
So good! Recommend recommend recommend
Gina and her team at Wild Flour NYC were wonderful! Prices were reasonable and the service and especially the product were EXCELLENT! Planning the wedding cross-country, Gina accommodated us the week of our wedding for a cake tasting. The cake tasting was short and sweet (just how we liked it) and though she guided us with what flavors usually go with what, the cake and fillings spoke for themselves! We chose a 3 tier alternating layers of dark chocolate champagne and vanilla champagne cake with salted bourbon cream in between and a naked cream cheese finish. SO DELICIOUS!!! Moist and flavorful! The cake was perfect for our wedding as they also nailed the look we wanted! Cake was beautifully made with the right amount of “naked” and accented with our florist flowers.
So excited for their brick and mortar store! Can’t wait to taste their cakes again! Thank you again Wild Flour NYC!!! -
-
![Nicole]()
Nicole Sent on 12/22/2021Amazing experience!
We were so pleased with the service provided to us by Gina and the beautiful cake that was put together for us! Highly recommend booking Wild Flour for your wedding. Gina was very helpful, kind, responsive, and extremely talented. Thank you for giving us a very tasty cake on our wedding day! -
![Mel]()
Mel L. Sent on 10/05/2021Delicious and gorgeous
The cake was phenomenal, gorgeous and tasty and everyone raved about the flavor combination. Gina patiently heard all my crazy and sometimes contradicting ideas and made them into a beautiful work of art. she was so kind, so thoughtful and attentive I cannot gush enough about the process and the outcome. The mini desserts were a complete hit, we only had 5 left which is amazing since we budgeted for 4 desserts plus cake per person. Everyone raved about the flavors, the variety and that they couldn't stop coming back for more. The 5 we had left over we devoured with champagne the next morning and will be dreaming about them for years to come. -
![Sam]()
Sam S. Sent on 05/18/2020An incredibly delicious experience!
Gina (The Owner) is an absolutely amazing baker. I have ordered several cakes from her and they were all deliciously flawless! She has so many different tasty options to choose from and the cakes are gorgeous. She had the cakes ready on time and her prices were incredibly reasonable.
Thank you so much for the cakes Gina! Will be buying more soon! -
![Loren]()
Loren Sent on 01/12/2020A unique, beautiful cake that tastes amazing!!
When we walked in for our tasting with Wild Flour, we knew pretty much right away this was going to be the perfect cake for us. Their flavors were so creative and absolutely delicious! And we loved that we were able to infuse some champagne and bourbon into our cake, keeping the party going at dessert time. Then there was the look! We absolutely loved the design of our cake. The naked cake frosting was the right style we were going for and it matched the look of our wedding perfectly. It really felt like a work of art, I almost didn’t want to cut into it! -
Katherine Sent on 09/21/2019
Delicious Cake!!
Our wedding cake was beautiful AND delicious — a combination that isn’t always easy to find but was very important to us.
The team at Wild Flour was easy and fun to work with, and we would recommend them over and over again.
Thank you, thank you!! -
-
![Elizabeth]()
Elizabeth Sent on 04/27/2019Delicious and beautiful
This cake was worth every penny. Our guests are still raving about this cake. We went with vanilla champagne and sparkling rosé cake with honey lavender buttercream. Our guests had not tasted anything like it. We are so happy! We also had a lot of fun at our tasting! Thank you so much Wild Flour!! Liz and Kevin -
-
![Natalie]()
Natalie Sent on 02/27/2019I didn't want to eat anything, it all looked so good (but tasted better!)
Yum! The whole experience with wild flour, from their responsiveness when we reached out to them with less than a month before our wedding, to the delicious tasting experience, down to their promptness, calmness, and professionalism when we accidentally forgot cupcakes were ordered as well, was amazing. The presentation was beautiful and it all tasted delicious with such fantastic flavors that all went so well together. Everyone loved it all so much we only left with 5 leftover cupcakes (which, we've since eaten :) ). -
![vannessa]()
Vannessa Sent on 11/27/2018Delicious and Beautiful Wedding Cake!!!
A beautiful and delicious cake, what else can I say? We really enjoyed the entire process with them, we had a hard decision choosing what cake and icing because they where all so darn good!! Pick them if you want to have a wedding cake that isn't only just beautiful on the outside, but tastes amazing as well! -
Lisa Sent on 12/17/2017The cake was absolutely delicious! We really enjoyed working with Kristina- she was super responsive and had a lot of great suggestions for flavors and general planning for the dessert buffet we envisioned. Highly recommend!!
-
-
![Cassandra]()
Cassandra Sent on 07/23/2023Delicious and well-designed cake
Gina made a delicious and beautiful cake for our wedding! The tasting experience was very fun. You get to go in and try a few cakes and a few fillings / frosting so that you can piece together a fully custom wedding cake. She perfectly implemented our request for an Art Deco design. The cake not only looked great but also tasted amazing. We loved working with Wild Flour and would recommend it to anyone looking for a delicious cake for an NYC wedding. -
![Julie]()
Julie Sent on 07/25/2022Omfg best cake ever
Seriously. First off, Gina is awesome. We had so much fun meeting her and doing our cake tasting. I think "fun" is a really key word here, because she allows (and encourages) you to customize your cake pretty much however you want. Our final product was a three-tiered cake, and each tier had alternating layers of Funfetti and Sparkling Rosé cake, separated by cream cheese and almond-flavored frosting. It looked gorgeous and tasted SO good. (Of course, if you want to stick with something more traditional, that's 100% doable as well!) Multiple people told me it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had. There was not a single crumb left by the end of the night. We did order on the conservative side (in the name of not wasting food), but also, several people told me that they went back for seconds. On the admin side of things, I really appreciated that we were able to adjust the size (and thus, price) of the cake a week prior to the wedding because it's hard to have certainty around guest count when you order the cake (for us, about 9 months in advance). In summary: Five stars for the process, and five stars for the final product! -
Jo-Ann Sent on 10/29/2021
Beautiful AND absolutely delicious wedding cake!
Before meeting Gina my now-husband was a pie person. I asked him if he would try out a tasting with Gina, and enough said he is now a cake person. Not only that, he’s now developed a discerning palate for cake, because he tried the best of the best!
Gina was super fun to work with, as she loves making cake dreams come true. I wanted fresh flowers and touches of gold and Gina made us a beautiful cake, it was exactly what we wanted. Now to the good part, not only was the cake beautiful it was also incredibly delicious. She layered for us about six different cake flavors and seven different butter creams in a three tier cake. With anyone else this would have seem weird but with Gina’s expertise and sunny disposition, it all came together spectacularly. She has such scrumptious cake and buttercream flavors we couldn't quite have just one!
We are looking forward to being repeat customers! -
-
![Librabride1013]()
Sheelyn Sent on 09/19/2018Wonderful working with the team.. we opted to do a dessert bar with mini cake shooters, cake balls, mini cupcakes and a 6 inch for us. The flavor choices are so unique and delicious. The tasting had me SOLD !!.. Happy we chose Wild Flour as our vendor for our big day. -
![Brekke]()
Brekke Sent on 06/08/2022Delicious and beautiful cake
The team at Wild Flour NYC really goes above and beyond to help you design your dream cake! The mix and match style of cake and buttercream + decor was perfect for dialing in exactly what we wanted at a price that worked for us. Wild Flour was professional and worked seamlessly with our venue and vendors to get our cake set up on the day of without us having to lift a finger. I'm looking for another reason to order more cake soon! -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?