The Inn at Millrace Pond Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
Featured
Mike Sent on 11/16/2022The Frungillos are simply the best!
I cannot put into words what the Frungillo family did for us for our wedding day. We booked the Inn at Millrace Pond when the barn house was still a concrete slab - just to show the trust we have in them. From the walkthrough and planning process with Michelle and Robert, to the day of with Gerry and Linda, everything was spectacular. Upon entering, our guests were greeting with espresso martini or champagne shooters which were delicious. Not only that, our guests could not stop raving about the food. The fresh mozz station was a hit, and our pasta and Tuscan stations were top notch. To top it all off, everyone’s filet (their top dish) was cooked to perfection. Some people even ate their table’s leftovers it was that good! We even had an afterparty at the gristmill… and you already know by this point how that went. All of our guests stayed at the venue in the multiple rooms they have to offer and we were able to have a brunch the next day to recap all the memories from the night before. I wouldn’t have booked my wedding with anyone else but the Frungillo’s. They’re not just your friends, they’re family. Thank you thank you!! -
-
![Grace]()
Grace Sent on 06/29/2026Truly the best experience
With all of the items that go into planning a wedding, it can get really overwhelming. For my now husband and I, we really just were really looking forward to getting married and found wedding planning a bit overwhelming, while still , having some details we really cared about. The Millrace staff and Frungillo hospitality did an amazing job with connecting with us, valuing what was important to us, and making the experience seamless. Consistent communication with Mary-Beth (who was immensely helpful) while planning always helped to put my mind at ease and supported us in all planning decisions. Tricia (the inn keeper) and our Maitre D, Keri, were truly so amazing to work with. They always made sure we were comfortable and truly made ours and our guests’ stay so incredible. Both Tricia and Keri are the most kind, hospitable, and helpful people, and really working with them was the cherry on top to make our day so perfect. We cannot say enough amazing things about them. If you’re thinking about booking Millrace, don’t think twice!! -
-
![Ryan]()
Ryan Sent on 07/24/2025Dream Come True
We got married about 2 months ago...here's how it went.
From the moment we stepped on to the grounds of The Inn at Millrace Pond, we knew it was something special. It wasn't just the charm of the property- though historic, beautiful maintained grounds, and vintage, cottage-core worth inn rooms definitely set the scene - it was the people who made this venue and experience incredible!
Maria was the first person we met, when I reached out online she got back to me in less than 24hrs to do a tour! She truly made us feel seen, welcomed and excited! She painted the vision of our day so effortlessly, and it only got better from there! Michelle was an absolute gem throughout the entire planning process. She responded to every email and question asked (there were a lot), and handled every little change with patience, clarity and kindness. Having her support made the planning process smooth and stress free.
And then there's Tracey- our Maître D and wedding day superhero. Tracey and her team went above and beyond to ensure every detail was perfect! Starting a week before thee wedding she called me and we had an hour and a half long chat and she asked questions i didn't even think about, sent me pictures and ideas for ceremony placement, inside rain placement, etc. She was everywhere at once, always one step ahead, and truly made our day a dream come true! We felt so cared for and supported - we didn't have to work about a thing, and that peace of mind is priceless on your wedding day. She took so many behind the scenes videos and pictures for me, I view them to this very day!
And let's talk about the food. Weeks later our guests are still raving about it! Every dish was delicious, beautifully presented, and served with care. The bartenders were fantastic - friendly, fun, and they made amazing drinks all night long!
The entire experience at the Inn at Millrace Pond was filled with warmth, charm, and exceptional service. It felt personal, magical, and so "us." If you're looking for a venue that combines beauty and character, and a team that truly cares- this is it. -
-
![Lauren]()
Lauren Sent on 06/02/2025The Day of My Dreams
I cannot say enough good things about the Inn at Millrace Pond! From the moment we booked until the final send-off, everything was flawless. The venue itself is stunning—charming, rustic, and romantic in all the right ways—but what truly made our day unforgettable was the incredible team behind it.
Tracey and her assistant Lia were absolutely amazing. Their professionalism, kindness, and attention to detail went above and beyond anything I could have imagined. They were always one step ahead, making sure every moment of our day ran smoothly. I felt so supported and calm knowing they were by my side. I am truly beyond lucky to have had them there with me on such an important day.
If you're considering the Inn at Millrace Pond for your wedding, don't hesitate. It was the best decision we made, and I would choose it again in a heartbeat. -
-
![Jen]()
Jen Sent on 05/25/2025Highly Recommend
We had the perfect wedding day at The Inn At Millrace Pond! Our guests loved the gorgeous grounds throughout and are still talking about how amazing the food was! Our friends and family loved having their room onsite after the wedding reception. The staff was extremely helpful and made sure every last detail was in place so we could just enjoy getting married. We would definitely recommend this venue! -
Taylor Sent on 04/22/2025
Perfect Wedding Setting
My wedding was at the Inn on 4/19/25. Having our wedding at the Inn was above and beyond all my expectations. It is clear the property is beautiful! We loved how unique the setting is and the history. There are not many properties that offer you multiple building locations for your day plus the ability to stay onsite with around 40 guests! What really blew me away was the entire staff and how good the food is! Tracey was our Maitre De, wow from the calls prior to the wedding to the day of I knew I was in such good hands. Tracey was like having another friend there the day of making sure me and my family were taken care of and making everything happen, I literally did not have to worry about a thing. I cannot express my gratitude to have wonderful this team is. Tracey had a captain Lia with her all day who was so kind and also was there for anything we needed, checking in all throughout the day! When I tell you the food is so good, I have never been to a wedding where so many guests were raving about cocktail hour AND the dinner meals. We were blown away at our tasting and the day of at how good everything was. Tricia the inn keeper, is so lovely. She was so helpful working with us and our guests. Truly a world class staff all around. If you are looking for a charming, boho, rustic venue. This is it, you will not be disappointed. -
-
Elise Sent on 04/18/2025
August 2024 wedding
Had the most wonderful experience with Inn at Millrace last August at our wedding. Cannot say enough about the service and care and attention to detail everyone gave us. Very responsive, really helped us stay on top of planning everything and we really felt like they put in the work to help make our day so special. Tracey is the absolute best at what she does! Kept everything running smoothly, got everyone where they needed to be, an hour out when we had a bit of a rain scare with an outdoor ceremony planned she walked us through all the possible options so we could make the best decision (ended up chancing it and rain held off!). She checked in on us enough without being overbearing, helped our very large bridal party from morning/getting ready time until the very end. She also took a bunch of pictures herself on her phone, so in addition to our professional photography we also have hundreds of additional photos to look back on! We ended up forgetting a bunch of stuff like decor and our guest book and she kept everything safe in her own home until we were able to drive out and get it!! Maria who helped us book the venue was also so helpful, listened to what we were looking for and laid out everything very clearly for us. Food was really good, especially cocktail hour!! Outdoor space was beautiful and big and very wooded, felt like we were in the middle of a forest. Cocktail area and reception room were beautiful and the setup was nice, being attached but still separate. The millrace team helped make a stressful planning process that much less so and we highly recommend! -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 03/23/2025Beautiful venue for a Winter Wedding
We got married at the Inn at Millrace Pond in February 2025. It was the best wedding weekend we could ask for! The grounds are beautiful and historical. The bridal suite and inn rooms were great. It was so nice to stay on property with friends and family. The reception barn was the perfect set up for our 115 guests. The Tavern on property was a great atmosphere for our after party.
Michelle was helpful through out the planning process. Tracey was my maitre’d. She was incredible. She spent time talking with my husband and I on the phone and through text the week prior to our wedding. She had great advice and was so helpful. Everything ran smoothly because of her and our bridal attendant, Lia. Tracey also took photos and videos throughout the night that captured so many great moments.
Even though we didn’t get a chance to eat, our guests shared that the food was delicious. We had the Millrace salad, rigatoni vodka pasta, and a choice of filet mignon, salmon, caprese chicken and vegetarian option. It was plated beautifully. It came out hot, was a good portion size, and did not taste mass made. Everyone liked their meal options. I heard the most compliments about the filet mignon.
I couldn’t be happier with our decision to have our wedding at the Inn at Millrace Pond. It was a dream come true. -
-
![Krystal]()
Krystal Sent on 11/13/2024Magical Wedding!
I absolutely adore this wedding venue—the staff, the grounds, the food! We literally just had to show up, and everything else was taken care of. Tracey made sure everything ran smoothly, and my guests still rave about how this was the best wedding they'd been to. The food was amazing, and I just appreciate the rustic historical charm that this venue brings. Your VIP guest can even stay on the premises with you. It's like having your own private small town for the night. I wish I could relive this moment! -
![Brenna]()
Brenna Sent on 10/15/2024A Dream Wedding at the Inn
We recently celebrated our wedding at The Inn at Millrace Pond, and it truly was the wedding of our dreams. From start to finish, the experience was nothing short of magical. The stunning fall scenery created the most beautiful backdrop for our special day—the vibrant colors of the leaves, the crisp autumn air, and the rustic charm of the inn made everything picture-perfect.
What really set the experience apart was the incredible staff. Every single person we worked with was professional, efficient, and above all, kind. They went above and beyond to make sure every detail was exactly how we envisioned it. Their attention to detail was impeccable, and they shared our vision every step of the way, helping to bring it to life flawlessly.
We can’t say enough about Michelle, the director of planning, who was amazing from the very first meeting until our wedding day. She was an absolute joy to work with, guiding us through the entire process with expertise and patience. Michelle made sure our every wish was heard, and her dedication to making our day perfect was evident in every interaction. She truly became an integral part of our journey and ensured everything went off without a hitch.
The farm-to-table food was absolutely outstanding! From the abundance of delicious samples during the cocktail hour to the exquisite meals served at dinner, each bite was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Our guests are still raving about the quality and variety. The seamless organization of the food stations, both indoors and outdoors, was expertly handled by Tracey, the on-site coordinator. She ensured the flow of the event was smooth and that every guest had access to all the amazing culinary offerings. It was truly a feast to remember.
A special shoutout also goes to our day-of coordinator, Tracey, whose professionalism and warm personality truly made our day even more special. Not only was she on top of every aspect of the event, but she also ensured that we were comfortable and taken care of throughout the day. She was attentive to our needs, and even made sure to bring us drinks and appetizers during cocktail hour so we wouldn’t miss out on enjoying a bite while greeting our guests.
Thanks to the team at The Inn at Millrace Pond, we were able to relax and truly enjoy our day, knowing that everything was taken care of. We are beyond happy with how everything turned out—it was more than we could have ever hoped for. If you’re looking for a wedding venue where you’ll be supported by an amazing staff and surrounded by breathtaking scenery, this is the place for you!
Thank you, Inn at Millrace Pond, for making our wedding day unforgettable!
With Love and Gratitude,
Brenna & Danny -
-
![Samantha]()
Samantha Sent on 04/30/2024Dream Wedding!!!
Our wedding reception on April 13th 2024 at The Inn at Millrace Pond was an absolute dream come true, and we owe it all to everyone at The Inn. The Frungillo Family, Tracey, Trish, Maria...the entire team. From the moment we stepped foot on the property, we knew we were in for something special. The Frungillo Family's dedication to excellence was evident in every aspect of our experience, from the seamless planning process to the flawless execution on the day of the event. Michelle was so awesome when it came to corresponding back and forth throughout the entire planning process.
Tracey, our incredible Maitre D, deserves special recognition for her unwavering support and attention to detail. She went above and beyond to ensure that every moment of our reception was perfect, allowing us to relax and truly enjoy the celebration.
And let's not forget about the food! The delicious cuisine prepared by the talented chefs was an absolute highlight of the evening. Our guests are still raving about the amazing flavors and presentation!! Cocktail hour started the night strong and continued into dinner.
Last but certainly not least, the venue itself was nothing short of breathtaking. The natural beauty of The Inn at Millrace Pond provided the perfect backdrop for our special day, and we couldn't have asked for a more picturesque setting.
We are endlessly thankful to The Frungillo Family, Tracey, Trish, Maria and everyone at The Inn at Millrace Pond for making our wedding reception so beautiful and memorable. They truly exceeded our wildest expectations, and we will cherish the memories of our special day forever. -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 04/23/2024The Inn at Millrace Pond- The PERFECT wedding venue!!
Where do I even begin? The Inn at Millrace Pond is the perfect wedding venue in New Jersey. If you are looking for an all-inclusive venue and personalized experience from catering, to accommodations- you NEED to check out the inn! You get the entire property to yourself the day and night of your wedding, and there are so many unique spaces! They recently built a brand new reception barn and a cocktail hour space which are absolutely gorgeous. This venue is super charming and historic, but has been refurbished with modern touches and feels like you are stepping into another world for the day of your wedding, away from the stresses of modern life. It is so peaceful in the quaint little town of Hope, NJ. Michelle, the sales manager was beyond helpful throughout the whole planning process, and the day-of staff blew our expectations out of the water with their attentiveness to detail and help throughout the day. The innkeeper, Tricia charmed all of our guests with her kind and uplifting spirit and, along with Keri and my bridal attendant and Tracey, helped me and my girls with our requests all day long- they even took candid photos throughout the day and sent them to me which was incredible! Our maître d' Linda was absolutely incredible and made sure the ceremony, cocktail hour, reception, and after party all flowed seamlessly. Even when we had to move our ceremony inside at the last minute due to rain, the team went above and beyond to ensure that it was beautiful (and the reception barn fireplace/mantle gives such a beautiful indoor ceremony space backdrop, I would do it all over again!) The food was incredible- our guests are still raving! I cannot recommend this venue enough! -
Kaitlyn Sent on 04/22/2024
dream wedding
Our dream wedding on was made possible by Michelle and the exceptional team at the Inn. Michelle guided us through the planning process with great attention to detail and promptly addressed all of our questions. Tracey and Leah ensured that our special day ran seamlessly along with their impeccable team. The outstanding food is still a topic of conversation among our guests! We wish we could keep reliving our wedding day over and over again. -
-
![Pam]()
Pam A. Sent on 12/22/2023Attended a great wedding at the Inn at Millrace Pond
My husband and I attended a wedding at the Inn at Millrace Pond. We had the best experience! Laura, one of the servers went out of her way to help me when it came to finding gluten free appetizers at the cocktail hour. There was a large selection to choose from and everything was delicious including the main meal. My husband doesn’t eat gluten free and he rarely enjoys any of the food at weddings but even he commented on how much he enjoyed the food and the amazing service we received! Thanks to Laura and the rest of the staff at the Inn we also enjoyed our overnight stay. If you’re looking for a wedding venue this place will not disappoint!! -
![Brendan]()
Brendan Sent on 12/11/2023Our Dreamy December Wedding at the Inn
I wish I could rate the Inn at Millrace Pond higher than the available five stars🌟. I can’t event begin to put into words how accommodating, kind, and thoughtful of an experience the Inn staff, and all the folks at Frungillo, were to us from our booking day right through to our wedding - which was just perfect!
We received impeccable guidance and assistance from Ed and Michelle at Frungillo, who helped us curate the most personalized and perfect celebration. The Inn itself was the most beautiful backdrop, beautifully and tastefully decorated for the holidays and carefully attended to by amazing staff. The compliments we received from all members of our almost 180 person group of family and friends speak to their amazing service. Tricia the Innkeeper is one of the sweetest, organized, and accommodating individuals we have ever worked with, and was with us from rehearsal dinner right through our cozy after party in the tavern!
Tracy was integral on our wedding day, and provided first class service to us and our bridal party, and made us feel like Kings from start to finish - simply the best of the best ! Katherine our Bridal attendant was lovely, kind, and generously accommodating!
We were told the inn would be our”village” for our big day and it really was, and because of the amazing folks who work here it was a dream come true ❤️
Thank you all !!
-Brendan and Nick
-
-
![Jessica]()
Jessica Sent on 10/08/2023Most Magical Day!
Venue/Caterer ⛪🍽️ - The Inn at Millrace Pond (Frungillo Hospitality): I happened upon The Inn at Millrace Pond because of a post in a facebook group. We had already started looking at venues and my fiance didn’t even want me to book a tour here because he felt we had too many tours planned already. I am so glad that I didn’t listen to him, because we both fell in love with the Inn as soon as we stepped foot on the grounds. The Inn perfectly combined our styles. I love the old-world, rustic charm that the Inn has to offer and my husband loves the new, modern touches that the recently renovated barn has to offer. I love that the grounds make you feel as if you’ve stepped into a private village. Maria, who gave us our guided tour was awesome and answered all of our questions. Ed, our event manager/maitre’d was amazing at guiding us through the planning process and making sure that things ran smoothly. He did become a little hard to get in touch with as our wedding date got closer (probably due to it being busy season), but leading up to our finals meeting, he was very good at getting back to me. Tracey, his assistant, was outstanding the day of our wedding and SO sweet! The staff made sure that our day was flawless, despite the many challenges that we faced due to the weather. The food was FANTASTIC! The venue looked stunning! Every staff member was professional, helpful, and genuinely so happy for us! It felt like we were surrounded by extra friends that day. My only complaint would be that Dan and I didn’t get to eat enough of the delicious food during cocktail hour because we were too busy saying hello to everyone (luckily Tracey was so wonderful and brought us a plate of food from cocktail hour so that we could enjoy some nibbles during the reception). The kitchen staff literally made a separate meal just for me because during our tasting I loved one dish, but we didn’t choose it as a menu choice for our guests. We truly had a magical day despite the tropical storm that was rolling through!
Hotel 🏨- The Inn at Millrace Pond: Tricia, the innkeeper was super helpful in booking the rooms on-site. She made sure that the priority rooms were cleaned in a timely fashion so that our guests could get ready. We had a delicious morning after breakfast with our guests that stayed on site. There were many food and drink options - there was definitely something for everyone! Everyone was happy with their stay on site. The rooms were immaculate and the beds were comfortable. They even accommodated our dog in one of their pet friendly rooms so that we could have him with us on our wedding day. One of the other things that we loved about the Inn is that we can go back to stay at the Inn after our wedding! We will definitely be back for anniversary trips!
-
-
April Sent on 10/15/2022
The most perfect day!
We had our wedding on 9/18/22 and it was the best day of our lives! We live in Washington state, so we had to tour the venue via video chat before the new barn was finished. Maria and Jerry were very flexible with us planning the wedding from 3000 miles away. We didn't even have a rehearsal because we had bridal party members coming from all over the place, but Jerry made sure everything ran smoothly. All our guests raved about the food and about how attentive Jerry was. A bunch us stayed at the inn overnight, hung out by the fire pit and had (complimentary) breakfast together the next morning. It's a truly unique venue and we highly recommend it! -
-
![Cristina]()
Cristina Sent on 10/14/2022Unique rustic venue- had an amazing wedding here.
My husband and I had our wedding at the Inn at Millrace pond on 10/9/22 and it was simply an amazing wedding. Our Maitre’D Jerry Pagano made sure everything went smoothly and if there was any hiccups they were taken care of without disturbance to us. His energy and personality gets the Job done! The barn brand new and gorgeous. There are so many unique areas of the venue including a farmhouse, bridal suite, tavern for after hours party. Food is from Frungillo catering who owns the Inn and it was delicious. I love that they offer you 4 entree options and include your wedding cake from Palermo’s bakery. If you are looking for a unique venue that has 17 rooms onsite for family to stay overnight with good food and what feels like a tiny village all to yourself on your wedding day, don’t hesitate to book this venue. -
![Deborah]()
Deborah Sent on 09/08/2022All in one Wedding Venue!
My daughter Rachel and her husband Tyler were married here on July 22,2022, it was nothing short of FABULOUS! It is the perfect destination wedding right here in New Jersey! The newly built barn is just an amazing space for the reception! We opted for the Hopes best package, which includes an after party, all 17 overnight rooms and a wonderful breakfast, all orchestrated by the Maitre D, Gerry Pagano. Gerry will assist you with all the fine details for your perfect wedding! -
-
Jane Sent on 03/14/2021
Baby shower
We held a baby shower here for my step daughter. Everything was perfect, from the food, to the venue, to the staff . Very accommodating, professional and friendly. I would highly recommend for any event. -
-
![Diana]()
Diana Sent on 05/25/2018My husband and I did the unheard of- we had our small intimate wedding during the week, (on a Tuesday in April) but we had the WHOLE place to ourselves!!! And it was worth it. From the start of the day, til our after party, Sue-Ann and Brett went above and beyond to help guide us throughout the planning process and with any questions we had. They are also very nice and down to earth people! We were very indecisive about what we wanted, and they made us very comfortable. Sue-Ann has the most calming voice, and is very funny! I have to say we loved the laid-backness and the vibe of this venue, rather than the formality of most vendors that are just trying to sell you. The staff genuinely cared for us and you could feel that....they did everything they could to make us happy. We're SO happy we chose this for our wedding....not only because of the amazing hospitality, but the FOOD!!!! Everyone loved and raved about the food- Frungillo Catering was AMAZING. Our guests were very very happy and had a wonderful, unforgettable time at The Inn at Millrace Pond. -
-
Rachel Sent on 10/16/2017Our wedding at the Inn was perfection. Taylor and her team were super attentive, helpful and accommodating throughout our entire planning process and weekend of our wedding. We chose the Inn because of its charm, ambiance, history and property and it DELIVERED on everything we wanted. Our guests loved our venue and had such amazing things to say even now that our wedding is over.
We had our close friends and family spend the night of our wedding in each of the 17 rooms the Inn has on the property. After our wedding 40 or so of our guests stayed on the property, enjoyed the bonfire and hanging out a bit longer before the night was over. The next morning, our overnight guests joined us for a complimentary breakfast at the Inn's Tavern on the property. This was so sweet for us because we got to enjoy our wedding and guests a little longer. The breakfast was DELICIOUS and it was so intimate and quaint because we had the entire Tavern to ourselves (since we booked all 17 rooms).
Overall, both my husband and I are 1000% happy with our decision to get married at the Inn. The Inn treated us like family and made our stay and experience so special. Now that our wedding is over (sadly - enjoy every minute future brides) we'll be going up to the Inn just for dinner (which their food is AMAZING) or a nice "staycation" and we'll get to keep enjoying the place that made our wedding so special.
Thank you Taylor Panetta and the entire Inn at Millrace Pond Team. Xo
Love,
Rachel & Ryan -
-
Ashley Sent on 06/25/2017This was such a beautiful exceptional wedding venue, the moment we saw it online we fell in love and Sue-Ann was the most helpful planned ever. She went above and beyond for my husband and I and the whole wedding. We had the whole house and we stayed after for our wedding night at the Inn and the breakfast the day after the wedding was EXCEPTIONAL!!!!!!!! If you are considering this venue. YOU WONT REGRET IT!
-
-
![Johana]()
Johana Sent on 10/23/2015My Dream Wedding,
when we got engaged xmas of 2014 little did I know we were going to find the wedding spot of our dreams, as you can imagine we had the daunting job of find the
perfect place without breaking the bank:-)but It became apparent to us how difficult was starting to get finding venues that cater to intimate weddings such ours of seventy five guest. Then like a dream from above one friday afternoon I came upon the "Inn at Millrace Pond" It was absolutely EVERYTHING we imagined and more!! it turns out the Inn is a historical site where more than 150 years ago was at the heart of Hope New Jersey's economy as a working mill. My husband and I knew we have found our perfect place and the exciment of planning our wedding was up on the air; made evermore special by meeting the Manager at the Inn " Taylor Panetta"
Taylor went aboved and beyond to assist us in planning our day, any inquries, suggestions, and even tips for our wedding invitations were terrific our guest loved our unique invitations. As you continued reading you would realized what a little historical gem you hve just found :-) and even better Taylor will be there to make your day as magical as ours and your guest would be delighted with the charm of the inn, the beautiful pond, the working mill and the gorgeous grounds.
Futhermore let's talk about Frungillo Caterers one word "exceptional" John Fucci the manager was incredible, he made sure every detail was on point easying our nerves and making our day one of kind :-) Our guest complemented us on how delightful the food was and the elegance of our wedding, Surprisingly people do noticed details as we do and are grateful for all the hard work and look forward to planning future gatherings with John and Taylor.
Cheers,
Johana & Tim
-
Kim B. Sent on 07/26/2023
Best food best place
Our daughter was married here in June 2023. I cannot say enough good things about the inn. We initial spoke to Maria I believe she is in sales . She was so helpful and accommodating and after showing us the grounds which are beautiful and the new modern farmhouse that was completed in May 2023 we were blown away and new this was the place . Maria even came the day of my daughters wedding just to see our vision come alive and also to say good luck. I thought how sweet was that that she took the time to do so.
The Inn at Millrace is modern farmhouse reception meets old farmhouse for the cocktail hour since they were attached it made it so unique, and what was even nicer was that we had the availability of the old farmhouse During our reception to use as well.
We could have chosen the gristmill for the cocktail hour I believe which is spectacular too as it’s 200 years old but our wedding guest size was too large but it surely made a great after party for us to all to party in
The Inn I believe has 16 rooms and the most amazing bridal suite that is a converted barn . The Character and charm it had was beautiful and the newlyweds can stay in this amazing space along with their guest at the Inn and not have to leave the grounds which made things so convenient.
It also serves as an amazing bridal suite for the bride to get ready in with her bridal party. Tracy was our bridal attendant and although they may not serve food as it’s something you have the option to bring in which honestly I believe would be an amazing touch if they offered that option for you even if they had to charge for it as it was a little bit much getting everything together to bring to this suite the morning of. The Inn did provide water and coffee set up and a few things but not food.
Tracy are bridal attendant who also cared for our head tables and bride and groom throughout the day was an absolute “GEM”. Caring, helpful, kind and totally attentive throughout the entire day and evening Always making sure even during photos that we all had enough to eat and drink and went out of her way for everything.
Since my daughter’s wedding was a true DIY we needed to get into the venue prior to her Thursday wedding. They were incredibly accommodating allowing us to stay there for hours the Tuesday before in setting up our vision.
Eddie was the maître d and he is busy sometimes not being able to get back to us in time with some questions we had prior to event however with we cannot say enough great things about Eddie either . He was so accommodating attentive and kind as well and is excellent at what he does.
Tracy and Eddie would make an incredible team. I feel like Tracy should be Eddie’s assistant they would make a killer duo together.
Our guest could not have said enough greater things about the food and the whole venue itself. Incredible caterers, absolute delicious food and everything was seamless.
The price point for all we got was totally worth every penny .
We did an outdoor ceremony and having someone who can delegate that a bit smoother would of been a bit more helpful .
Our extended family stayed at the inn and loved their stay . Even the innkeeper Trish was helpful that day.
If you are looking for a great country unique setting in beautiful Hope nj and want the added touches of old meets new modern farm house with a beautiful old inn for your guest to stay plus the best food ever The Inn at Millrace was top notch. We couldn’t of been happier in the most magical day our family shared in together. Thank you Inn at Millrace Pond our daughters wedding was a dream come true!
-
-
![Marissa]()
Marissa Sent on 11/28/2022A perfect wedding at the Inn
My daughter’s wedding was at the Inn this month. I couldn’t have been happier. It’s a beautiful rustic venue - from the grounds to the the gristmill and barn to the bridal suite and on the site rooms. Jerry was incredible - easy to work with, totally professional and made sure that everything was as we wanted. Even though he gently questioned some of our decisions (like an outdoor evening ceremony in late November) he made it work. He was there for the entire weekend and made sure everything was perfect. Maria was also fabulous, helping from the start with booking our date to our guests rooms and so much more . I would absolutely recommend The Inn at Millrace Pond! -
![Laura]()
Laura Sent on 10/31/2012My October wedding at The Inn at Millrace Pond was an absolute dream come true. Nestled in the heart of quaint Hope, New Jersey, the Inn at Millrace Pond is an absolutely gorgeous location, complete with a fantastic restaurant, tavern, 17 guest rooms, and wedding services. My husband and I were so thrilled to book this place- we loved the idea of having our ceremony & reception in one spot, and that our family & bridal party could stay on the grounds with us.
Besides looking as though it is straight out of a storybook, the Inn is run by a hard working & exceptional staff that were quite accommodating during our stay. Because we had the every room booked for the night of our wedding, I was able to utilize the entire grounds for wedding decor & activities. The outdoor ceremony was perfect, the wedding tent & cocktail hour building are comfortable and beautiful, and the rooms are charming. I loved the little fun details of having our wedding here- like the fire pit we were able to enjoy post-reception, and the use of the tavern for late night drinks. Breakfast the next day was delicious, too!
The *only* reason I did not give a full five stars for this location, is because I felt the Inn could have comped the room that my husband and I stayed in on our wedding night. Many hotels extend this courtesy, and we did have family and friends book every room in the Inn. We did not mind paying for the room, and at the end of the day that one cost is certainly not a deal breaker. Still in all, we spent a great deal of money at the Inn, and one comped room would have been a nice accommodation!
That detail aside, I will reiterate how pleased we were with the Inn and its staff. Exceptional service, and a completely perfect rustic & country wedding location! I highly recommend getting marred at the Inn at Millrace Pond! -
![Michele]()
Michele Sent on 05/09/2013We had a wonderful experience with John, Alberto, Christine, and the rest of the staff at the Inn at Millrace Pond. We did everything here--from the rehearsal lunch to the wedding itself to afterparty and the morning after. The food and service were incredible, and our guests raved about the elegant but comfortable atmosphere. They were very flexible in letting us bring in a lot of decor items the day before the wedding; they even helped us pack our things up at the end of the reception. My only complaint was that they surprised us with a complimentary lighting element for our reception, which we suspect was on the same circuit as our DJ because the power went out at one point during the dancing. It was only a few seconds (and not in total darkness) and actually made for a funny memory (our guests are still laughing about it), but just be sure that if they surprise YOU with lights that the DJ has separate power :) -
Ilissa Sent on 11/20/2024
Hindsight is 20/20
I have waited to write a review until after my daughter’s wedding at the Inn at Millrace Pond . She and her husband fell in love with the venue. They loved the vibe of the various buildings, the property etc.
Let’s start with the positives. The staff the day of the event were fabulous. I cannot say enough about Tracy and Leah. If you have the luck of having them ,then your event will be seamless! The rest of the staff.. servers, bartenders etc could not have been more friendly, accommodating and everyone got a multitude of complements from the guests. The food for the main course at the reception was delicious and the presentation was excellent. My cousins,who are caterers in NY and guests at the wedding, even commented on the food! The new ceremony/ reception space is amazing.
From the start they charge for everything! I was able to negotiate not having to pay $150.00 to use a 3 sided wooden arch for the ceremony and another price for vendors. As previously mentioned, my family is in the catering business so I was aware of customary chgs. In return for this they upped my min from 110 to 140 guests!!! I thought 125 was fair but they were firm.
They did tell us if there was a wedding the night before we would have to get ready in the farmhouse. The up and down stairs, the moving everything back and forth was not a great option in hindsight.
The farmhouse for the cocktail hour was crowded and the outdoor space we were shown initially was not open. I don’t know if they were waiting for permits?? There was minimal seating and tables for guests. So much so that people that got seats did not want to move. Watching people holding a drink and plate with no where to go and trying to navigate the stairs was a concern. One of the guests fell on the stairs carrying his 3 yr old.
The line for one station upstairs was overly long and a lot of people were not aware of another station in a small room on the first floor.
If I had it to do over I would ask for a tray of the pass arounds because I missed a lot of them. I even think asking for some pass arounds for the bridal party would have been a good idea. I don’t feel that would have been out of line as I paid for a majority of the venue cost.
We wanted pillar candles placed on the table. They were box ready with the candles in each. They wanted to charge us $450.00 to put them on the tables. A friend of my daughters had them done in 30 min. When we booked thankfully we were told we could bring snacks to munch on while having hair and make up. Presently there is a charge for that.
We were given pricing for the rooms onsite. The prices were $165/205 etc. I understand prices do go up but we should have been told that so we could inform our guests. The rooms ended up being $289.00 which included an $8.00 room cleaning fee!
The venue is beautiful but with that and the historic rustic buildings there are risks for elderly, handicapped etc guests that one needs to think about. Getting my mom around the venue and even into her room was a project that many people don’t consider. -
-
![Maureen]()
Maureen Sent on 08/30/2019My One Wedding Regret
Due to its proximity to Jack’s Barn, my husband and I decided to book the accommodations for our guests and our rehearsal dinner at the Inn at Millrace Pond. And out of everything I had planned for our wedding, it is my greatest regret. In fact, I am HUMILIATED by the experience my guests had and cannot express strongly enough how much you should NOT book rooms at this inn, which does not even offer basic amenities, is rude to its guests, overcharges for basic services and is run ineffectively.
Frungillo Caterers bought the Inn a couple of months ago and prior to the closing, the Inn was beautifully run, offered delicious food at its restaurant, and had an innkeeper named Taylor who was incredibly responsive and friendly. It was meticulously maintained and charming. Then, Frungillo came in, let Taylor go and only opens the inn for catered events. And everything changed.
Frungillo did provide delicious food for our rehearsal dinner and all of the staff working the dinner were friendly, attentive and hard-working. In that regard, I do not fault Frungillo. Yet, as for the rest, it was a disaster.
1. The new innkeeper, Jessica, is unpleasant, unhappy and rude to the guests. When everyone was calling to make reservations, no one answered the phone and my guests had to call multiple times to get a reservation. During their stay, she was rude to them (several of them let me know this) and locked the door after a certain hour in the evening, making it impossible to get any help or ask any questions. When I would email her, it would take her days or weeks to reply, and when she did reply, her answers were clipped and curt.
2. Upon arrival at the inn, all of the guests received a slip of paper saying there was no cable TV in any of the rooms. I was not notified in advance that this would be the case. For all guests stuck there during the day before the wedding began or my Aunt who was there the night of the wedding watching my cousin’s baby, they had no TV to watch. They did not reduce the rates of the rooms despite not providing this basic amenity.
3. On the day of the wedding, the main building had NO HOT WATER!!! Therefore, all of our guests including the bridesmaids and groomsmen had to take an ice cold shower. The men had to do cold shaves. The showers also have no water pressure, so they had to take an extremely long shower under trickling freezing, cold water. I was humiliated. The boiler was broken in the main building, something that should have been checked prior to our weekend event. Again, no discount was offered to our guests and they had to pay full price.
4. The phones in the rooms were all disconnected. Therefore, when our guests tried to call reception (when there was NO HOT WATER), they could not do so. All lines were dead. They had to go down to talk to Jessica, only to find no one at the main desk.
5. I had made arrangements with John to hold an after-party until midnight after the wedding. To simply open the space, they charged us $350 and then another $150 for the bartender. My husband and I and the bridal and groom’s parties did not get back to the inn until 11:30pm. Despite the arrangement that it would stay open until midnight, they locked the door to the tavern on us at 11:30pm. I contacted John about this and asked for a reimbursement for the time we were denied and he never got back to me. He said the owners wouldn’t do it because of the cost of turning on the lights. Huh?!
6. We also paid money to have the firepit made available to us both nights and due to rain, the firepit would not work one night. We were supposed to be refunded for that and again, that never happened.
The Inn at Millrace is extremely charming and does have beautiful rooms. Yet, in the transition to the new ownership, it is no longer being effectively run. Therefore, while they figure it out, I would refrain from booking any major events there. I worked extremely hard to make sure our guests would have a fabulous experience at our wedding and the inn let me down in every respect. I cannot apologize enough to our guests and am quite frankly embarrassed by this entire debacle. We brought thousands of dollars into the inn with our event and were treated distastefully.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?