The Historic Old Bermuda Inn Reviews

We held our reception here and it was truly fantastic. Friendly & amazing staff, delicious food, beautiful venue, super accommodating. We loved Mike & our maitre’d Stefania. Our guests complimented everything from the venue look to the food. We loved the family run feel and they were flexible with a lot of our options. We had a truly perfect night!

What a beautiful venue & the food was absolutely amazing. All everyone talked about was how amazing the food was & how beautiful our wedding was

I had my daughter’s bridal shower here; and the entire event was wonderful! Our maitre’d Bill and our server Joe were absolutely the best! They were so professional and catered to our every need! The only thing I would suggest is improved sound proofing! There was another party right next to us; and the music sounded like it was in our room. However, for me it didn’t diminish from what was a beautiful day! Great job guys!!

Great venue, very accommodating and professional.

Words cannot express our experience with Old Bermuda Inn. We fell in love with the location upon our first visit after doing research on venues all over NYC. We thought we knew what we wanted until we arrived and met with Michael for our tour and to review the package. We were impressed with the space, the amenities, the staffing, the upkeep of the venue and its rich history. By far, the facility is absolutely beautiful, and suitded us as a safe, neutral space for our dual Hindu Jewish ceremonies. Leading up to the wedding, we were impressed by the accomodations, the package, the customizations, the knowledge of the staff and the ease to which everything was completed. We were given deadlines, and ample time and flexiblity to provide everything. The staff worked with us, understandng our family needs, cultural needs, religious needs, and helped us piece the wedding together. The day of the wedding we were taken aback by Mike, Cindy, Joan and all of their staff who went above and beyond to make everything come together. We accomplished a lot, in a team, and we felt like they were part of the family, part of the planning from the very beginning. They checked in with us on everything and we felt like we could relax and not worry because all of our needs were met. I highly recommend Old Bermuda Inn, for any event, especially a wedding, or just as a B&B which was also a relief to have onsite. We are looking forward to using them again!

Old Bermuda Inn did a wonderful job for our wedding. They were very flexible with us having to reschedule twice with COVID. When we finally had our big day, everything went smoothly and was beautiful. Our bridal attendant was very helpful as well as the whole staff. All of our guests had a wonderful time. Would definitely recommend!

I cannot believe I forgot to write a review to The Old Bermuda Inn. We had lunch here prior to our 2016 wedding and the food was amazing. I worked with Mike DeForest (manager/coordinator) on a Wedding Plan that held more than 100 people. I have to say Mike was absolutely, positively awesome from setting up a food plan, decorating plan, and allowing us to bring in our own items as well. When most folks plan a wedding it is a bit stressful because of the costs, i.e. limo, photographer, dj, etc. Mike helped me budget during this stressful, but amazing time in my life; his knowledge and experience was greatly appreciated. Again, I honestly cannot believe I forgot to write a review. We lost both our grandmothers (both were at our wedding) and cousins (both were at the wedding) and as I am sitting here in tears remembering them, it also made me think of Mike, Cindy and the Bermuda staff on the absolute beauty of this wedding. I recall how AMAZING, AMAZING the food and spread was; I still remember the steak and beat myself up to this day for not finishing all my food :). If you are searching for a place to hold your special day, look no further, trust me when I say Mike, Cindy and the Old Bermuda staff went ABOVE and beyond to ensure my day was special. FYI - they even coordinated the outside vendors we hired. Money comes and goes (trust me at the time we were stressed), but the memories was so worth it. Thank you to the Bermuda team - My wedding was amazing thanks to your efforts and quality. Again, the food WAS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!.

I cannot say enough good things about The Historic Old Bermuda Inn. Cindy, Francine, Mike, Joan, and the entire staff are wonderful. They answered countless emails from me since May;. They eased every worry. They answered every question. They made our wedding a dream come true. It was the perfect Christmas wedding. I would highly recommend this location for any event. Our guests raved about the food, decor, ambiance, and staff. If you book here, you are in the best hands!

I am so taken back by how thoughtful the staff is and made my wedding a night I will never forget. Everyone who works there are amazing. Mike, Cindy, and Joan made sure everything was perfect and for that, I’m extremely thankful.

The staff and management were wonderful and really helped us pull off an amazing surprise birthday party. Very accommodating and professional. I would definitely book them for other events.

The food was delicious. Everyone was very attentive. Service was excellent. Would definitely recommend

I was very pleased with the service and food. Beautifully decorated and attention to detail. Everything went well ! It’s my 2nd party and would recommend to all having your next event here.

Excellent service and value. Food was fantastic, and the service was just fine.

My experience with your venue was stress- free and gracious. The method of payment, amount of guests, and table linens were all decided on a timely basis close to the event. We requested the food to be "Kosher Style" and the staff was very helpful in deciding the menu. On the day of the event, we were allowed to set-up one hour and a half before it started. The tables were set perfectly, The buffet food was hot plentiful and delicious. Nick was our waiter, his attention to detail would make me recommend The Inn to my friends.

An AMAZING reception. Myself along with my family have been having all our special occasion parties here for years. I wouldn’t go anywhere else. The staff, the service, the decor, and the food is absolutely excellent. I always feel so at home when I am there. Many, many thanks to everyone there for always makings our affairs a success and a precious memory.

Excellent all around; Mike was wonderful!

We had a wonderful night celebrating our daughters engagement. This is the 3rd party we’ve had here in 2 years. Unbeatable value

My husband and I were beyond pleased with our event at the Old Bermuda Inn. The food and service were spot on! I couldn’t have asked for a better execution!
We hope to be able to plan another party here and look forward to building wonderful memories.

Beautiful! Staff friendly and professional!

The evening well perfect. Everyone attentive. Food fabulous. Highly recommend

Had a wonderful experience with everyone who works at the Old Bermuda Inn, everyone was so kind and helpful and I would definitely book another event there in the future.

From beginning to the end had a wonderful experience with everyone who works there. Would definitely do another party in the future there.

Everything was wonderful, just like every other event I've had.

Fantastic service and great food. Place was also lovely. Everyone had a great time!

Food was great. Room set up the way I wanted. Very accommodating. Staff was very respectful and responsive.