The Caketeria Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Dasha]()
Dasha Sent on 08/12/2025Cake for wedding
We had Caketeria for our wedding--Beth was so delightful to work with and the cake was fantastic, our guests raved about it. -
Katelyn Sent on 06/03/2024
Looked great and tasted even better!
We are so grateful to Beth for making the perfect wedding cake for us! Exactly what we asked for and envisioned and it tasted amazing. She was also extremely flexible when we had to squeeze in our tasting after moving out of the area last minute. I would recommend her to any couple! -
-
![Jenna]()
Jenna Sent on 03/23/2024Great cake and great service!
The Caketeria made our wedding cake and it was super delicious. Beth was super responsive and the cake testing was great as well. All of our guests loved it and so did we! -
-
Marisa Sent on 09/10/2023
Amazing cake!
We had the option of the Caketeria or another place included in our package and we went with the Caketeria. From the initial tasting, we were absolutely obsessed with the cake flavors we picked and could not stop thinking about them. Beth was wonderful and helped us pick our flavors and made us the most gorgeous and delicious cake. Highly recommend!! -
-
Anna Sent on 07/09/2023
Made an amazing VEGAN chocolate wedding cake!!!
Our venue works with this bakery and includes a cake or cake topper with our wedding package. We went with the cake topper option and as I am dairy free we went with the vegan cake. The vegan options we so tasty! The chocolate, chocolate option was so good my husband could not believe that it was VEGAN like he actually thought it was a mistake. It wasn't and it was so good we decided we needed chocolate chocolate for our wedding! The cake was simple and exactly as we described it! Couldn't have asked for a better experience! -
-
![Madison]()
Madison Sent on 09/22/2022Divine Cakes!
Our wedding cake came as part of the package with Lambertville Station. But we still got to have the fun cake tasting experience because they had two bakeries they contracted with to make the cake, and we got to try them both! We ended up going with The Caketeria, in Newtown, PA. Beth, the head baker, is phenomenal. Her cakes are divine! They do wedding and special event cakes, but they also have a small bakery to just buy baked goods like cupcakes at her location, and we have made it a regular place to go for special occasion desserts. It is obvious she has been doing this for a very long time, and she has a great working relationship with Lambertville Station. All we had to do was show up to the tasting, pick our flavors, and she handled the rest. Our guests said the cake was the best wedding cake ever! -
![Elise]()
Elise Sent on 12/07/2021A truly yummy wedding cake!
The Caketeria makes the most delicious cakes and cupcakes. Our wedding cake came with our wedding package at the Barley Sheaf and it was from the Caketeria. It was so good. We went for the tasting and had a hard time deciding. We finally decided on Yellow pound with lemon and raspberry with buttercream and it was heavenly.
We also had dozens cupcakes and mini cupcakes of various flavors for our guests that were "out of this world" good!
Next time we need to get a cake for a birthday aor a special event we are heading to Caketera because they are so good. Thank you for the lovely wedding cake. -
![Valerie]()
Valerie Sent on 01/09/2020Best wedding cake
I’m a HUGE dessert person so cake was important for my wedding. Caketeria had the best tasting cakes and they customized layers as well as the design how we wanted it! Their carrot cake and cannoli cake was amazing ! They also helped me customize a surprise grooms cake which was a philly sports team cake! Sooo amazing!! -
-
![Allison]()
Allison Sent on 11/26/2019Stunning and Tasty
An excellent-tasting wedding cake was essential to both of us, especially as it was the only dessert at our wedding.
Fortunately, we chose The Inn at Barley Sheaf Farm as our venue and they work with Beth at the Caketeria.
Beth helped us create our perfect cake. Two cakes, in fact. She worked with all of our ideas, added her own and we came up with just what was right for us:
Yellow cake with lemon, lemon curd and raspberry preserves and buttercream. The cake looked amazing and tasted even better.
We also had a chocolate raspberry ganache cake for people who like chocolate. Everything tasted incredible.
Our cake tasting was easy, informative and fun. She was always available to answer questions and collaborate. She cares just as deeply about the look of the cake as the taste. We couldn't have been happier. Our guests continually tell me they have never had better wedding cake. -
-
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 07/24/2019Best and Most beautiful cake
Beth is absolutely amazing. Her and her team make delicious cake and they are beautiful too! It was a pleasure working with her and being able to enjoy her amazing work! -
Brianna Sent on 06/15/2019
Gorgeous and Tasty!
We had an amazing experience with the Caketeria. Beth baker my older sister’s wedding cake and once I was engaged, we knew we had to have a Caketeria cake for our wedding. Every flavor of Beth’s cakes taste incredible! When we met for our tasting, Beth met with us for a while and even read that I was not necessarily one for traditional looking cakes so she asked about my wedding style and made great suggestions that led us to a marble cake with different shaped layers! It was more beautiful than I ever could have imagined.
Needless to say, we started the day out getting compliments on how beautiful the cake was and ended it with compliments on how amazing it tasted! -
-
Jonna Sent on 01/08/2019
Words can’t even describe!!!
When my now husband and I were making our tasting appointments, we scheduled two for the same day since the two locations were close by. The Caketeria was first on our list and honestly what we were most excited for.
From the start Beth was so friendly and willing to accommodate the ideas we were thinking. I told her the flavors we were thinking because we didn’t want just traditional wedding cake flavors. She delivered! We were able to try so much besides just the idea we had. After our tasting, we canceled our second appointment because we knew we were going with Beth! Our cake was absolutely beautiful and DELICIOUS! Our guests raved about our cake! We decided to go with a 4 tier cake: 2 tiers were pumpkin cake with cream cheese frosting and the other two were a cinnamon pound cake with salted caramel frosting and a little layer of salted caramel on the cake! Yum! We were married in November, so the flavors fit perfectly! We now have our top layer in our freezer and are not sure it’s going to make it until next year! We could not have been happier with our experience, thank so much to Beth and The Caketeria for making our day that much better! :) -
-
Jenna Sent on 10/01/2018My husband and I just got married at the end of September. Beth was so incredibly helpful and professional from the first point of contact. Our cake was more than we could ever hope for! So beautiful and exactly how we imagined it!
-
-
Kelsey Sent on 09/20/2018My husband and I got married in August and we got our cake from The Caketeria. Beth was so helpful with picking flavors and design! I got a cake and cupcakes because I couldn’t pick just one flavor. I changed my mind so many times about what cupcake flavors I wanted and they were so patient and had great ideas. My guests couldn’t wait for the cake after they tasted The Caketerias amazing cake at my shower and they didn’t disappoint. Not only was everything beautiful, but it tasted amazing! We had some cake and cupcakes left over and they were just as moist and delicious the next day. We will be getting all of our cakes from The Caketeria! 5 stars isn’t enough!
-
-
Chloe Sent on 12/01/2017My husband & I got married in November & Beth and The Caketeria made cakes for a few of our wedding events, my shower, the rehearsal dinner (groom's cake) and our wedding cake. They absolutely nailed every single cake, not only did they look amazing but they also tasted great too.They did an AMAZING job on on our wedding cake, a "naked" style almond pound cake with raspberry filling. It was great and so beautiful! My only regret is the caterer threw out leftovers and didn't package them for us to take home, I wish I had some now LOL thank you so much The Caketeria! You guys are awesome
-
-
Jessica Sent on 10/31/2017My husband and I got our wedding cake from The Caketeria as part of our wedding package from Jamie Hollander Gourmet Foods & Catering. Beth from The Caketeria is fantastic to work with, and her cakes are to die for! We had a multilayer cake with two flavors: lemon soaked pound cake with lemon curd and raspberry and a chocolate cake with coffee filling. Both flavors were a huge hit amongst guests. I particularly recommend the chocolate/coffee combination for any couple who loves coffee! Beyond this, the decor of the cake was exactly what I described to Beth when we met for a cake tasting. I asked for a birch tree look with space for leaves and flowers (provided by The Pod Shop in New Hope), and the final product was perfect (even better than I imagined).
Beth was also wonderful to work with throughout the wedding planning process. My parents were helping me plan the day, since I no longer live locally, and Beth was great at accommodating this. First, she met with my parents and took them through a tasting. Then, when I had a surprise work trip to the area, she scheduled a second tasting for my sister and I at the last moment, and was very accommodating. I felt very comfortable working with The Caketeria, and I was incredibly happy with the wedding cake. I highly recommend The Caketeria for wedding cakes and any other occasion you want something delicious! -
-
![brieliz]()
Brielle Sent on 03/10/2017Caketeria was included as one of the bakeries of choice from our venue. After tasting the cake at a bridal show, I knew this was the bakery to choose. Beth was so helpful during the tasting and helped us come up with exactly what we were looking for with our wedding cake design. She also planned and made a surprise groom's cake for my husband for the rehearsal dinner, which he loved! The cake was very affordable and delicious! My husband is picky but couldn't get enough. We also already ate our cake topper (it was that good) and are planning on ordering a 1 year anniversary cake from them next year. I highly recommend Beth and Caketeria. -
![Abby]()
Abby Sent on 06/17/2013Our wedding cake was AMAZING! Felix and his staff did an amazing job. Everyone raved about the cake. We also had cupcakes and cookies made for the reception! Needless to say there weren't any left at the end of the night! I would totally recommend to anyone!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?