Tastings Caterers Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Julia]()
Julia Sent on 04/24/2025Perfect Caterers!! Amazing experience!
Tastings just catered our wedding of 90 people at the Lyman Estate this past weekend and they did an incredible job! Communication was excellent and food was amazing. We had a few offbeat requests like sliders and grilled cheeses for appetizers and they were so kind to make that happen for us! They had a vast array of menu choices in every category that met any dietary need you could think of. Most importantly, everything was delicious! Especially their short ribs entree which was my favorite. The entire Tastings team was also wonderful on the day of the wedding! They set up the tables perfectly, were so kind to the guests while serving, and at the end of the... -
![Michelle]()
Michelle Sent on 03/04/2025Can't praise enough
From the moment we started working with Tastings Caterers, my wife and I felt as though we were being taken care of by a close family member. Their dedication to our event was evident in every interaction—whether it was in-person meetings, email correspondence, or phone calls, they consistently went above and beyond to ensure every detail was perfect.
Tastings Caterers worked within our budget without compromising on quality, creating a truly memorable experience for both us and our guests. Their team took the time to understand our vision and made sure the entire event flowed seamlessly. The food was absolutely delicious, and everything was executed right on schedule, relieving us of any stress. If you're looking for a caterer that treats you like family and delivers exceptional service, Tastings Caterers is the perfect choice. Highly recommend!
-
![Andrew]()
Andrew Sent on 11/01/2024Great experience!
We had Tastings cater our wedding at the Lyman Estate. We lucked out with the timing, we were able to go to a group tasting before signing the contract, but truthfully if you don't manage to go to a tasting beforehand signing the contract, you can trust that Tastings will delivery great service and food. They are definitely very experienced with setting up and executing at Lyman, we didn't worry about a thing. Most importantly though, the food was delicious! We did a buffet set up with 3 entrees and a couple of sides. We even got a bit of leftovers to take home which was awesome. -
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 10/27/2024Amazing experience!
Tastings Catering was highly recommended by our venue - Lyman Estate - and I cannot say enough great things about them.
Sue and Eileen were wonderful. From the tasting events, to planning, to helping us on-site, they made the whole process fun and enjoyable. They were also incredibly helpful in providing menu suggestions that fit within our budget and provided accommodations for our guests' dietary restrictions.
The food, desserts, cake, and drinks were absolutely fantastic! The Tastings team went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect for our wedding and we are so grateful. -
![Stephanie]()
Stephanie Sent on 10/10/2024Guests loved the food
The food was all delicious, especially for the price. Our guests kept complimenting the dishes and asking who we had do our catering! We loved that they use local foods where possible and they were very flexible with menu ideas. We aren’t cake people but thought their cakes were delicious and even our guests who claimed not to like cake wanted a second slice.
-
![Marina]()
Marina Sent on 04/04/2024The BEST Wedding Food!
Best caterer hands down!! Sue and Eileen were great to work with and answered several questions over the course of many months. What made them stand out compared to other caterers was not only the quality of the food they cooked and served but all the extras they threw in. They worked with us on our budget, let us borrow centerpieces for the reception, made the best French almond cream cake from scratch AND served fresh chocolate chip cookies to our guests. They even went above and beyond and packaged all left overs for us to enjoy after our big day. Everyone raved about the beef short ribs and haddock. We were told by several guests that we had... -
-
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer Sent on 01/02/2024Absolutely the BEST experience!
Mother of the bride here...I cannot recommend Tasting Caterers enough! They were amazing through the entire process and responsive to every email I sent. They were great about my last minute linen changes and graciously managed 32 pints of custard and 500 homemade cookies that came from Wisconsin! The food was fabulous and our guests loved the meals. Their staff that managed the event were kind and professional and they did a wonderful job setting up the venue (tables, centerpieces, welcome sign, memory table..). The cake was delicious and they even made a small cake for the bride and groom to take home. We can't thank them enough for helping make the day magical! -
![Jennie]()
Jennie Sent on 10/30/2023Tastings is a DREAM TEAM!
We were over the moon with our experience with Tastings Caterers and could not recommend them enough. Sue, Eileen, and Amanda are a dream team!
We were blown away by the delicious food, cake, and dessert. Our friends and family are still raving about the food they enjoyed on our special day. There were options for everyone, and they were so accommodating to all of our needs.
Tastings was so organized and made for an "easy" day for all of us. We can't wait to use Tastings again for a future party/event!
-
![Emily]()
Emily Sent on 10/25/2023Excellent food and great staff!
We were looking for a caterer who could be flexible and create a custom menu that for our needs.
Tastings was extremely professional and was able to offer options for every request that we had.
Their staff on the wedding day was absolutely wonderful and they made our day so special! -
![Madeline]()
Madeline Sent on 07/19/2023Fantastic!!
Tastings was incredible. They were great to work with, even when we couldn’t make any of the group tastings they held. Sue and Eileen were very responsive and day of, helped deal with unexpected issues (unrelated to catering). They went far above and beyond. Could not recommend more! -
![Kristy]()
Kristy Sent on 01/22/2023Reasonably priced catering that guests raved about
We went to sample tastings for a few caterers and chose Tastings because they were the best at working with dietary restrictions: my husband has celiac, and we wanted a fully gluten-free meal. The fact that Tastings was so clear in labeling allergens at their tasting events made us confident they were the right caterer for us. Their prices are on the lower end for full-service caterers, which initially made us wonder if they'd be lower quality, but it turns out they're just affordable. All of the food was absolutely delicious, and our friends and family still talk about how great the short rib was regularly. The service they provided was also great. I especially appreciated that one of... -
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 01/03/2023The absolute best!
We had heard such amazing things about Tastings that we changed our wedding date to line up with their availability. We’re so glad we made that decision – we were blown away by their expertise and incredible food! From our private tasting to the collaboration on our menu, Sue and Eileen were such professionals. They were also very familiar with our venue and guided us on the event flow. We consulted Sue and Eileen on some last-minute layout changes, and they were so accommodating. We were thrilled with the level of customer service, and so many of our guests praised the food! Thank you to Tastings for helping us create such a memorable day and experience. -
![Prepped]()
Prepped&Primped Sent on 11/17/2022Planner Recommended!!
I have been in the industry for quite some time, and I can say that Tastings is hands down one of the best that I have worked with. It's such a delight to work with such warm professionals who are a joy to work with throughout the process & DELIVER on the day. Working with them, I am not worried about the hospitality, quality of staff, or how the food is going to taste.. reason being, it's going to be top notch on all fronts. Highly Recommend! - Patricia, Owner + Lead Designer, Prepped & Primped -
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 10/23/2022Absolute perfection from beginning to end
Our experience with Tastings was perfect from beginning to end. My partner and I had so much fun at one of Tasting’s “tasting” events that we decided to go to another after booking them for our wedding—a truly unique, fun and festive way to research our wedding food! Then, Sue and Eileen were incredibly responsive throughout the planning process, and helped us to design our absolute ideal menu (with plenty of vegetarian, gluten free, and nut free options for our guests with different dietary preferences). Food was one of our very top priorities and we could not have been happier with our dinner—truly one to remember. Throughout our wedding reception, not only did everyone comment on how incredible the... -
![Matt]()
Matt Sent on 08/14/2022Start to finish, a wonderful experience
From the very start, Tastings was nothing but a pleasure. Of all the vendors we got quotes from, they were the most affordable AND the only ones who had an opportunity for us to taste the food before committing to them and putting money down. They put on regular events at which you can try their food, drinks, and see their decor. This, combined with one phone call with Sue, made us sure Tastings was right for us.
Throughout the process, everyone at Tastings was accommodating, responsive, and helpful. They took care of so many details and set my mind at ease. They brought TONS of additional decor for the bar and food areas that looked beautiful... -
![Daria]()
Daria Sent on 07/21/2022Great food, service, and value - highly recommended!
My husband and I worked with Tastings to cater our June wedding at Eustis Estate in Milton and we highly recommend them! They were incredibly helpful and accommodating during the planning process and their private and group tastings were a great way to sample lots of different dishes to get a sense of what we liked. It was amazing that they let us use some of their dinnerware, linens, and games at no extra cost to us whereas many of the other caterers we spoke with early on charged a huge premium for those items. As a family owned operation, we felt that their service was more personal and we appreciated the special touches, like getting sent home with... -
![Hannah]()
Hannah Sent on 06/19/2022So happy with Tastings!!!
If you are considering Tastings, you should absolutely go for it!! They played a huge part in making my wedding day so amazing. First of all, they were so patient and flexible through the last 3 years while we dealt with 2 pandemic postponements and multiple changes to our guest list size. They were incredibly professional and open - helping make suggestions to ensure we could have a delicious dinner that was still within our budget. If we had been undecided, trying their food at our tasting would have absolutely sealed the deal. We left knowing we had to have their amazing short rib at our wedding.
My mother and brother both have celiac disease, and the Tastings... -
![Nuare]()
Nuare Sent on 11/23/2021Great company to work with
We had an incredible wedding! Thanks to Tastings. The food was delicious and the service spot on. They took care of us before, during and even after our wedding ( Sue sent us home with the best apple cake)
We were lucky to find them and they were on over 6 preferred list at the venues we looked at but we ended up with a tent wedding at our relatives house; this took even more planning to make our visions come to light.
Matt is amazing - he was our event manager and also set up the most beautiful buffet, bars, appetizer table, dessert table.
They let us borrow decor items too and this saved us tons of money.
We will be forever thankful to have them in our memories. What a great company to work with! -
![Brittany]()
Brittany Sent on 11/05/2021Very Impressed with Tastings!
We received so many compliments about Tasting's food and desserts! Everything was a hit, especially their short ribs and churros :) Sue was wonderful to work with from the start, and Matt was AMAZING. He was so great coordinating everything day of and really made everything go so smoothly - we highly recommend him! -
![Alison]()
Alison Sent on 10/31/2021I’d give Tastings 6 stars if I could! Delicious food & excellent service!
We are so grateful to Eileen, Sue, and the rest of the Tastings team for making our big day so special! First of all (and most importantly), ALL of the food was incredible. We loved that we could attend two tasting events beforehand not only to see the food but to see the staff in action. The dishes were unique, and our guests raved about how great the food was - a few said it was the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding - and they even sent us home with leftovers to enjoy for weeks to come! A few of our favorites included the slow-cooked short ribs, butternut squash ravioli, meat balls on pretzel sticks, marbled... -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 10/24/2021Tasty food and amazing staff!
If you are looking for great food and great service than Tastings is amazing! The options they provide are so different from old school wedding dinners and they work closey with you to make sure the menu and serving style is exactly what you want! They were so good at "catering" to our specific requests and they had so many great options in regards to dietary needs. They also did an amazing job setting up the venue and making everything so beautiful! They are super talented and made sure everything was smooth and easy for us the entire evening! Catering is so much more than food! It is a real art! They were all so amazing. Thank you Sue, Eileen, Amanda and everyone else! You were fantastic! -
![Kathy]()
Kathy Sent on 05/15/2020The Best Caterers!
We have been using Tastings since 1996, when my husband and I got married. They have done numerous events for us, for our children and for our friends. I can't say enough good things about them. Sue is wonderful to work with, very laid back and helps make a stressful event easier, and she is a fabulous baker. John cooks the most amazing food. Matt and Amanda are doing more of the setup these days, and having learned from the best, they are fantastic as well. If you are going to have an event, USE THEM. You won't be disappointed! -
![Porntida]()
Porntida Sent on 11/21/2019Went above and beyond
The team went above and beyond to have the night run as smooth as possible. They were able to help with our travel theme and decorated everything we want. They were really quick setting up and break down. I would highly recommend them. -
![Lauren]()
Lauren Sent on 10/06/2019This is the Caterer You Want!!!
Tastings catered my 100 guest wedding at the Lyman Estate. I could say many amazing things about them, but let's go with pricing, customization, and staffing as the top 3.
We taste tested at a few caterers in the area. Some were just as tasty, but none gave you as much for your money as Tastings did. We were able to afford stationary appetizers (delicious dips and skewers), passed appetizers (fun, unique selections), dinner with several entree choices (I heard about the beef short ribs over and over and over...) and a whole mess of desserts (Sue's cakes are heaven!!) for the price of just a couple entrees and a few apps at other places.
If you... -
![Joanna]()
Joanna Sent on 10/06/2019Absolutely wonderful!
Tastings was absolutely amazing for our wedding. Not only was their food wonderful, they were extremely helpful and accommodating throughout the whole process. We continue to have guests compliment the amazing food we had on the day. We couldn’t have been happier with our choice, and we absolutely loved our donut wall and cookie cake!!!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?