Stella's Pizza Pie Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Featured
Jarett Sent on 11/22/2024Best. Wedding. Ever!
You’ve got to book Stella’s! We had nothing but the easiest, most pleasant experience working with Stella’s Pizza Pie, and we’d love to work with them again in the future. From the initial tasting to the day of our wedding, working with Amy and co. at Stella’s was a straightforward, exciting, stress-free (and ultimately delicious!) process. Stella’s Pizza Pie was one of our venue’s recommended vendors, and day-of operations were a breeze! We opted to have a couple of extra hands (hired as an option through Stella’s) and the entire service and clean-up was smoother than we could have dreamed. They even cut our assortment of pies for the dessert portion of the meal! We have had multiple of our attendees say to us that it was some of the best pizza (if not THE best pizza) they’ve ever had. And the tub — and I mean a tub! — of Caesar salad was a huge hit. If you want to offer your guests a meal that’s different than the standard chicken-and-fish wedding fare, and if you want to save yourself a number of headaches trying to find a great vendor partner, do yourself a favor and book Stella’s! -
-
![Akira]()
Akira Sent on 12/08/2025Stella’s Pizza Pie - We Absolutely Love You!!!
I don’t even know where to begin because Stella’s Pizza Pie wasn’t just our wedding caterer, they became one of the reasons our day felt so full of joy, comfort, and love. From our very first conversation, their kindness and genuine care shined through. It felt like we were being taken care of by people who truly wanted our day to be perfect.
On the wedding day, they exceeded every hope I had. The food… absolutely incredible. The most delicious, heart-warming pizza that instantly brings people together. Our guests kept coming up to us all night saying it was the best wedding food they’ve ever had. Even our vegan and vegetarian guests felt so seen and included.
But what touched me the most was the team themselves. Their energy was so warm, so positive, so present. They handled everything quietly and flawlessly in the background while we lived out the most important moments of our lives. I could feel that they cared. That means everything to a bride. AND when I asked THEM to dance with ME on the dance floor? They brought on the vibesss!! -
-
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 10/09/2025Wedding Pizza Party
Stella's was absolutely amazing for our wedding! Their pizzas and appetizers were all delicious and our guests absolutely loved it. They were all so friendly and helpful at the tasting as well, it was one of our favorite parts of wedding planning. Highly, highly recommend! We can't wait to have more of their food in the future :) -
![Alexis]()
Alexis Sent on 07/06/2025Excellent food and services!
We chose Stella's Pizza Pie for our wedding back in 04/2025 and it was amazing! Many things went wrong in our wedding but something that was absolutely perfect, was the food! Thank you Amy and your team for delivering high quality food and excellent service. We decided to add the chicken scaloppini and Francesco's baked pasta, and my husband still talks about that chicken and I still dream about that delicious pasta! Everything was wonderful, every single item we chose was a hit! We selected the Berry Bruschetta, Ceasar salad, chicken scaloppini, Francesco's baked pasta, and 4 pizza options (Fresh King, Pig Pen, Bird's the Word, Pesto Pie). I would highly recommend Stella's Pizza Pie!!! -
![Sydney]()
Sydney Sent on 06/05/2025Stella’s Pizza Pie – A Slice of Wedding Perfection!
From the very first tasting to the final slice served on our big day, Stella’s Pizza Pie was absolutely phenomenal. Amy and her team went above and beyond every step of the way — their professionalism, warmth, and attention to detail made the entire process feel effortless.
The pizza? Incredible. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about it! But what really set them apart was how smoothly they handled everything — from dietary restrictions to last-minute modifications and even a few quirky requests. Amy just made it all happen, no stress, no fuss.
If you want a vendor who’s not only talented but also a total joy to work with, Stella’s is it. They brought the flavor, the fun, and the flawless service. 10/10 would get married again just for the pizza. -
![Brad]()
Brad Sent on 05/21/2025Look No Further!
When we first started looking for catering for our March 2025 wedding, we weren't sure what exactly we wanted. Then we heard about Stella's Pizza Pie. Our wedding coordinator told us they were one of her all-time favorite caterers, and we quickly learned why. Stella's is AMAZING! If you want pizza for your wedding, you have found the right place. From our initial conversations to our tasting to their service on our wedding day, we could not have asked for more. They were incredibly flexible with us when our guest count fluctuated. The tasting experience was so much fun. And don't get us started on their amazing day of services. Not only is the food fantastic, but they are quick, professional, and experienced. Not a single hiccup day of and everyone raved about the food. We HIGHLY recommend the shrimp appetizer and you can't go wrong with any of their pizzas, but the Volcano and the Fig Fantastico are to die for! They also did a fantastic job with our cake cutting! You truly cannot go wrong with Stella's and we cannot recommend them enough! Thank you, Stella's! -
![Brianna]()
Brianna Sent on 09/29/2024We ❤️ Stellas Pizza Pie
We hired Stella’s pizza for our wedding reception and have nothing but good things to say! The pizza, appetizers, and salad were all incredible. We received many compliments from our guests! The staff was super friendly and Amy was super helpful through the entire planning process. I would definitely recommend their service! -
![Mark]()
Mark Sent on 09/24/2024Perfect 50th Birthday ... thank you, Stella's!
I can't say enough great things about Stella's Pizza Pie Catering, their crazy delicious food, or their amazing staff! We interviewed & researched around 10 different companies and Stella's came through with the perfect combination of the best charcuterie display we've ever seen, strawberry salad, and several of their mouth-watering pizzas. Everything was perfect: from the communication with Amy leading up to the event, to the staff on site the day of, the gloriously beautiful food displays ... and the flavor of their food. We made the right choice for my 50th birthday party and highly recommend this amazing catering company for any event you might be considering. Thank you, Stella's! -
-
Alena Sent on 07/25/2024
The KINDEST team and the most DELICIOUS pizza
My husband and I are so blessed to have been able to have Stella’s Pizza Pie at our wedding. Everyone absolutely loved it. From the beginning they were so kind to us and made sure our ideas and desires were being met. We also live being able to support a family business. They were also very accommodating with our gluten free and dairy allergy guests.
Thank you so much to the entire team for an amazing experience! -
-
![Sommer]()
Sommer Sent on 05/27/2024Overall Amazing! Hire them!!
Highly recommend Stella's Pizza Pie! We had them cater our wedding and they were such a joy to work with!! They are very responsive, which was a huge plus for us. They are also just super genuine and kind. The best part, all of their food is delicious! After we had our tasting, we had a very hard time deciding what we wanted on our menu for the wedding.
They were very on top of everything on the wedding day and made everything seamless! We also had a wedding of close to 140 guests, and they kept up the entire time.
When we wanted to book them, we weren't 100% certain if our venue could fit their pizza truck, so the Stella's team decided to drive out to our venue on their own time and meet with our venue coordinator just to make everything work! I thought that was super sweet of them! They did this before we even signed a contract with them!
On the wedding day, they made sure we ate. When me and my husband were taking our couple photos during cocktail hour (which was across the street from the venue) one of their staff members actually walked our appetizers over to us during our photos. They also provided table side service to our sweetheart table during dinner.
Overall, the food was amazing, the people running Stella's are amazing, and I wouldn't have wanted anyone else to cater our big day! -
![Kristen]()
Kristen Sent on 12/19/2023Fantastic Caterer!
Stella's was stellar ;) Honestly, we wanted a laid-back, delicious caterer with amazing food and a great staff, and we got everything and more! We learned about Stella's through our venue, Milagro Winery, and I'm so glad we took their vendor rec and booked with them. We initially almost went with another pizza vendor, however learning everything that Stella's offers, plus the customer service upfront working with Amy and the team really won us over. The value is great, the tasting experience was scrumptious, and we are so pleased we booked with Stella's. They went above and beyond, and our guests are still raving about their pizzas (get the fig fantastico!). All in all, hiring Stella's to cater our wedding was a cornerstone in the success of the entire day. Thank you SO much to their entire team. We'd recommend them a million times over. -
-
![Mary]()
Mary Sent on 12/05/2023Over delivered and under paid
You might be questioning this review title. This vendor over delivered, and I would have paid a heck of a lot more for the service and quality food provided. All I can say is wow!!! They wowed our entire company with incredible customer service, delicious and plentiful food. I had many team members tell me this was the best corporate party ever. Thank you, Vito and Sara Romani and the entire staff, for going above and beyond to serve 300 people hot food. No easy task. -
Natalie Sent on 09/20/2023
Amazing experience with Stella's Pizza Pie
We hired Stella's Pizza Pie for a very important event we were hosting at our home. They were professional from the moment we were considering them during the bidding process to the execution day. They delivered on everything they promised and the food and presentation was phenomenal. Despite some challenges with rain, they were flexible and understanding and worked with us to find solutions that highlighted their food and service and still made for a good party flow. Their staff at the party were also great and brought good attitudes and smiling faces. I highly recommend them for your upcoming events! -
-
![Michael]()
Michael Sent on 08/12/2022Amazing food and service
Food was delicious, and service was impeccable! We, did not have to look far for food. The server were constantly nearby with a passed Hors d’oeuvres. The pizza has prepared fresh in a pizza oven brought to the house. The guest really enjoyed the taste and show. Most, importantly the staff did a great job cleaning up after themselves!
In a nut shell, this is a good catering company. -
![William]()
William Sent on 07/25/2022Pleasure to work with and great food!
Stella's was very responsive and went above and beyond to make our day special. When a supplier ran out of our requested plates, the Stella team went out and found them for us. They also accommodated some last minute menu changes for vegan and gluten free guests. We would definitely recommend this company! -
![Penny]()
Penny Sent on 07/17/2022Great wedding dinner!
We loved working with Stella's Pizza Pie for our wedding at Sacred Mountain Julian! Communication from day one (big shout out to Amy, their Client Services Manager) was absolutely wonderful. She always answered my questions in a timely manner, and made everything SO clear. We loved the tasting we attended months before our wedding to choose what we wanted on the menu... it was tough to choose because everything was SO good. Our guests really enjoyed the pizza and passed appetizers at our outdoor summer wedding, and Stella's made it look classy. We also loved the fruit infused water station they provided. Overall such a great experience with Stella's Pizza Pie, and we'd highly recommend them for any event! -
-
Samantha Sent on 06/08/2022
The caterer of your dreams!
We recommend Stella's so, so highly! The hype is real, folks. Working with Amy, Gina, and the whole crew was a true highlight of our wedding day (and in the months of planning).
They provide service par excellence, from the moment you contact them to the last pizza they serve. In addition to the food being the best I've ever had at a wedding (if I may say so myself), they really are a joy to work with.
Some absolute must-haves:
* Mama Gigi’s Scampi (we had as an appetizer)
* Charcuterie board (such an amazing, sweeping presentation - just like you're in Tuscany!)
* The Fig Fantastico (pizza)
* Mimi’s Dolce Extravaganza
On a side note - I would also highly recommend doing a taste test -- so much fun, and we left so full. Thank you, Amy and Gina! -
-
![Katelyn]()
Katelyn Sent on 05/21/2022Exceptional experience
We chose Stella's because of the personable experience we received right off the bat - and that they continued to deliver over the course of the planning process. Not only do they use fresh ingredients and family recipes, the food is delicious - you feel the family energy and love in what they do! Guests loved it, and the food was something I was looking forward to most in our wedding day. Stella's did not disappoint, worked with us through TWO postponements and were kind the entire way through. Highly recommend - can't say enough positive things! (I low key already want another party they can cater!) -
![Sasia]()
Sasia Sent on 11/11/2021More than a caterer
Where do I even begin? I wish there was an option for more than five stars. Amy, Vito, Gina, and the whole family is just a class act. My husband and I chose Stella's Pizza for our wedding, through Milagro Winery. This was the best decision we could have made. We wanted something different for our food and we wanted a memorable experience. We wanted to make sure that our guests left full and pleased with our food. All night we heard about how amazing the food was and saw line after line getting seconds and thirds. Not only did this entire family take care of us through planning a pandemic wedding, their food was the best food we have ever had. From the tasting that we did not want to leave, to a year later, stuffing our faces at our wedding, we were in amazement of Stella's.
Besides the insane amount of delicious choices you're given, to curate your perfect event, this family cares about you. Amy made time to check in on my family through a tough COVID situation with my brother, at the end of 2020. 24 hours before the wedding, Amy and Gina rallied together and saved our dessert bar that was provided by another company. They were ready to go purchase platters and stands, between their two weddings they had booked, so that we had the display of our dreams. And Vito, wow. This man and his team are some of the kindest and hardest working people we know. After putting out hot pizza after hot pizza, Vito stayed and helped clean up the venue with us. We talked, laughed, and discussed how we will be coming to more tastings as proof of all of the good that comes from Stella's...and for more yummy food of course. The entire Stella's team made us feel loved in so many ways. We chose a company to feed our wedding and gained friends, wedding planners, family, and a preffered caterer for life.
An infinite amount of thank you's just isn't enough to show our gratitude for Stella's Pizza Pie. -
Andrea Sent on 10/25/2021
Treated like family!
Stella's is the definition of a family run business. They welcome you in and you know that this is a catering company that has your back every step of the way. Stella's was my favorite vendor to work with. Amy was so understanding when my indecision got in the way and was compassionate when walking me through the logistics of their services and sharing her expertise and advice. The food tasting was at their home and they gave us a clear snapshot of appetizers, main courses, and dessert options of which we could choose from. There wasn't even a second choice for us. We knew we had to use Stella's.
At the wedding, guests absolutely raved about the charcuterie appetizer. Stella's went above and beyond and rolled out two tables worth of charcuterie for guests to enjoy! It was a bride's dream to have her guests so well fed in cocktail hour alone!! The main course of artisanal pizzas were perfect for dinner (a selection of 4 continuous pizzas) and we were able to satisfy everyone's dietary restrictions. It kept the dinner light but satisfying! For weeks after the wedding, guests were talking about how well organized the catering was, how kind the staff were, and how awesome it was to have pizza at a wedding. No rubbery chicken at this event!! Stella's was by far the easiest vendor to work with and the one that made the biggest impression. Book your catering with Stella's. You won't regret it! -
-
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 10/24/2021Above and beyond experience with Stella's!
Booking with Stella's was by far one of the easiest and most rewarding decisions my husband and I made for our wedding. They were such a dream to work with, and a special shout out to Amy Zinman who took such good care of us during all our planning phases! She was incredibly prompt with her communication, helpful, and so sweet. And the food is absolutely incredible! Out of this world, truly. Serving delicious food at our wedding was high on my husband's priority list, and the moment we had a sampling of their pizzas and appetizers, we knew they'd make the perfect fit. It was a fun experience for our guests too, to have so many choices at the buffet table and receive hot, fresh pizza! I can't recommend them enough. We were incredibly satisfied with our experience with them and would not hesitate to book with them again for any sort of future event! -
![JT Heglund]()
Jt Heglund Sent on 03/06/2020Best food for the Best Day Ever
The experience that we had with Stella's Pizza Pie truly cannot be beat. From the way they handled the business side of things to the incredible customer service, to most importantly the DELICIOUS food they provided, we would get married again JUST to have Stella's cater our big day. Seriously, we still crave the fig pizza and the hand made croutons on the ceasar salad and did I mention the meatballs? Everything is simply divine. Choose them to cater your big day; You AND your guests will NOT be disappointed. -
-
![katelyn]()
Katelyn Sent on 01/15/2020Amazing Job!
Stella's did a great job at our wedding. Vito and his family are so helpful and kind. They were always accommodating to our needs and they were very easy to get ahold of. We got multiple complements from our guests as well! -
![Hayley]()
Hayley Sent on 12/20/2019The catered my wedding and everyone LOVED THE FOOD!
Working with Vito and his team at Stella's was an ABSOLUTE pleasure! The pizzas were incredible and the apps still have our friends and family raving. It was one of the highlights of our wedding for sure! The best part? Vito asked which pizza my husband and I wanted and made sure that he set them aside for us in a little pizza box to ensure that we had some. Being the bride and groom, we barely got to eat anything during the actual wedding...so when we got to our hotel room that night, we had a delicious snack. A PRICELESS moment! Thanks to the whole Stella's team, from Amy to Vito and everyone in between. You won't regret booking this vendor because who doesn't LOVE pizza? Especially GREAT pizza? -
![Adriana]()
Adriana Sent on 07/31/2019The Bride wants fig pizza, please! :)
Where do I start? As soon as we got to our food tasting we felt like we were with family. This family owned business is extremely loving, make you feel comfortable, and are extremely flexible with all your needs for you special day. With communications and questions, they provided rapid responses! I highly recommend them for those reasons but they food is truly one of kind; its as if you can taste the family owned recipes with every bite. The meatballs and shrimp scampi was our choices of apps and we can't pick which was our favorite but between the Fig Pizza and the Volcano, please don't skip out on tasting these. I actually wish that Stella's had a restaurant just so I could have fig pizza often! Let me not forget that as the bride, I had a tree nut allergy and once I told them once, it was all over the documents! They made sure that everything was nut free, it just made me feel trusting of them that I didn't have to worry about anything. Oh and one more thing, they also have an option of an ice cream bar, and it was a picture touch for us foodies! Just everything, from beginning to end, it was perfect! Thanks again Stella's! -
![Jordan]()
Jordan Sent on 03/26/2019Awesome Food
We used to Stellas for our wedding this past weekend and boy was that a wonderful decision! The guests raved about our appetizers, pizza, and cannolis! Everything was delicious and no one left hungry!!! The staff was friendly but focused on the job at hand and I’m just so pleased with the entire experience. Amy was my contact leading up to the day and was an absolute joy to work with. Thank you for everything. It was perfect. -
![Kelly]()
Kelly Sent on 11/02/2018Absolutely loves Stella’s Pizza Pie!
Stella’s pizza pie was one of those vendors that we booked a year in advance of our wedding and it made us wish our wedding was sooner! Vito, Amy and Gina are all absolutely fantastic to work with. They let us do a full tasting of pretty much anything we wanted on the menu. Their pricing is very budget-friendly and our guests absolutely RAVED about the food! We did the passed appetizers during cocktail hour, salad and pizza. My only regret was not eating more myself! I hope to have another event in the future where I can hire them because we just absolutely loved it!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?