Nantucket Bake Shop Reviews
12 Reviews
Rated
4.9
out of 5.0
Recommended by 99% of couples
Awards
4 User photos
-
Phoebe H. Married on 09/12/2020
Best of the best!
I grew up visiting The Nantucket Bake shop and when it came to find a bakery for our wedding cake, we immediately reached out to Magee. We did do a couple other tastings as well, but our experience in the kitchen of the bake shop with Magee quickly rose to the top. She is so accommodating, family-oriented, welcoming and talented! She made us the most delicious naked carrot cake with cream cheese frosting and fresh berries that blew us away. We and our guests are still talking about how delicious it was. There was none leftover because everyone was so amazed with how good it was! We are now connecting with her to make us a small version of the same cake to celebrate our 1st year anniversary. -
-
User2106912 2+ years agoSo nice and easy to work with. Cake was beautiful and delicious!!! -
User2111528 2+ years agoMagee and her crew literally put the icing on the cake for our fantastic wedding weekend on Nantucket. The cake (carrot cake with cranberries) was beautiful, made to exacting specifications and, most importantly, was utterly delicious. Raves from all of the guests!
Thanks for making our day really special! -
User2218354 2+ years agoThe Nantucket Bakeshop was extremely helpful throughout the wedding planning process. The owners took time out of their day to meet with us and even set up the dessert's beautifully the day of our ceremony. I would recommend them to anyone! -
User2098923 2+ years agoI asked Nantucket Bake Shop to recreate my grandparents cake and they did a fabulous job! I wanted a classic, delicious cake and that is exactly what we got! We were able to taste different flavor combinations of cake and filling, all of which were delicious. If you want great value and excellent service hire Nantucket Bake Shop for your next event!
-
User2130375 2+ years agoThe Nantucket Bake Shop made our dream cake for our wedding! I had a very specific design that I wanted (including some candy "bubbles" that I wanted incorporated into the design), and Magee was more than happy to work with me to make the cake absolutely perfect. We had so many comments at our wedding on how beautiful the cake was. And, it was scrumptious, too! Deliciously balanced flavor and texture! I highly recommend this shop for all your baked-goods needs! -
User2132965 2+ years agoBeautiful and delicious cake!
-
User2130948 2+ years agoThe cake I requested was prepared exactly to my request and was delicious! A big hit with all of my guests.
-
User2099618 2+ years agoThe bakery was great: The tasting was a lot of fun and there were lots of yummy cakes to choose from. Everyone was very sweet and helpful. The cake looked beautiful and just how we requested. The only downside was the taste of the actual cake we received. The cakes at the tasting were moist and delish, but the wedding cake was dry and the icing was different than what we sampled.
Are you interested?
Send a message