Molly's Cupcakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Emily]()
Emily Sent on 02/25/2025Amazing Cake and Cupcakes for Our Wedding
We used Molly's Cupcakes for our wedding cake and cupcakes in 2024. My husband and I lived near them and had their cupcakes before and didn't even consider anything else. The process for using them for our wedding was an absolute breeze. The cupcakes were a huge hit for our guests and the cake was delicious. I would definitely recommend Molly's Cupcakes. -
![Jess]()
Jess Sent on 09/09/2024Molly’s Forever
Late review here, but we had our wedding cake made by Molly’s for our wedding on 9/16/23! It only made sense for us to have Molly’s as our first and only thought of an option to do our cake because Molly’s actually holds a very memorable place in our hearts since we’ve been getting Molly’s cupcakes since our college days when we first met!—& pretty sure we’ve tried every flavor from them and have never had one we disliked, so we knew a cake would be a hit with our guests!
The communication and process to get the cake we wanted was so quick, easy, and flawless as we worked with Yaritza! We got a 3 tiered cake, along with 2 extra half sheets, with flavors in our favorites (peach purée filling with vanilla cake for the bottom and top tiers, chocolate buttercream filling with vanilla cake for the middle tier) all covered in white buttercream frosting with a simple border because we wanted it to be decked out with fresh florals from our florist! Delivery of the cake was also so easy to set up and coordinate with our venue coordinator! & costs were well within our budget!
We wanted to make sure we had a wedding cake that we wanted to enjoy and for our guests to enjoy, & Molly’s certainly fulfilled that! We got so many compliments on the cake on how delicious it was and how it’s not often wedding cake is actually THAT good—we even had guests ask if they can take home extra slices! Even to this day, we have guests who still remember the cake! Overall, we would choose Molly’s to do our cake over and over again if we could! But at least now for every anniversary, we can always get cupcakes from them to always remember our wedding day! Thank you, Molly’s for being a part of our special day! -
-
![Katherine]()
Katherine Sent on 08/21/2024Wedding Cake
My husband and I got married in September of last year and we couldn't be happier with our decision to go with Molly's Cupcake.
The cake tasting process was amazing, fun, and delicious. There are tons of flavors to try from. We ultimately went for a vanilla cake with peach puree filling and a chocolate cake with raspberry filling for our three tiered cake.
Communicating with the coordinator was easy and efficient. Molly's Cupcake delivered the cake carefully to the venue in a timely manner.
Thank you again! -
-
![Mady]()
Mady Sent on 02/11/2024Gorgeous & Tasty Wedding cake!
Molly's made an amazing cake for us that was soooo tasty! We added a topper and flowers and it was just perfect for what we wanted. Thank you Molly's! -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 07/07/2023So delicious!
As soon as we got engaged, I knew that I wanted Molly's to be a part of our special day. Not only are they my favorite cupcakes in Chicago, but they are also one of the very first dates my now husband and I went on. From the minute we reached out, Yaritza was na absolute dream to work with. Courteous and responsive, she answered all of my questions about quantities, flavors and dietary restrictions with ease and grace. Our tasting was wonderful and Yaritza asked great questions about our catering setup and menu, so that we made choices that paired will with our overall menu and so that the frosting wouldn't melt in the unrefrigerated ballroom. When I sent a last minute panicked email about a guest's nut allergy she responded almost immediately to assuage my anxiety. They did all of the setup, and the dessert table looked beautiful. We opted for mini-cupcakes because we wanted our wedding guests to be able to try multiple combinations of cake and frosting. I'm so happy that we went this route! Even now, several weeks after our wedding, guests are STILL complimenting us about how good the cupcakes were. They were such a hit that there was not a single cupcake left at the end of the night. If you're looking for a fun, delicious dessert choice I'd highly recommend going with Molly's! -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 04/03/2023The best there is!
I used Molly's cupcakes for my wedding cake this year and I cannot say enough good things about them! From the beginning of the process, Yaritza made the process so enjoyable and stress-free! She hosted us for a tasting and we had an incredible time talking with her as we asked about our vision for the day to help us pick the perfect size and flavors for our dream cake. We ordered sheet cake on the side for additional servings and it was so gorgeous you really could not tell it was sheet cake. It was truly a dream!
Her team was above and beyond gracious and professional working with my wedding planner and venue to nail down the logistics and delivery for the day. We had my florist add matching flowers to the cake and Mollys Cupcakes was more than accommodating! Truly the cake was gorgeous and their customer service and attention to detail was so appreciated on our big day.
Finally, the cake was DELICIOUS! Everyone at the wedding was complimenting how delicious it was and how gorgeous it looked. I couldn't be happier with our decision to work with Molly's cupcakes and I HIGHLY recommend them to any bride looking for a stress-free, reliable and delicious cake choice! -
-
![Erin]()
Erin Sent on 11/23/2022Amazing cupcakes and cakes
Molly’s has been my go to cupcake place for years, so I went there first when considering cake for my wedding. They did not disappoint. Their wedding coordinator, Yaritza, was so knowledgeable and easy to work with! She even made sure we had a single gluten free cupcake for one of our guests! The cake tasting was super fun and the cupcakes and cake day of were perfection! I highly recommend working with Molly’s for your wedding or next event! -
-
![Theresa]()
Theresa Sent on 01/03/2022Great experience with Molly's cupcakes!
We had the vegan vanilla and vegan chocolate cupcakes at our wedding. Our guests loved them. We worked with Yaritza for the ordering. Great communication. -
![Christine]()
Christine Sent on 11/19/2021Amazing Cupcakes!
Mollys had the best cupcakes and our guests loved them so much!! We ordered more than we planned to and even with our guest count going down we didn’t even have a full dozen left at the end of the night! Our wedding cake was also made by Mollys and was amazing!!! -
![Devon]()
Devon Sent on 09/08/2021Everything was perfect! :)
Words cannot express how much I love Molly's Cupcakes!! I had them cater my wedding and literally everything came out perfect! The communication with staff over the cake designs we wonderful and everyone was seriously so kind. We had a variety of cupcakes and a two tier cake. Everything was delicious and our guests couldn't stop raving about them even weeks after the wedding! Thank you so much for helping to make our special day even more perfect than I could have imagined! :) -
-
![Tejal]()
Tejal Sent on 01/16/2020Highly Recommend!
Our planning process started when we found out that our dream wedding venue would be closing, forcing us to move up our wedding date by nine months. This essentially gave us only 90 days to plan our wedding. When we reached out to Molly’s Cupcakes event team, Kristine was quick to respond. She was so pleasant to work with along with being patient and knowledgeable in answering my many questions. Kristine accommodated my request to add a second tasting at a minimal cost so that my mom and sister could join me and my husband. At the tasting, all staff were prompt and excited to share their product - already being a fan of Molly’s Cupcakes, we weren’t suprised at how delicious everything was. We ultimately decided to go with the 9 inch, 5 layer Creme Brûlée cake, with a semi-naked finish in addition to 125 Creme Brûlée cupcakes. Additionally, Molly’s had vegan and flourless options available which we were able to make single purchases of so all our guests with dietary restrictions could enjoy.
Kristine kept in constant contact in the weeks leading up to our wedding. We connected her with our wedding venue coordinator and both parties assured us that we would not have to worry about anything - delivery by Molly’s (worth the small charge!) and cold storage provided by the venue was seamless.
We received so many compliments that evening and people kept coming back for seconds...and thirds! Our wedding cake was everything we had hoped for and more, perfectly moist, not overwhelmingly sweet, and beautifully made! Almost a year later we still have guests talking about these cupcakes and reminiscing about how delicious they were!
Working with Molly’s was one of the easiest decisions we made and we highly recommend them! -
-
![Zack]()
Zack Sent on 09/26/2019Such Great Cake
My wife and I had been big fans of Molly's for years and were so excited to learn they did full-size cakes for events. The cakes were delicious and affordable, so what more can you ask!? The preliminary tasting was so fun and relaxed that we ended up picking 3 different custom flavor combinations for our 150 guests -- 1 tiered cake for cutting and 2 sheet cakes. Communication was smooth and delivery had no problems out to our farm venue in the Chicago suburbs. So great! -
-
![Jane]()
Jane Sent on 10/21/2018Delicious, beautiful, and affordable
Everything about Molly’s Cupcakes was incredible, from how delicious the cupcakes were to how wonderful the people were to work with! -
-
![Keladriel]()
Kelly Sent on 06/17/2018We picked Molly's Cupcakes for our wedding because they are my favorite bakery in the city! I had a really great experience with them throughout the entire process. The tasting was fun and the ordering, payments, and delivery was very easy. We ordered a 9" cake with assorted flavors of cupcakes and mini-cupcakes. Everyone loved the desserts so much that my husband and I barely got to eat any ourselves. There wasn't even anything left at the end of the night to take home! -
-
![hazelgrace]()
Theresa Sent on 02/10/2018Love Molly's cupcakes. They were my favorite when I lived in NYC and I was delighted to find out their original location was in Chicago, which meant we could get their cupcakes for our wedding. Since we were outside of the city, they did not offer setup, but they delivered the cupcakes for a reasonable fee and our caterer set them up for us. They are SO delicious. My favorite is the creme brûlée, and the guests were raving about it as well. -
Shayna Sent on 07/27/2022
So Delicious!
We loved the cake (and experience) so much that we're coming back for our anniversary! So delicious and absolutely beautiful. We highly recommend Molly's Cupcakes to anyone looking for cakes in the area. -
-
Paige Sent on 10/01/2019
Delicious cake, easy to work with, fairly priced
We got a Molly's cake for our wedding (ended up doing one large tiered cake with a few half sheets). From the tasting to the wedding day delivery, their team was professional and easy to work with (one less thing to worry about, am I right?).
I had several wedding guests come up to me or tell me later that the cake was amazing. We were going to save the top layer for our anniversary but my husband dipped into it the day after our wedding. Too good to save. -
-
Kathleen Sent on 03/24/2019
Seamless and Fun
We used Molly's Cupcakes for our wedding cake and to have cupcakes for our sweets table. Kristine was great with communicating and made the process from tasting to ordering seamless. They were flexible even when we wanted to make changes to the order. For our cake we chose for the 9 inch creme brulee and requested it be a naked cake. Not only did it look beautiful but guests kept asking me about it weeks after and admitted they may have overindulged at the sweets table as there wasn't a bite left within the first hour of it being served. I would use Molly's again and will find an excuse to have that cake made any chance I'd get. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?