Maggie's Bakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Meredith]()
Meredith Sent on 11/13/2024Our cake was perfect!
It was EXACTLY what we asked for and tasted amazing! Drop off at the resort was seamless. -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 06/05/2024May 2024 Wedding
Maggie is amazing! She is so kind and was willing to make us an extra little cake to save for our one year anniversary and hold it until we returned from our honeymoon. The cake was delicious along with her brownies/cookies. The cake was beautiful and turned out exactly has we had envisioned it. -
![Kelsey]()
Kelsey Sent on 03/18/2024Delicious!
Maggie and her team did the dessert for our wedding a couple weeks ago. We went with a dessert table and had mini cupcakes, key lime tart
tarts, and cheesecake shooters. Every single one was delicious! The presentation looked amazing. I highly recommend! -
-
![Katy]()
Katy Sent on 10/13/2023Magnificent Maggie!
Maggie creates the most scrumptious, delicious, and beautiful dessert spreads! She was so kind and welcoming when we stopped by for our tasting, instantly bringing the best vibes. Then we tried her cakes and the vibes got even BETTER! She worked closely with us to craft the perfect dessert table: a 2-tiered cake, mini cupcakes of different flavors, key lime tarts, gluten free panna cotta shooters, and even vegan cupcakes...all at an incredibly reasonable price. She also worked with us to adjust the amounts we needed based on our response rate, rather than just charging us whatever amount we initially estimated. Our guests raved about how tasty her desserts were, and we were just so happy to have such an amazing and sweet experience :) Thank you Maggie! -
![Sandra]()
Sandra Sent on 10/11/2023Let them eat cake!
Maggie was very accommodating and made the cake process simple! We went with the key lime flavor covered with cream cheese frosting!!
Maggie went out of her way to provide samples and make sure we felt comfortable with our decision. She also did her best to make the cake to my liking, adding details like cake height. She provided me options and delivered exactly as promised!
I ordered cake pops, macaroons, and other treats which I heard were delicious! Thank you Maggie!! -
![Kayla]()
Kayla Sent on 05/20/2023Beautiful and delicious!
We absolutely loved our dessert bar at our wedding! It has almost been two weeks and the guests are still raving about the mini key lime tarts! Absolutely beautiful display. Thank you! -
![Lauren]()
Lauren Sent on 04/27/2023Amazing Cake and Cupcakes!
Maggie's make cupcakes for my welcome party as well as my wedding cake. She had awesome flavors to choose from and even a gluten free dessert option for one of my guests. She was so great to work with and my cake turned out even better than my inspiration photo. Everything was on time and perfect! We saved our top tier for our anniversary! -
-
![Alison]()
Alison Sent on 04/14/2023Cake was beautiful and tasted great!
Maggie was very helpful during the whole process. We made changes a few times and she was very responsive and professional throughout the whole process. The cake not only looked beautiful but it also tasted great! I highly recommend using Maggie at your next event -
-
83F3E1Fa19993B3A041Bf4E9D5Bae752129E14A2 Sent on 04/13/2023
Beautiful cake
If you’re searching for a very responsive bakery , I highly recommend! We chose the Key lime cake with key lime icing and it was absolutely delicious! Maggie made our cake look exactly like the Pinterest board I shared with her. She allowed me to bring my own handmade flowers and cake stand purchased from Etsy! Thank you so much Maggie for the beautiful wedding cake and being a part of our special day! ❤️ -
-
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 03/21/2023Very delicious!
Very delicious, she dropped off our cake and cupcakes, and set up. Very quick, she was very good at response time!! -
![Kathryn]()
Kathryn Sent on 02/22/2023The best cake ever
Maggie’s Bakery was great to work with and the cake was beautiful and delicious! -
-
Taylor Sent on 11/19/2022
Perfect experience!
I booked Maggie for my wedding at Coral Beach on 11/15/2022 and she was amazing! She was so super easy and kind to work with. I sent her a picture of the cake that I wanted and it looked the exact same day off as the inspiration picture. Not to mention the cake was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS and so were the cupcakes. I’ve never tasted cake icing as good as that! 🥰 in the future I would most definitely book Ms. Maggie again! -
-
![Carolina]()
Carolina Sent on 10/27/2022Best cake & most beautiful cake
I just had my wedding on 10.20.2022. I just have to mention that my cake was the best cake I have tasted. My guests were praising and saying how delicious my wedding cake was. I am so grateful for Maggies Bakery because she also made my cake look exactly how I envisioned it. It was so beautiful. Even doing the cake tasting a long time ago she made it so fun! We had a great time with our cake tasting and she made it so organized, fun and easy. We enjoyed the whole experience. It was just so beautiful and soooo delicious. I highly recommend Maggies Bakery.
Thank you so much! -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 09/28/2022Best cake I have ever had!
I had to order a dairy-free cake, which is usually a pain because I don't like being "that customer," but I just can't eat the stuff. We got a Pina Colada cake, with coconut icing and pineapple cake (no coconut flakes). Let me tell you this was the best cake I have ever had in my life! We purposely ordered a cake that was too large to save some for the next day and ordered fresh flowers from the florist. The guests were all raving about the cake and there were even people who don't usually eat coconut talking about how great the cake was. We pulled out the leftover cake the next day and guests were bombarding the cake stand. I cook professionally and I was so impressed! We also ordered a donut bar and they were just as delicious and lasted us the few days we were at our venue. Order from Maggie's Bakery! 10/10 -
-
![Samantha]()
Samantha Sent on 07/12/2022Wedding Cake of My Dreams!
Maggie's Bakery is the absolute best! We had a tasting in the spring and the cupcakes and icings were phenomenal. They were so delicious that we actually had her ship us another tasting for our one month anniversary! For our wedding, we ordered a 2-tier cake and 6 dozen mini cupcakes. Our guests were raving about the cake/cupcakes and said it was the best wedding cake they've ever had! We definitely agree! On top of tasting amazing, our cake was unbelievably beautiful! Our cake topper we had ordered on Etsy didn't arrive on time, so she was able to help us out by using flowers from our florist to make our cake absolutely beautiful! Additionally, we were getting married on my uncle's birthday, so she also made us a personal birthday cake for him! We are so grateful for everything she did for us. Truly amazing service and absolutely delicious cake! -
-
![Sheena]()
Sheena Sent on 06/28/2022Extremely talented wedding cake designer and baker
Maggies is not only the sweetest woman ever, but she is also so extremely talented! We gave her a few pictures of intricate designs from a few different cakes we saw on pinterest and around the web. She met with us during our tasting and explained all the different options and styles. She made us a breathtaking cake that made us cry when we saw it on our wedding day. It was perfect. Thank you, Maggie!!!! -
-
Beth Sent on 05/24/2022
The Best in Key Largo, FL
We booked Maggie because another bride recommended her and she did not disappoint! Our cake was so delicious and it was dropped off on time with the cake stand we rented. We got a naked 2 tier cake the Key Lime favor and our guest loved it! -
-
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 05/16/2022Better than my vision!
Maggie was my third baker and she was definitely a charm! Situations happened with two other bakers, so I was hesitant it wouldn’t workout. I never was able to visit to meet Maggie and taste test anything. I have nothing but nice things to say about her and her business! From the beginning she has been very efficient, responsive, and a pleasure! I sent her a picture of what I desired my cake to look like. The picture only had a small coconut on it, she decorated the cake with two small pieces and a half of a coconut. On top of bringing two palm leaves to go under our other dessert plates. The setup was absolutely gorgeous, thank you again!! Sara -
-
![Erin]()
Erin Sent on 04/17/2022The BEST Cakes in the Keys (vegan + regular)
I was referred to Maggie's Bakery when I was looking to order some vegan cupcakes for my wedding (I wasn't having cake at all and already had a dessert order places elsewhere). Well, everyone seemed to have a birthday around my wedding so a simple vegan cupcake order turned into needing also a vegan cake, a regular cake, and many regular cupcakes as well for the wedding weekend. EVERY SINGLE ITEM was delicious. They were decorated perfectly (I didn't give her a lot to go on lol), they were priced so well... I honestly wish I lived closer so I could order myself a cake to eat in my daily life lol. I (obviously) recommend Maggie's Bakery 100%. -
![Marci]()
Marci Sent on 04/07/2022The best wedding cake ever
The wedding cake Maggie made for us was the most delicious cake I've ever tasted - and I don't even really like cake!! Maggie was super accommodating with our request for a vegan wedding cake and let me tell you, no one could tell it was vegan. It was a frosted rum cake and was rich, moist, and seriously SO good. We ate the leftovers every day for a week!! We also got a bunch of mini-desserts from Maggie that everyone raved about. On top of the quality, Maggie is such a sweetheart. Our phone calls and email correspondence were always a highlight of my day because she is such a genuinely lovely person. Response times can be a little slow, but that's just because it's a small operation so don't let it worry you. I highly, highly recommend Maggie's Bakery! -
-
![Jacob]()
Jacob Sent on 04/06/2022LOVED the cake and the vendor!
Maggie was so wonderful and sweet, such a great vendor for our wedding! Back when we did the tasting, Maggie gave us so many wonderful options to mix and match during COVID, letting us take a do-it-yourself box back to the hotel. She then worked with us to make the perfect design and flavor combination for our wedding. She was great at communicating, affordable, and the cake tasted AMAZING! -
-
April Sent on 04/05/2022
Soo delicious!!
Maggie was amazing!! She took my vision and excelled!! Not to mention, the taste was too delicious! She had the job of not only the main cake but the grooms cake and a special birthday cake for our ring bearer. All looked and tasted amazing!! -
-
![Alan]()
Alan Sent on 03/14/2022Delicious and Beautiful!
Our wedding cake was beautiful and was so delicious! They were able to recreate a cake that we found online and we ended up choosing to do it in key lime flavor with cream cheese frosting. Thanks for our cake, it was amazing! -
![Laura]()
Laura Sent on 01/19/2022So sweet and easy to work with!
Maggie was so sweet, responsive, easy and fun to work with! Her cakes are absolutely delicious and she makes the whole process so fun, positive, upbeat and exciting. She offered a cake tasting box to-go so we could taste on our own time, which was so fun and delicious. We loved the vanilla cake with fresh raspberry frosting. We even asked her to bump up the raspberry flavor by adding more fresh raspberries between the cake layers and she did it no problem. The cake was stunning and everyone said it was delicious! We had her make key lime tarts also, which were just gorgeous (little graham cracker cups, so cute!) and so yummy! Hiring Maggie will make your life so easy and she'll produce amazing desert all with a smile and positive attitude! -
-
Falon Sent on 12/29/2021
Ms. Maggie!!!
I am so happy I decided to hire Maggie for my wedding desserts!!! She was professional, kind, friendly & obviously magical. Maggie worked closely with me from the beginning of my planning to give me exactly what I wanted! I ordered a small semi naked cake, 4 dozen glazed donuts & 4 dozen cake pops (vanilla, Chocolate & key lime flavor). Unfortunately I didn't get to meet the women behind the magic but I wish I had. EVERYTHING WAS BEAUTIFUL & PERFECT!!!!
Thank you so much Maggie ❤️ -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 11/20/2021Maggie’s Bakery
The icing on this cake was sooooo silky. It was delicious and so beautiful. Exactly what I was going for when I sent Maggie the picture! They delivered on time and put the flowers on it too! I even saved some to freeze for my one year anniversary. The cake was a hit and the chocolate was so so so good! -
-
Nicole Sent on 09/19/2021
Gorgeous cake
Not only was my wedding cake delicious and stunning, but Maria was wonderful to work with. Very responsive and willing to help any way she could. -
-
![Jodi]()
Jodi Sent on 09/06/2021Amazing Wedding Cake
Maggie did an amazing job on our special request wedding cake. Both my bride and I have major allergies to food, which did not stop Maggie! She made the most AMAZING, gluten free, dairy free and tree nut free Coconut Rum wedding cake ever! And it was absolutely beautiful, exactly what we had envisioned. To top it all off she provided our guests with 5 different dessert choices as well! We highly recommend Maggie for any baked needs. -
-
Amy V. Sent on 08/25/2021
Nailed It!
I LOVE Maggie! Even though we never met in person – she was absolutely FANTASTIC and she designed the EXACT wedding cake I had envisioned. It was absolutely beautiful and delicious! She also made additional dessert options for our guests (key lime tarts, chocolate & caramel shooters, white chocolate key lime cookies) and at the last minute – gluten free chocolate cupcakes! If you are getting married in the Florida Keys, and are looking for a baker – look no further and hire Maggie! You will not be disappointed! Thank you, Maggie – for everything!♥
~ Amy & Damon -
-
![Jenna]()
Jenna Sent on 08/19/2021Beautiful wedding cake
We ordered a two tier wedding cake. Key lime flavor was SO good. Thank you so much! It was beautiful -
-
![Brooke]()
Brooke Sent on 06/10/2021Maggie is the Sweetest!
Maggie was such a joy to work with! She brought our vision of a dessert arrangement to life and even created special apple pie tarts to pair with delicious cheesecake bites & other tasty desserts. She was easy to communicate with and responded quickly to questions. Our cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing. I would recommend working with Maggie’s Bakery to anyone planing a florida keys wedding! -
-
![Brandi]()
Brandi Sent on 05/20/2021Delicious and Beautiful
Maggie was amazing to work with. So sweet and caring. She listened and she succeeded in giving us exactly what we wished for. -
-
![Sonya]()
Sonya Sent on 05/18/2021Sweetest, best baker!
We loved Maggie! What an amazing person!! We actually did a tasting months before and she made sure it was ready for us super early in the morning...the cake however, was So much better than the tasting! It was absolutely amazing. I sent her a few photos and she made the cake exactly how we wanted it. She made sure the cake flowers and everything was perfect! Can't thank you enough Maggie, we will be getting more cakes from you in the future!! -
-
Sherri Sent on 05/05/2021
Beautiful wedding cake for my wedding at Key Largo Lighthouse.
Well we had our beautiful destination wedding last week in Key Largo. I was from out of town so was not able to go and visit or taste the cake. I loved working with Maggie I showed her a few pictures of what i wanted and everything was perfect.
She also made special starfish cookies for our guests and everything tasted amazing. -
-
![Margaret]()
Margo Sent on 10/20/2020Maggie is Amazing!
We hired Maggie back in February just before Covid hit and shut down the world. She's been amazing since day one. She brought our vision to life.
On the day we met her for our tasting, she suggested a variety of flavors and we added one flavor combination that no one had ever requested of her and it was a "shot in the dark" flavor on our part as well. (Strawberry with Passionfruit icing).
The cutting cake was beautiful and the cupcakes delicious (Key Lime with Key Lime icing / Strawberry with Passionfruit icing). Everyone who tried them, loved it.
*all photo credits go to Barbara Knowles Wedding photography (Richard Knowles) -
-
![Sheena]()
Sheena Sent on 04/03/2020Beautiful and Delicious
Maggie's cake/cupcakes were Amazing!!! Beautiful and SO delicious! We live in GA and made a trip down to visit our venue/vendors prior to our wedding. Maggie had several options of cake and icing to choose from and pictures to help us decide how we wanted our wedding cake to look. We may have to make a trip down to Key Largo each year for our anniversary just so I can have some of Maggie's Bakery! Highly recommend! -
![Silje]()
Silje Sent on 03/24/2020Creative wedding/donut cake
Maggie made our day amazing. She was so sweet and understanding about the stress with planning from far away. Our donut wedding cake combo was amazing and everybody loved it.
-
![Tayler]()
Tayler Sent on 01/22/2020Absolutely great!
She is so easy to work with. She took my ideas and turned them into an amazing creation. She delivered my cake and I didn’t have to worry about anything!! -
-
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 09/28/2019Such taste!
Loved our cake so much! Our guests could not stop raving about it! We did Key Lime with Cream Cheese Frosting -- OMG! I want more now! Thank you Maggie and Team! -
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 05/07/2019Great experience and amazing cakes!
We loved working with Maggie! We asked for a custom flavor for our cake and she was very accommodating in trying a new recipe out and making it perfect for our wedding. She was so sweet and personable during the tasting and very adaptable when I requested a custom grooms cake at the last minute. We highly recommend Maggie's Bakery for your next big event or wedding! -
![Sharon]()
Sharon Sent on 04/24/2019Absolutely Fantastic.
I sent Maggie's bakery a picture of what i wanted and it was perfect. Simply beautiful. It tasted wonderful too. Very creative and would highly recommend them for your cakes. -
-
![Christina]()
Christina Sent on 04/15/2019Wonderful to work with!!
Maggie was wonderful to work with. We unfortunately were not able to go to taste anything or meet with her prior to our wedding but her communication was great and even made us canoli filling cake!! She sent us a hand drawn example of what we described we wanted and loved that. We wanted something simple but she made it look wonderful!! It was so good and cannot wait to have our 'anniversary' cake next year! Thank you Maggie!!! -
-
Lauren Sent on 03/27/2019
Maggie is Amazing!
Maggie is fantastic! Everything tasted and looked perfect, and she’s a joy to work with. Highly recommend. -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 03/19/2019Maggie is THE BEST!
I’m so glad we chose Maggie four our wedding cake. The cake was delicious and so moist! I cannot explain how nice and accommodating Maggie was. She was always so quick to respond to my questions via email. This was a destination wedding so communication was key and she delivered. She also made cookies for us as a wedding favor for our guests. I mailed her the personalized stickers for the cookie bags and she put them all together for us. I cannot say enough about Maggie. Love her! -
-
Danielle Sent on 01/31/2019
Maggie is absolutely the best baker!
My husband and I fell in love with Maggie as much as we did her baking. Our wedding cake turned out exactly as we had described, and tasted absolutely amazing. Our guests were such huge fans that we shared the top tier. We'll be visiting Key Largo every year for our anniversary to have Maggie bake us our cake. -
-
Katelyn Sent on 05/26/2018I love Maggie! She was so sweet, so personable; therefore, made the process so personally and made us feel so special. Where do I begin. Not only was my wedding cake absolutely beautiful, a dream, everything I could image. It was delicious, super moist and fresh. She was even accommodating to us as to provide a tasting when we lived out of town.
All my guests were raving it was the best wedding cake they have ever had. We choose coconut key lime cake with fresh raspberry filling and then a layer of chocolate and coconut filling. What a great added detail to our modern tropical theme to our wedding !
MOST RECOMMENDED! -
-
Mollie Sent on 04/28/2018Maggie is a sweet heart. Beings our wedding was destination we were unable to meet, But from emailing prior to wedding I felt trust with her and confident dessert would turn out great! The desserts were indeed a huge hit! She is so easy to work with and great at communicating and responding back via email. I would go with her again any day.
-
-
Mariana Sent on 03/31/2018Maggie’s Bakery was the best experience, service, delivery on time, very tasty cake.
She made the best wedding cake. Maggie thanks for all your creations and that love you put in every detail you do! -
-
Amanda Sent on 03/11/2018I LOVED our wedding cake from Maggie! We met with her for about 30min. to discuss cake options, and from that she designed the perfect cake for our beach wedding. When we met with Maggie, I only had a few requirements for the cake - and asked her to be creative with the design. She did just that! The cake not only looked beautiful and fit perfectly with our theme, it tasted delicious! Our guests raved about the cake as well. I highly recommend Maggie - she is sweet, flexible and loves what she does.
-
-
Anabel Sent on 11/27/2017I absolutely loved my cake. It was beautiful and exactly what I asked for! My family and friends enjoyed it and we had enough to enjoy for a couple days after!
-
-
Alli Sent on 11/17/2017Maggie did an awesome job on my wedding cake. It was exactly what I wanted. I was an out of town bride so everything was through email. I sent her a picture and she gave me a quote. I trusted that it would be great from reviews and my planner. The cake was exactly how I envisioned it. The cake was beautiful, tasty and she delivers. She made everything as easy as possible and she is fairly priced compared to others in the area. Thank you so much Maggie!
-
-
![Dara]()
Dara Sent on 11/01/2021Beautiful and Delicious
Want to thank Maggie on providing a delicious and beautiful cake. It was exactly how I described it to her. Being a destination wedding was extremely hard because we went into things blind. Did not ever taste any of her cakes or know if the flavors were how we thought they would be. I had to take my faith on the reviews and they weren't wrong. All my guests were extremely happy on how the cake tasted. It was simple but elegant being a beach type wedding. This is how we wanted it. The colors matched the Tiffany Blue, Coral and white theme. Please consider Maggie for your cakes. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?