Tasty Creations Caterers Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
![Damian]()
Damian Sent on 12/31/2025Amazing from start to finish!
We had our wedding at Cityview Rooftop in Queens. From our initial consultation with Susanne, to our food tasting, and all in between leading up to our wedding day. Everything was great! The food! Absolutely amazing! Our guests are still talking about it, The Staff, Polite and attentive from start to finish. Tasty Creations is highly recommended if you are looking for a caterer who will give you the attention you deserve, and food that will blow you away! Thanks Joe and team for making our day amazing! -
-
![Domenic]()
Domenic Sent on 12/23/2025Made our Wedding Reception!
Meeting with Susanne at first put our minds at ease for the big day. Then we met Joe and had a tasting that brought our excitement to the next level. I can't say enough about the great food they provided, and I more so, we are truly grateful to Joe and his team for the amazing service, they treated us like family. This is the best team in NY to bring your dreams and expectations to the next level. Thank you so much guys!! -
![Briana]()
Briana Sent on 10/16/2025Best catering team out there!
I cannot express how amazing the catering team was! From start to finish they were kind and professional. My guests not only raved about how delicious the food was but how nice the staff was. Thank you so much for making my day special! -
![Jesse]()
Jesse Sent on 09/24/2025True Professionals and Excellent Service!
We can't say enough about our experience with LCI Caterers. From our first email more than a year before our wedding they were so welcoming, responsive, and warm. Susanne, who was our main contact throughout the process, is tremendously organized and communicative, and Joe and his team are experts in food and hospitality. At our tasting, Joe and Susanne gave us great suggestions to tweak our menu, and welcomed our feedback. Renting table linens and coolers for our bar through them was also a breeze, removing a layer of stress from planning. Not to mention, LCI's rates for their excellent service were more than fair, and we really appreciated their price transparency on their website.
On our wedding day, the food was just as good if not even better than at our tasting. Several guests approached us to give their compliments about the meal, and my family who works in hospitality was particularly impressed by the level of care paid to every detail, down to the sparkling clean silverware. One of the best moments for us was seeing the entree Joe made for our vegan guest, who was nearly moved to tears by how thoughtfully it was prepared!
During cocktail hour, the passed appetizers came out at a steady pace, and I'm pretty sure the last table called was up at the buffet before my wife and I even finished our plates. We spotted plenty of guests going up for seconds, too.
As for the bar, the bartender was friendly and quick, and he executed our signature drinks perfectly. On top of that, it was great to see how seamlessly the LCI team worked with our coordinator and the venue.
Great food was one of the most important aspects of the wedding for us, and LCI more than exceeded our expectations. We can't thank them enough for helping to make our day so special! -
![James]()
James Sent on 09/19/2025Wedding day
Everything about the Taste Creations team was absolutely professional—from the excellent food to the outstanding service and responsiveness. It was truly a pleasure working with them for my wedding, and I couldn’t recommend them more highly -
![Isabella]()
Isabella Sent on 11/06/2024We are so happy we chose LCI!
We are so glad that we chose LCI to cater our October 2024 wedding in Brooklyn. From the very beginning, they were communicative and honest. Their pricing is very fair and the quality is extremely high. So many guests told us how wonderful the food at our wedding was! Thank you LCI! -
Ikiya Sent on 04/16/2024
Incredible!!!
I'm a wedding planner who had previously worked with LCI Caterers for another couple and I loved working with them so much (plus their food was anazing), that I knew I wanted to work with them for my own wedding. They did NOT disappoint! From the moment we booked, they would check in regularly with any upcoming to-do items and were always available to answer our questions. They truly listened during our tasting and had no problem accommodating specific diets and adjustments.
On wedding day, they truly shined. Our wedding was on a windy day at a rooftop venue and we really wanted use of the rooftop, and they made it work. They helped keep our timeline on schedule and everyone RAVED about the food, it was so good!! The staff was super friendly and everything was so seamless with them. Joseph checked in with us to make sure everything was good and that we were good, which we really appreciated. I would absolutely hire them again for anything and will be recommending them to all of my clients!! -
-
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 09/26/2023Don't overthink it - just book with Joe.
Music and food were definitely a priority for our wedding and Joe surpassed any expectation we had in regards to the food and open bar. The process of setting up at the venue was seamless, the food was to die for and the open bar was a success. Joe and his son went above and beyond to make my wife and I happy in every sense of the word. They are so incredibly thoughtful and they truly care about the customer service they are providing. You can taste the passion they have through their incredible food. Everything was so delicious, and everyone at the venue had only great things to say. A text from one of my bridespeople:
"Please save the caterers number. Maybe someday, someone will want to marry me and I can look forward to that chicken again :)"
We had the angel hair pasta - SO GOOD.
Chimichurri steak - AMAZING.
Chicken and chorizo - WOW.
Slow roasted pernil asado - LORD JESUS!
Arroz moro and vegetables - JUST FAB.
Open Bar - A1.
You guys truly made an impact. Thank you for your hard work and dedication! -
![Charlotte]()
Charlotte Sent on 09/14/2023Couldn't have done it without them!
We could not be happier with LCI Caterers, we used them for our wedding in Brooklyn. Joe's food was incredible (received so many compliments, some saying it was the best wedding food they've ever had!) and he and his team were so helpful in getting things ready day of. We were a little disorganized and Joe jumped in at every chance he could to lend a hand, even helping us when we got locked out of one of the bride/groom suites. He helped with some last minute cake decorating adjustments, and probably did so many more things day of I (the bride) don't even know about. The whole team was smiling, helping, and celebrating with us the entire event. Susan was amazing with all my questions (of which there were many) leading up the wedding, answered in the speediest fashion every time, and was so informative. Getting to get to know Joe and Susan during the tasting was so fun and just made us all the more excited about the day. What a wonderful team!! So many things come included with the price, hors d'oeuvres, linens, glassware.. which is so hard to find! And we got all our rentals through them, so easy to just have all in one vendor. Could not recommend them highly enough. -
-
![Stephan]()
Stephan Sent on 09/03/2023Excellent experience with LCI
We had an overwhelmingly positive and satisfactory experience with LCI as our wedding caterers. I found them to be incredibly flexible - we wanted a mostly vegetarian menu for our wedding and Joe and Susanne were happy to accommodate - we even converted some entree ideas to appetizers and LCI handled it. I was impressed by their setup presentation - our wedding was at a rooftop venue that was also a soccer facility, and LCI arranged the lounge into an unexpectedly tidy and upscale buffet. Last but not least, Joe and Susanne were a dream to work with from the start. They were clear and friendly in all of our communications, and on the day the entire staff was warm and professional. Joe worked our wedding, and made us plates and saw to it that we were taken care of. You can tell they are proud of their work and it really reinforced the joy of the occasion. We’re grateful to LCI and would recommend them without reservation to anyone planning a wedding in NYC. It was also a great value for 100 guests! Also their staff set up and took down our rental tables! -
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 06/27/2023Incredible Caterer in the NYC Area!
LCI was the absolute perfect partner for our wedding day. They helped us to develop an amazing family style menu for our 200+ guests. They were flexible and responsive to all of our questions. All of our guests just loved the food and raved about how attentive the service was from Joe's Team! We couldn't recommend them enough if you are getting married in the NYC area. -
![Christine]()
Christine Sent on 12/04/2022The Tastiest Food Around!
When our original wedding caterer canceled less than 6 months shy of our wedding, we were stressed to find a replacement. Where would we find the type of cuisine we were hoping for? Luckily we found LCI caterers and our hopes and ideas of what we'd like for our wedding were met and exceeded! Joe and his team at LCI caterers were incredible from start to finish. We eagerly met him and his team for a tasting in the summer before our wedding and his food completely blew us away! His options to choose from were vast and his expertise was impressive. Susanne helped us every step of the way, answering questions, taking our calls and easing our fears whenever they arose. Not only did they cater, but they helped us with all our rentals and helped us create the wedding of our dreams. The tables were gorgeous and they set up everything for our venue perfectly. Our guests are still talking about the wedding and the delicious food. Unfortunately we haven't gotten our professional photos back and don't have any family photos of the food, but we do have a few of the table settings that they set for us. If you're thinking about hiring LCI for your event, don't hesitate! -
-
![Shanaz]()
Shanaz Sent on 04/07/2022Delicious food, quality service
Joe and Susanne are absolutely awesome. Everyone loved the food. Joe's able to cook a variety of cuisines so we were able to have South Asian, American, and French dishes. Unfortunately, we were way too pumped to eat at the wedding but luckily we had an amazing tasting session with Joe. We left so full and with a ton of leftovers.
LCI staff at the event were very friendly. Delicious food, quality service and great vibes all around!!! Also, during the process, I had a million questions and every time I emailed Susanne, she was always so responsive and answered every single one of my questions. The team is absolutely fantastic. We're glad we hired them!! -
![Lindsay]()
Lindsay Sent on 10/11/2021LCI can't be beat!
Joe and his team are beyond amazing! We hired them for our 2020 wedding - they were extremely flexible with all the changes for our 2020 scheduled and 2021 rescheduled events at Greenpoint Loft in Brooklyn. Our guests were blown away by the quality of the food- people keep talking about Joe's penne ala vodka! Their service, overall responsiveness, and flexibility made wedding planning easy. I can't recommend these caterers enough! -
![Theodora]()
Theodora Sent on 08/30/2021Hire LCI Catering! Amazing!
Hire Joe Cutulo! I hired Joe for my wedding and it was probably the best decision I made. After my wedding was rescheduled 3 times due to the pandemic, we decided to hold our reception for 100 people in our yard. I was skeptical that any caterer would be able to pull off an elegant affair under the circumstances. JOE DID! Not only did Joe work with me every step of the way but he went above and beyond to provide advice, suggestions, and support. He took the time to come out to see the very small space and reassured me that not only would everything work out, he would see to it personally. He is an excellent chef and goes out of his way to make your day perfect, well above and beyond the typical responsibilities of a caterer. I myself tend to micro manage so giving up the reigns for this event was hard. Well, I could not have put my trust in a better man! He is very organized, trustworthy, honest, professional, and hard working. Even with an impending hurricane, Joe and team went out of their way to help out in any way they could. My guests called me up after the event to let me know how amazing the food and catering staff were during the wedding. I would recommend LCInc Catering for any event. You get so much more than just amazing food. Thanks Joe and staff! -
![Sandy]()
Sandy Sent on 04/29/2021Mother of the Groom
While Covid dampened my sons original wedding a year ago, LCI came to us through the Queens Botanical Gardens. With less than a month to plan, Susanne came to the rescue! From our first email to the day of the reception, we were greeted with smiles, delicious food and no matter how many questions we asked, they were ready to help. Thank you Joe and all who helped, in making it easy and delicious. Mevorah/Jackson Families -
![Bianca]()
Bianca Sent on 01/16/2020Best Investment Ever!
Where do I even start with Joe and his team...They are absolutely hands on with EVERYTHING. We hosted a buffet style served dinner for our guests who til this day can’t stop talking about how delicious everything was. We’re a mixed family of Puerto Rican’s and Dominicans’, so to us it was imperative to have Spanish food served on the day of our wedding. To have Joe tell us he could deliver the best “Maduros” (sweet plantains) was a relief. Everything tasted as if my mom would’ve made it at home. The food was piping hot, fresh and in abundance. Not only was our dinner everything we wanted and more, to top it off, we had a full blown desert bar equipped a spread of fresh fruits, a wide selection of Italian cookies and cannolis’ (which were my mother’s favorite part) lol He and his staff were such a pleasure to work with especially during the planning process as my family and I had received news that my father had been diagnosed with stage 4 cancer, just a few months before our wedding. They made every interaction after that much more than just business. They made it almost like a break a way from the stress and helped me get this done just as we planned it. I’d recommend them in a heart beat because they’re so much more than just amazing food and service. They’re a whole lot of heart. -
-
![Alejandro]()
Alejandro Sent on 12/19/2019Above and Beyond Expectations
My wife and I could not be happier with the quality of service provided by Joe, Susanne and the rest of the LCI team. The food was delicious and everyone who attended our wedding could not stop raving about how good it was. They even went as far as saying they have never attended a wedding in which the food was delicious. Joe took his time with us when he invited us for a tasting and made recommendations to transform our menu from traditional to a different ordinary menu which you do not typically see at weddings. If we are ever in a situation in which we need to cater to a large group of people again I will not hesitate to call LCI to hire them for their services. They went above and beyond what was expected from them. Thank you very much JOE AND Co. -
![Kate]()
Kate Sent on 10/31/2019Trust this excellent caterer with experience
Joe and the LCI Team bring years of experience catering and serving events in NYC, and it shows. For a bride and groom planning a large wedding for the first time, some of the details, options, and questions can seem overwhelming. Joe and Susanne, and their entire staff, always provided us all of the information and answers we needed -- and none that we didn't. Their options allow you to pick the menu that is right for your guests, and they are straightforward in their pricing and approach, focusing on the food and the service always. On the topic of food, our guests are still raving about the delicious bites from our wedding. Joe took special care to listen to our interests, likes and dislikes, and heritage, incorporating every little detail into our night (including perogies for my husband's Polish relatives!). He was always careful to remind us it was our preference that mattered. I loved working with the LCI team and highly recommend them if you are considering it! -
![N]()
N Sent on 09/09/2019Awesome experience
Our wedding was on August 31st and we could not have been happier with Joe and his crew. All of the food tasted great, the communication was on point, and the delivery of everything just wonderful. I loved every minute of our wedding and was thankful for every signature drink and the fact that they packed leftovers for us. Staff was efficient and polite. If anything went wrong we didn’t know, haha. Go with Joe! -
![Ann]()
Ann A. Sent on 07/24/2019Excellent Service and Amazing food!
Joe and the staff at LCI Caterers were wonderful to work with from start to finish. Joe helped us create a menu our guests would love by providing us with a food tasting and making great recommendations. (Tip- attend the food tasting on an empty stomach... you’ll want to taste everything!) out menu was a mic of both American and Latin dishes....Joe reassured me that the latin dishes would taste authentic and he was right! Joe and his staff were available by email/phone and always responded quickly. After our wedding, the guests raved about the food! All the servers were so friendly and the food was delicious! Special shout out to our personal server Lisa... she was so sweet and attentive with us throughout the evening. The bartenders were also engaging and friendly. The evening flowed nicely and everything was perfect. We highly recommend LCI Caterers and hope to use them again in the future. -
![Margie]()
Margie Sent on 07/22/2019Wonderful team
LCI was wonderful! Joe was super cool to work with and the food was delicious! -
![A.]()
Alyssa Sent on 06/13/2019Amazing Wedding Catering!
Joe and his team were absolutely fantastic! Joe was open to communication/phone calls/emails and always made us feel like we could call him with any changes or concerns. We knew we were going to hire him once we had our food tasting. It was so impressive as Joe always adds his own twists to popular foods. Everything was fresh. Joe’s team nailed our signature drinks and made them absolutely perfect. Our guests kept raving about how delicious the food was. Joe and his team worked extremely hard to make sure that we were happy with our meals and that the guests loved it as well. Excellent job and will definitely recommend in the future! -
![Heidy]()
Heidy Sent on 02/17/2019If you want a caterer that does more than you could ever hope for… Please hire Joe
My now husband and I were looking for a good caterer that would please our picky parents, appeal to both our cultures (My husband is Mexican and I am Dominican) as well as our American co-workers and friends. We looked at several caterers but when we met with Joe we knew he was the one! The tasting was everything we wanted and more and Joe seemed super knowledgeable and had experience with our venue (26 Bridge) everything we could want…. He helped take our vision and create a menu that was beyond all our expectations including ALL our favorite things!! And kept us within our budget which we both thought would be impossible to do, but it’s Joe so of course he makes it happen. Joe is an amazing caterer but he was so much more than that for us! Joe was always available to me over the phone or via email no matter the time and no matter how anxious I got (and trust me I am a worrier!) he always had a solution!! Joe even spoke to me on his way to his vacation because we were a month away from our wedding and he wanted to make sure I was okay with the menu. Joe was able to fix problems that even my coordinator said “there is nothing you can do”… Joe would come in and say “we can fix that!” Two days before the wedding our bartenders canceled on us!!! One call to Joe and problem fixed!! We needed more tables last minute… Joe fixed that! AND THE FOOD!!! DELICIOUS!!! All our guests raved and complimented us on the food and everyone left full and happy; and remember this our picky family and everyone was happy!! …. Everything that my hubby and I wanted for our special day. But Joe’s amazingness does not end there, after the wedding Joe heard that with all the running around we did not get to taste everything, and he offered to cook for us so that we could taste what we had missed at the wedding …. WHO DOES THAT? JOE DOES!!!
If you want a vendor that goes above and beyond that does not stop at just food… and truly cares about the success of your big day please please please pick Joe! No one else will do!! -
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer Sent on 01/31/2019Good quality
Food is so delicious. The taste, flavor and quality is excellent! -
![Celeste]()
Celeste Sent on 01/28/2019Amazing food, service and value for money! & Joe is a darling
Joseph is a Godsend. I am from a foreign country and my husband is American, so having to go through the wedding process twice, in two different countries, was not only daunting but also weighed heavily on our pockets. We decided on our wedding venue first, and Joe's company was listed as one of the preferred caterers that the venue enjoys working with. I was happy and wary at the same time with how pocket-friendly Joe's services were compared to other wedding caterers. But after reading all the shining reviews the company has on various sites, we decided to give Joe a call. Joe was so friendly and easy to talk to over the phone, and very very knowledgeable and experienced. We instantly knew that we were in good hands. To be really honest, I was still nervous even after finalizing the menu as my parents were traditional and very picky eaters, but it turned out that I did not have to worry at all. Everyone enjoyed the food immensely, and Joe's staff was incredibly nice and helpful, even Joe himself was there to make sure everything ran extra smoothly. We owe him and his team a giant thank-you for such an amazing night. Definitely highly recommended! -
![Ella]()
Ella Sent on 09/23/2017Joe and LCI catered our wedding this past weekend, and we could not be happier. From the get-go, Joe's focus on great-tasting food let us know that we were in the right hands. He provided a free tasting with an amazing variety of delicious foods for us to choose from. After listening to what we wanted for the event, Joe craft a menu that fit our budget, arranged for rentals, and dealt with every other last minute crisis that we generated. He was very responsive in the weeks leading up to the wedding, and gave us peace of mind that all the details were being well taken care of. On the day, Joe made sure that everything went off without a hitch and the food was fantastic. We got rave reviews from our guests, and Joe even had a couple of staff members chasing us around with plates to make sure we got to try all the goodness. We were sent home with some delicious leftovers, and our only regret is that they're all gone! -
![Uni]()
Uni N. Sent on 02/04/2020Affordable wedding catering-Best Bang for your Buck!
We used LCI Caterers for our winter wedding in January. All of the food at the tasting was delicious and the food at the wedding matched our expectations from the tasting. Throughout the process, Susanne, our contact for LCI, was a pleasure to work with. With their many affordable packages and options, there is a reason why they were one of our venue’s recommended vendors. Thanks LCI Caterers!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?