Icing on the Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer Sent on 05/17/2024Beautiful cake!
My wedding cake was so incredibly pretty and also delicious! Everyone loved it and also the cupcakes Debra made. Highly recommend! -
Annie Sent on 08/19/2023
Amazing gelato bar!!
We had a homemade gelato bar from Icing on the Cakes at our wedding and it was the PERFECT touch and fun treat for our reception! We wanted a dessert option that was different than the norm and summery. This was perfect and our guests raved about it! So many amazing flavors and the set-up was incredible! Debra was wonderful to work with. Can't recommend enough! -
-
Kristen Sent on 09/04/2022
Simple and Delicious
Debra made our wedding cake for our wedding at the Hilton Pier House this summer. We wanted a fairly simple cake, but it was delicious and even more beautiful than we expected. It was also very affordable. Debra made us exactly what we were looking for - we highly recommend using her! -
-
Morgan Sent on 06/26/2022
Amazing Desserts
We loved our cake and various desserts that Debra provided! She gave us a nice variety to sample prior to the wedding. She was willing to take any requests, including making buckeyes which is a staple from where my family is from in Ohio. Debra delivered the desserts directly to the venue on the day of. It was a very stress-free experience! Thanks again Debra! -
-
![Kelly]()
Kelly Sent on 09/06/2021Blown Away By Taste
I just stopped eating my leftover wedding cake from my 8/28/2021 wedding, and that's only because I couldn't figure out a way to pack it to bring back home. It was still good a week later. We had the most amazing key lime wedding cake that our guests were raving about (and they also happily took some home from the reception). Debra made the whole process so easy from start to finish. Even with Covid. We picked up a box of samples to try at our own pace, and I do suggest pacing, there were ten amazing flavors! But we immediately fell in love with the key lime. It was the perfect summer beach wedding flavor. And we went with a beach wedding themed cake, which turned out simply gorgeous. She was able to figure out what we wanted and make it happen, even with us planning from 6 hours away. And she kept the prices to a reasonable range.
I'll admit, I cared more about the cake than my flowers, decor, etc... I spent four years working in a bakery and decorating wedding cakes, so the cake was the one big piece I was concerned about, but Debra absolutely nailed it in both looks and taste (which let's face it is more important).
We can't wait to come back to OBX next year and order a key lime anniversary cake (none of that freezing stuff for us, we were too busy eating it!). -
-
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 10/04/2020Delicious Cake!
Icing on the Cakes did an amazing job with our wedding cake. We had a 3 tier cake and chose 3 different flavors and they were all amazing! Debra was super flexible in letting us do a tasting two days before the wedding because we were out of town. The cake was AMAZING and looked gorgeous, it was exactly how I wanted it! -
![Terrie]()
Terrie Sent on 12/03/2019Great Cake
Deb was great. We met with her for a tasting and she had lots of options for us to pick from. My husband is not a cake person - that's all me - and he loved the tiramisu wedding cake. She made the cake look like the beach and added little beach chairs on top. We did a couple of little finger desserts but the gelato bar was a HIT!! I totally recommend Deb (Icing on the Cake in North Carolina) and the gelato bar. -
![Stephanie]()
Stephanie Sent on 11/21/2019More than just cake!!!
My guests (and my husband & I) were INSANE about my cupcakes. FREAKIN DELICIOUS. And Debra is a hoot! Also, use Argyles Restaurant for your rehearsal dinner. I wish I could eat there every night if my life. -
-
![Arianna]()
Arianna Sent on 10/26/2019Delicious!
When my now-husband and I did our cake tasting with Debra, we almost ate the whole tray of cake samples! The cakes were delicious! We went with two flavors, eclair and amaretto chambord. The cake was beautiful and delicious! Debra was able to make some gluten-free cupcakes for my sister who has Celiac disease. I was so happy that she had gluten-free options! -
-
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 10/01/2019Yummy cake!!
The cake we had for our wedding was a 3 tier cake which satisfied all of our tastes! Top was a vanilla gluten free, dairy free and egg free, which is talent already. Very moist and flavorful. Middle was pina colada, my daughters choice and bottom was peanut butter filling with chocolate cake, husbands choice. It was fun t try all the flavors. Very accommodating, when we had to move our wedding date up two days due to a hurricane. Greatly appreciated. Thanks so much! -
-
![Stevie]()
Stevie Sent on 11/01/2018Tasty Cake!
We had a small wedding of only 11 people so we ordered 2 dozen cupcakes. They were white cake with lemon icing and raspberry filling and chocolate with chocolate icing and peanut butter filling. They were delicious! We ate them for breakfast for two days after the wedding because why not?!? Fair price and great service! They were flexible with time for us to pick them up and take them to the restaurant. -
-
![Abby]()
Abby Sent on 10/29/2018Delicious desserts and flawless communication/delivery
Debra makes delicious and beautiful cakes, it was hard to choose a style and flavor because they were all so good! Flawless communication and delivery of our cake. -
-
Ashley Sent on 06/29/2018I absolutely LOVED my wedding cake! It was perfect for our beach wedding in the outer banks! Thank you Debra!
-
-
Jackie Sent on 05/19/2018We loved our cake! Debra did an amazing job creating our beach themed cake. We sent her a few pictures and she created her own vision and it was beautiful. The cake was delicious!
-
-
![Erin]()
Erin Sent on 01/18/2017I am beyond amazed and grateful for the service that we received from Debra and Icing on the Cakes. Our wedding was during the week that Hurricane Matthew hit the OBX in October 2016. Debra was diligent about keeping up communication with me with the hurricane coming and wanted to make sure that our day was perfect! She was reliable and calm despite a hurricane barreling down on her town a short 12 hours after our reception ended. The cake was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS... I was eating it for breakfast quite a few days after the wedding! She was also able to create a beautiful cake from a picture that I had sent her. We went with a key lime cake with white chocolate mousse, chocolate grand marnier cake with chocolate mousse, and she made a special flavor for our anniversary tier... a butter rum cake! I am completely impressed with her professionalism and the quality of her work. I would highly recommend Debra to other OBX brides! -
![Chris]()
Chris Sent on 10/13/2016We couldn't be happier with the job Debra did for our wedding! We ordered cupcakes and an anniversary tier and everything came out exactly how we had asked. Our guests loved the cupcakes and her fondant work on the anniversary tier was excellent. We gave her a few pics to guide her with what we wanted and she knocked it out of the park! -
![Donna]()
Donna Sent on 06/30/2014Our cake/cupcake combination was delicious and exactly as promised. Our guests loved the different cupcake flavors. By the day after the wedding there was not a crumb left. The cake design was done simply and to our specifications. It was perfect for our beach themed wedding. -
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 08/23/2016Debra did a great job and the cupcakes were exactly what I wanted. I had rave reviews on the flavors we chose (key lime, chocolate hazelnut, and spice cake) and there were hardly any left over, even though we ended up with more cupcakes than guests! -
![Giovanna]()
Giovanna Sent on 06/20/2017More beautiful than we could have imagined! I highly recommend doing a cake tasting with them. We had our flavors in mind, but their cakes were so delicious we completely changed our order! PJ and Deborah were a big part of our day. So glad we chose them. Two forks up!!! -
![Morgan]()
Morgan Sent on 06/02/2021The cake tasted amazing
It was amazing so talented and they’re not the everyday cupcake. I emailed and called with no response and she said she wasn’t getting emails. May have been going to spam not sure but all worth the flavors. -
![Andre]()
Andre Sent on 10/20/2019Could have been better
Let me just start by saying that the cupcakes and cake that were made for us were very good but with that being said let me get into the not so good parts of the review. Emails were sent about what type of cake we wanted for our anniversary tier but we received no response. Couple of weeks prior another email we sent with the very specific color of the cake we wanted and once again no response. We had to continually reach out to render a response even when it came to receiving our final payment. The product is good but the service was much to be desired. -
Kristin Sent on 06/01/2023
Dissapointed
I am so disappointed in the cupcakes that were done for my wedding.
My friend was going to make the cup cakes and decorate them, however her father passed away and she was unable to do.
We had to rush to find a place to make cupcakes and we found icings on the cake. It was two weeks prior to my wedding and I was worried I wouldn't find a place.
I was so thrilled that icings on the cake said they could do the 4 dozen cupcakes and when asked if they could do sunflowers I was told yes. Especially seeing the cupcakes on the website icingsonthecakes.com (picture 3).
What I got was so dissapointing. (Picture 1) which looks does not look like a professional did
Thankfully I had friends who went out and fixed (picture 2). After spending over $200 dollars on cupcakes they should not have been fixed.
I emailed the owner and did not receive a response back in 24 hours. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?