Fairy Cakes Cupcakery & Bakeshop Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Jamie]()
Jamie Sent on 08/16/2025Whimsical and delicious!
My husband and I went with Fairy Cakes for our wedding based on a recommendation from our photographer and we had a really great experience with them!
They were open to our request for a mixture of a small cake for cutting, mini cupcakes, and mini pies, and were able to accommodate our request to have some gluten-free cupcakes for our guests with celiac disease. They also had a really wide selection of unique flavors for both the cupcakes and pies, which we were really excited about!
They were quick and professional throughout all of our communications and answered all of our questions. The desserts were delicious and we basically had nothing left by the end of the night. The cake was both stunning and whimsical. We were just really pleased with everything that Fairy Cakes had to offer and provided. We will definitely be turning to them in the future for any other cake/dessert needs! -
![Jamie]()
Jamie Sent on 09/10/2023Wedding 09.09.23
Created the most beautiful and delicious desserts for my wedding day. so unique and unlike any other. East set up and take down, so accommodating and easy to work with! Highly recommend to any bride! -
-
![Quinn]()
Quinn Sent on 11/15/2022Delicious desserts
We loved working with fairy cakes! I have celiac and they were able to provide an amazing mix of gluten free and regular desserts for us as well as a small gluten free wedding cake. The flavors were incredible and our guests are still talking about how delicious all of the desserts were. My husband & I are huge Bills fans and they were able to incorporate subtle touches of the Bills throughout the dessert table. Easy to work with and delicious desserts! -
![Kailin]()
Kailin Sent on 09/06/2021Delicious!
We had Fairycakes make us a dessert table and it was perfect! They made everything how I wanted, and in all of the flavors I wanted. I couldn’t be happier. -
![Melissa]()
Melissa Sent on 07/22/2021Everything was DELICIOUS!
Our guests couldn’t get enough of our cupcake table. Everything was absolutely delicious, and our double chocolate and baileys cutting cake was absolute perfection. We did a mix of minis and medium cupcakes, so everyone got as much or as little as they wanted. The flavor list is so extensive, there is something there for everyone’s taste. The Mississippi mud cupcakes were INCREDIBLE.
Not only were the cupcakes delicious, but the setup they provided for us was beautiful. They have so many different options for any style of wedding. Moe and Kelly were also super easy to work with! We cut down our guest list due to COVID, and they were so quick make those changes.
Do yourself a favor and hire fairycakes! -
-
![Courtney]()
Courtney Sent on 10/28/2019Wonderful dessert bar!
Fairycakes was excellent. From the initial tasting, to helping us decide on some flavors, to making special desserts for our vegan guests. There were more than enough desserts but they were all gone because they were so yummy!! We did a dessert bar and it looked beautiful. Can't recommend them enough! Also an excellent value. -
![James]()
James Sent on 06/28/2019A Highlight of our wedding!
Fairy Cakes was a major highlight of our wedding! We had a dessert table filled with brown butter rice krispie treats, various cupcakes, cookies, donuts, and macaroons (including an amazing rice krispie macaroon). The cut cake was by far the best part, which was a delicious brown butter cake with blueberry frosting.
We received so many compliments about the dessert table from our guests, and it was a major highlight. They were an absolute pleasure to work with from beginning to end and I highly recommend them for your wedding! -
-
![Kristin]()
Kristin Sent on 06/26/2019Amazing amazing amazing!
We hired Fairy Cakes to do a 24 foot dessert table for our wedding in May. They went above and beyond my expectations, and I was in total awe when I walked into the reception. Kelly and Mo were amazing to work with. Every crazy idea I had was welcomed with a "Sure, we can do that!" - and the end result was EPIC! Not only was it beautiful and full of variety, but every single piece of dessert was incredibly delicious! Our guests are still raving about our dessert table. It definitely achieved the WOW factor we were going for!! Thank you so much Fairy Cakes! -
-
![Marney]()
Marney Sent on 05/06/2019We loved our cupcakes and pie!
Everyone at Fair cakes was wonderful to work with. They were very flexible and did a great job turning our vision into reality. We chose to cut an apple pie instead of a cake and they easily accommodated that, as well as letting us change our cupcake stand weeks before the wedding!! We will definitely be ordering from Fairy cakes for future events. -
![Mackenzie]()
Mackenzie Sent on 10/22/2018Delicious Cupcakes and Weddinf Cake
We loved Fairy Cakes from the first bite at our tasting with them. It was no surprise our guests devoured the cupcakes at our wedding, and that the small cake for my husband and I was so delicious. They were easy to work woth, had so many options, and did the setup of our cake table on their own to match our wedding look/feel. They were amazing and I would HIGHLY recommend them to any other WNY wedding. -
-
Maria Sent on 10/04/2017When my husband and I went in for a cake tasting, they were so helpful and accommodating. All we wanted was a small one their cake for the day and they really delivered! We loved the look, and taste of our wedding cake!
-
-
![Julie]()
Julie Sent on 08/18/2014Most amazing cupcakes, decor, and wrappers! They were easy to work with being an out of town couple and made the look I was looking for! Everyone loved them and they looked incredible!!!!!!! Their chandelier stands are beautiful! -
![Nicia]()
Nicia Sent on 11/18/2025Great Desserts!
We ordered a bunch of mini cupcakes in different flavors as well as some custom cutout Buffalo Bills cookies and they all turned out so good! The cookies tasted so good and the designs turned out amazing! We saved a couple to freeze and eat them on our anniversary. We also were able to rent the props to hold the desserts from Fairy Cakes as well as some other desserts we got from other places and received a table design for the props as well. -
![Fai660]()
Fai Sent on 10/16/2016This local small business delivers big flavor and great service. We used them for our late night goodies at our wedding, and all our guests loved the cupcakes. And my hubby and I were their biggest fans. We very much recommend Fairy Cakes for your wedding! -
![Kate]()
Kate Sent on 06/05/2012We ordered our wedding cake and cupcakes through Fairycakes, and I have to say not only were the cupcakes delicious and crowd-pleasing, the owners of Fairycakes were so easy and enjoyable to work with. I highly recommend Fairycakes!! We got mini cupcakes and 2/person was more than enough.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?