Carols Cake Cupboard Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9 out of 5 rating
4.9 out of 5 rating
153 Reviews
99% recommend it
-
![Teresa]()
Teresa Z. Sent on 08/29/2024Beautiful job!
Carol made my daughter's wedding cake and let us come to her home with family to taste and make selections beforehand. Delivered on the day and time as promised and she put our topper on. Many compliments and my daughter and now son were happy and so were the guests and especially the groom's Dad and my Mom and that's what I aimed for! -
![Samantha]()
Samantha S. Sent on 10/20/2023We hired Carol to bake our daughter's wedding cake.
My daughter's wedding cake was not only beautiful but tasted delicious as well. I received many compliments from wedding guests. Everything about Carol was professional. I would highly recommend! -
![Naomi]()
Naomi B. Sent on 08/29/2023A Hidden Gem
When my original bakery went out of business I was scrambling to find someone at such short notice. Carol responded very quickly. At the cake tasting we picked the style and design of the cake. The finished product far exceeded our expectations. It was beautiful. Our wedding was this past weekend 8/26/23. My guests are still raving about the cake. It was absolutely delicious. The portions are very generous. I will be using her again and recommending her to everyone. -
-
![Em]()
Emily G. Sent on 09/10/2023Delicious Cake!
I met Carol at a small wedding show and was intrigued as she was a small business out of her home. I personally like supporting local, small businesses. I went for a trial at her home and was sold. She had many intricate and simple designs to choose from to meet our vision. She even let us incorporate our dog figurines into the cake. When she found out my husband and I never got the chance to have cake at our wedding, she offered to make us a small cake. We did vanilla and chocolate. The way she makes it allows everyone to have a reasonable portion of each. Carol was very responsive to our questions and had a clean, organized work place. She has perfected her craft! Book now, you won’t be disappointed! -
-
Makayla C. Sent on 08/29/2023
Wedding cake was great
Cake was amazing beautiful so satisfied with my wedding cake !! -
-
Amanda Sent on 10/30/2022
Everything was perfect!
The cake was beautiful and delicious! Carol is such a pleasure to work with and I highly recommend her. I was so happy with how the cake turned out and it was a perfect touch to our Happily Ever After -
-
Kat K. Sent on 10/24/2019
Amazing, would highly recommend!
Carol is a sweetheart and a cake that perfectly complimented the elegance of my wedding theme. Not only did it look flawless, it tasted great! Looking forward to having our anniversary cake next year. -
-
![Megan]()
Megan S. Sent on 10/23/2019Delicious!
Carol's cakes are delicious! They were by far the best we tried at the wedding show we went to, which led us to hire her! Carol is so sweet and made it easy to decide what we wanted for our cake at a reasonable rate. She always responded quickly, and, most importantly, the cake is delicious! There were no slices leftover from our wedding. We decided to eat our anniversary cake at our 1 year engagement anniversary and 1 month of marriage anniversary a few days ago and I am so happy to have enjoyed more of her delicious cake. Highly recommend! -
![Stephanie]()
Stephanie M. Sent on 10/08/2019Wedding Cake
Carol is great! The cake and frosting were so so so good we ate our year anniversary cake early because we couldn't wait and wanted to eat more! -
Lexi Sent on 10/24/2019
Wedding Cake
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! Carol was awesome to work with and was always available to answer any questions we had. We wanted to add real flowers to the cake and Carol made sure she could meet the florist at the venue to add them. Looking forward to eating our anniversary cake next year! -
-
Nicole Sent on 08/07/2019
Fun-fetti Wedding Cake
Carols cake cupboard was amazing!
5 stars, no doubt ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Carol is a very sweet and genuine lady. She has very fair prices and the cake was amazing. She did a funfetti wedding cake that matched the color theme of my wedding. She is so easy to work with and is very caring about your special day! The cake was exactly what I’ve always dreamed of and tasted delicious. I highly recommend using carols cake cupboard in Lockport! -
-
Dana I. Sent on 07/09/2019
Overall Carol was a pleasure to work with for our big day.
Carol was very friendly, professional and flexible with us for our wedding on June 22. We met with her months ahead of time and at that point we thought we would be having about 125 people at our wedding so we decided on a four tier cake. Once we started getting the RSVPs in it turned out that we would only be having about 90 people, therefore a few weeks before the wedding we called Carol to see if we could cut the cake down, and she was more than understanding with us! Not to mention the cake was amazing... Both presentation and taste! We got many compliments from our guests. -
-
Christine K. Sent on 06/02/2019
We love Carol’s Cake Cupboard!
Carol was a delight to work with! She welcomed me, my fiancée, and my mom into her home that smelled of delicious cake! We had tea and cake tastings together and she showed us all of her options. She was flexible with design, had lots of shapes to choose from and was patient with me when I was indecisive. Our cake was everything we wanted and more! We absolutely loved the taste of the yellow-chocolate combo and her buttercream frosting is the perfect balance of sweet but not overly sweet. She even added dowels so we could put my parent’s cake topper on top! The cake meant a lot to us and Carol absolutely nailed it!! Thank you so much Carol! My husband and I will definitely be back the next time we hold a special event! -
-
Mark F. Sent on 02/09/2019
Best cake ever!
If there were a way to give Carol 6 stars I would. To say that our wedding cake was the best cake I have ever tasted does not do it justice. We first met Carol in her quaint Lockport home, where she and her sister personally make every cake to order. She invited my wife and I in and served us the lightest, sweetest, most delectable cake either of us had tasted so far. This was accompanied by an offer of virtually any beverage you can imagine, and she even gave us a piece to take home for our parents to try. After Carol rolled out an impressive display of the cakes she had made previously, my wife asked her to make a custom cake, the likes of which Carol had never seen. After expressing hesitation at first, Carol agreed, and the cake turned out exactly like the photo we showed her. Carol takes pride in the fact that she does not use fondant in her cakes, and she provides a much better value than the “big name” bakeries in town. I can guarantee you will not be diapointed with Carol as your cake maker. -
-
![Danielle]()
Danielle Sent on 12/27/2018Choose Carol!
We hired Carol to bake our wedding cake for our 11/24/18 wedding. It was AMAZING! Carol was easy to work with, and such a sweet lady. She had us over to taste test some cake, it was delicious! She worked with us on our budget and what we envisioned. She was so flexible with what i requested and when i changed my mind about things here and there. She made one gorgeous cake and it was yummy. It all went at the wedding, and we are so excited that we also got a free top tier so we can enjoy it on our anniversary. Carol was overall amazing, and her work is excellent. We would highly recommend her! -
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 10/16/2018Easiest planning expand BEAUTIFUL cake
Carol is absolutely AMAZING! Our cake was so delicious and it was exactly what we wanted. The ordering process was very easy and stress free, Carol walked us through everything to make sure we got everything we wanted. Her prices are extremely fair, especially considering the GORGEOUS result, we could have spent hundreds more at a store front. We are so blessed we found Carol, we will be using her for every cake need we have in the future! -
-
Anna Sent on 08/21/2018We really enjoyed working with Carol for the wedding cake! She did an amazing job creating the cake, keeping in mind all of the elements of design we were looking for. We met with her early on at her business to find a very professional show room with lots of photos for ideas along with real size replicas of her cakes in various shapes and sizes. It was clean, organized and made it easy to visualize your future wedding cake. The prices quoted for the work were very reasonable as well. After all the planning, months later I was stymied by the colour of my lovebird wedding toppers I bought on line. I contacted Carol and we redisigned some elements and changed the hue of the blue. Carol was extremely understanding and was eager to create a cake to make us happy. She succeeded! On the wedding day, Carol brought the cake to the venue and set it up. It was gorgeous and received many compliments. It tasted excellent! Thank you Carol so much and we were thrilled with your creation!
-
-
Jenny Sent on 07/03/2018Amazing Lady to work with! I can not say enough good things about the experience. The cake was amazing, delicious and at a very fair price. She goes above and beyond to make everything stress free and treats you like family. She made us a anniversary cake that was packaged up ready for the freezer and followed up after the wedding to see how the day went.
-
-
Jessica Sent on 01/18/2018The entire process was easy and the outcome was everything we wanted. We went to taste at Carols house, she was super inviting and easy to talk to. She explained all our options and we could decide how we wanted our cake in detail. We thought the pricing was very reasonable and the cake was delicious! We chose the simple yellow cake with buttercream frosting. Thank you Carol, our guests were very pleased. We loved our cake!
-
