Cake Me Happy Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
Olivia Sent on 11/05/2025
Such a beautiful cake!
The cake tasted amazing, the pricing was competitive & it was beautiful. Matched my vision exactly! I also felt like the cake during the tasting tasted so much better than another bakery that I tried. There were also no issues with delivery on the day of. Highly recommend!! -
-
![Eliza]()
Eliza Sent on 10/21/2025Delicious and Unique!
Amy was amazing to work with. She was always so helpful and timely with her response and stayed on top of everything. We decided to do a cinnamon roll cake with a milk chocolate filling and cream cheese icing. We loved it and so did our guests. Thanks Amy!!!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your extremely kind words! It was such a pleasure working with you and creating your cake :) Congratulations again on your wedding!! -
-
![Cassara]()
Cassara Sent on 09/28/2025Best cake and cupcakes ever
Amy was absolutely amazing. She was very so nice, easy to work with, quick with her responses and was beyond helpful with decision making. Our cake came out absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing!! All our guests continuously complimented how good the cupcakes were all night long. I highly recommend Cake me happy!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Cassara! I loved working with you and it was a pleasure to create your cake and cupcakes. Thanks again for your kind words and a huge congratulations on your wedding!! -
-
![Kelly]()
Kelly Sent on 08/22/2025Wedding cake
Amy did a fantastic job on my daughter’s wedding cake. It was as delicious as it was beautiful. She was responsive, flexible and easy to work with! Would highly recommend!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Kelly! It was such a joy to create this cake - it was a nice challenge to create a larger 4 tier cake - and your florist was so delightful to work with and did such a wonderful job as well. Thank you for being so great to work with and for your kind review! Congratulations to you, your daughter and her new husband! -
-
Lauren Sent on 08/16/2025
Perfect Cake!
Amy (Cake Me Happy) did a wonderful job designing our cake for our special day! It was exactly what we wanted and we received so many compliments. The cake itself was absolutely delicious - she offered cake tastings that were easy to coordinate and helped us pick out which flavors we wanted. She was also a great communicator, super kind and reliable as a vendor. Thank you for being apart of our special day, Amy!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Lauren! This was one of our absolute favorite cakes to make- the design you chose and with those hydrangeas.. so beautiful. Your whole wedding was so gorgeous. Thanks for letting us be a part of it and thanks for your kind words!! -
-
![Sue]()
Sue Sent on 08/14/202550th Wedding Anniversary Cake
Cake Me Happy did a beautiful job in creating a memorable cake for our 50th wedding anniversary celebration! I sent a picture of our original cake so that the vintage piping could be re-created. It was so pretty and well done! I highly recommend Cake Me Happy for all of your special cake needs!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Sue for your kind words! It was a joy working with you! Congratulations again on your anniversary! ❤️ -
![Emilee]()
Emilee Sent on 07/14/2025Amy went above and beyond
There were two things we really wanted at our wedding: Chocolate Chip Cookies and Cookies and Cream Cupcakes. And Amy made it happen! I appreciate her going above and beyond and making something that wasn't on her menu. At the end of the night, there wasn't a crumb left on the dessert table. Highly recommend Cake My Happy for your wedding cake needs.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Emilee! Thank you so much for your super kind words! I had so much fun creating the fun desserts for your wedding - it was nice to do something a little outside the box :). And you were a breeze to work with! Thanks again and best wishes in your marriage!! -
-
![Rydge]()
Rydge Sent on 07/11/2025The most beautiful & delicious cake ever!
Amy made the most beautiful cake for our wedding! She hit our inspo pic spot on and it tasted just as good as it looked! Our flavors were vanilla almond, lemon, & champagne and we can honestly say each one of them was some of the best cake we've ever had!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your kind review, Taylor & Rydge. It was such a pleasure working with you and I wish you the very best in your marriage!! ❤️ -
-
![Emerald]()
Emerald Sent on 07/05/2025A Crowd Favorite
Amy was great from beginning to end. There was a moment where we needed to change our delivery address for the cake and she was flexible. Not only that, the delivery was early! Amy’s team kept the cake safe and refrigerated during the delivery process. It was absolutely beautiful. Lastly, the cake tasted and looked amazing!! Highly recommend ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Emerald!! I'm so glad you enjoyed your cake and that you were happy with the delivery process. I absolutely loved creating your cake, especially with the beautiful design you chose - you have great taste :). Thanks for your kind words and wishing you the best in your marriage!! -
![Siqi]()
Siqi Sent on 07/01/2025Great experiences!
Absolutely loved our wedding cake! It was beautifully designed, incredibly delicious, and exactly what we envisioned. Amy was professional, responsive, easy to work with, and made the whole process stress-free. Highly recommend!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your incredibly kind words! It was such a pleasure to bring your unique vision to life! You were truly a breeze to work with and I'm so pleased to hear you were happy with everything. Please let us know if you need anything in the future, and in the meantime, enjoy married life!! :) -
-
![Maria]()
Maria Sent on 06/23/2025Love our Cake!!
Our cake was Butter pecan with black berries!! It’s the was the best combo for us. Our guest loved it so much.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Maria! Thank you so much for your review and for sharing this fun photo!! It was a pleasure working with you and I’m so happy to hear that you loved your cake. Congratulations again on your wedding! ❤️❤️ -
-
Nicole Sent on 05/24/2025
Highly recommend
Amy did an amazing job creating our wedding cake! She is so sweet, very responsive, and worked with us to create the perfect cake for our day. Not only was our cake beautiful, it was absolutely delicious! Highly recommend her for all your wedding cake needs!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Nicole! It was such a pleasure working with. you and creating your cake! Congratulations again!! :) -
-
![Brittny]()
Brittny Sent on 05/20/2025Everyone Loved the cupcakes! There were none left over!
Amy did a great job creating our wedding cake the way we wanted and everyone said the cupcake were delicious and adorable. She is very responsive and easy to talk with. Thank you for everything!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your kind words!! Your wedding was a blast to work on, such a fun theme. Congratulations again on your wedding and best wishes in your marriage! -
-
![Agontene]()
Agontene Sent on 04/09/2025Make Me Happy, Made Me Happy.
Amy works with you to make your dream wedding cake a reality. I appreciate her candid suggestions as we brainstormed ideas of what I had envisioned. Yum it was.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Agontene! You were such a pleasure to work with and I absolutely loved seeing your vision come to life. Thank you so much for your kind words and for trusting me with your cake. Congratulations again! -
-
Ellie Sent on 04/05/2025
Yummy yummy and beautiful!
Cake me happy was so great to work with. She’s so easy to talk to and talented! She created exactly what we had in mind, delivered it on time, and it was not only beautiful but so so good!! I wanted to just keep eating it! 😆 she was a wonderful choice for our cake!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Ellie! Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! It was a breeze working with you and I LOVED the decor you chose for your cake.. it was such a fun one to create. Thanks for trusting me with your cake and congratulations again ❤️!! -
-
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 03/29/2025Best wedding cake!
Highly recommend choosing Cake Me Happy for your wedding cake! Amy was so easy to work with and the cake was amazing. Amy responds to communication quickly and her pricing is extremely reasonable. Many of our guests said it was the best wedding cake they've ever had! I cannot recommend Cake Me Happy enough!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Rebecca! Thank you so much for your kind words! It was such a pleasure to work with you, and I wish you the absolute best in your marriage! We'd love to work with you again anytime :) -
Jayla Sent on 03/24/2025
Wedding Cake and Cupcakes
Cake Me Happy was so easy to work with and very talented at what they do. The cake and cupcakes were not only beautiful, but also delicious! Highly recommend strawberry cake with chocolate ganache. So GOOD! She was very communicative, checked in frequently, and made sure we had exactly what we wanted for our special day!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your kind and thoughtful, review, Jayla... and I love the pictures! You looked beautiful! It was a pleasure to be a part of your big day, and it was lovely working with you - you were so organized and helpful :) Thanks again and best wishes for a happy life together! -
-
Zach Sent on 10/07/2024
Amazing cake, Was an absolute hit at our wedding!
Amy was simply fantastic, she was beyond knowledgeable about wedding cakes, had excellent communication, and delivered this amazing, beautiful cake. If you're looking for an unbelievably good tasting, spectacular looking cake-go nowhere else. Amy and cake me happy made us the best wedding cake I have ever seen/tasted. My niece could not stop eating it, there was a big line to get more! Ty amy!!!! You crushed it!
-ZachCake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Zach! It was a joy working with you.. I loved the flowers you guys picked out and it was such a fun cake to create. I hope married life is treating you wonderfully! -
-
Brianna Sent on 09/16/2024
Would recommend her every time!
Amy made our wedding cake and cupcakes. They were beautiful! She made them look exactly as we pictured! They were delicious. She was super easy to work with. My husband and I were very pleased and will be using her for future events. I highly recommend Amy!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Brianna! Thank you so much for leaving this super kind and thoughtful review. It was such a pleasure working with you, and your family and friends were so sweet and helpful at the church. I really enjoyed it and I'm so glad you were happy with everything. Congratulations again and best wishes in your married life!!! -
-
Annie Sent on 09/15/2024
Amazing cake, Amazing woman!
She was so professional while also being fun and flexible with me. Whenever I had questions, she was super informative and helpful. The cake she made looks EXACTLY how I dreamed it would! 10/10Cake Me Happy's reply:
Aww Annie thank you so much for your kind words!! It was such a pleasure working with you as well! Your pictures turned out amazing and thank you so much for sharing them. I really appreciate you leaving this review. thank you so much and congratulations again!! ❤️❤️ -
-
![Tommy]()
Tommy Sent on 09/01/2024Perfect August Wedding
My wife and I got married quickly, leaving little time to prepare and that included putting a rush on a cake. Amy went above and beyond to accommodate our requests and the cake was absolutely perfect. Couldn’t have been happier with the service and the TASTE. Raspberry/Champagne was just phenomenal. The blueberry lemon too was amazing. Thank you Amy so much for making our day special!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you, Tommy! It was such a joy to work with you and Jennifer and to be a part of this. You are both such a delight and it was an honor to be a part of it. Thanks for the kind words ❤️ Congratulations again! -
-
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer Sent on 09/01/2024Sweet Summer Wedding Cake
Amy was so helpful from the very start of our wedding cake ideas! She helped up pick flavors and worked with us on the color and decoration for the cake. She matched the color to the bridal dresses perfectly. To top it off, the cake was absolutely delicious!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Jennifer! It was such an honor to be a part of your and Tommy’s wedding. Thank you for trusting me with your cake, for your kind words and for letting me be such a big part of your special day 😔 -
-
Katie Sent on 07/02/2024
Amy was wonderful!
We needed a wedding cake ASAP and Amy was there for us. She was wonderful and so friendly. She gave us exactly what we asked for and our guests LOVED it. We had messages the next day asking who made the cake. Thank you again Amy! We 100% recommend!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much Katie! And thanks for being so easygoing and laid back throughout the whole process- you were such a pleasure to work with. I loved seeing your pictures afterward.. you looked beautiful and it seemed like such a joy-filled wedding. Congratulations again and best wishes to you and your husband! -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 06/21/2024Wedding Cake Experience
We ordered a two-tier lemon Gluten free cake with white ganache from Cake Me Happy and were very happy with the result. They created exactly what we wanted! Amy was easy to work with, provided lots of options and suggestions if asked and was very prompt with responses. Additionally we appreciated her patience as we were not quite as prompt as she is. Very professional and easy to work with. Would recommend.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Amanda - thank you so much for your kind words! Also, you were a joy to work with! I'm so glad you enjoyed your cake. Thanks again for trusting me with your cake :) -
-
![Kimberly]()
Kimberly Sent on 06/03/2024Best wedding cake ever!
Amy is an ABSOLUTE GEM! Her cake for my wedding day was the star of my show! Everyone could not stop raving about how delicious it was! She created the most beautiful cake and it was EXACTLY what I envisioned! She HAND DELIVERED tastings to our door! I have not only found my baker for all of my future cakes, I found a wonderful friend as well! You will not regret working with her...she is TOP NOTCH!!! WE LOVE YOU CAKE ME HAPPY!!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Kim! It was an absolute joy and pleasure to work with you and Darin. You were so sweet and lovely and I hope your wedding was absolutely marvelous. So glad I could be a part of it and happy to hear you and your guests were so pleased with the cake!! Thanks again and Congrats to you both!!! -
-
Kayla Sent on 05/07/2024
Cake me happy
Cake me happy went above and beyond for my wedding cake! She made the tasting experience so much fun for me, my mom and matron of honor. I wanted a really special cake to fit my greenery theme and a nod to my Irish heritage and she spent so much time perfecting the shamrocks of my dreams! It tasted delicious and everyone was talking about it! We also just love how cute and friendly she is. You won’t be disappointed hiring Cake me happy!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for your kind words, Kayla! It was such a joy working with you. It was great meeting you and your mom and matron of honor at the tasting, and working with you to design your cake was special for me as well. Thanks for being so laid back and easy to work with. Best of luck in your marriage and life! -
-
![Marissa]()
Marissa Sent on 04/28/2024Great cake
The cake tasted so good and the service was amazing. Will be ordering again!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Marissa! It was a pleasure working with you and I’m so glad you enjoyed your cake! -
Krista Sent on 03/16/2024
Simply Amazing!
Recently a co-worker was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer. After her boyfriend proposed to her, her co-workers did our best to rally around her. That included me discovering “Cake Me Happy” and Amy on The Knot. Not only did Amy offer to make a cake for the lovely couple on very short (days) order, she did so at no charge!!! Amy was lovely to work with and I am told by guests at the wedding that her raspberry filling is AMAZING!! Thank you, Amy, for working with a stranger to help provide a blessing to someone so loved.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Krista, thank you so much for your gracious and kind review. It was truly an honor to be a part of such a special wedding.. I was so touched by it and so glad that you asked me. It blessed me so much as well. Thank you again. -
-
![Richard]()
Richard Sent on 02/24/2024Fantastic experience
There are no words to describe the quality of service we received from Amy and Cake Me Happy! With all of the things that you have to worry about going into a wedding, this was not one of them. The design was perfect down to a T from what we requested. A truly deluxe service for a “friends & family” price! We recommend her all day everyday.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you for such kind words! I had so much fun designing your cake and working with you and Erin to design your cake 😊 Thanks again for trusting Cake Me Happy! -
![Colleen]()
Colleen Sent on 02/21/2024Best Cakes Around!
Cake Me Happy did an amazing job on our cake! Amy was easy to communicate with and paid great attention to details we requested. Not only was the cake beautiful, it was delicious. We received many compliments and would 100% recommend her for all cake needs! We were very happy with our overall experience.Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much, Colleen! I had so much fun with your cake and loved seeing the joy it brought in your pictures afterward. Thanks again for your business and kind words 🥰 -
![Mandy]()
Mandy Sent on 02/16/2024Quality cake & delicious taste
Amy made a cake for our family Thanksgiving dinner and not only was it incredibly moist with excellent flavor, she decorated it with beautiful fall colors and desgins. Amy was very professional, listened to my wants and was punctual with our agreed upon deadline. 10/10 - would recommend! I only wish i was getting married again as i would love to hire Amy to make, bake and design our cake!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for the kind words , Mandy! It was a pleasure baking for you. Looking at these pictures I have to giggle because my decorating skills have sure come a long way in the past couple of years 😂 but anyway- so glad you liked your cake! Let me know if you need another in the future. -
-
![Kristine]()
Kristine Sent on 02/16/2024Best tasting cake of my life
I was privileged to try Amy’s cake at an event this past fall, and it was a lovely Carrot cake, with cream cheese frosting. I absolutely adored it and had to let her know it was the best cake I have ever had. I am not saying this lightly, if you saw my figure you’d be able to tell I’m quite a cake conessouir. But what I especially appreciated was the fact it had the perfect amount of sweetness, not too much, and it was very moist and had the best texture. It was addicting, but I somehow controlled my urge to eat the whole thing. To me, flavor is king, and if you are going to have a memorable wedding you want the cake to not only look good but taste amazing and be memorable! And Amy will deliver no doubt!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you SO much, Kristine!! This is such a high compliment and I appreciate your kind words more than you knows Let me know if you ever need a cake in the future! 😊 -
![Anne]()
Anne Sent on 02/10/2024Great experience!!
Amy Murnane owner & baker of Cake Me Happy did such a fabulous job serving up some delicious cupcakes for my Valentine Dinner party. Highly recommend her!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Hi Anne! Thanks so much for your nice review. It’s always a pleasure working with you and baking for you! 😊 -
-
![Christy]()
Christy Sent on 02/10/2024A dream come true!
I was so stressed planning everything and I could not find someone local that could achieve my dream cake! I am so blessed to have found Cake Me Happy! The owner was so kind and got my vision right away! Not only did my cake look amazing, it tasted amazing as well! I have used them again since for a few other parties and have always gotten raving reviews from my guests!!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Christy- thank you so much for your kind words!! It was an absolute pleasure working with you and I’m so glad you were happy with your cake 😊 -
-
![Kelsey]()
Kelsey Sent on 02/10/2024Amazing Service and Highly Skilled!
Wonderful service and the cake was amazing. The detail was everything and the taste was top notch. Definitely recommend!Cake Me Happy's reply:
Thank you so much for taking the time to write this nice review, Kelsey! It was a pleasure working with you, and thanks again for your business.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?