Blue Mesa Grill Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
![Kelly]()
Kelly Sent on 08/17/2025Perfect Experience
Karen and everyone at Blue Mesa was simply wonderful to work with, from start to finish. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! Quality, price, and literally everything overall 10/10.Blue Mesa Grill's reply:
Kelly! Your compliments just put the biggest smile on my face! Thank you so much for them and for the recommendation. I absolutely loved working with you and Jayson! Wishes for so much happiness in your marriage! ♥ Karen -
![Carrie]()
Carrie Sent on 01/15/2019Delicious appetizers + flexible service
Blue Mesa customized their appetizer package to meet our needs without going overboard; we couldn't be happier! The restaurant helped us figure out the menu, and we got more for the money than we expected. I especially recommend the pork empanadas. Service included one attendant to keep the buffet tidy. -
![Jazz]()
Jazz Sent on 10/10/2024Wedding Planner raves over Blue Mesa
I am a Wedding Planner and have worked numerous events with Blue Mesa as my couple's chosen caterer. No matter what team is sent out for my event, they are always professional and, on their game! Always eager to assist me in any outrageous request that might arise. The food being great is a bonus- the catering teams are divine and dang they are hustlers!!
I can't recommend them enough!
Jazz Whitney
Jazz Whitney Events - Planner/Coordinator -
![Christine]()
Christine Sent on 10/30/2025Fantastic service
Blue Mesa was one of the best decisions we made when selecting vendors. I didn’t have to worry about a single thing—Karen was so sweet and kind throughout the entire planning process. You can tell she truly loves what she does and wants the best for her clients. Her whole team executed the event flawlessly! The food was just as delicious on our wedding day as it was at the tasting. When I told our venue/coordinator who was catering, they were thrilled too—Karen is clearly loved by everyone she works with! -
![Leigh]()
Leigh Sent on 12/23/2024A Delicious Choice for Our Wedding Reception!
Karen and the team at Blue Mesa Grill delivered a flawless catering experience that left our guests raving! Karen guided us through menu planning with ease, offering creative ideas and professional insights that enhanced our reception. Her ability to accommodate last-minute requests, such as managing the cake cutting, demonstrated her flexibility and commitment to exceptional service.
The food was simply phenomenal. The fajitas were a crowd favorite, packed with bold, fresh flavors that had everyone returning for seconds. The mid-reception quesadilla bar was a perfect addition—our guests loved the energy boost it provided after hours on the dance floor. From the elegantly arranged buffet to the impeccably presented passed hors d’oeuvres, every detail was thoughtfully executed.
The service was just as impressive as the cuisine. The catering staff ensured that tables were quickly cleared and that every aspect of the dining experience ran smoothly. Karen’s team’s professionalism and attentiveness truly elevated our reception, and I would wholeheartedly recommend Blue Mesa Grill for any event in need of outstanding food and service.Blue Mesa Grill's reply:
I am so happy that everyone enjoyed the food so much and had such a good time! What a fun bunch of friends and family you have!! And you're right! The quesadilla bar was such a hit!
We so appreciate your thanks and compliments as well as your recommendation. It was truly my pleasure to help make your wedding day unforgettable! Wishing you the most fabulous first year of marriage!! Karen -
![Katie]()
Katie Sent on 12/04/2024Great Tex Mex for a TX Wedding
Karen was so wonderful to work with! She and her team went above and beyond to make our day smooth and stress free Everyone loved the food (even the picky kids and older folks!) The corn cakes are a must have and she was easily able to accommodate dietary restrictions and made sure everything was labeled Can't thank Karen and the hard working people at Blue Mesa enoughBlue Mesa Grill's reply:
Thank you Katie ~ I'll be sure to share with my caterers and the kitchen staff! We appreciate the trust you placed in us for your very special day. So happy to hear everyone was pleased! Send your pictures when you get them ~ looking forward to seeing them! All my best wishes to you and Sam, Karen -
![Kriscynthia]()
Kriscynthia Sent on 10/06/2017Food was amazing. Not one complaint of quality of food. Everyone loved the way it tasted. -
![Raymond]()
Raymond Sent on 12/19/2024Great choice
Our experience with Karen Hartzell for wedding catering was nothing short of amazing. Karen's expertise, combined with her attentive and friendly approach, made the entire planning process a delight.
Karen's thoughtful recommendations perfectly matched our preferences and budget, showcasing her understanding of creating a special dining experience. Her quick responses and approachable demeanor created a positive and collaborative atmosphere throughout the planning stages.
In summary, if you're in search of a knowledgeable and friendly guide for your wedding catering, Karen Hartzell is the perfect choice. Thank you, Karen!Blue Mesa Grill's reply:
Thank you Ray, again, for such kind words. You and Rachel made my job so easy! And it was my pleasure to help plan your dinner, thank you for allowing me to be a part of your day. Wishing you so much love and happiness ! Karen -
![Staci]()
Staci Sent on 01/02/2025Best of the Best!
Choosing Blue Mesa Grill as the caterer for our November 2024 wedding was one of the best, and easiest, decisions we made throughout the wedding planning process! The personal touch was what made Blue Mesa such an unforgettable RIGHT choice! Karen Hartzell, Blue Mesa’s catering manager, was an absolute dream to work with. She always provided quick, detailed, polite responses and remained so patient, gracious, and understanding with a very overwhelmed bride! Karen was a much-needed breath of fresh air after months of scouring catering sites and reaching out to potential caterers. Not only is Karen delightful and comforting, but she works to ensure that couples have the best experience possible.
At first, I wasn’t sure that Blue Mesa would fit within our catering budget, but Karen expertly took our budget into consideration and presented us with a few different cost-effective, and delicious, options. Even better? Guests are continuing to talk about Blue Mesa’s food weeks after our wedding. Oh, and Karen even wrangled us a couple of drinks as we were waiting to take photos after the ceremony. Her demeanor and customer service excellence are unmatched. I only wish we had another reason to book her and her incredible, professional team again.Blue Mesa Grill's reply:
Staci! There will definitely be another reason to see us! You call me when we get to your first year wedding anniversary and I'll re-create your wedding dinner for you and Kevin! And anyone who was as gracious and calm as you were during iffy weather definitely deserved a cocktail during photo time! I will share you lovely comments with the staff ~ thanks so much for taking the time to review us. And me :) So glad we could all participate in your happy day! Karen -
![Alissa]()
Alissa Sent on 06/03/2017Blue Mesa was AMAZING!! The catering coordinator is ON TOP of it. They did everything they could to make it seamless! Our street taco party was delicious, the full service caterers and bartenders were great... nothing but great things to say about them, and they fit our budget! They went above and beyond what they told us they could do too. THANK YOU Blue Mesa for making my wedding so much fun! -
![Crystal]()
Crystal Sent on 01/21/2022Rehearsal Dinner
Great space for our rehearsal dinner. Excellent food, excellent service. -
![Andrea]()
Andrea Sent on 04/09/2025Above and beyond
From our first meeting with Karen, she took such wonderful care of us. At the tasting we had a custom menu with our name on it, and all the food we selected - there were so many choices and everything tasted wonderful. As the planning process continued, Karen was always quick to respond to emails and so kind. When the big day finally arrived, everyone raved about the food- I'm so happy we choose Blue Mesa! I highly recommend!!Blue Mesa Grill's reply:
Andrea! You and Sharva were one of the most fun couples I've had the pleasure to work with! You were always so precious with each other, full of energy and love. I know you have an amazing marriage ahead of you. I'm so happy to have been part of making your day so wonderful. ♥ Karen
Are you interested?
Are you interested?