Recommended by 98%
Lori · Married on 06/03/2017
Best wedding cake I have ever had. You can not go wrong!!!
Kristine · Married on 06/03/2017
SOO glad we chose to have Andrea make our cake! My husband and I love cheesecake, but we didn't know if we wanted to take the chance in case not everyone liked cheesecake. We decided to do half cake/half cheesecake and omg it was the best thing ever! It looked absolutely beautiful and everyone said it was delicious! I was sad when the next day we only had one piece left!!
Taylor · Married on 04/23/2015
Andrea's wedding cheesecake was amazing! Going to her store and taste testing all the variety of flavors available was so much fun. I ended up going with a traditional layer (the best traditional cheesecake you will ever have) and a layer of amaretto almond. Let me tell you, the amaretto almond is AMAZING! Andrea was helpful in deciding what shape the cake should be for the amount of guests I had and matched the ribbon on the cake to my bridal party colors. The cake looked like a traditional wedding cake from the outside but it was so much better that it was actually cheesecake :). Andrea was easy to work with and very friendly, I would highly recommend using her for your cheesecake wedding cake needs. I would drive from Kentucky where I live for this cheesecake!
User4233803 · 2+ years ago
They made our grooms cake because my husband is obsessed with cheesecake. They only charged $5 for a flavor other than original and it was delicious. They made it exactly what we wanted. It was great!
Shelby · Married on 06/13/2014
We used Andrea's for our grooms cake and had such a great experience. The cake came out exactly how we had pictured it and was absolutely delicious!
Carra · Married on 05/18/2014
This is one of the best cheesecake I had in a long time.. our wedding cake was soo good it was gone before the bride and groom even got piece. . Its was delicious !!!!!
User4351097 · 2+ years ago
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious.
Mackenzie · Married on 03/17/2012
Delicious!! We had a 3 tiered Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake. It looked like any other wedding cake, but it was cheesecake. We ordered a cake large enough so that we could keep the top tier and we had 40 cupcakes in case people didn't like cheesecake. I am pleased, but a little disappointed that there wasn't even a slice left for us to bring home. We will have to order a fresh one for our one year anniversary.
Sharon · Married on 11/13/2011
At first we were leary of having a cheesecake for our wedding cake. We went to Andrea's for a tasting and we were amazed and hooked. We have tasted so many different cakes and frostings and Andrea's cheesecake was by far the best is taste and price. You could not even tell it was a cheesecake. I was happy that we choose Andrea's to make our wedding cake. She was very easy to work with, the cake was so elegant and delicious! Our guest LOVED it and we received so many complimants on our cheesecake wedding cake.
Barbara · Married on 06/07/2009
Andrea's was great and my husband's family kept raving about the cake!!
marilee · Married on 04/12/2015
There service was exceptional.
Elizabeth · Married on 02/18/2012
Love, love, love Andrea and her cheesecakes!! We tried several other cake vendors- boring and the cake was yuck! We knew right away with Andrea that we had to have her cake! We had it transported two hours from her store and worth every penny!! Her cakes are a bit more expensive then some we could have chosen but the quality is worth it! If you want your guests raving about your cake, use Andrea!! We'll be buying again for each anniversary!!!
CP · Married on 07/19/2008
My Family Loves Andrea's Cheesecake, makes my mom feel like she is still in New York!! Andrea's is the Best!! Two Thumbs Up
Athalia · Married on 02/18/2012
AMAZING wedding cheesecake and service! It was the BEST cake any guest would have been lucky to taste and we still feel blessed to have shared our happiest occasion yet with such a wonderful staff.
Timothy · Married on 12/17/2011
The cheesecake wedding cake was a huge success. Great tasting cake with lots of compliments. Will be in for more cheesecake in the future. Thanks so much
April Nicole · Married on 09/20/2014
We got our wedding cake from Andreas. Yes it was solid cheesecake and yes it was delicious. Best cheesecake i have ever had ( ny style). And yes soo good we drove to Orlando to pick it up. She is very accomodating and prices were cheaper than traditional cakes. She does not charge extra for designs however the color and design were not the same as the picture she assured me she could do. However i was able to cover the entire cake in bling wrap ribbon with the roses between the layers it was more gorgeous than.the original design I wanted. Cake was perfect just be aware of the design you are getting.