11 User photos
Kacie T. · Getting married on 10/02/2021
We ordered a unique cake for our wedding of 100 guests. We asked for alternating layers of cakes and a specific design and Nicolle did an amazing job!!!! She was so fabulous to work with and quick to respond. We went to her tasting where she was patient with us. I even emailed her after our tasting to change my mind on the cake and she was so accommodating and nice to work with. The cake was so beautiful and I could not be happier with her and her work ♥️Sent on 10/25/2019
Samara · Married on 11/16/2019
Wedding cakes in NYC can be exorbitantly expensive for absolutely no reason. I'm so glad that we found Nicolle; all we wanted was an elegant, delicious yet simple cake at an affordable price and she nailed it! She was so fun and easy to work with and was so genuinely excited for us! We sent her pictures of our invitation and she was able to mimic the skyline from our invitation onto the cake which came out beautiful and tied everything together! We highly recommend A Simple Cake!Sent on 12/07/2019
Arielle F. · Married on 09/12/2019
Incredible cake and communication!
Nicolle was extremely helpful, amazing, kind, responsive and spectacular from our very first email to the end. She is something else!! Planning a wedding is so stressful and using A Simple Cake was one of the most enjoyable parts of planning because of Nicolle!! The cake was out of this world delicious!!!!!!! Fresh, moist, unique, beautiful. I can still remember the taste of the buttercream frosting with fresh raspberries mixed in! I wish I had it right now. Classic vanilla, buttercream frosting, and raspberry jam filling. I had ordered the 4 tier cake for 200 guests. We had the HUGE bottom layer left over, but I’m not sure if my venue actually served it to everyone because we had other deserts too. So I’m not sure about the sizing. But the leftovers were incredible days later ... everyone at work devoured it. The only mistake was I had my florist put the flowers on the cake after it was delivered and they did not listen to my vision. I should have used Nicolle!!! They played Cherish by Madonna as we cut the cake and it’s a moment I will never forget!Sent on 10/16/2019
Haein · Married on 09/07/2019
Best choice for our intimate winery wedding!
If you are looking for a simple, elegant, and DELICIOUS wedding cake, this is it!!
Nicolle was super nice and helpful in our cake shopping process. We wanted a simple, elegant cake for our wedding and it was just like how we imagined! The process was clear and professional. We visited the kitchen and had a tasting session and it was a blast. :) We ended up ordering a three-tier wedding cake in Devil's food chocolate with layers of white chocolate cream filling with "Rustic Linear Ruffle" design. Our guests raved about the cake and we also loved it! The cake looked exactly like the sample photo. Thank you so much, Nicolle!Sent on 09/10/2019
Sarah C. · Married on 08/30/2019
The best value with the tastiest outcome!
Working with Nicolle at A Simple Cake was truly a pleasure! From our first consult to the final creation, the process was easy, flexible, and well "simple" :) We started by going for a tasting where she brought us three different slices to try based on the flavor preferences we sent in beforehand. After tasting them all, she mentioned that she was working on something new and asked if we might like to try that too. We were so grateful, as that helped us land on our final choice, which was a lemon scented cake with layers of passion fruit curd and raspberry filling (a truly personalized creation). When it came time to coordinating with our florist to dress the cake, Nicolle was more than happy to be flexible and ensure that our cake looked perfect. After having looked at a number of bakeries, A Simple Cake is one of the best values with the tastiest outcome. Thanks, A Simple Cake!Sent on 11/30/2019
Tiffany · Married on 03/23/2019
Perfect cake for my NYC Elopement
When looking for a cake for our small NYC elopement with ten guests, I came across A Simple Cake. I reached out for some information and Nicolle responded right away and answered my questions. The ordering process could not have been easier and the cake was delivered to our hotel where we would be cutting it. The cake was absolutely beautiful. I did add some flowers to the cake but she is able to that if you deliver them to the bakery. We did not have time to do that as we flew in the night before. One of my concerns was being able to carry the rest of the cake back home on the plane and freezing it for our Anniversary. She provided boxes for each layer and little post it notes to tell me which one to put in which box.
As far as the taste, we LOVED it. We ordered the dark chocolate cake with hazelnut cream and cappuccino cream filling. Not only did I enjoy it on my wedding day but I enjoyed it even more when I came home from my honeymoon and took a slice out of the freezer. Just an FYI, it freezes well and defrosts easily on the counter. We cut one layer in several large wedges and one will be traveling to Jamaica soon for my in laws to taste it since they could not be there on our wedding day. Thank you Nicolle for our beautiful, delicious and affordable wedding cake, I will be ordering another one when this is gone!!Sent on 07/14/2019
Irene · Married on 10/06/2018
Amazing cake for a great price
To be honest, I wasn't planning on having cake at my reception originally, as our caterer included a dessert parade as part of their dinner package. However, ultimately we decided on having a cake to cut, so I started looking for vendors... and let me just say, NYC-area prices are ridiculous. I eventually decided on A Simple Cake and another vendor to taste, and despite being about half the price of the other vendor, A Simple Cake's was much better, and a simpler, lighter cake. Day of, the cake was just as good as it was during the tasting (we got the red velvet with buttercream), with our guests telling us it was the best wedding cake they'd had. Nicolle from A Simple Cake was also very easy to work with and responsive. I'd highly recommend working with her and A Simple Cake.Sent on 10/20/2018
Ayesha · Married on 06/21/2018
Such a nice cakes order again this beautiful cake
https://www.cakes.com.pk/Sent on 06/13/2018
Soomin · Married on 06/16/2018
Our wedding cake was 4 tiered devil's food chocolate cake with white chocolate mousse filling frosted with swiss meringue (pearl dot design). The cake was gorgeous and delicious! Nicolle was so sweet and responsive and easy to work with! Both the sample and wedding cake were amazing and our guests really enjoyed their dessert :) Thank you so much again, Nicolle!Sent on 08/11/2018
Mike · Married on 01/14/2018
OMG!! We are so happy with the cake and cookies. We wanted a simple design and great taste combinations. We meet with several others then we sat down with Lauren. She listened and then started to sketch. We wanted a New York City vibe with bicycles incorporated in a subtle way, as this is how we met. She got it sport on simple 4 layers with a skyline motif and a few bikes thrown in. The cake was moist with a chocolate chip cake and mocha frosting. and the fondant with hombre blue dots added to the nighttime of the wedding. but as we talked, we discussed adding bicycle cookies as part a end of night goodie bag with custom bike socks. it all worked so well. Lauren is a professional and in all ways strives to meet and exceed our expectations. Well worth the inspiration!Sent on 01/23/2018
Emily · Married on 03/25/2017
So glad we found "A Simple Cake". Not only was the cake exactly what we wanted - simple, delicious, good value - working with Lauren was great. She was always very responsive. Coordinating the cake tasting samples was easy. She worked directly with our venue with delivery and no issues. We went with the vanilla cake with white chocolate cream filling and buttercream icing. It was perfect. I didn't want anything complicated and this worked perfectly. Definitely recommend. Thank you Lauren!Sent on 04/14/2017
A Simple Cake's reply:Thanks Emily, it was so great working with you guys and I'm thrilled that you loved your cake!
Mark · Married on 06/06/2016
I absolutely loved the cake with both the design and the taste. I received a lot of compliments as well!Sent on 07/20/2016
Katie · Married on 05/28/2016
We were so happy we chose Lauren to make our Wedding Cake! She was absolutely lovely to work with and made the planning process easy and seamless. We met with her at her bakery which is very cute and quaint, and a true reflection of her passion and artistry. We brought pictures of ideas that we wanted for the design and she sketched a few drawings which were great-- the end result blew us away and our cake was gorgeous!Sent on 07/17/2016
Most importantly, the cake tasted like heaven. We went with a chocolate cake and salted caramel buttercream filling-- which was the perfect combo for my husband and I's decadent, chocolate-loving taste buds!! We received compliments the entire night about the cake! We took home the top layer of the cake, and my husband and I, our parents, and brothers all ate it the next morning since none of us had a chance to get a taste at the wedding--I wish I had a piece in front of me now because I'm still remembering how delicious it was-- moist, fluffy cake, and the filing was slightly salty and not too sweet! The price was also very reasonable.
I would recommend A Simple Cake to anyone, and I can't wait to come up with another event to get our next cake from Lauren!
Leidy · Married on 02/27/2016
Lauren was an absolute delight to work with! From our initial conversation to the very end of our wedding, we have loved our experience with her. SHe took her time in answering all our questions, prepared some amazing options for us to try during our cake tasting, coordinated with the florist on the design and delivery of the cake, and was an absolute professional the entire while being truly kind and patient. And, of course, our cake was absolutely delicious! We can;t take to have our top tier on our one-year anniversary!Sent on 04/05/2016
Whitney · Married on 10/18/2015
A Simple Cake is just what I wanted, but it was so much more! It was beautiful, elegant and delicious! Lauren is extremely professional and talented. She made it all so easy and accommodated my last minute scheduling. My fiance and I enjoyed the tasting experience and came up with our favorite combination of chocolate cake with cappuccino cream and chocolate cream fillings. We took the top tier of our cake and ate it on our mini moon!Sent on 10/25/2015
Melissa · Married on 10/10/2015
Delicious beautiful cake! Lauren was really easy to work with, the cake tasting was incredible and our wedding cake was outstanding!Sent on 10/11/2015
Lindsay · Married on 10/10/2015
I am a Wedding Planner with Storybook Weddings and Events, and I had a client who ordered their wedding cake from Lauren for their wedding back in June. The term "simple" can be used to describe the cake, but "simple" is not to be used in a boring way, but in an elegant and classic way :) Lauren was even willing to do a very last-minute change to the cake when an idea came to the couple literally a couple of weeks before the wedding. (We ended up not making the change, but I really appreciated her being open to the idea, and for helping out). Pictures can be seen at: storybookchicago. com/jess-and-mattSent on 01/10/2016
Alexandra · Married on 02/21/2015
Wow, Lauren is absolutely amazing! I called her 4 days before the wedding and asked her if she could do something for us. She not only understood our budget limitations, but made a cake that received compliments from EACH guest at the party! We picked red velvet cake, made with buttercream with a sugar swag design...Couldn't be 1. more beautiful and 2. more delicious. Above that, talking to Lauren was a pleasure, she is a sweetheart!Sent on 02/22/2015
I will definitely keep her contact for future events!
Teresa · Married on 11/15/2014
We are SO happy we chose A Simple Cake as our cake vendor. While we wanted the outside of our cake to look elegant and pretty, we were more concerned with the cake actually tasting good (which is where we have found a lot of cakes at other weddings to fail). A Simple Cake's approach seemed perfect for us, and we were right! Our cake was not only simple and beautiful on the outside (we just did butter cream frosting with a pearl dot design and fresh flowers/ivy), but also incredibly delicious on the inside; we've been told multiple times already that it was the best cake many of our guests had ever tasted at a wedding. The unique, elevated flavor combinations offered really allowed us to personalize the cake to our theme and the season as well - we had a 4 layer cake and went for Buttermilk Spice Cake with Hazelnut Cream filing for two layers and Dark Chocolate with Triberry Compote for the remaining two. Both combos were AMAZING. Lauren was funny, sweet, and incredibly easy to work with too, which really added to the sense of trust and ease we had while working A Simple Cake. We wouldn't hesitate to recommend them to anyone!Sent on 11/22/2014
Eugene · Married on 09/30/2014
We had a great experience with Lauren and A Simple Cake. We wanted a no - frills cake for our small (50 people) wedding. Lauren had many designs and delicious flavors to choose from and our cake was a huge hit with the guests.Sent on 10/31/2014
User4552878 · 2+ years ago
Lauren was such a pleasure to work with - accommodating, caring, and super creative. Our style leans much more modern than most of the fluffy, over-the-top "wedding cake" offerings that are out there so to discover her was a godsend. Her sensibility and style was perfectly "simple" and chic. She has a true love and talent for baking, and our wedding cake was both stunning and delicious. Honestly, I wish she could bake all our cakes for future special occasions. We only wish we had more cake leftover to enjoy!Sent on 11/17/2014
User4515090 · 2+ years ago
I had a great experience with simple cake! I called Lauren in July ( only 1 month before the wedding! ) and I still got the cake I wanted. No compromises. Lauren called me two weeks before the wedding to finalize things and that was that. The cake was at the venue on time. They coordinated with the maitre d'themselves. I was very very happy with my cakes got a ton of compliments!Sent on 10/30/2014
Krista · Married on 08/22/2014
I can't recommend A Simple Cake enough! Lauren was a pleasure to work with and helped answer all of my questions. She coordinated directly with our venue, which made everything so easy! Our cake turned out to be beautiful and so delicious!Sent on 01/19/2015
Laura · Married on 05/03/2014
My husband and I got our wedding cake from A Simple Cake after tasting samples from a few other places. We were so happy with our decision! The cake was gorgeous and delicious -- we were sad not to have ordered extra to have more left over! But we plan to order a small one for our one year anniversary, it was that good. The people we worked with at A Simple Cake were professional and responsive, and the cake was delivered in perfect condition.Sent on 05/24/2014
Oksana · Married on 11/09/2013
Lauren was amazing! She created the cake of my dreams! It looked awesome and tasted so good. All the guests loved it! I would highly recommend her to my friends.Sent on 11/11/2013