Keys Cafe & Bakery

Kenzi from the Stillwater location helped us with our wedding dessert bar/table setup. They also made us an adorable little cake for the traditional cake cutting. We had a huge variety of desserts we could choose from, and they also said that if there was something not on the list we could let them know and they would more than likely be able to make it happen. They were super personable and flexible. It was clear that they just wanted us to have an easy, pleasant experience. We had some cheesecakes, some cupcakes, and some bars. We were told by several people that it was the best desserts that they ever had! My cousin owns a chain of therapy centers, and said that she will only go through Keys Cafe now for any of their dessert/treat needs. Because we were so busy on our wedding day, we didn't end up getting a chance to try the desserts until several days later. The cupcakes were still SUPER soft! Highest recommendations are the German Chocolate Cupcakes and Strawberry Cheesecake, thought we heard the other options we had there were great, too! Also: super affordable!

We would highly recommend Keys as a wedding vendor! Our experience with them was fantastic. They were extremely good with communication throughout the planning process, and we were able to adjust the menu to our needs and customize menu items. The Keys team helped make everything go super smoothly for the day of the wedding. They brought the food right on time and set everything up quickly and efficiently. They were also able to work with what was available at our venue for storage and setup with no issues. The food itself is also delicious; we got tons of compliments on it from our guests!

Amazing desserts for wedding reception! Keys made us a small two tier cutting cake decorated exactly how we were hoping, and then we had an assortment of cupcakes, cookies, cake balls, and bars. Everything was so yummy and their team handled the set up of everything so smoothly. They were so helpful helping us decide on how many items to get for our guests, and we ended up having the perfect amount. They also were super accommodating with the amount of flavors I wanted of everything. I would recommend them to anyone!

Our wedding cake was absolute perfection! I sent them multiple cake designs I loved, along with specific details from each that I wanted incorporated, and they completely understood the vision. They brought everything together beautifully and were so accommodating throughout the entire process. Working with them was incredibly easy and stress-free, which made such a difference during wedding planning. I couldn’t recommend them enough!

Keys Cafe & Bakery never disappoints! Everything is always fresh, delicious and beautifully done. There is so much pride in what they do and I love supporting a local family business that consistently delivers and would choose none other for my wedding desserts!

Absolutely recommend!

I had the absolute pleasure of having my wedding desserts made by Keys Cafe & Bakery, and I couldn’t have been happier! From start to finish, I didn’t have to worry about a thing. Everything was beautifully set up, delivered right on time, and taken care of so professionally.

And the tres leches cake… WOW! 🤤 It was talked about for weeks after the wedding, and our guests are still raving about it!

We had the pleasure of working with Keys for my sisters bridal shower and when I tell you they were fabulous, I truly mean it. The food and desserts were incredible, the amount of detail that went into everything they created, it was so nice not having to worry!

Their communication was on point, ensuring the day would be set up for success. If you would love to cross this off your own list, and leave it in the hands of the professionals, you won’t be disappointed!!

I sent in photos of ideas for the sugar cookies I wanted, and they executed beyond what I asked! They even made special shaped cookie cutters so my sister could have the shower of her dreams.

Thank you again Keys!!! Much appreciated!!!

We had the absolute best experience with Keys for our wedding desserts! They were so flexible and easy to work with throughout the entire process. They listened to our ideas, offered creative suggestions, and helped bring our vision to life in ways we never would have thought of ourselves. Everything matched our wedding theme and colors perfectly, and the desserts looked absolutely beautiful! We also loved having such a wide variety of options for our guests. There was truly something for everyone, and our guests could not stop talking about how delicious everything was. We received so many compliments! We couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out. If you’re looking for a bakery that is talented, creative, accommodating, and genuinely cares about making your special day perfect, we highly recommend Keys!