I Want Pretty Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
![WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2024 Winner]()
5.0 out of 5 rating
169 Reviews
99% recommend it
-
Paula B. Sent on 11/06/2023
Eric and Kathleen's Wedding
We had to plan a wedding very quickly and Preeti was recommended to us by a friend. Preeti listened to what we wanted and then she gave us exactly what we asked for. The cake was absolutely stunning and it was DELICIOUS!! -
-
![Robert]()
Robert L. Sent on 09/18/2023Beautiful cake for a beautiful wedding!
Super nice, professional, detail oriented and fun to work with! Very helpful for gathering specifics for how the cake should be made and what it should look like. The end result was a beautiful MASTERPIECE of a cake that was equally just as delicious! The cake was a big hit at our wedding and if there was ever an occasion I gotta have a special cake, look no further!!! 10/10 -
-
![Diana]()
Diana F. Sent on 08/08/2023Beautiful and Tasty!
We hired Preeti as our wedding cake baker based off the glowing reviews and let me tell you we did not regret it one bit! First off, the process for tasting was so easy and Preeti was super helpful with tips and recommendations. Second, the cake came out absolutely beautiful and it tasted phenomenal. She was super flexible and affordable. I will definitely use her services again. -
-
![Dawnisha]()
Dawnisha Sent on 07/06/2023I thought the vendor did a wonderful job!
Thanks Preeti the cake was beautifully made and tasted delightful! Thank you for keeping in contact with me until the end making sure everything was good to go. And delivering the cake on time. Everyone enjoyed the cake so much most of it was gone. -
![Alicia]()
Alicia H. Sent on 07/31/2023Personable and kind very detailed oriented and cakes are delicious and moist
Pretty cakes was very personable to make sure your vision is just what you imagine. She pays attention to detail very responsive, kind and communicates well! She is professional, and I would highly recommend! -
-
Annetta Sent on 06/17/2023
Preeti is very professional and the cake was so beautiful!
The cake was absolutely gorgeous and Preeti was very patient in custom designing a 4 tier cake for us with 3 different flavors with the colors and patterns we talked about. She was very responsive and delivered exactly as promised. Everyone loved both the look and taste. Would absolutely recommend Preeti to anyone looking for a very special cake. -
-
![John]()
John K. Sent on 11/25/2022Extraordinarily talented baker & cake designer!
From our initial consultation, to finalizing the cake design, to the delivery at our wedding, it was a pleasure to work with Preeti. Her cake is the best I have ever tasted, and her talent as a designer allowed us to display and enjoy a truly unique cake that not only fit with our wedding theme but accentuated and elevated it. We are serving the delicious leftovers at our holiday party, and we cannot wait to get the professional photos back so we can marvel once again at our beautiful wedding cake! -
Gregory S. Sent on 07/04/2022
Wonderful Experience!
My wife and I loved our experience working with Preeti as our wedding cake vendor. During the planning and contracting phase, when we were unsure of how many guests we would have at our wedding, she gave us the flexibility within the contract to “start smaller” than we expected, with the option to pay more as needed if we predicted that we would need a cake larger than originally projected. This flexibility not only brought us peace of mind (since we could potentially ask for an increased size up to three weeks in advance) it also saved us money, because we ended up only needing the smaller size she recommended! We were impressed how Preeti went out of her way to make sure we had everything we wanted and needed while saving us money. For example, she showed us examples of how she could visually decorate the cakes with buttercream frosting to look like fondant icing, without having to pay the additional expense that usually comes with fondant icing! My wife loves the look of fondant icing on cakes, so we were really pleased that we could capture that look while staying within budget. Preeti also beautifully decorated our cake with “frosting pearls” and fresh roses provided from our florist; it was a beautiful work of art. Beyond her willingness to find ways for us to save money without sacrificing quality and the striking visual aesthetic of her work, the taste was outstanding! During the tasting period, social distancing was still encouraged, so she baked us “mini-cupcakes” of up to six cake and filling combinations to take home as samples. We chose a strawberry cake, pineapple filling combination. Our guests loved it; it was the perfect size, there were very few leftovers for us to take home (though the perfect leftover portion for my wife and I), the colors (white frosting, red strawberry cake, gold pineapple filling) perfectly coordinated with our wedding colors, and most of all, it just tasted superb. Pretti also lent us a golden cake stand ($200 security deposit, fully refundable upon return to Pretti), which matched perfectly with our décor and saved us the money of having to buy an additional piece of décor. Thank you Pretti; our day couldn’t have gone any better, and both your prep work before the wedding and your work the day of shone through brightly! -
-
Won R. Sent on 04/17/2022
Happy time with local vendor
We love working with local vendors over bigger brands. Preeti was easy to talk to and we felt really cared for as if by a very friendly neighbor. The cake came on time just as expected and Preeti decorated it for us with the flowers that we provided which were very kind of her.
Would recommend to all locals! Just a note: our total includes a $200 cake stand deposit which we were able to get back promptly after the wedding. -
-
![Sarah]()
Sarah C. Sent on 11/28/2020Excellent cupcakes
Preeti created a red velvet cupcake tower with a cake topper for our wedding. It was a beautiful display, and the red velvet cupcakes were so delicious. I would highly recommend I Want Pretty Cakes for any upcoming event you may have. -
![Kerri]()
Kerri U. Sent on 08/31/2020The BEST Wedding Cake Ever
We are so thrilled that we chose Preeti with I Want Pretty Cakes for our wedding cake!! When we went for our consultation, I literally moaned out loud when I tasted the first sample. Her cakes are THAT good! She was incredibly knowledgeable and worked with us on the design.
The day of our wedding, our cake looked exactly how we wanted - it was absolutely beautiful! We had 3 layers and each was a different flavor. I feel like most wedding cakes are kind of tasteless and dry. But every layer of ours was amazing! Moist and flavorful and delicious! Plus, it smelled fantastic! We were able to take a couple pieces home with us, and every night we wish we had some more! I can't speak highly enough about Preeti and her cakes. Her prices are great, she's a very kind and talented baker, and our wedding cake tasted sooooo good! -
-
Sgl Sent on 11/05/2021
Extraordinary
We were honored to have Pretti prepare a unique cake that exceeded our expectations on the wedding day, 10/16/2021. As an SGL couple, we appreciated the level of care and happiness for us to get married. The cake was phenomenal and a hit with our guests. Before our wedding used her creative expertise for a friend's birthday, and many were in awe over the level of detail put into the cake, which made the experience even more special. Thank you for all that you do in making those served experiences one of a kind and unique. Till we meet again.
Neal and Moe -
-
![Misty]()
Misty R. Sent on 05/24/2022Beautiful cake and amazing service
I highly recommend any cake for an event done by Preeti. We were able to order samples prior to picking flavors and every single one of them was amazing. We settled for white cake and strawberry filling, chocolate cake and peanut butter filling, and strawberry cake with lemon filling. All of the flavors were perfect and the guests couldn't get enough of it. The presentation was absolutely beautiful. She did all the requests colors and set up as I asked. I can't imagine having a better cake and cupcake stand for our wedding. Thank you so much, you've given our guests something to talk about for time to come. -
