Dortoni Bakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.7 out of 5 rating
![WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2024 Winner]()
4.7 out of 5 rating
480 Reviews
94% recommend it
Awards
-
Featured
![Meagan]()
Meagan L. Sent on 07/18/2024Wedding Cake - Harbor Club at Prime
We had a great experience with using Dortoni for our wedding cake! Our cake was contracted with our venue, Harbor Club at Prime, in which we got a 4 tier cake. We went for a cake tasting and were able to choose 1 cake flavor and 2 fillings for our cake. We went with funfetti, chocolate ganache and cannoli and our cake was DELICIOUS. We used their design book to pick out the design and it came out exactly how we envisioned it. -
-
![Taylor]()
Taylor J. Sent on 08/27/2024Highly Recommend!
If you’re planning a wedding in Long Island, Dortoni Bakery is the way to go! The cake was exquisite, and the staff was professional and friendly. They made the entire process stress-free and enjoyable. -
![Jenifar]()
Jenifar Sent on 08/27/2024Exceptional Service
Dortoni bakery provided exceptional service for our wedding. The cake was a true work of art, and the flavor was divine. Highly Recommended for every couple -
![Anthony]()
Anthony Sent on 08/31/2024Incredible Flavours
We were blown away by the incredible flavours of our wedding cake from Dortoni bakery. Every layer was perfectly moist and flavourful. The whole staff was wonderful to work with, ensuring that everything went smoothly on our big day -
![James]()
James L. Sent on 08/24/2024Amazing Cake
Was blown away by my wedding cake we gave her a picture and she did the rest. They were so nice and pleasant from start to finish. Thanks Dortoni -
![Johnsonn]()
Johnsonn C. Sent on 08/26/2024A Cake to Remember!
Our wedding cake from Dortoni Bakery was a masterpiece! It looked stunning and tasted even better. The team was professional, attentive, and made the entire process a joy. Five stars all the way! -
![David]()
David H. Sent on 09/01/2024Unmatched Professionalism
Dortoni bakery truly stands out for their professionalism. From the moment we first spoke to them, they were organized, responsive and detail oriented. The wedding cake was perfectly designed, fresh and moist. Their quality of service is simply the best in Long Island -
![Kyle]()
Kyle W. Sent on 08/26/2024Flawless Service
We couldn’t be happier with dortoni bakery. The wedding cake was flawless and the service was exceptional. The staff went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. Highly recommended -
![Michael]()
Michael S. Sent on 08/31/2024An Unforgettable Cake
Our guests are still talking about our wedding cake from Dortoni Bakery! It was not only beautiful but also unforgettable in taste. The staff made the entire process enjoyable and stress-free. Five-star service -
![Chris]()
Chris M. Sent on 08/30/2024Beyond Our Expectations
Dortoni Bakery exceeded all our expectations with our wedding cake. From the initial consultation to the final product, everything was perfect. The staff truly listened to our ideas and brought them to life. Highly recommend!! -
![Johny]()
Johny N. Sent on 08/31/2024A seamless experience!
Working with dortoni bakery was seamless from start to finish. they made our wedding cake process easy and enjoyable. The cake was not only gorgeous but also full of flavor. The team's professionalism is top-tier -
![Donna]()
Donna C. Sent on 08/24/2024Delicious ! Best Wedding Cake
The best Bakery for Wedding Cake. Taste was amazing. Highly recommend!Dortoni Bakery's reply:
Thank you Donna! We sincerely appreciate the opportunity to bring your dream cake to life and hope to celebrate many more sweet occasions together. -
![Stephanie]()
Stephanie A. Sent on 02/03/2024Delighted with Dortoni
We used Dortoni for our wedding cake and were so very happy with the results.
First of all, we love Dortoni’s because they make some of the best cannoli you can get this side of the Atlantic - just an FYI.
Regarding our wedding cake, we were thrilled with the result. It looked beautiful and tasted delicious. Ours was 4 layers with the 1st and 3rd layers being a chocolate cake with raspberry mousse and chocolate ganache filling, and the 2nd and 4th layers was a carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. Everything was delicious. To top it all off, they gave us a certificate to come back in one year for a free “top of your wedding cake” - perfect for that 1 year anniversary tradition! Thank you to all who work at Dortoni, we could not recommend you enough!
-
-
Jacqueline Sent on 01/08/2024
Wonderful Wedding Cake
We got our cake from the Dortoni location in Levittown and it was wonderful! They are partnered with our venue so 4-tier cake was included in our contract, which made organizing everything very simple. We had heard good things about this bakery pre-wedding both from people who got wedding cakes there and friends who just use it as their go-to bakery and everyone had good things to say. It was quick and easy to book our tasting, the bakery was very accommodating and the staff was kind and helpful. We got to try 3 flavors of cake and 6 fillings. They offer a great variety of flavors of both that cater to all different tastes, from very sweet to more fresh with fruit, and everything in between. Some flavors of cake and filling are an extra cost to choose, but they make clear which carry the upcharge when tasting and making your decision. Everything at the tasting was absolutely delicious, really light and moist. It was some of, if not the, best wedding cake we’d ever tried! They were also able to easily accommodate our request to pick 2 cake and filling flavors for our cake… everything was SO good it was hard to pick just one of each! We ended up going with 2 tiers of chocolate cake with chocolate pudding filling and 2 tiers of vanilla cake with fresh berry chantilly cream filling to make sure the cake would include something virtually everyone would like one way or the other. We made the order right there at the tasting and picked our frosting design from their book of options, and then that was it! Everything arrived beautifully done to the wedding venue day-of and the cake was beyond delicious. They also include a gift certificate for a mini recreation of your wedding cake to use on your first anniversary, which is so smart and special, we’re looking forward to using it! We would highly recommend and are so happy with our experience! -
-
Cara Z. Sent on 11/30/2023
The staff during the entire process were so lovely! Our cake tasting experience was so delicious and they helped make it so intimate.
Our cake was absolutely gorgeous and they matched our reference picture exactly! It was also delicious!! -
-
![Kace]()
Kace Sent on 12/27/2023Book them! Amazing
This was the best cake I ever had at a wedding. So many people were talking about how great it was! They even made my top layer gluten free so I could have some! Thank you!!! -
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer S. Sent on 11/17/2023Delicious and Amazing!
Dortoni Bakery exceeded our expectations in crafting the perfect wedding cake for our November 12th celebration. The entire process was seamless, thanks to their easy-to-navigate approach, and the staff's communication was top-notch. The cake itself was not only delicious but also a true work of art, adding a delightful touch to our special day. Highly recommend Dortoni Bakery for their exceptional service and delectable creations! -
![Jenny]()
Jenny A. Sent on 11/08/2023A perfect cake
What to say… I have dreamed of a dortonis wedding cake since I was a little girl and it did not disappoint. The tasting was a smooth process and we even surprised ourselves on what our final pick was. The cake was Moist, full of flavor.
The best part is they give you a certificate to come back on your one year anniversary for a small replica! -
-
![Lauren]()
D. Sent on 10/22/2023Excellent Quality and Service
It was a pleasure to work with Dotorni Bakery in East Norwich. From the initial tasting to all the emails finalizing the order, I was confident my cake would be a beautiful supplement to my wedding. Delivery was perfect and on time. The cake was delicious, we cannot wait to tastt the top layer at our first year anniversary! -
-
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 10/15/2023Beautiful and Delicious Cake
Dortoni's did an excellent job from start to finish. They were sweet and professional throughout the process. From scheduling to first tasting, their communication over the phone and over email was seamless. They also go the extra mile. We asked for some edible seashells for the cake and they covered it in colorful, beautiful shells. They also provided us with a cake voucher on our 1 year anniversary! Even "not cake people" loved the cake. Thank you Dortoni's! -
Cynthia C. Sent on 09/22/2023
Beautiful cake!!
Our cake came with us booking The Watermill. We did our tasting a few months ago and had so much fun trying all the flavors. Our favorite was the chocolate cannoli! We went with an all chocolate cake with different fillings in each tier. It was delicious and so beautiful!!! Exactly what we were looking for!! And, you get a certificate to return for a cake for your first anniversary!! -
-
Kamika Sent on 09/08/2023
Wonderful!!
I truly loved the flavor of our cake. Our cake was so moist. We are still eating it and it's been a week since our wedding
-
Are you interested?
Are you interested?