Frosted Pumpkin Reviews
Reviews
4.8 out of 5 rating
4.8 out of 5 rating
141 Reviews
96% recommend it
Awards
-
![Morgan]()
Morgan C. Sent on 08/09/2023Wonderful!
I heard many good things about Jeff just based on word of mouth & social media. From scheduling our tasting to delivering our cake, everything was great. The tasting was so much fun & Jeff is so personable. All the cakes we tasted were amazing. We had done a few other tastings and weren’t really sold on any of the flavors, but ALL of the flavors we tasted from Frosted Pumpkin were fantastic. We ended up doing a vanilla genoise with a raspberry preserve & then a chocolate cake with chocolate mousse & ganache filling. Both flavors were wonderful. All of our guests talked about how good the cake was.
During the tasting we also tasted a carrot cake. Jeff told us it would be the best carrot cake we ever had & he was not wrong. The cake was AMAZING, just like all the other cakes. Frosted Pumpkin uses some of the best ingredients and you can tell in the quality & taste of the cakes. I can’t wait for fall to hopefully get a carrot cake.
If you want an experience that is great from start to finish, Frosted Pumpkin is the baker you want. From communication, to tasting & design, to delivery of cake, it was all seamless. Frosted Pumpkin will not only give you an amazing wedding cake but they’ll have you wanting more & more cakes for years to come after your wedding! -
![Alisa]()
Alisa M. Sent on 06/27/2023Absolutely delicious!!
Jeff is unbeatable! It was really hard to narrow down the selection to 2 flavors because all of them were so delicious. The final 2 were definitely crowd pleasers! -
![Morgan]()
Cole F. Sent on 06/22/2021Frosted Pumpkin is THE BEST in the business
Word's can't express how amazing this husband and wife duo are. The quality of their ingredients and the level of creative execution are unmatched. They're cakes and desserts are delicious and flawlessly decorated. They not only make incredible cakes but they also went above and beyond to share their wealth of wedding experience with me which made the planning process so easy and fun. -
-
Brandon H. Sent on 11/12/2020
The best cake I've ever tasted
Frosted pumpkin was so easy to work with. We were able to taste cakes in their home, which was very convenient. The cakes tasted amazing and looked even better -
-
![Sarah]()
Sarah M. Sent on 02/15/2021Amazing Design, Taste, and Great to Work With!
I could go on all day about how great Frosted Pumpkin is to work with. Jeff is very personable and really listed to my thoughts on the aesthetic I wanted for our wedding. He then came up with a completely unique-to-us design, combining elements of other cakes he had done. He also had the wisdom to guide me to doing 4 tiers instead of 3 which I have to say.. honestly it just looks so much better and was a bigger statement.
The taste of these cakes are also divine. We had two options for our guests, one was decadent (chocolate with salted caramel and fudge icing) and one was lighter (vanilla genoise with cream cheese icing and raspberry glaze). For our top tier, we did a carrot cake and I can't wait to eat that on our one year anniversary. I loved that they gave us flexibility to mix things up like that.
You can't go wrong going with Frosted Pumpkin! Do it! -
-
![Terri]()
Terri Sent on 10/24/2020Wonderful cake!
Frosted Pumpkin made our beautiful cake. It looked just as beautiful as the photos on the website. Most important is that it was tasty and enjoyed by all! -
![Lilibeth]()
Lb Sent on 05/11/2021The most delicious cake!
Jeff is amazing! We had a few cake tastings scheduled but once we met with Jeff we cancelled them all. The tasting was delicious! We had trouble deciding which cake to choose as all flavors and combinations were absolutely delicious. At the tasting we were not yet sure of the style of cake we wanted and Jeff helped us figure that out as well. He spent time going over pictures of different cake styles to help us figure out what we wanted. We had to reschedule a few time due to COVID and Jeff moved our date with no issues. The day of the wedding the cake was just as delicious as it was at our tasting! We picked two different flavors and our guests were served both and everyone loved them! -
![Heather]()
Heather R. Sent on 11/22/2019Delicious and Beautiful!
Jeffrey’s cake was fantastic!! I fell in love with the flavors at the tasting. Salted caramel, with fudge and then vanilla with buttercream. Everyone went on and on about it. There wasn’t a slice left over. Thankfully I have my top layer saved! It was classic and beautiful. I was very happy! Thank you Jeffrey. -
-
![Ellette]()
Ellette Sent on 11/17/2019Delicious and Beautiful!
Frosted Pumpkin cakes are not only beautiful, they are also delicious! They made our wedding cake and a grooms cake. We had enough cake for 150 people with 130 guests and all the cake was gone. So good! -
![Rachel]()
Rachel H. Sent on 01/14/2019Wonderful!
Jeff was wonderful to work with. He was very knowledgeable and helpful while we were tasting/designing our cake. The cakes are also fantastic! Our wedding cake was so good that we ended up digging into it when we got back from our honeymoon 😊 -
Barbara Sent on 11/18/2020
Exceptional Wedding Cake
Jeffrey is a true genius when it comes to wedding cakes! We had a cake tasting earlier in the summer where he provided a number of small tastings of a variety of his creations. Each one stood on its own, but the carrot cake with cream cheese filling and swiss butter cream frosting won by the slimmest of margins over the chocolate ganache. Throughout the process Jeffrey stayed in tune with the wedding and due to COVID, modified the plan for the cake that would be displayed. It was just as beautiful - exactly the style our daughter wanted, and when the cake that was passed, was safe for our guests. Whether you like white cake, chocolate, and carrot - with many choices in between - you cannot go wrong with the creations from Frosted Pumpkin. -
-
Amy Sent on 08/19/2018Frosted Pumpkin cakes are delicious, as well as beautiful. Jeff is very talented in working with you to design a pretty, elegant looking cake for your wedding. For our daughter’s summer wedding, he listened to what our decor plan was and then drew up a mock plan of the cake design, right then and there! We had a good idea of what the cake would look like well before the wedding day. But, most important to me, his cakes taste incredible and will be enjoyed by your guests! The only hard part is deciding which flavor(s) of cake to choose!
-
-
Payton Sent on 05/25/2018Frosted Pumpkin is AMAZING, and we LOVED our cake on our wedding day (so did all of our guests). We got married at the Georgian Terrace Hotel on April 21, 2018, and we had a 4-tier cake with alternating vanilla and chocolate layers to serve 200+ people. We met with one of the owners, Jeff, about 2 months prior to the wedding for 1.5 hours for the tasting and design meeting. He is so personable and fun, and he really took his time to get to know us and talk through details and different variations of the cake so we could get exactly what we wanted. You cannot beat the customer service, design, or taste of Frosted Pumpkin! My husband and I can't wait for our one-year anniversary to eat the topper ... but maybe we will dig in before that!
-
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message