Toby McAllister Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 12/12/2025Complete Wedding Music Service
I won’t focus on the quality of the Jameson Four’s music because from any video or song you hear, it’s instantly clear how amazing they are. They kept the energy high all night and made sure our wedding truly felt like a celebration.
Working with Toby during the planning process was incredible, he is the definition of a professional. He made choosing the music a breeze and thought of every detail. Just 15 days before our wedding, when we mentioned that our caterer had canceled, Toby immediately offered help. From sharing contacts to even offering that he’d pick up pizzas if it came to that, he went above and beyond anything you’d expect from a wedding band.
Day of, Toby and the Jameson Four were punctual, prepared, and brought everything needed for a seamless ceremony and reception. Toby nailed the timing of our ceremony music and first dance, and the entire night flowed perfectly. They truly provide a full-service package including supplying a microphone for the officiant and toasts, ceremony music, cocktail hour music, lights, introductions, and of course the reception. We’re so grateful we chose the Jameson Four and can’t wait to see Toby at some of his concerts in the future! -
![Alex]()
Alex Sent on 12/07/2025The most personal and attentive music vendor!
Toby was so easy to work with and took the time to make sure our wedding day went perfect. He is a great communicator and makes sure to do regular check-ins before the big day! Super down to earth and flexible. His band plays amazing music and can play anything/genre! Toby did an outdoor acoustic wedding ceremony on his guitar that made coming down the aisle so special and romantic. Toby is trustworthy and made sure the schedule was flawless. Would recommend this band 100%!!! -
-
Matthew Sent on 12/05/2025
The best!!
My wife and I can’t recommend Toby and his band enough! We saw Toby performing at a local brewery and we were immediately impressed. I approached him to ask if he played weddings and was happily surprised to hear “yes,” and that he had a band that would be available to join him. He offered his information and we reached out to schedule the rest. Fast forward to our wedding date and they were absolutely phenomenal! Our dance floor was alive the entire night thanks to the energy they brought to the space with their amazing music. Toby himself was so helpful to work with and even helped us out with some sound equipment for our welcome dinner the night before. Can’t recommend them enough! -
-
![Omar]()
Omar Sent on 12/05/2025Simply the Best
Where to even start. Toby and his band were phenomenal, not just the day of but throughout the entire process. Toby was always willing to hop on the phone and talk through all things sound, microphone, and logistics related and he was genuinely just one of the nicest guys we could've hired for our wedding. Throughout the day, Toby was on top of everything, making sure microphones were set and crushed the acoustic renditions we asked for while walking down the aisle. We had some weather issues throughout causing some shifts in schedule and Toby's calmness and demeaner was truly felt by all. Once that was all sorted, the band kicked off and truly made it feel like a party! The amount of texts I got the day after talking about how awesome Toby and his band were are also definitely a testament to how good they are. Of all of our vendors, Toby was definitely the most responsive and we simply could not recommend him and his band enough. -
![Dan]()
Dan Sent on 06/29/202510/10 would book again!
We cannot say enough amazing things about Toby and the entire band! From our very first conversation, Toby was incredibly responsive, communicative, and genuinely excited to be part of our wedding. He and the band were incredibly flexible and accommodating throughout the planning process; even learning a few special songs that meant a lot to us. That level of effort truly made our day feel personal and unforgettable.
The setlist was diverse and perfectly curated, with something for everyone, from classics to dance floor favorites. Our guests didn’t stop raving about the energy and talent of the band, and the dance floor was packed all night. Toby has an incredible voice and stage presence, and the entire group brought such a fun, professional, and polished vibe to the evening.
Beyond the music, they were a great value and just a joy to work with. Toby went above and beyond to help put us at ease in the weeks leading up to the wedding which was so appreciated. If you’re lucky enough to book them, do it. They made our wedding night one to remember forever -
![Jacob]()
Jacob Sent on 10/25/2024Couldn't have asked for better!
Toby was amazing to work with and super easy! My wife and I did a destination wedding in Maine (we're from Minnesota) and he made the process of getting everything set up effortless. Even when he was in the studio recording an album, he answered our questions promptly. In person, you will not meet a friendlier guy. I even surprised my wife by bringing one of my guitars to the wedding and Toby and the guys were more than willing to accommodate me last minute.
As for the music, what a banger! We were a little concerned that we wouldn't get much dancing since it was a live band rather than a DJ, but with the classic 90s hits and a few cool renditions of modern pop songs that they did, I don't think we had an empty dance floor all night.
Long story short, if you're looking for a wedding band in Maine, hire Toby. You won't find anyone better. -
![Kristin]()
Kristin Sent on 11/25/2023Wicked Good!
We are SO glad we followed up on a recommendation to hire Toby and The Jameson Four for our wedding on MDI! Our family and friends are still talking about the awesome live music that got everyone on the dance floor! Toby is a down-to-earth professional who absolutely nailed the vibe we were going for. Besides the awesome music, we knew we could totally trust Toby to take care of emcee duties, the sound system during the ceremony, collaborate with the other vendors, etc., etc. If you’re thinking about having live music and hiring Toby, go for it, you won’t regret it. There’s nothing like wicked good live music! 200% recommend and would hire again! -
![Zachary]()
Zachary Sent on 11/02/2023the HIGHLIGHT of our wedding!
Toby and his band played at our wedding up in Baxter State Park - not an easy place to get to, and their performance absolutely made the trip worth it for everyone - Guests were talking about the band for weeks!! We can't say enough about how great they sounded, how friendly, helpful and responsive Toby was in planning, and how insanely fun the band made the reception. Highly highly recommended, I might crash your wedding to hear them play again if you book them. -
-
![Kristen]()
Kristen Sent on 11/02/2023So fun! Fantastic to work with and HUGE hit with everyone
Toby and his bandmates did an incredible job with our wedding! Toby was really easy to work with, very responsive, and took time to answer my many questions and help with planning! On the day of the wedding, they were super flexible and chill (Hurricane Lee hit that day) - played music for our ceremony and then absolutely killed it at the reception. The band was SO FUN, sounded amazing, took requests, played for so long, and definitely hit all of our favorites. Everyone loved them; the next morning, every single person we talked to commented on how awesome they were. Absolutely a great deal for the cost. We couldn't have been happier, and 1000% recommend Toby for whatever music you need! -
![Aaron]()
Aaron Sent on 09/02/2023Fully & Totally, Good Great!
Toby is a genuine and EXCELLENT human and that was evident on our first phone conversation. He is a consummate professional and highly responsive. He preformed with The Jameson Four at our wedding and it was an absolute dream! The owner of our wedding venue came in to say hello during the reception...Upon hearing the band she said they are going on her preferred vendor list! All of our guests were blown away - you need to hire them to play at your wedding! -
![Steve]()
Steve Sent on 07/23/2023Couldn’t have been better
Had Toby as a solo act for my wedding in June. He responded to everything and answered every question my wife and I had. We met him to discuss plans over a drink a few weeks prior and when the day came all the details we laid out were taken care of flawlessly.
My wife and I gave toby a small playlist of things we wanted and he took the ball and ran with it creating a better experience than we hoped for. Truly an amazing artist and I can’t recommend enough. -
![Melissa]()
Melissa Sent on 06/04/2023Awesome addition to our wedding!
Toby played live music for our wedding ceremony, cocktail hour, and first dance, and then was our DJ for the remainder of the reception. He learned songs for us and performed them beautifully. He was easy going, flexible, and made everything come together perfectly the day of the wedding. We are so glad he was part of our day! -
-
![Meg]()
Meg G. Sent on 11/22/2022Toby made our wedding music dreams come true!
We can’t say enough good things about our experience with Toby and his band mate. We chose to go with an acoustic duo to entertain our small wedding and it was more than we could ever dream of. From our first communication, to our wedding day, Toby exceeded our expectations. We were vague with our music requests but we 100% trusted him to deliver. He rocked it! We had a blast celebrating with you Toby! Thanks so much for everything. - The Gables -
-
![Meredith]()
Meredith Sent on 10/14/2022Best wedding band ever
Toby and his band were fantastic! They totally made our wedding night so incredibly special. Even our guests that weren’t dancers thoroughly enjoyed listening to them. Toby was so easy to work with and he was fantastic on adapting on the fly on the day! We had almost a near crisis with no music to walk down the isle to and he saved the day! We truly can’t say how much we appreciated everything he did for us and just made it easy! Would recommend them 1,000,000 times over! -
![Alex]()
Alex Sent on 10/13/2022THE BEST! The band 100% made our wedding!
We first heard Toby playing songs out at a bar - the crowed was loving it, and we knew this was the exact vibe we wanted for our wedding. Toby was so responsive and great to work with. He thought of everything, even all the questions that we didn’t know we should be thinking about yet. We totally trusted him to do his thing and knew he’d be great, but it was even better than expected. The band made our wedding so fun and memorable. Literally couldn’t recommend Toby more— SO worth it. Thanks for everything Toby!! -
![Maggie]()
Maggie Sent on 10/04/2021A wonderful addition to our day!
We had Toby come play at our wedding while everyone got seated before the ceremony & cocktail hour! We had SO MANY guests compliment the music and how perfect it was! It totally made our cocktail hour. It was the perfect entertainment. Toby was super professional and took care of everything. I just told him to play whatever he thought & he totally nailed it! Highly recommend for weddings- you can tell Toby actually cares about the couple and making their day special! If you want your guests to have a guaranteed good time this is who you want to hire. -
-
![Phoebe]()
Phoebe Sent on 08/25/2021Toby & the Jameson Four made our Wedding one for the record books!
If I could give these guys 10 stars, I would! Toby and the Jameson Four guys were just INCREDIBLE. We had multiple calls with Toby leading up to the wedding which helped us get all of the details straightened out and then on the day of, they were just amazing. We hadn't heard them play live before hiring them and we were just blown away when it came to the big show. They were SO MUCH FUN and us and our guests had the best dance party EVER. We danced ALL NIGHT and Toby DJed in between the band sets so the party did.not.stop. It was so awesome. We cannot thank them enough for making our wedding one for the record books! -
![Ariana]()
Ariana Sent on 08/02/2021Awesome band!
Finding The Jameson Four last minute for our late wedding reception was a miracle! Toby was so responsive, accommodating, and overall just the easiest guy to talk to! We had our original band cancel on us and gave up hope. Having them play for us was better than any expectations we ever had! I would use them 10 times over and cant wait to see them/him play elsewhere! Thank you guys for making our night so epic. I don't think we left the dance floor for hours!
-Ariana and Adam Lindquist -
-
![Caitlyn]()
Caitlyn Sent on 06/03/2021Best wedding ever!
The Jameson Four was the perfect choice for our wedding. Toby was amazing with communication from the get-go and we had multiple zoom meetings (thanks covid!) ahead of our date. All our guests raved about them and kept saying how much fun they were having. Cannot recommend them enough, and absolutely would not change a thing. Best. Day. Ever. -
![Leika]()
Leika Sent on 11/12/2024Book this band!!
I cannot recommend Toby and his band enough. From touching base and going over everything prior to the wedding, checking in leading up to the wedding, setting up the sound for out outdoor ceremony, MCing, to jamming out during our reception.. Toby knocked it out of the park in every single aspect. Most importantly, him and his band were super high energy and kept everyone on the dance floor all night long! We are so happy we chose Toby and the Jameson Four for our wedding band, and highly recommend you do the same for yours, or any event you are planning!! They are what helped contribute to our spectacular wedding day!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?