Three Sisters Cake Shop Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Morgan]()
Morgan Sent on 12/14/2025Exactly what you hope for when planning a wedding... we received countless compliments on how incredible everything tasted!
Three Sisters Cake Shop was an absolute dream to work with and exceeded every expectation we had. From start to finish, the entire process was seamless, stress-free, and incredibly well organized — exactly what you hope for when planning a wedding.
They went above and beyond by offering excellent gluten-free options for my now husband, who has celiac disease. Knowing that his needs were not only accommodated but treated with such care and attention meant so much to us and gave us complete peace of mind on our wedding day.
And the desserts — truly unforgettable. Three Sisters created the most delicious and beautifully curated array of desserts we could have ever asked for. Every single item was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely loved by our guests. We received countless compliments on how incredible everything tasted, with many people going back for seconds (and thirds).
If you are looking for a bakery that combines professionalism, thoughtfulness, and exceptional quality, Three Sisters Cake Shop is it. We couldn’t recommend them more and are so grateful they were part of our celebration. -
-
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 09/15/2025Stunning and Delicious!
We were smart enough to choose Three Sisters Cake Shop to make our wedding cake and they did not disappoint! They were incredibly responsive and organized, answering every question we had throughout the process. The introductory appointment was so helpful, not only getting to try slices of all of their amazing flavors but it gave us the opportunity to talk about our vision for the cake. They were all so delicious, we ended up choosing a different flavor for each tier! After sending a handful of pictures, they created the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake we had ever had! They made sure to deliver the cake promptly and ensure it was staged beautifully at the venue. The cake was exactly what we had envisioned and it was one of the first times we had ever seen guests ask for seconds. We can’t wait for our 1-year anniversary cake and cannot recommend them enough! -
![Deirdre]()
Deirdre Sent on 08/28/2025Delicious!
All of the flavors were delicious but we chose lemon and spice cake and everyone said both were delicious! Super helpful and no drama - exactly what we were looking for! Highly recommended -
Maddy Sent on 09/28/2024
Customizable, fresh, delicious, pretty!
We loved the fantastic cupcakes and cake from Three Sisters Cake Shop for our wedding! It was fun to have several customizable options for all our guests’ many tastes. We made sure to order some unique seasonal flavors such as lemon blueberry, which was delicious. They really went above and beyond like helping deliver vegan cupcakes from another bakery for our guests. -
-
![Molly]()
Molly Sent on 07/31/2022Best Cake Ever
We had the most delicious cake ever! White cake with layers of chocolate ganache and raspberry preserves! And the best part is no need to freeze you cake for your anniversary, Three Sisters gifts you a small top tier cake fresh in you anniversary! -
-
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 06/20/2022Delicious and Beautiful!
Our cake was delicious! We got a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting and a raspberry filling for our wedding cake. It was delivered on time and all of our guests commented on how beautiful it was decorated. -
-
![Karen]()
Karen Sent on 09/24/2021Beautiful and delicious cupcakes!
Holly and her team were wonderful throughout this entire planning process! We started our search for a baker relatively late in the wedding timeline, and they were able to accommodate our relatively last-minute request with aplomb. They answered all of our questions promptly and professionally, and even provided us a to-go tasting when we ended up being in their area at the last minute. The inspiration pictures and other thoughts we sent them were perfectly followed, and the end result was amazing. We ended up going with a small cutting cake for us and three flavors of cupcakes for our guests, and received MANY complements about the cupcakes. They were also able to deliver (for a reasonable fee) up to Maine! Three Sisters is a wonderful choice for a customized, professional wedding baker experience that will live up to your every expectation! -
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 09/30/2019As Tasty as it was Beautiful!
Our cake tasted even better then it looked--and it looked amazing! They were so sweet to work with, can't say enough good things about them! Would definitely recommend! -
-
![Josephine]()
Josephine Sent on 06/11/2019Best Cake I've Ever Had
I already knew this from the tasting, but three sisters did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake/cupcakes!! I seriously can't get over how good their stuff tastes (not to mention looks)! They are so great to work with and everything came out exactly as we envisioned. They even helped us create a cake for the groom's aunt, who turned 50 on our wedding day! All of our guests raved about the cupcakes for the whole night. -
Jen Sent on 04/04/2019
Dessert Bar
Super accommodating! We had a dessert bar with a huge variety. Many many compliments. They also made us a small cake to cut for pictures. Perfect and delicious. -
-
![Katy]()
Katy Sent on 12/09/2018Best cupcakes in the area!
My husband and I knew we wanted to have cupcakes instead of a traditional wedding cake, with a small cake for us to cut. Three Sisters knew exactly what we envisioned and went above and beyond. The flavors they have to chose from were all so amazing that we got a certain amount of EVERY flavor. At the end of the night there was only 5 cupcakes leftover - EVERYONE ate them in minutes. The cake we cut was exactly what we wanted but also tasted incredible. We ate it the next day, we could not allow ourselves to freeze it and wait a year to eat. Three Sisters was always available to answer questions and worked seamlessly with Flag Hill our wedding venue. I live right near their bakery and many of my co-workers also use their bakery for events and personal baked goods. You cannot beat the price for the quality you get!!! -
Amanda Sent on 04/04/2018We were so happy we used Three Sisters Cake Shop for our wedding. The cupcakes were absolutely delicious! My personal favorite was the carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. We should've ordered more because they went so quickly. I think some people even went up for seconds. The girls at the shop were wonderful to work with. They were friendly, accommodating and surprisingly affordable. Everything was set up so beautifully. It was exactly what we were looking for. I'd highly recommend them to anyone.
-
-
![Kendra]()
Kendra Sent on 09/12/2017The cake was amazingly delicious and they nailed the decorative details that we requested! Everyone got a cupcake flavor they loved. Thank you so much for enhancing our wedding- and WE LOVED the sparkles!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?