The Vintage Cake Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Chloe Sent on 07/17/2024
Best Wedding Ever!! MPI 06/29/24
We had such a wonderful experience with The Vintage Cake for our wedding! From start to finish, they exceeded our expectations. First of all, their cake flavors are absolutely delicious – we chose a chocolate cake with espresso buttercream, and it was a total hit with our guests! Even those with gluten allergies were able to enjoy the same delicious flavor thanks to the gluten-free cupcakes they specially prepared alongside our wedding cake.
The Vintage Cake was incredibly accommodating throughout the entire process. They seamlessly incorporated our requests, including a beautiful custom vintage piping design on the cake that made it not only delicious but also a stunning centerpiece at our reception. The cake was included in our MPI wedding package and there was a small additional cost for the custom piping, but it was worth every penny for the exquisite look it added to our cake. The team at The Vintage Cake made sure everything was perfect, from the initial tasting to the final delivery on our big day. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience or a more delicious cake. Thank you to The Vintage Cake for helping to make our wedding day truly special! -
-
![Michelle]()
Michelle Sent on 09/12/2023Delicious, decadent designs!
All I can say is WOW! Our experience with The Vintage Cake was incredible.
Gina and Nancy’s booking process was seamless.
From their communication, to the decadent custom design that they created for our very special wedding, Gina and Nancy designed a picture-perfect, delicious wedding cake for our Hamilton Farm Golf Club wedding.
We were between a few flavors. Gina recommend a tasting to finalize our details and we were absolutely blown away. Everything was so delicious and from there we knew exactly what we needed to order.
Following our tasting and finalizing our guest count, all details were set and Gina and Nancy created a picture-perfect, delicious vanilla sponge, vanilla custard and fresh strawberry wedding cake for our day.
Thank you so much, Gina and Nancy for everything! -
![Jaclyn]()
Jaclyn Sent on 12/26/2022Gorgeous and delicious cake
The cake was beautiful and exactly what I envisioned. I decided to upgrade and do a more intricate design to go with my beach themed wedding and Gina and team nailed it! The cake itself tasted amazing and the butter cream was the best I’ve ever had. We enjoyed this cake for weeks afterwards. We will be ordering a cake for our one year because we didn’t want the stale frozen cake! -
-
![Giana]()
Giana Sent on 11/29/2022Breathtaking wedding cake
We can’t get over how delicious our wedding cake was, even our guest won’t stop talking about it. From our taste testing kits to our actual wedding cake we couldn’t have asked for a better experience. -
-
Elsie Sent on 06/05/2022
Best cake ever!
AMAZING!!!!! Our cake was super beautiful and delicious. Nancy and Gina are amazing. I’m going to get a small cake from them again for our anniversary because it’s too good not to — I need another excuse to get more! 10/10 I would highly recommend The Vintage Cake! -
-
![Michelle]()
Michelle Sent on 01/30/2022Best Bakery
Gorgeous cake, wonderful flavor. She did exactly what we asked for, delivered it to the venue without any issues and it was at an amazing price. -
![Eliza]()
Eliza Sent on 09/28/2021Delicious AND gorgeous cakes
The Vintage Cake did a stellar job on our cake and I could not be happier with how it turned out. She took my random barrage of inspirational cake photos and designed exactly what I wanted. In addition, the cake is simply delicious, which can be very hard to find in wedding cakes. I loved the cakes so much that I had her do a grooms cake and she came up with the most whimsical and gorgeous golf/sports-themed cake that my husband was blown away by. I can’t wait to use them for all my future cake needs! -
![Maggie]()
Maggie Sent on 09/24/2019Absolutely amazing
The team at the vintage cake made this so fun for me and my husband. I was going for a bit of a non traditional cake, and man did they deliver. From the tasting process to the actual cake being delivered, they were on point every step of the way. I had asked them to create something they had never done before, but you truly would never know it because of how amazing it came out. They even made us a mini version of the cake for us to cut so we wouldn’t butcher the real one! We are STILL eating leftovers 5 days later, and somehow this cake has gotten even better. We went with a cookie “cake”, so it’s layers of chocolate chip cookies with buttercream in the middle. Highly recommend if you want something a little more fun!! Me and my husband agreed that every year on our anniversary we are going to order this cake :) -
-
![cheryl]()
Cheryl Sent on 06/10/2019Delicious cake!!
Can't wait to have an excuse to order from them again soon!! -
-
![Kiamarie]()
Kiamarie Sent on 05/11/2019Prettiest Cakes Ever!
I ordered 3 cakes for my engagement party & they were delivered exactly as I had explained & hoped they would be & extremely delicious! My guests were in awe over the pretty detail of them! -
![Victoria]()
Victoria Sent on 05/10/2019Perfect Cake
The Vintage Cake gave me the wedding cake of my dreams. It was everything I wanted. The design was beautiful. They listened and made my vision a reality. More importantly, it tasted amazing. We did two different flavors for the cakes. We picked out our flavor combos, with some guidance during our consultation tasting. They were fantastic. My guests haven’t stopped raving about how great the cake was. They are easy to work with and make you feel comfortable. Highly recommended. -
-
Varsha Sent on 08/14/2018We are extremely happy to have chosen The Vintage Cake for our wedding. Nancy's happy and warm personality made us very comfortable in discussing our ideas. She promptly replied to all our queries with her expert inputs which makes her reliable in every sense. Our wedding cake looked so beautiful, it came out just the way we had envisioned it. It was delicious, rich and everything a cake should be.
-
-
Susan Sent on 08/13/2018Absolutely exceptional! The cake was the talk of the party. From the prompt response to my inquiry, to the final product and delivery, my experience was flawless. A definite WOW from all the guests. And it tasted great, too!!!
-
-
Kristine Sent on 06/25/2018The ordering process was very easy. They made the cake to my exact specifications. One layer was red velvet and the other was carrot. They both tasted amazing. I will order from The Vintage Cake for all my future parties.
-
-
Natalie Sent on 06/11/2018I would like to thank the team at Vintage cake for such a beautiful cake for my bridal shower - you truly made my vision come to life. I can not even tell you how many people complemented the cake, it was absolutely gorgeous! It was so pretty that a few people even thought it was fake! It was very delicious, too - we had 2 tiers with Carrot cake + Cream cheese frosting, and Vanilla cake + Pistachio buttercream. I didn't want it to be too sweet and I chose these flavors from Nancy's recommendations. Thank you, thank you for such an amazing cake!
-
-
Joan Sent on 10/03/2017Could not have asked for a more beautiful, perfect wedding cake! Gina and Nancy are incredible. From the cake tasting, to planning, there are no truer professionals. They were not intimidated by my desire to have a Harry Potter wedding cake with a beach theme. My cake was spectacular, a sand castle Hogwarts faded into the ocean, complete with a Whomping Willow and sea creature. Not to mention, I ordered macaroons as favors. Not only were they delicious, but Nancy and Gina assembled all the macaroon boxes for me and delivered with the wedding cake! I will be going to The Vintage Cake for any of my cake needs in the future and will recommend to anyone who asks. Thank you ladies for the wedding cake of my dreams!
-
-
User3205735 Sent on 09/12/2017These gals are something special? My guests were wowed by how beautifully detailed the birch tree cake was! Not only did it look wonderful it tasted incredible. We had three different cakes flavors and buttercream fillings.. chocolate and marshmallow, red velvet and cookies and cream, vanilla and chocolate....Unbelievably talented artists!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?