The Cakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
-
Meaghan Sent on 11/21/2025
Whimsical Fall Wedding Cake
We couldn’t be happier with our choice to go with The Cakery for our Fall wedding cake.
The tasting process was so much fun. Peggy was so personable, was able to help guide us on what size cake to go with to ensure we had enough for all of our guests, and also helped us to choose some mini desserts to go along with the cake. We did the mini cheesecakes, mini apple pies and mini pumpkin pies.
We went with the marble cake and cannoli cream filling - Simply delicious!
We showed her inspiration photos and she did an even more amazing job than I could have imagined. We wanted a whimsical painted floral look for the cake and she flawlessly executed and also made it her own and it was just so unique and beautiful. We were almost sad to eat it.
The cake and desserts were delivered with plenty of time and I didn’t have to worry about a thing. I showed up to the venue and everything was already there.
I will recommend The Cakery to all my friends and family for future events.
The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Meaghan for the great review I appreciate you taking the time. I enjoyed working with you and you did a beautiful job decorating The Pine Junction it was such a perfect fall wedding. -
-
![Grace]()
Grace Sent on 11/17/2025Beautiful & Delicious!
Peggy at The Cakery was awesome to work with for our wedding! She listened to what we asked for and presented exactly what we wanted. The vanilla cake with buttercream frosting that Peggy made matched the picture that we gave her perfectly. It was not only beautiful, but tasted amazing. We selected several other desserts to go along with the cake. Each selection was delicious and presented beautifully. Our guests were wowed, and we were delighted! She understood and stayed within our budget and gave us professional service throughout our planning. We would recommend The Cakery to make any desserts for any special occasions. -
-
Lydia Sent on 11/17/2025
Everything was Perfect!
From the first samples that Peggy made for us to the day of our wedding- everything was just perfect!
I had a vision for my cake and how I wanted it presented and Peggy nailed every detail! From the colors that I envisioned to the precision of every daisy on my cake, it was all just stunning!!
And the taste and combination of flavors -- scrumptious!! We chose lemon and raspberry for cake flavors and fillings, along with an almond frosting. We chose some of her apple and pumpkin tarts to compliment the display, along with her cannolis and brownie bon bons.
It was all just perfect!
Thank you Peggy for your time, patience, professionalism and your talent! You truly have a unique gift and we thank you for that from the bottom of our hearts!
Lydia and Caleb Donaldson
10/25/25The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Lydia and Caleb so much for your wonderful five-star review! It was an honor to be part of your special day. -
-
![Colleen]()
Colleen Sent on 11/02/2025Loved working with Peggy
I loved working with Peggy. She replied to my emails quickly, had online payments available and I made a couple of changes 2 or 3 weeks before the wedding and she worked with me. Drove to Erie, cake set up was beautiful as were the cupcakes.The Cakery's reply:
Thank you for the great review. It was my pleasure working with you and your daughter . The Erie Yaht Club was a beautiful water front venue. -
-
Kenna Sent on 10/05/2025
Beautiful wedding cake + cupcakes!
Peggy perfectly executed our vision for a smaller, heart-shaped, vintage inspired wedding cake paired with 150 cupcakes for our guests. She included lovely flower details to differentiate between cupcake flavors. On top of the appearance, the cake was absolutely delicious and a hit amongst our guests. Peggy was extremely responsive, helpful, and conveniently delivered all of our cupcakes and cake to our venue. Would highly recommend the services of The Cakery!The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Kenna for the wonderful review and also for the beautiful photograph’s photos of the small wedding cake and cupcakes. -
-
![Caroline]()
Caroline Sent on 09/26/2025Loved our wedding cake
excellent tasting cake and beautiful design, she created it exactly the way our inspiration pictures were designed!The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Caroline for the five star review. The Chautauqua Athenaeum Hotel was a beautiful location for your traditional wedding. -
![Cayla]()
Cayla Sent on 09/19/2025Perfect wedding cake and cupcakes!
I reached out to Peggy after I saw her shop across the street from where I was getting my wedding dress altered. I emailed Peggy and she responded immediately the same day! She was great answering all my questions and was very accommodating. We are not from the area, about an hour away, and she was able to arrange for us to pick up samples and our meeting to order our cake and cupcakes quickly. She was very easy to work with and did an amazing job on both our wedding cake and cupcakes. They tasted even better than we remembered! Thank you so much! I would definitely recommend her!The Cakery's reply:
Thank you for the great review Cayla. I so glad you found me and chose me to be part of your wedding.
Peggy Rose -
-
Katie Sent on 09/19/2025
Wedding Cake
Wonderful wedding cake!! Peggy the owner is so great to work with! I gave her a photo of what I wanted and she nailed It!The Cakery's reply:
Thank you for the wonderful review. I loved working with you to create the wedding of you dreamed of. The Chautauqua Institute was a beautiful venue for your romantic wedding.
Peggy Rose -
-
Erica Sent on 09/18/2025
Wedding cake
Planning a wedding from 4 hours away in a different state is not an easy or simple task. When I found that the Cakery was local to our venue I called in inquiring about a wedding cake. I had a very specific idea in my head of what I wanted the cake to look like and they executed it perfectly. Communication was amazing and I really appreciated the quick responses. They made the whole process smooth and seamless.The Cakery's reply:
Thank you for the wonderful review. Small weddings like yours are so special and The Daisy Farm is a beautiful venue for an intimate wedding.
Peggy Rose -
-
![Amanda]()
Amanda Sent on 09/16/2025Crandall Wedding; August 2, 2025
Peggy from The Cakery did an amazing job with the cake and cupcakes! The cake and cupcakes were delicious and so beautiful. We told her what we wanted, and Peggy made it happen. We had a vanilla cake, with vanilla buttercream frosting. Real flowers from Flowers by Anthony (Alice runs the shop. She also did an amazing job with the flowers for the wedding.) The cupcakes were vanilla with buttercream frosting, red velvet with cream cheese frosting, and vanilla with raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream frosting. She made it so that the frosting was dyed purple to match the colors for the wedding. She even made it so that the toppings of the cupcakes had a different decoration on it to know which one was which.The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Amanda it was my pleasure being part of your special day. The Grandview in Ellington was a perfect wedding venue.
Peggy Rose -
-
Diana Sent on 09/16/2025
Highly recommend!
Peggy was wonderful to work with for our wedding back in June. She absolutely killed it on the cakes, they were exactly what I wanted and I only sent her a few pictures for inspo. Great price and we got so many compliments on how good they tasted! Thanks Peggy for being a huge part in making our day so specialThe Cakery's reply:
Thank you Diana for the great review.
I love the black and white photo; such a classic wedding picture.
I always enjoy delivering to Lakeshore Vineyards in Ripley. You had a perfect summer day for an outside wedding.
Peggy Rose -
-
Matthew Sent on 09/16/2025
Saved The Day!
What can I say? Peggy saved our day. Unfortunately (in hindsight fortunately) our original cake maker decided to flake out on us extremely close to our wedding date. I frantically was calling and texting others in the area and Peggy came through in an instant. She actually had family in town yet despite that and seeing our predicament she made herself available. The cake and flavors were amazing, she did exactly what my wife wanted to the T. On top of that she also made a last minute sheet cake for our night before/birthday party. Above and beyond. Super nice. Very affordable. Solid work. Really could not have asked for much more.The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Matt,
Thank you for the great review. I am so glad to be part of your special day. I loved creating your pastel color wedding cakes.
Peggy -
-
Brittany Sent on 09/16/2025
Excellent service
Peggy was such a pleasure to work with. We had a 4 tier cake and a personal cutting cake excellent pricing and quality. The cake went so fast with our guests. Definitely recommend and we'll be back for future ordering.The Cakery's reply:
Thank you Brittany, I enjoyed creating your beauty and the beast themed wedding cakes. You did a wonderful job decorating to match the theme. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?