Stoddard's Market & Catering Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9 out of 5 rating
4.9
Excellent
14 reviews
Recommended by 99% of couples
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 4.7 out of 5 rating4.7
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 4.9 out of 5 rating4.9
-
Featured
![Leah]()
Leah Sent on 10/11/20235 out of 5 rating5.0-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Everything amazing
Stoddards catered our wedding on 10/7/23. Everything from scheduling the food tasting to picking up our leftovers was quick, professional, and tasty. Every staff member is friendly and puts care into what they do. We had them prepare a 2 meat buffet and 4 sides for our guest count of 160 and we received so many compliments on the food. If we had to do it all over again Stoddards would still be our top choice. -
Quality of service
-
Tessa Sent on 11/04/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Best catering experience
Stoddards did an amazing job catering our wedding. The staff was very responsive and always willing to answer our questions while planning. Additionally, the staff that were at the venue set up and served with a smile! They did a great job getting our used napkins together for ease of packing up at the end of the night. Overall, very happy with the service and employees! The day went smoothly thanks to their great work. -
Quality of service
-
Jodi Sent on 10/11/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Delicious wedding catering
Stoddards went above and beyond our expectations for catering service for my daughter’s wedding. Nothing but positive reviews on the delicious food, amount of food, set up, clean up, correspondence, etc. we highly recommend Stoddards for your wedding or celebration needs. We will continue to use Stoddards for our catering!!! -
Quality of service
-
John Sent on 09/20/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Fantastic people to work with! GREAT FOOD, reasonable price and personal attention to detail!
This was a big wedding with some logistical challenges. They met and exceeded every expectation and included a personal touch along the way. They were chosen partly for the great people that run the business, combined with great food at a reasonable price. We would highly recommend them to any and all event organizers! Thank you Stoddards for help in making our dream day come true!❤️ -
Quality of service
-
![Amy]()
Amy R. Sent on 09/14/20235 out of 5 rating5.0-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Exceptional!
Delicious food still very hot even though they had to travel to Fort Atkinson. Very responsive to all questions. Highly recommend this caterer. -
Quality of service
-
Katie Sent on 07/06/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Amazing food and awesome customer service!
Stoddard's Catering did an amazing job at our wedding. The food was delicious and many of our guests later commented on how good it was. We especially loved the stuffed chicken breast and mashed potatoes. So so good!! There was something for everyone, and they catered to our guests with allergies as well. We did not have to worry for a second about anything catering related, and the staff were wonderful to work with. It was also awesome to be able to get our plate set and napkins from them. One less thing to worry about! We would recommend Stoddard's for your wedding or event! -
Quality of service
-
Sophia Sent on 06/06/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Wedding Day Catering
My husband and I have nothing but positive things to say about Stoddard’s food, staff, and service. Everyone was complimenting everything about them: good quality, taste, staff, efficiency, etc. Jerry also took the time to come up and talk to us throughout their service which was very kind and left a great impression of the company. I highly recommend Stoddard’s for your next event! -
Quality of service
-
Emily Sent on 06/06/20235 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Stoddard's Catering
Stoddard's catering was very easy to work with. They provided excellent service prior to our wedding and day, the day of the wedding, and even after our wedding. We received many compliments regarding our food. We would recommend them 100%!! -
Quality of service
-
Ashley Sent on 10/06/20225 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Excellent Catering Company/Butcher Shop
The staff at Stoddard's was warm, friendly, and professional from the first phone call. Jerry and Tami walked us through their menu and made helpful suggestions. Tami always got back to us quickly with answers to our questions. Stoddard's was one of the many vendors we enjoyed working with. They toured our venue before our wedding which helped immensely with keeping things organized, timely, and made our appetizers flow seamlessly into dinner. Our guests loved the food some of the items that were raved about included the BBQ Meatballs, Deviled Eggs, and the Spinach Dip, before dinner even started. We had Baked Chicken and Ham for dinner with mashed potatoes and macaroni and cheese. Our dinner service was family style with plated meals for the wedding party and our vendors. Our catering bill was by far the largest expense of our wedding, but our guests were happy and full with zero complaints. The staff that catered our event were extremely courteous to and conscious of our guests. We honestly could not have found a better catering company to put our trust in. They went above and beyond in a time of so much stress for us, Stoddard's was an upstanding, and honorable company to work with. All we can say is THANK YOU! -
Quality of service
-
Jess Sent on 05/31/20225 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Amazing meatballs
We had a heavy hors d’oueuvres style reception that stoddards catered and our guests absolutely loved it -
Quality of service
-
Ashley Sent on 10/13/20234.8 out of 5 rating4.8
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 4 out of 5 rating4.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Wedding Review
Stoddard's was a wonderful choice to have for our wedding catering. They were pretty responsive when we emailed them questions. Their food was so delicious, our guests raved about them! Especially the meatballs! They add personal touches such as when we did our tasting the owner sat down with us and went over the menu. I highly recommend the buffet. We had a lot of left overs and were able to take them home the next day! It was great working with them. -
Quality of service
-
Jenna Sent on 10/11/20234.8 out of 5 rating4.8
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 4 out of 5 rating4.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Professional service & delicious food
We had Stoddard’s Market cater our wedding. We had a dinner buffet and the food was delicious. Everyone loved it. We also had enough for leftovers! The only small hiccup was that they forgot to put out napkins at the place settings, which was most likely due to a lack of communication about that between us and them. Other than that, the food was delicious and the staff was extremely professional. -
Quality of service
-
![Shelley]()
Shelley Sent on 06/27/20234.8 out of 5 rating4.8-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 4 out of 5 rating4.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 5 out of 5 rating5.0
Stress free and tasty
Our tasting and first meeting with Jerry had us confident that we would be taken care of. They were accommodating to some special requests I had made and really did make everything (from linens, refreshments, set up) easy. Our venue was even toured before our event by Jerry and our venue coordinator to get familiar with the space. The staff at wedding were wonderful and extremely pleasant. Lots of complements on the food from guests. We did beef tenderloin, stuffed chicken breast, mac and cheese, baked potatoes and various sides and appetizers. All great! Stoddard's will make your catering experience stress free. -
Quality of service
-
Ariel Sent on 10/04/20224.6 out of 5 rating4.6
-
Quality of service 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Average response time 4 out of 5 rating4.0
-
Professionalism 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Value 5 out of 5 rating5.0
-
Flexibility 4 out of 5 rating4.0
Great quality, value and service.
Stoddard’s food was delicious. We did buffet style and were very happy. They were great to work with too. I would recommend them! -
Quality of service
Are you interested?
Are you interested?