Simma's Bakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.7 out of 5 rating
4.7 out of 5 rating
213 reviews
94% recommend it
-
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer Sent on 08/12/2022Absolutely delicious and gorgeous wedding cake!
We were SO happy with the wedding cake we ordered from Simma's Bakery! We went with a two-tier round cake plus a couple sheet cakes for a reception of ~100 guests. It was so, so delicious! The raspberry filling with the mix of vanilla and chocolate layers was yummy... plus, the buttercream frosting is rich but oh so tasty! I was able to send a couple pictures of design ideas, and the final product turned out perfect. Looking forward to going back for our anniversary cake next year. :) -
![Nicole]()
Nicole Sent on 05/10/2022Delicious Cake!
We got married at The Ivy House on April 16, 2022. We did popsicles as a dessert for our guests, but we still wanted a traditional cake for ourselves and our wedding party. Simma’s is our favorite bakery in the area, so this was a no-brainer when we decided on having a cake. We went in for a tasting which answered all of our questions and was extremely helpful to the process. It was pretty hard to narrow it down to one flavor, but we eventually agreed on a delicious combination!
We did a two-tier cake with fresh strawberries inside and blue painted decor to match our wedding colors. The cake arrived on time and in perfect condition. Everyone said it was delicious! We decided to save the top part and freeze it so we can enjoy it on our year anniversary. I can’t wait to eat more of it! Simma’s has a huge variety of flavors and options. You will not be disappointed in whatever you order from them! Best desserts around! -
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 11/17/2021Great service, even better cheesecake!
I'm from St. Louis and hired Simma's without even having the opportunity for a tasting. So many great reviews cannot be wrong. We had a small wedding in Milwaukee in August 2021, and had hands down, the best cheesecake of our lives. I could not have possibly been happier with the outcome and the price was so reasonable, especially for something like cheesecake. -
![Autumn]()
Autumn Sent on 05/25/2021So beautiful!
SIMMAS did our cake for our wedding a few weeks ago and it turned out amazing! Came in with a picture and they were able to do even better! Also great flexibility due to COVID. We had to drastically cut our guest count and SIMMAS was able to work with us! Everything went so smoothly would highly reccomend! -
-
![Kari]()
Kari Sent on 01/12/2021Delicious Cake - Easy Process!
This was hands down the most delicious cake we've ever had! The ordering process was extremely easy as well, the team at Simma's is great to work with! Can't wait to dig into our top tier of our cake on our one year anniversary! -
-
![Erin]()
Erin Sent on 12/01/2020Delicious Cake! Great Service.
Simmas did a wonderful job on our cake! We asked for a special key lime pie flavor, and they delivered. -
-
![Jack]()
Jack Sent on 11/05/2020Amazing Experience and Cake!
Simmas was excellent walking us through all of our options and making adjustments as necessary. All of our wedding guests loved the cake! Will be using Simma's again for birthdays and other celebrations. -
![Cindy]()
Cindy Sent on 10/29/2020Best Cake EVER!
When you have your guests ask the servers for more cake after they ate the first piece, I think that says it all! It was one of the best cakes we have ever had.
We chose to create our own cake with cream cheese and a layered raspberry filling and it was a huge hit!
the professionalism and creativity this bakery has is out of this world. No wonder every time we went there the line was out the door!
we HIGHLY recommend this bakery for anyone in the Milwaukee area.
-
![Aimee]()
Aimee Sent on 10/14/2020It is known that Simms’s is the best!!
All the wedding professionals, from the coordinator to the photographer said “Is that Simms’s cheesecake?” We enthusiastically said “yes”, and they all said the same thing “good job, very nice, Simma’s is the best” Our wedding cake was talked about for days after our wedding.. everyone said what a beautiful wedding it was, and WOW, that wedding cake. -
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 10/08/2020Delicious and Beautiful!
Our wedding cake was amazing! Our guests loved the two different flavors and the cake looked absolutely beautiful! Looking forward to purchasing our anniversary cake next September! -
-
![Jessica]()
Jessica Sent on 08/23/2020Beautiful wedding cake; so delicious!
Simma’s is amazing! We went there for a wedding cake tasting. We got to try four different cakes of our choice. The pricing is very reasonable and they did all the delivery even on a holiday. They were spot on when it came to how much we should buy. We didn’t have so much left over but also didn’t have too little for guests. We were able to change the design of the cake up to a month before the wedding. They exceeded my expectations and mimicked my Pinterest picture! Would definitely recommend Simma’s! -
![Ruth]()
Ruth Sent on 08/07/2020Delectable cake
Simma's cake was extremely delicious and was the most beautifully decorated cake I have ever seen! They were very professional and helpful. I would definitely recommend them to my friends!
The guest number is not what we were planning originally but due to covid19 we cut down but we still wanted the original cake. -
![Matt]()
Matt Sent on 01/06/2020Couldn't have been better.
Incredibly generous, efficient, and "MMMmmm" inducingly tasty, Simma's made everything effortless for us to have a beautiful cake in time for our day. -
-
![Michael]()
Michael Sent on 12/09/2019Go with Simma's for your cake
If you want a place that's easy to work with, has amazing cakes and decorations, and will leave a strong impression with guests, go with Simma's. Our guests loved it (so did we). Worth every penny! -
![Kurtina]()
Kurtina Sent on 08/19/2019Wedding Reception Cake
This cake was out of this world, they worked with the budget that we had and made the cake just how we wanted it. I had so much that I took some to work, and everyone was raving about it. They have the best cake in town. -
![Amber]()
Amber Sent on 06/03/2019Yummy wedding treats
My fiance and I decided against wedding cake and have chosen mini pastries instead. Simma's bakery was exceptional for this type of dessert. We had a wonderful tasting experience and cannot wait to share our pastries with our guests. -
![Brian & Sara]()
Sara Sent on 01/10/2019Delicious!
We would absolutely recommend Simma's Bakery to anyone! Our tiered cake, with three different flavors, was simply delicious and was decorated exactly as we had envisioned. Working with their shop was so easy ... you won't be disappointed! -
-
![Stephanie]()
Stephanie Sent on 05/25/2018The cake was perfect and the mini pastries were to die for, everyone is still talking about it! Thanks for the wonderful desserts!!! -
![Windows]()
Karen Sent on 05/25/2016Simma's was great. We were able to taste cakes ahead of time, and the wedding specialist explained that the cool design we thought would be a nice touch was fondant and would therefore double the price of our cake. We opted for buttercream, as we are also doing a dessert bar offered by our venue. We were able to taste their marble cake (separate layers of chocolate and vanilla, it is not swirled together), carrot cake, cheesecake and the yellow cake. We chose the yellow cake with buttercream and raspberry filling, with buttercream icing. They did not try to oversell us extra cake, either, which I greatly appreciated. We ordered a 3 tiered cake that serves 45, and are expecting 90 at the reception. -
![Becky]()
Becky Sent on 10/16/2013my husband and I love Simma's cheesecake to begin with so the decision to choose them as our cake maker was easy. But let me say that they did an awesome job. Everyone commented on how the cake looked awesome and tasted even better. -
![Jessica]()
Jessica Sent on 10/06/2013We went with Simma's traditional wedding cake for our wedding on 9/21/13. For those of you who aren't familiar with the traditional cake, it has a chocolate cake base, cheesecake layer, raspberry filling, and chocolate ganoche. We had their "S & C" swirls on the cake in white, which gave it a very elegant look.
As my husband and I went to greet all of our guests at their tables, we received so many compliments on our decision for going with Simma's for our cake.
Simma's coordinated with our reception hall to deliver the cake as close to dinner as possible, as we were concerned with the cake sitting out too long with the cheesecake in it. They delivered right on time and everything about the cake was perfect, down to every little detail.
We will definitely be using Simma's for all of our cake needs in the future! -
![Nicole]()
Nicole Sent on 10/11/2012Simma's Bakery is full of a lot of talented people! My cake turned out great, and to be honest during the whole cake cutting scene I didn't even get a chance to take a good look at my cake! But looking back the pictures it was so pretty with all the flowers and ribbon that they put on. I also chose their famous cheesecake and red velvet for the flavors! Their cheesecake has always been my favorite for a long time so I knew right away when we were planning the wedding who would be creating the cake! -
![Margaret]()
Margaret Sent on 08/25/2012There really is not anything to say that you do not know already!
Absolutely amazing! Our cheesecake was to die for. We are still receiving compliments from our guests. -
Ellen Sent on 12/16/2022
So Amazing!
Simmas is a family favorite on my husbands side as he is from Milwaukee so he insisted that’s where we got our cake and it was the best choice! Our guests were going back for seconds and we were able to take some to our work friends that didn’t attend the wedding and they kept saying “this is the best cheesecake I’ve ever had” aside from taste Simmas was so easy to work with as we were coming in from out of town and they made it as simple as possible for us. I would recommend to anyone in Milwaukee or surrounding areas. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?