Rochester NY Wedding Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
5.0 out of 5 rating
34 reviews
100% recommend it
Awards
-
Denise Sent on 02/03/2025
Denise 60th Birthday Cake
The cake and the service were perfect!!! It was the talk of the evening. Love, love it. Then we tasted it😳!!! Drop the mic, it was delicious, light and fluffy. The raspberry and butter filling were scrumptious😋!!! Michael and Erin, you have a customer for life and I will be referring you to whoever ask. Actually they do not have to ask, I will tell them, regardless. Thank you again!! -
-
Maria Sent on 08/27/2024
Bridal shower cake
The cake did not disappoint!! It was as beautiful as it was delicious. The theme of the bridal shower was pearls and Prosecco, so the cake was loaded with edible pearls. It was great working with Michael and his wife. They made the cake look very elegant. I had many people ask me where the cake came from. -
-
![Kirstin]()
Kirstin Sent on 08/16/2024Fantastic !!
Absolutely amazing they had a great job. The tasting was fantastic. Everything was so delicious. It was so hard to choose even help us customize it a little bit more so that we could really truly enjoy our cake 1000% recommend -
Joan Sent on 06/05/2023
Special Birthday!
This cake not only looked fabulous , but was so delicious. Sometimes a decorated cake is dry, or tasteless, but this was awesome. The different tiers were completely different cakes as each Twin chose their own. Thank you Michael for this gorgeous, fun, special 16th birthday cake. We will all remember it fondly.
Sorry I forgot to take pictures before we cut into it. This, refridgerator shots 😋😊❤️ -
-
![Beth]()
Beth Sent on 05/03/2022Beautiful and Delicious!
My wedding cake was beyond beautiful and tasted amazing! I’m so glad that we saved the top ahead of time because there wasn’t a single slice of cake or pastry left at the end of the night! The guests raved about how wonderful the desserts were and the presentation, and taste, were exceptional. -
-
Mariam Sent on 10/17/2021
Wedding cake
Michael did a wonderful job on our wedding cake! Not only was the cake beautiful and just what we pictured, it was very tasty! My husband and I were super impressed and would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a great cake and a great price. -
-
Michelle Sent on 07/13/2021
Perfection
Michael was absolutely amazing to work with from the beginning. He works right out of his home and had us do a wonderful tasting of so many flavors that we didn’t even know existed! And as a bonus we got to take it all home with us at no cost! As time went on we had to postpone due to covid and he was able to do that, no questions asked. He was very accommodating throughout the whole planning process and as a result we got the most delicious and beautiful cake we have ever seen! I highly recommend Michael and will be using him for future celebrations! Thank you again! -
-
Meghan Sent on 06/07/2021
Amazing cake!!
Michael created the most beautiful and the most delicious cake we’ve ever seen! It was challenging planning a wedding during Covid, but Michael make the experience so wonderful by providing a tasting plate to help us pick flavors - which only make it harder since they were all phenomenal! All of our guests told us it was the best cake they’ve ever had. I cannot recommend Rochester NY Wedding Cakes enough! -
-
![Cindy]()
Cindy Sent on 07/15/2020Wonderful and delicious wedding cake ever
I just want to let Chief Michael and his lovely bride Erin how wonderful they were to work with and how easy they made the process during COVID-19. My new husband and I were blown away with our delicious wedding cake, and all my guests ranted and raved how excellent it was. They came on time as promised and put the finishing touches on it at our venue.I will definitely use them again. Thank you so very much. Cindy and Allen -
![Diane]()
Diane Sent on 12/17/2019Unbelievable talent
I couldn't be more pleased with the cake you did for my son's birthday party.
It was beyond words! There were so many comments; the best one, can you really eat this? Beside being extraordinary, it was delicious! My son ate one piece of vanilla and one chocolate. Everyone asked me who did the cake, so you had many referrals.. You are a MASTER. Thank you so much. The cake was a big hit.
-
-
![Hannah]()
Hannah Sent on 10/14/2019Delectable desserts!
Michael is such a talented baker and I am so happy that I went with him for my wedding desserts! From the beginning, with the cake tasting, he was professional and went above and beyond to make sure I had the right cake and desserts. We went with a two tiered wedding cake, plus a variety of his pastries, and everything was absolutely delicious! You cannot go wrong with anything you choose. I also ordered a grooms cake of a rubber duck with my husband’s favorite college football team’s colors and name to surprise him...it was awesome! My husband loved everything about it :) -
-
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 10/01/2019Absolutely amazing!
WOW! That was exactly what we said when we saw it! It was everything we had pictured it would be. Mike nailed it! Our guests were raving about the flavors- almond with raspberry, choc. Chip w peanut butter and carrot cake with cream cheese frosting! The pastries were amazing too! HIGHLY recommend! -
![James]()
James Sent on 09/20/2019Amazing Desserts & Cake At A Price
We made the decision to work with Michael and Rochester NY Wedding Cakes when we tasted the cakes. Oh my word, these were and still are the best cakes I've ever tasted. I will be honest, if you're looking for a cheap wedding cake vendor, do not waste your time with Michael. But if you're willing to pay a little more, be prepared to have the best vendor experience of your life. He went out of his way to work within our budget to provide the optimal amount of cake and mini desserts for our wedding guests. Our tasting interaction was awesome - the tastings were delicious, the questions were on point, and the level of honesty and professionalism is unmatched. Every time I called, Michael answered, quickly pulled up our file, and worked through whatever concerns I had. He took the time to explain the optimal time to have the guests eating the desserts and why, which was much more than I expected. And our wedding guests were impressed by the presentation of both the cakes and desserts, but more often than not the compliments were on the taste of each of the three cakes we picked. I've had them since the wedding and they are still amazing. I can't wait to use Rochester NY Wedding Cakes for a future event. -
-
![Wendy]()
Wendy Sent on 09/10/2019Excellent and Amazing
We are so grateful for the pastries that you made for our wedding. They were absolutely AMAZING! Words can’t even describe how good they were. All of our guests were in awe, not only in how they tasted but how they were displayed. We can’t wait till we get to order some more. My mouth is watering just writing this review. Thank you again, you have gained forever customers. 🙂 Rob and Wendy Kennedy. -
![Shanna]()
Shanna Sent on 06/06/2019Amazing baker to work with!
Michael and Erin are awesome! They gave us the best wedding cake and it tasted delicious! We had a large reduction of guest attending and they accommodated us even though we already paid for it in full!
Michael listened to our every wish and delivered a wonderful cake! We would order from them for any occasion! -
-
![Courtney]()
Courtney Sent on 05/21/2019Such amazing quality and taste!
When we went for the cake tasting we got I think about 12 full size pieces and frostings to try. Everything was amazingly delicious! We got a two tier cutting cake and four different flavors of cupcakes. They were all a hit! Michael was so easy to work with and we had so much fun choosing all the flavors! Our cake was absolutely beautiful too! There were so many different flavor options too!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?