Pennington's Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
5.0 out of 5 rating
131 reviews
99% recommend it
Awards
-
![Katherine]()
Katherine Sent on 01/19/2024Exactly as we imagined!
The cake company was very easy to work with and executed our vision perfectly! -
-
![Christi]()
Christi Sent on 07/01/2023The Best Cake
One of the best cakes we have ever eaten. (Strawberry layers and vanilla almond layers) So moist and flavorful! Enjoyed our cake tasting day, but it was even better for the actual wedding! Everyone loved it! -
-
Courtney Sent on 09/19/2021
Absolutely Amazing
Pennington Cakes went above and beyond our expectations. They delivered a stunning cake that tasted absolutely amazing. The owner was extremely flexible and customized our cake exactly the way we wanted it. We also ordered sugar cookies from them that were a major hit with all of our guests. As an added bonus they are extremely affordable. Highly recommend for all your dessert needs. You won’t be disappointed!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Courtney! And congratulations!! We are thrilled the cake and cookies were a hit! Wish you and husband many blessings and a long and happy life together!! -
-
![Wendy]()
Wendy Sent on 09/17/2021Simply gorgeous
The wedding cake and cookies at my daughter’s wedding were beautiful and delicious. The guests are still raving about them. I highly recommend this bakery.Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much for your review! We are thrilled that the cake and cookies were a hit. Thanks for letting us know. Congratulations to you and your daughter and husband! -
-
Rachel Sent on 09/10/2021
Highly recommend!
I had a great experience with Pennington! My guests raved about how tasty it was, and we overheard lots of Mmmms!
We ordered chocolate with raspberry filling. Sometimes there’s not enough filling, but this was the Perfect filling to cake ratio! So moist - and the presentation was exactly what I’d asked for! So happy with itPennington's Cakes's reply:
Thank you, Rachel and congrats again! We are thrilled to hear your cake was a hit! Many blessings to you! -
-
Monica Sent on 01/23/2020
Best cake ever, exceeded my expectation!!
My wedding cake was everything I could want and more! Not only was it beautiful and exactly how I imagine but it was the best cake I have ever tasted!!! My wedding was over three months ago and people still talk about how amazing the flavors of our cake were. Steve was a pleasure to work with and he always took time out of this day to answer any of my questions and concerns. I HIGHLY recommend Pennington’s to every bride and groom. The prices are unbeatable. -
-
Ashtyn Sent on 12/17/2019
Outstanding! I would not have another cake besides Pennington's!
Very easy to work with and made my vision come alive while tasting one of a kind!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thank you Ashtyn! You came with an inspired design in mind, and we were thrilled to execute it for you! Congratulations and many blessings in a long and happy life together! -
-
Deborrah Sent on 12/09/2019
Beautiful and Delicious Wedding Cake!
Pennington’s Cakes was outstanding and profesional to work with in creating the exact Wedding Cake my daughter and son-in-law wanted for their Big Day in September of 2019. The cake was beautiful, moist, fresh, and so delicious! They were right on time for set-up and discreet with all the other happenings taking place at the same time. I would Most definitely and highly recommend them to anyone considering a professional cake for a Wedding, Anniversary, Birthday, Retirement, Holiday, or event party. Pennington’s Cakes are a great value for the price and oh so delicious!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much! We loved making your cakes. And we love to visit Fischer Hall! We hope to see you again soon! Many blessings to the newlyweds for a long and happy life together! -
-
![Shelby]()
Shelby Sent on 12/04/2019Beautiful, Tasteful, and Reasonable
Beautiful cakes for a reasonable price! Tasted amazing which is the important part. Our meeting was quick, but Stephen was willing to brainstorm for as long as needed. On the day, Pennington's came in and did their job. Didn't disrupt me; just took care of it all. Excellent price for a 4 tier and a grooms cake.Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Shelby! We strive to make the cake the least of a couple's worries on the big day! We are thrilled you were pleased. We wish you the very best, many blessings, and a long and happy life together! -
-
Laura Sent on 12/01/2019
Best decision for cakes!!!!
Pennington’s was a fantastic choice for my husband and I for our wedding! They were very friendly and responsive to all of our questions in person and through email making working with them a breeze. Pennington’s worked with my gluten allergy at a very affordable rate and incredibly tasty cakes (and cupcakes) with fresh berries!!!! We shopped around a lot for cakes through San Antonio, New Braunfels, and San Marcos area. They were the best by far in both price and quality!!!! Best choice to top off an absolutely perfect day!!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks Laura! Congratulations to you and Adam! We are so pleased that you loved your cakes. Many blessings to you and a long and happy life together. -
-
![Felicia]()
Felicia Sent on 12/01/2019Delicious wedding cake!
Our cake was beautiful and so good. Our guests loved it.Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Felicia! We loved making your cakes. Thanks for letting us be a part of your big day! Many blessings to you and Bryan. We wish you a long and happy life together! -
Oscar Sent on 12/01/2019
Wedding reception
Thank you for making our wedding so special...Pennington's Cakes's reply:
You're welcome! We loved making your cakes. We wish you many blessings and a long and happy life together! -
-
![Alyse]()
Alyse Sent on 11/11/2019My cakes were beautiful!
Pennington’s did two cakes for my wedding and they both turned out awesome. Anything you can imagine or honestly pull off Pinterest Stephen and his team can pull it off. We did a simple wedding and Star Wars groom’s cake. First off they looked amazing but then they tasted even better! I’m looking forward to eating the top tier of my wedding cake next year already. Great job Pennington’s!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks Alyse! We loved making your cakes. So much fun! Glad you enjoyed them! Congrats and wishes for a long and happy life together! -
-
![MELANIE]()
Melanie Sent on 06/19/2019Wonderful Service! Amazing taste!
Stephen was great from the beginning to end! Scheduling the tasting was simple and convenient and they even prepared a sampling for my children. Stephen was flexible with changes throughout the entire process and did everything with a smile. The day of delivery went smoothly and even though they forgot the stand (I didn’t even notice) everything was beautiful and perfect! And the taste? Oh wow!!!! We chose the pineapple and the chocolate ganache and both were to die for! So delicious and fresh! Thanks again Penington’s! I couldn’t have asked for anything better!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Melanie! We loved making your cakes. We wish you many blessings and many happy years together! -
-
Maggie Sent on 06/17/2019
Weddingcake
We had a fabulous experience with Pennington’s! We ordered 6 cakes total and everyone LOVED them. In fact, we had none leftover! They captured just what we wanted as far as the design and overall look of the cakes. We would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for wedding cakes out there!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Maggie! We loved making your cakes!! God bless you and congrats!! We wish you all the best! -
-
![Natalie]()
Natalie Sent on 05/06/2019Natalie and Ryan
We wanted a carrot cake, needed it shortish notice. I was referred to them from a friend I trusted, and baked herself but only did cupcakes. They were flexible with testing and the returning of our stand! Had the perfect stand, was in the window and probably had not seen a wedding in awhile. Took it as a sign, since it was perfectly antiqued and went amazing with our wedding and venue. Kind people, and the cake was great( I think, did not get to eat that much the night of) (; I heard great things and it looked great! Delivery, communication and all else was amazing.Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Natalie! We loved making your cake. Congratulations and many blessings to you both! We hope to see you again soon! -
![Alison]()
Alison Sent on 12/01/2018BEST tasting cakes EVER & gorgeously designed!!
I'm absolutely blown away by the taste and design of their cakes! They couldn't have been better to work with - Stephen and team are AMAZING! We told them exactly what we wanted for both cakes, and they blew us away! We found them, but our caterer confirmed we made the right choice (kept insisting she's tasted all & they're the best). Then, other vendors & ALL the guests were asking where we got our cakes! We are thrilled to this day to have used them - best wedding cakes ever! Thank you so much!Pennington's Cakes's reply:
Thanks, Alison! Many blessings to you both! We loved doing your cakes. Thanks so much for the honor of being a part of your big day! Hope to see you soon!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?