Our CupCakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
![Katlyn]()
Katlyn Sent on 04/22/2025Amazing Cupcakes and Wedding Cake
We ordered cupcakes and a small wedding cake from Our Cupcakery for our wedding. Laura and the entire team did such a fantastic job of working with us to select flavors and deliver the desserts the day of the wedding. The cupcakes and cake themselves were amazing! We got so many compliments from our guests about how good they were. We can’t recommend Our Cupcakery enough! -
![Mackenzie]()
Mackenzie Sent on 03/01/2025The Sweetest Finale to Our Wedding Day
If there’s one thing guests always talk about after a wedding, it’s the food—especially the dessert! And let us tell you, Our CupCakery delivered perfection. If you’re in Central Ohio and want the best-tasting cakes and cupcakes, look no further.
From the very start, Laura made the process incredibly easy. She took the time to go over every detail of our wedding cake, ensuring it was exactly what we envisioned. Their cake batter? Moist, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Their frosting? Perfectly balanced—not overly sugary. Instead, they created a stunning cake that was both beautiful and delicious. Their cheesecake rounds were a huge hit as well!
One thing we especially loved was their attention to presentation. They even provided elegant cake and dessert stands, making our treats look like something straight out of a fairy tale ballroom. And if you want fresh flowers on your cake, no problem—they’ll coordinate with your florist to make sure everything comes together flawlessly. And it truly did. Our wedding cake the day of the wedding looked exactly the way we had imagined and more. Just was absolutely breathtaking!
But here’s the best part—our wedding desserts were so good that we actually went back after our wedding just to get more! That’s how irresistible their cakes and cupcakes are. Our favorite being the lemon cake with raspberry buttercream icing.
If you want to ensure your guests leave with full hearts and happy bellies, Our CupCakery is the place to go. We couldn’t recommend them enough!
-
Amanda Sent on 09/13/2024
Amazing Wedding Day Cake!
Our Cupcakery was an absolute joy to work with. I knew from the second we had our cake tasting that we were in good hands. We had no idea what we were doing when it came to designing our wedding cake, but Laura was so helpful and so prepared. She had examples to show us and really worked with us to create something beautiful. The cakes are also delicious! Our cake was a huge hit with our guests. We didn't even have any left to take home. I can't recommend Our Cupcakery enough! -
-
Kristen Sent on 11/14/2023
Best Bakery
I had the pleasure of working with Laura at Our Cupcakery for our wedding cake and tasting. Our Cupcakery did a fantastic job!! The cake not only looked beautiful and exactly how I imagined it, but it is the best wedding cake I've ever had. Their cupcakes, icing, cake is incredible. We also ordered Buckeyes from them for our wedding welcome bags. We picked unique fun flavors for our wedding cake and half the cake was one flavor and half the other. Thank you SO MUCH Our Cupcakery! I would recommend them to anyone. -
-
![Emma]()
Emma Sent on 10/31/2023Delicious cake
We absolutely LOVED working with Our Cupcakery. Laura was so kind and patient, even when I was indecisive at our initial tasting/consultation on what exactly I wanted. I am intolerant to gluten and lactose and she made me feel totally at ease by saying “Everyone deserves to have yummy cake on their wedding day.” Despite our cake being gluten/lactose free, nobody noticed a difference. I even had guests come up and tell me it was the most delicious cake they’d had in their entire lives. They also decorated the cake exactly according to my vision and left a box for leftovers. If you want to support a family-run local bakery, look no further than Our Cupcakery. -
-
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 08/30/2022Best Decision is Hiring OurCupcakery
Laura at Our Cupcakery is the absolute best. Not only is she the most bubbly, personable woman you will meet - but she delivers come your event day. When I saw my 4-tier cake at the reception, I cried because it was so beautiful. It was exactly as I had dreamt it to look like, and even better! It tasted amazing! All of our guests were shocked at how delicious the cake tasted. We received numerous comments from guests that our cake was nothing like any wedding cake they have ever tasted before. Book Our Cupcakery, do not second guess yourself. Your design, your vision, and your taste buds will thank you! -
![Cynthia]()
Cynthia Sent on 12/31/2021Gluten-free Options! Delicious and Beautiful
We worked with Laura to make the plan for our wedding cake, and we couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out! I needed a gluten-free cake, so we had one tier made gluten-free for me and the other gluten-free guests while the other tier and kitchen cakes were standard cakes. Our two-tier cutting cake was beautiful and exactly what we had imagined, and it was delicious too! We heard rave reviews from everyone about both the chocolate and strawberry cakes! We can’t wait for our anniversary cake next year! -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 11/09/2021Perfectly Delicious!
I highly recommend the Cupcakery. I did extensive research (tastings!), received many quotes and decided on them based on their great flavor. I could not have asked for better people to work with planning a covid wedding. I am thankful for their flexibility and support. The cake and cupcakes the day of tasted SO GOOD! The lighted display was worth every penny. I am beyond happy with my choice!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Cant wait for my anniversary cake! -
![Cassie]()
Cassie Sent on 08/16/2021Perfection
A absolutely perfect cake! Gorgeous, delicious, everything that we wanted. I would definitely order from her again. They help with every step of the way for planning the cake of your dreams. -
-
![Laura]()
Laura Sent on 03/01/2020Amazing all around
Besides our venue, this was the best vendor we had. From day one every email and question was answered almost immediately. We found a photo of a cake we wanted and they made it look exactly as we had hoped. Very friendly customer service and great product! -
-
Trusha Sent on 10/25/2019
Beautiful and Memorable Wedding Cake
Laura and her wedding cake design team at the CupCakery in Dublin, OH are incredible. My mum and I had a very challenging cake design and Laura helped execute it to perfection! I would absolutely recommend to anyone looking for a beautifully put together cake, amazing customer service and delicious dessert for your guests! -
-
![Stacy]()
Stacy Sent on 10/22/2019Best cake hands down
We had the best wedding cake (we are biased lol) from the kindest people in the baking world for our big day. Laura and the rest of her team went above and beyond for us. Before we had gone in to discuss pricing and flavors she asked us for a vision. We told her what we wanted and they created a cake flavor that they didnt even have on their extensive list. A brunch cake with a cinnamon flavored cake and vanilla icing (this was a cinnamon roll style cake). It was perfect and everything we wanted. Cannot thank them enough! -
-
![Deidra]()
Deidra Sent on 10/17/2019Loved them!
Laura is amazing and will handle every single detail you need with the sweetest attitude ever. She's so accommodating and will make your vision come to life! She set up everything perfectly and it looked amazing. I will say the owner, Linda, is a little less friendly than Laura and not nearly as accommodating. She can be almost rude at times, but you mostly work with Laura anyway, who doesn't have a rude bone in her body! The food tasted amazing and my guests raved about them! I did a full dessert bar with chocolate covered strawberries, macaroons, buckeyes, brownies, and two different cheesecakes and she took care of it all! Highly recommend. -
![Aderonke]()
Aderonke Sent on 10/07/2019Super helpful and flexible
Working with them has been extremely easy. The tasting was easy to schedule. Laura was so helpful and knowledgeable. And all of the flavors/icing tasted great! They worked with our budget but were able to come up with all of the elements that I wanted at a great price. After our initial meeting, I found additional elements that I wanted to add and they were super flexible. I can't wait to see the final product! -
![Abe]()
Abe J. Sent on 09/30/2019Staff was friendly and responsive, plus the food was amazing!
We ordered a cake and entire dessert bar for our reception. I wish I could say more about the taste of everything, but there was little left because our guests love it that much! I think that speaks for itself.
Laura couldn't have been nicer, professional, and willing to go above and beyond for our special day! We will be using this company for special life moments into the future!! -
-
Brittnay Sent on 09/21/2019
The most delicious desserts we've ever had!
All night long we were told how delicious our desserts were. The cake was absolutely amazing and very good. We were not able to have any of our pecan tarts or fruit tarts because they were the first to be eaten. The brookies, buckeyes, sugar cookies, and cupcakes were very good. We couldn't have asked for a better place for our desserts to come from. They were the best to work with! We will be foing back just to have desserts in the future. -
-
![Allison]()
Allison Sent on 10/20/2018Beautiful to look at and so delicious
Our cupcakery did a FANTASTIC job for our wedding cake and cupcakes. The presentation was absolutely beautiful and they were DELICIOUS. Laura was easy to work with and truly brought our vision to life. Everyone loved the cupcakes and they were almost gone by the end of the night. They were prompt in delivery and even picked up the cake stand that night. Highly recommend! We will most definitely use them again in the future. -
![MsToMrs]()
Pamela Sent on 10/01/2018Ridiculously delicious cupcakes. My husband saw that they offered a cupcake bar so that was already a plus, but the taste sealed the deal. The team was very responsive to any questions I had along the way and were great to work with. -
Tasia Sent on 09/16/2018I would highly recommend Our Cupcakery! I enlisted them to make my wedding cake and I was thrilled with how it turned out. I wanted one of the cake flavors to be pink champagne flavored and it was hands down the best cake I’ve ever had. All of our guests commented about how delicious it was (we also had red velvet cake!) and how beautiful the cake looked. Working with Laura was great too. I showed her some pictures and she knew exactly what to do. She also made sure to coordinate a delivery time with me and my vendor based on the temperature of the wedding day to ensure the buttercream frosting was not subjected to too much heat prior to the reception. They did a fantastic job!
-
-
Charity Sent on 09/15/2018Cake was great, they traveled from Dublin to Granville, and it looked amazing! Thank you!
-
-
Carley Sent on 06/21/2018Absolutely perfect!! From the first meeting to me adding on a few weeks before to the delivery and set up! Laura was fantastic!! Thank you soo much for making it perfect!!
-
-
![Mr. & Mrs. Flowers]()
Lindsay Sent on 02/21/2015We loved working with Laura she knew exactly what we were wanting. The tasting was great. I brought along 4 people and they were very nice about accommodating for all of us. The cake tastes delicious and their pricing is right on point. If you want a beautiful cake that also tastes amazing I would go with Our Cupcakery. Their cake and fillings and icing just melt in your mouth. The tasting experience was great, they have great visual ques with styrofoam cake layers to visualize the sizes you could choose from. They also have books filled with pictures of cakes that they have made not just pictures of cakes that they could make. I also liked the fact that they deliver your cake and let you rent different options of cake stands. It is nice to not have to worry about those details on the day of your wedding.
Laura is super organized, easy to work with, and very nice! The overall experience was great I would definitely recommend them! -
![Aisha]()
Aisha Sent on 03/15/2014Laura did an amazing job! Our cupcakes and cake tasted wonderful!!! It was beautiful as well! -
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 04/04/2019Amazing icing!
The almond buttercream icing is so yummy! Our cake was delicious! -
![User1389515]()
User1389515 Sent on 10/20/2013Despite the fact that the cake was much higher than other vendors, it was a major disappointment. I met with them and specifically designed the way it was to be decorated. It looked very amatuerish, it leaned and they just stuck flowers on the top in no arranged manner than looked ridiculous. The scroll work was inadequate, patchy and incomplete. Although promised I would receive box to freeze the top tier for my anniversary, they failed to do so. They only had one 1 cake stand to choose from and I had to post a $150.00 deposit that was tarnished, scratched and it was silver square when I requested gold round. Although the cake did taste good, it was to serve 118 per their dimensions and we barely got 90 pieces out of it. I would not recommend them for the value or quality of the decorating. I was promised it would be decorated by the owner and was told it was by a student.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?