Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co Reviews

Name: Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co
Address: 901 High Street, Columbus, OH, 43085
Telephone: 1614888743
Rating: 2.0

Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co

Columbus, OH

2.0 out of 5 rating, 11 reviews

View more information

Reviews

We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

2.0 out of 5 rating

2.0

11 reviews

Recommended by 40% of couples

Write a review

Quality of service
2 out of 5 rating
Average response time
2 out of 5 rating
Professionalism
2 out of 5 rating
Value
1.8 out of 5 rating
Flexibility
2.1 out of 5 rating

Write a review

Sort by:

Katie Sent on 09/24/2025

5 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  5 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  5 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  5 out of 5 rating
- Value
  5 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  5 out of 5 rating
Lesley… this is embarrassing

I dont even work at Mrs Goodmans but I’m a regular customer and it’s super obvious that all of these bad reviews are from the same person, I assume Lesley is your real name because it started with those… this is just sad. Give it up.
Donna Sent on 05/23/2015

4.4 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  5 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  3.5 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  5 out of 5 rating
- Value
  3.5 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  5 out of 5 rating
My daughter and her fiance selected Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co. for their wedding cake. They had a simple design for their cutting cake and several sheet cakes for serving guests. The cake table was perfect. The cake was set as expected and looked beautiful. The sheet cakes were delicious. Not your ordinary cake but very a very moist dense cake. Many compliments on the taste.
User3161382 Sent on 01/10/2015

4.4 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  4.5 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  5 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  4 out of 5 rating
- Value
  3.5 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  5 out of 5 rating
The cake was a little pricy, but it was gorgeous and totally delicious. It had intricate scroll piping that was gorgeously done, the flavors were rich, and the buttercream icing was just right, no too sweet! Totally worth it!

Are you interested?

Kelley Sent on 09/24/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Based off of the reviews

Have been going here for couple years my daughter decided she wanted PASTEL PINK cupcakes, when i went to pick up they were purple, not pastel pink and when I made remark about it, the baker said unfortunately that's how it came out...that was their excuse. Not getting my money back.
Cathy Sent on 09/23/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Very stale cakes that are dry

The cakes are very old stale and dry, thought I was the only one experiencing this then saw that all the five star review are fake from people the bakery knows like family/friends. Saw others were complaining about the extremely overpriced cakes that look average at best and taste like a blind person made the cakes no disrespect to blind people. This bakery clearly doesnt know how to make a decent cake that isn't spoiled. Beware.
User88900 Sent on 09/22/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Not satisfied

If you want old and dry cake that isn't fresh this is the bakery for you! While their cake may seem "pretty" on the outside you're in for a treat when you take that first bite. It's dry and not at all what cake should look like.
Userg82929202 Sent on 09/21/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Bad customer service disgusting cake

My cake order was messed up and the cake was dry then they try to replace it with a cheap looking cake that’s worth way less than what I paid for almost 100 for a tiny dry as hell cake if that what you call a cake
User28393738 Sent on 09/21/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Messed up my order

They messed up my order and cake was very dry. Better off going to different bakery so that they dont get offended when someone points out an error
Customer Sent on 09/21/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
You’re cake is very dry

Not only is your cake dry but you don’t know what customer service is, if you own a business and someone says hey this cake is very dry don’t you think that’s alarming and maybe you should refund the the money they spent on a cake that they didn’t like because it was again DRY and wrong order.
Lesley Sent on 09/21/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
I expect a full refund for dry ass cake

$85 for cake that was 1. Wrong order and 2. DRY you tried to give me a cheap ass replacement cake that wasn’t worth what I paid for what i asked for
Lv Sent on 09/20/2025

1 out of 5 rating
- Quality of service
  1 out of 5 rating
- Average response time
  1 out of 5 rating
- Professionalism
  1 out of 5 rating
- Value
  1 out of 5 rating
- Flexibility
  1 out of 5 rating
Super dry cake and bad customer service

If someone tells you that you messed up their order and the cake is dry as hell you give them refund and not give them a cheap cake from Walmart

Are you interested?