Recommended by 99%
1 User photo
Ashley · Married on 10/13/2018
Our cake was beautiful and delicious!
Amanda · Married on 09/22/2018
Absolutely loved our wedding cake and groom's cake. Jennifer was super easy to work with. I'm not normally a cake person and I absolutely loved our cake!
Jenna · Married on 09/15/2018
Jennifer is absolutely wonderful to work with. She is professional, creative and went above and beyond to design the perfect cake for our special day. In addition to our tiered wedding cake, I requested a custom groom's cake. Jennifer worked with me to create one of the best cake designs I have ever seen. I was completely blown away when I walked into our rehearsal dinner to see the beautiful cake displayed exactly how I had envisioned it to be. Our wedding cake was equally wonderful and tasted delicious. We highly recommend Main Street Sweets for any event.
Sascha · Married on 07/20/2018
Jennifer made the most magnificant cake and cupcakes for our wedding! They were absolutely delicious and our guests were in love with the details!! We can’t thank you enough for making our wedding cake!! We highly recommend Jennifer for every occasion!!
Melissa · Married on 06/09/2018
I am the kind of person who does their research before doing anything. I met with at least two vendors for every aspect of my wedding. I can confidently say that I made the right choice with Jennifer. She was communicative, flexible, and knowledgeable! She took my vision and turned it into a beautiful and delicious reality! I would highly recommend her!
Kristi · Married on 05/12/2018
We decided to do a 2 tiered, small cake with cupcakes for our wedding. We had yellow cake with vanilla buttercream, chocolate with chocolate buttercream, strawberry cake with vanilla buttercream, and red velvet with cream cheese filling and vanilla buttercream. The hardest part about this vendor was trying to narrow down the flavors! All of the samples were absolutely delicious, flavorful, and moist. Also, Main Street Sweets did an awesome job with setting up our display at our venue to make it look so perfect. We had tons of compliments on the cupcakes and would recommend Main Street Sweets to everyone!
Kristina · Married on 03/10/2018
Jennifer was wonderful to work with in designing a beautiful and delicious cake. She immediately provided details of her services including costs and serving approximations along with pictures of cakes she has designed for weddings. She was accommodating when we had to reschedule a tasting due to the flu and immediately prepared a take home box full of cupcake samples of cake flavors and icings. The cake turned out STUNNING and so delicious. We are still enjoying pieces of cake that we froze after the wedding.
Patricia · Married on 11/03/2017
Main Street Sweets is outstanding. Not only is the cake beautiful, it is delicious. If you want to enjoy the experience of delicious cake, hire Main Street Sweets.
Lindsay · Married on 09/09/2017
Jennifer at Main Street Sweets was amazing to work with! We had a three-tier wedding cake and five dozen cupcakes at our wedding and hardly had anything leftover, it was all so delicious. The way she handles cake-tastings was excellent, by far the best bakery we met with prior to the wedding. All day during our reception we heard how amazing the cupcakes were. She showed up on the reception and helped set everything up beautifully. We couldn't have asked for a better bakery to work with!
Ashlee · Married on 07/29/2017
Our cake was perfect. Exactly what we want and tasted great!
Amber · Married on 07/29/2017
They did an awesome job on my wedding cake! Not only was it beautiful but it tasted great! Wouls highly recommend!!
Natasha · Married on 04/22/2017
They were so flexible and our wedding cupcakes were delicious. They have the best gluten free cupcakes and we definitely want to use them in the future!
Kierstin · Married on 10/15/2016
Fantastic cake and great flavors! We had our tasting and were impressed with the variety of flavors and fillings. Jennifer was very patient and helpful when it came to picking a design for our two-tiered cake. She was communicative and quick to respond. HIGHLY recommend!
Nicole · Married on 09/25/2016
I was not really enthusiastic about the cake tasting because I've never really had a wedding cake that I'd write home about. However, I was pleasantly surprised by how moist the cake was. My husband and I chose the a naked almond cake with raspberry mousse. We couldn't wait to get home from our honeymoon to get more cake (no exaggeration!)...and my guests still talking about the cake 2 months later. I must say, it was the best darn wedding cake I've EVER tasted. Can't wait for our anniversary to crack open our topper.
Connie · Married on 09/17/2016
Main Street Sweets made our wedding cake and it was beautiful and delicious!! Jennifer was amazing to work with from the tasting clear thru til our wedding day. Highly recommend!!!!
Lisa · Married on 09/16/2016
Because of my work schedule, I was only able to communicate with them via phone and email. They were very responsive, have me plenty of options, and made exactly what I wanted for our big day. Everyone loved the beautiful cupcakes and they have plenty of flavors within budget. Definitely recommend!
Meagan · Married on 07/02/2016
Main Street Sweets made a 3 tier wedding cake and 200 cupcakes for our July 2 wedding in Gettysburg. My husband and I had a free taste-testing where we were able to tastes 12+ cake flavors, fillings, and icings. We mixed and matched and tried it all! It was so much fun and really allowed us to make a good decision. After choosing a cake flavor and 3 types of cupcake flavors, Wendy sat down with us and I showed her pictures and told her ideas of what I had in mind. She drew up a sketch and wrote out notes.
When I finally saw the cake on my wedding day, I was so pleased. It was everything I had wanted- absolutely beautiful! We had tons of wedding guests compliment the cake and cupcakes. I would recommend Main Street Sweets to anyone looking for a wedding cake vendor!
Nicole · Married on 06/25/2016
We had a great experience working with Main Street Sweets from start to finish. We ordered a two-tiered 'naked' cake (which turned out gorgeous!!!) and several types of cupcakes. Jennifer was so accommodating and flexible with what we wanted. On the day of our wedding, our cake arrived on time and in great shape! The girls placed the cake on the table and created a beautiful display with our cupcakes. They also placed flowers from our florist on our wedding cake just as we pictured it! Everything was delicious, and luckily we have our top tier of our cake and some cupcakes left over to enjoy and remember our day :) If we could go back and get married again, we would choose Main Street Sweets a thousand times over! Wonderful!
Sharon · Married on 06/18/2016
YUM!!! Main Street Sweets prepared and delivered my daughters wedding cake. Not only was it beautiful it was delicious as well!!! It was raspberry and lemon and everyone enjoyed it so much!! I would highly recommend them!!
User5164407 · 2+ years ago
Main Street Sweets is supplying the pies for my wedding day this June! They are quick to answer phone calls and their pies are INCREDIBLE. I highly recommend using them for your wedding or event!
Callie · Married on 06/10/2016
Main Street Sweets was amazing!! From the time we met them at the tasting (which was so fun!) all the way up until my wedding day, they were a great team to work with. Very affordable and the cupcakes tasted delicious! All of our guests loved the different flavors we provided and the way they decorated my cupcake cake looked great!! Very pleased :)
Lauren · Married on 05/13/2016
Best cake we have ever had at a wedding! That was something extremely important to us and Main Street Sweets nailed it! We decided on a 4 tier alternating carrot cake (which was to die for!) and strawberry cake. And we heard rave reviews. Jennifer and her team were very responsive anytime I had a question and for that I am very grateful, as it helped eased my stress. We highly recommend Main Street Sweets!
Sarah · Married on 04/08/2016
We used Main Street Sweets for our April wedding in Gettysburg. Being out of town, we had limited availability to schedule a consultation. From the beginning, they were so responsive and flexible. We met with Jennifer at her home for the tasting and consult. There were so many wonderful choices and we took home a huge box of cupcakes for the ride home! With our venue, we received a cake credit which was included with the venue cost. Jennifer was so helpful explaining all of our choices and helped make the choice of our 3-tiered cake effortless. We decided on different flavors for each tier, which all were amazing. Main Street was there for the whole process and was able to answer all of our questions quickly and efficiently. One of our cake toppers was a sword inserted in the middle of the cake. We were all nervous about how it would work out, but it turned out great and was a highlight of the reception!
I would highly recommend Main Street Sweets to anyone getting married in the area. They were friendly, easy to work with, and helped make an out-of-town wedding much less stressful. The delivery was on-time and they made sure everything was perfect before leaving. All of our guests loved the cake and we have an awesome anniversary cake waiting in the freezer for us this time next year!
Katie · Married on 03/05/2016
We were thrilled with the cakes that Main Street Sweets provided us for our wedding. First and foremost: everything was delicious! I also really appreciated the flexibility of choosing different flavors for each layer. Second, both cakes (a groom's cake for the rehearsal dinner and the wedding cake) were beautiful. The groom's cake had the specialized design we asked for and looked great. The wedding cake was simple but absolutely stunning. Finally, the prices were very fair and Jennifer and Wendy were willing to supply part of the wedding cake as a sheet cake (that was served but not displayed) to help us manage our budget even better. I highly recommend Main Street Sweets!
Sandy · Married on 10/24/2015
Main Street Sweets did a great job for our wedding. We had a 2 layer cake as well as 150 cupcakes. They were delicious! We had several different cupcake flavors which made it nice for the guests to choose from. The almond cake was fantastic. The delivery and setup was seamless. The dessert table looked beautiful and several guests told us how delicious the cupcakes were!