Recommended by 94%
Donna · Married on 11/30/2017
Phyllis is amazing. She also gave me suggestions for favors
Brittany · Married on 03/19/2016
Not only was my cake gorgeous and looked exactly like I wanted it to, it was also by far the best tasting cake I have ever had! I got so many compliments and have barely any leftover at the end of the night. She did a fabulous job and I could not have been happier!
Misty · Married on 03/16/2015
Our cheesecake was to die for! Phyllis made my cake look exactly like the picture I provided. Many places say they are unable to stack cheesecake. However, my cheesecake was stacked and looked perfect. This is the most amazing cheesecake I have ever had! Heavenly Cheesecakes is definitely worth the money!
Kim · Married on 06/07/2014
The name says it ALL !! This cheesecake is heavenly!!! Phyllis and her team provided our rehearsal dinner cheesecake,raspberry cheesecake with oreo crust and also the Grooms double layer cheesecake for the wedding reception. Both were so delicious we had very little left. We were all blessed by their wonderful tasting cakes!
User3062481 · 2+ years ago
They deliver to Saint Augustine, which is huge because of thier reasonable prices. The cake was absolutely delicious, as well as the cheese cake. We only had 70 guests, the cheesecake that contained 40 servings as well as two layers of cake were gone before I turned around. The cake was decorated beautifully. It was also lactose free, the cake not the cheesecake. While they missed the scheduled delivery time by 30 min. We had plenty of time before the ceremony began let alone the reception.
Christina · Married on 07/13/2013
Our cake was amazing!! It was very unique and tasted so good!!! Thank you!!!
User2400838 · 2+ years ago
Phyllis at Heavenly Cheesecake did an absolutely amazing job with my wedding cake. The cake was stunning and was the best cheesecake I've ever had. Guests are still raving about it! If you are looking for an awesome cheesecake wedding cake, I highly recommend Heavenly Cheesecakes!
Michele · Married on 04/20/2012
Heavenly Cheesecake created a beautiful and delicious wedding cake for our special day! So many of my guests commented on what an excellent cake it was. Phyllis is the owner and she was extremely helpful and accomodating. She actually threw in a larger base of the cake for free because she felt it would make the cake prettier! I highly recommend the almond vanilla cake! Excellent!!
Andrea · Married on 03/24/2012
Heavenly Cheesecakes & Chocolates made us a beautiful cake. I changed my mind a few times with the design of the cake and they were so helpful and patient with me. We did a few cake tastings with them and they are delicious. I would recommend any future brides to have them make your wedding cake.
Kelly · Married on 02/05/2012
When we first decided we wanted our wedding cake to be cheesecake- and serve 125 people- we though it was impossible. Then we found phyllis at Heavenly Cheesecakes and Chocolates. Not only was she able to make a 3 tier wedding cake out of cheesecake- she was able to make it the best cheesecake you could imagine- and it was stunningly beautuful! I cannot thank you enough for making us such a wonderful surprise for our big day!
Michael · Married on 11/25/2011
Heavenly Cheesecake created my wife's dream wedding cake. A gorgeous 6 tier cake that was absolutely amazing to look at and to eat! We absolutely recommend Heavenly Cheesecake & Chocolates to anyone & EVERYONE!
Lauren · Married on 01/22/2011
Phyllis is an amazing cake artist! She took all my ideas and made them real! Thank you!!!
Kalisha · Married on 10/30/2010
Phyllis did a wonderful job with our cake. It was beautiful and we got many compliments on how beautiful and delicious it was. She was also a pleasure to speak with when we had our first tasting. Thank you so much Phyllis.
Melissa · Married on 09/05/2010
My cake from Heavenly Cheesecakes was not only beautiful but delicious! Many of my guests said it was the most beautiful wedding cake they have ever seen!
BRandy · Married on 08/21/2010
They did my flowers and my cake--and they made my dreams come true, and the owner gives you her all even when they have tons of orders...
Ciarra · Married on 07/17/2010
The wedding caked looked exactly as I had imagined and tasted even better. All of my guests complimented on both the look and the flavor of the cake!
Meghan · Married on 06/19/2010
Our wedding cake from Heavenly Cheesecake was AMAZING! Not only did it look beautiful, but it tasted wonderful! Our guests commented on how great the cake was. The service was also wonderful. Heavenly Cheesecake listened to what we wanted and gave us a cake that exceeded our expectations!
Kimberly · Married on 05/15/2010
We had a beautiful custom cake made by Heavenly Cheesecake. They made the cake exactly as I imagined and it was DELICIOUS. All of our guests loved it! We even had a mini version of our cake made for our first anniversary and it was just as delicious as it was on our wedding day. I highly recommend their tropical carrot cake, it's AMAZING!
Krista · Married on 02/27/2010
My cake was awesome and tasted soooooo good, I had a three tier with vanilla, carrot and pineapple coconut, it was amazing, they also worked with me which was such a great help. I will defintely use them in the future.
Mindi · Married on 02/06/2010
My wedding cake was gorgeous AND tasted great! It was a huge success and helped to set the mood at the reception. They were easy to work with and helped to make my vision come true!
Lucky · Married on 06/18/2009
Fantastic! Loved it all, had been recommended this place by my mother-in-law, and it was perfect!
Rebecca · Married on 10/11/2008
Phyllis is the BEST! She made our beautiful wedding cake and Groom's cake, both were out of this world! Not only was the outside of the cake perfect, it was the best tasting cake- all of our guests loved it!
Dr. Cassandra · Married on 02/08/2008
I cannot begin to say enough about this baker. From the moment we did the taste testing; we were hooked. Phyllis went out of her way to design our cake which was a little out of the ordinary; since we were going with an Italian theme. She searched for months for the right grapes to use on the "Wine-grape"cake and then even lent us the fabric to stage the cake on. The bottom layer was Italian cheesecake, then Chocolate Tiramasu, then Marble and finally Red-Velvet. It was fabulous; and even turned out so well that I believe it is on her website. People are still talking about the presentation and the wonderful taste.
Amanda · Married on 05/19/2007
Heavenly Cheesecake did our wedding cake 6 years ago and just recently did a cake for my husband's surprise 40th birthday. Not only do the cakes look amazing, but they taste as good as they look, too. All the other guests raved about the cake as well. The service is also outstanding! Phyllis and Mary are wonderful people to work with. They can do anything you ask as well as give great input on their ideas. They have tons of experience and are very reliable. They will also set up your cake for you and create a beautiful display. You won't regret using them and they will surely exceed your expectations.
Erica · Married on 01/02/2015
The wedding cake was amazing and everyone loved it. They showed up on time.