Frosted Memories LLC Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
5.0 out of 5 rating
93 reviews
100% recommend it
-
![Jenna]()
Jenna Sent on 09/02/2022We love Frosted Memories!!
Cheryl did such a great job with our wedding cake! She was so nice and responsive and really made our wedding cake experience go seamlessly. She came to our venue the day of to drop the cake of and decorate it with our flowers, she made it look gorgeous!! The cake itself also tasted amazing! We couldn’t have asked for a better wedding cake😍 -
-
![Kris]()
Kris Sent on 02/28/2022Amazing cake, cupcakes and cookies
I was so happy to have found Frosted Memories, LLC for my wedding needs. My cutting cake, cupcakes and cookies were by far the best I've tasted. Cheryl was wonderful to work with and displayed her confections beautifully. -
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 10/15/2021Delicious!
Cheryl was so great to work with for our wedding! When we first talked, she dropped of a whole platter of cake samples and frostings for us to try in the comfort of our home. She was very helpful in deciding what we wanted to do. We ended up with lemon cupcakes with strawberry frosting (AH-mazing!) and red velvet cupcake! We also had a small cutting cake as well. The cupcakes and cake looked beautiful and she lent us some of her glass stands to use as well. I got soooo many compliments on how delicious the cupcakes were. Cheryl came to the venue too and set everything up for us. So thank you again, Cheryl! -
![Kaitlyn]()
Kaitlyn Sent on 09/13/2021Could not have asked for a better cake and cupcakes!
Cheryl was absolutely wonderful to work with! She made my vision come true and everything was perfect! Each flavor of cupcake was incredible and our cake was exactly what we wanted! All of our guests raved about how amazing the desert was! Can’t wait to order from her again! -
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 07/14/2021Great Cake!
Picking cake was one of our favorite experiences! We got to mix and match some cake flavors and fillings, and everything was so good it was hard to choose! Everyone commented how delicious our wedding cake was. Cheryl was so easy to work with, even able to add another small cake for my friend's birthday within the last few weeks. Pricing was much more reasonable than other places I had looked at. I'd highly recommend her! -
-
![Katelyn]()
Katelyn Sent on 06/07/2021No brainer
Cheryl was amazing with helping me bring my vision to life. Our cake and cupcakes were amazing and people raved about them. I highly recommend! -
-
![Olivia]()
Olivia Sent on 08/24/2020Wedding Cake/Cupcakes
Cheryl did an amazing job! She understood exactly what I was looking for and did exactly that! Her cakes and cupcakes are baked and iced to absolute excellence! She is so sweet to work with and very understanding. I had to postpone my wedding due to covid and she was very easy to work with on changing the date a few weeks in advance. I highly recommend using her for your wedding cake! Overall I was extremely satisfied!! -
-
![Thomas]()
Thomas Sent on 12/28/2019Great cakes
Had the best tasting cakes and was very nice -
![Grace]()
Grace Sent on 12/28/2019Exceeds expectations
Always goes above and beyond everytime! She helped us come up with the complete vision for our cake. She has been a trusted Baker for my family for years and we will go to no one else! -
![Kimberly]()
Kimberly Sent on 09/22/2019Excellence!
Cheryl was AMAZING! She followed everything we asked, and our cupcakes and cheesecake were PERFECT! A -
-
![Brieanne]()
Brieanne Sent on 07/30/2019I highly recommend Frosted Memories
I met Cheryl at one of my friend's weddings, and when I tasted her cupcakes, I knew we had to have her for our wedding. Cheryl was able to stay within our budget. My husband and I had a cake that we cut, and then we had cupcakes for our guests to enjoy. Every flavor we chose was absolutely delicious, and the decorations on each cupcake were so beautiful, our cutting cake was also extremely gorgeous, and of course delicious. I highly recommend Cheryl and Frosted Memories, we had a great experience. -
-
![Katherina]()
Katherina Sent on 07/05/2019amazing flavor and presentation!
Cheryl had made our wedding cake and cupcakes for our wedding and did an amazing job! We had so many compliments on the cupcakes and everyone loved the fun flavors! I really loved how we could customize each flavor with the frosting we liked best. The cakes were so moist and rich. The pricing was also super affordable compared to some of the other bakeries we had looked at! Cheryl also drove all the way to Edgerton to deliver our cakes. Definitely recommend!! -
-
![Morgan]()
Morgan Sent on 10/14/2018We had a cake and cupcakes from Frosted Memories for our wedding on Sept. 29th and they were AMAZING. We got so many compliments on how great the cupcakes were. The almond was my absolute favorite. I might have to order an anniversary cake from Cheryll every year because I have not been able to find anything that compares. :) -
![Kailin]()
Kailin Sent on 07/10/2017Cheryl did an amazing job! Since our wedding was in July she suggested a fake cake so that it would last longer in the heat and be more budget friendly. She did a fantastic job and our cake looked amazing! I highly recommend her! -
![Tim and Allie]()
Tim A. Sent on 06/16/2016Cheryl at Frosted Memories was amazing to work with in creating our perfect wedding cake and cupcakes! She was always quick to respond, attentive to our ideas, and very creative with her work. She went above and beyond by doing such things as dropping off cupcake decorations at our house for our flavor sign, etc. It was evident that she wanted our day and our cake to be perfect! She worked hard to give us everything that we wanted. Our cake/cupcake table turned out beautifully. I would highly recommend Cheryl and Frosted Memories for weddings or any other occasion!!
-
![MalB]()
Malinda Sent on 10/22/2015I absolutely loved working with Cheryl from Frosted Memories. I was searching for a cake baker from out of state and she was always so responsive. When I was visiting Wisconsin to do wedding planning she worked around my schedule. The cupcakes she gave me to try were so delicious. The cake is moist, the frosting is just sweet enough. Cheryl also did an amazing job on my cake. It was exactly like the picture I sent and my guests gave us so many compliment on the look and flavor. Her prices are also very reasonable for the area. I cannot recommend Cheryl enough! -
Tera Sent on 02/17/2025
Multiple flavors of wedding cakes
Cheryl is so helpful and easy to work with. In choosing someone to make cakes for our wedding we tried many bakeries in the area. Frosted Memories by far the best right down to the tasting platter. We had 8 square wedding cakes in different flavors and each one was moist and delicious! Her frosting is amazing too! We will definitely be ordering all of our special occasions cakes from her! Thank you so much for helping make our day perfect! -
-
Jake Sent on 12/11/2024
Absolutely Incredible!
Everything was more amazing than we could have ever imagined! The attention to detail, the highest quality, and the absolute deliciousness of the cake and cupcakes...it was perfection at it's finest. My wife and I are so thankful that we chose Frosted Memories for our special day, we received so many compliments and the incredible cupcakes 💜 Cheryl took our detailed ideas to incorporate our custom cake topper of our pups and absolutely perfected it. Thank you for giving us these special memories! -
-
Brett Sent on 10/29/2023
Amazing Vendor!
Cheryl did an amazing job at creating our cupcakes and cake for our wedding! They were sooo delicious and were a huge hit. She was great to work with. -
-
Jon M. Sent on 12/08/2022
Great wedding cake experience
Cheryl made two cakes for us and both were outstanding. One was a three tier cake for cutting and the sheet cake was a big crowd pleaser. She provided great quantity recommendations and was very flexible with our delivery and return of the cake board. Most importantly, the flavors we chose were fantastic. Highly recommend. -
-
Andrea Sent on 11/13/2022
Everything was perfect and amazing
Frosted Memories did a fantastic job at creating the cupcakes with designs that I wanted. They were so delicious and were such a big hit at my wedding! She was very quick at responding when I had questions or needed anything from her. I will definitely be using her for birthdays and other parties later on in life! -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?