Creations by Sergio Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Featured
![Kelsey]()
Kelsey Sent on 03/12/2025Kind, attentive, and great Food
We had the absolute pleasure of having Creations by Sergio cater our wedding, and we couldn't be happier with the experience! From the very beginning, Randi was incredibly kind, helpful, and full of great suggestions during our tasting, making the menu planning process smooth and enjoyable.
On our wedding day, the food was nothing short of amazing! We had appetizers and a buffet dinner, and everything was delicious. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about the flavors, the presentation, and the overall experience. What truly set Creations by Sergio apart was the outstanding service. The staff worked so hard to ensure our guests had the best experience, clearing plates promptly and making sure everyone was taken care of with warmth and professionalism.
Randi and her team went above and beyond to personalize our menu, accommodating dietary restrictions and even creating options tailored for the children attending. It was clear that everyone at Creations by Sergio is passionate about what they do, and it showed in every detail. The number of compliments we received—not just about the food but also about the kindness and attentiveness of the staff—speaks volumes about their dedication.
If you’re looking for a caterer that delivers incredible food, exceptional service, and a truly personalized experience, Creations by Sergio is the way to go! Thank you again for making our wedding day so special.
Kelsey & Matt
2/15/25 @ Arizona Historical Society Museum (such a beautiful venue!) -
![Shelly]()
Shelly Sent on 11/07/2023Absolutely wonderful!
Wonderful catering! They were so accommodating of a menu with a large number of dietary restrictions (non-dairy, nut free, vegetarian and pescetarian friendly, and gluten free!) and I would happily 100% hire them again! The caterer even managed to convince our venue to allow us to do buffet style catering! We were highly impressed with the food and also the way that we were able to work with them to customize a menu that fit as many needs as possible. Everything was absolutely delicious! -
![Erin]()
Erin Sent on 03/02/2022Award-Winning for a Reason!
Creations by Sergio was fabulous to work with for our wedding. The guests commented on how fantastic the food was and one guest commented that our wedding "raised the bar" for what good wedding fare should be. They were wonderful to work with the build a menu and we had a tasting before the event that made us look forward to our own event so we would get to eat Sergio's Creations again! They served a beautiful selection of Sonoran-inspired dishes and were able to accommodate a range of dietary restrictions (including gluten-free). We are so grateful to Creations by Sergio as they provided a memorable dining experience for our guests. We had excellent communication throughout the planning with Randy and Sergio. A wonderful team to work with, and, most importantly, excellent food and service. I would recommend them for any event: corporate meetings, conferences, weddings, parties, Wednesday.... They are amazing. -
![Anna]()
Anna Sent on 03/16/2020Delicious food and professional staff
We knew we wanted tacos for our reception, and when we contacted Sergio's we were impressed right away with how they were on top of everything. On the day of the wedding, the staff were all efficient and professional, and of course the food was delicious! -
![Sage]()
Sage Sent on 10/11/2019Incredible food!!!
Sergio is just amazing. They were all super communicative and professional. If you want truly good home-cooked food, Sergio and his team are your future go-to's for any event. They catered for mine and my husband's wedding, and it was absolutely delicious. We had so many compliments about our caterer and everyone stated they kept going back for more! It's all absolutely mouth watering. On top of his amazing food, Sergio is just a genuine and charismatic human. He's simply the best! Highly recommend!!! -
![Liz]()
Liz P. Sent on 03/09/2021Delicious Windmill Winery Food Vendor
Sergio, Randy, and their team did an awesome job the day of the wedding. Everything went smoothly and all of the food was prepared properly and delicious. Our menu included pork, chicken, roasted vegetables, and pasta. One of the guests who owns a restaurant and does a lot of catering herself commented that they did an amazing job.
During the process, we were able to have a potential menu food tasting with a thorough review of the wedding day expectations. Randy and Sergio were very friendly and accommodating throughout the process.
A few cons for us were the slightly pricey menu upgrades and speed of email responses to confirm the contract details.
Overall, A+
We would hire them again and recommend them as a great choice for a Windmill Winery Wedding!
Thank you so much Sergio, Randy, and team!! -
![Angela]()
Angela Sent on 02/23/2025Great food and presentation!!
Sergio and his team served fantastic food, and set up a great presentation of their here at the Windmill Winery in Florence, AZ! 💕 -
![Savanna]()
Savanna Sent on 11/20/2018Unprofessional service
I inquired about catering services for my Sept 2019 wedding! I had been to a friends wedding that creations by Sergio had done, with a taco bar and loved it. The food was so good and it was definitely more upscale than the traditional taco bar. I inquired with him about pricing and such. I am a full time working mom/student and fiance that I don't have time to sit on a phone call, or even more that's the LAST thing I want to do. Email is my preferred method of contact and I explained this to him. I was confirming the price per person, as well as seeing what the service charge was. After about a month with no response I reached out again, to be met with a nasty person. Was told I was difficult to deal with, and that a caterer must be desperate to do my wedding party. ALL BECAUSE I wanted a confirmation about price per person as well as wanted to know about the service charge. I'm still in shock with how unprofessional this guy is. Don't waste your time.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?