Conner Catering Reviews
Reviews
4.8 out of 5 rating
4.8 out of 5 rating
156 Reviews
97% recommend it
Awards
-
![Emily]()
Emily H. Sent on 09/20/2022Wonderful !!
I really can’t say enough about Conner Catering! The staff and food was amazing. They made everything so easy for us and really listened to what we wanted. Had a little mishap(things happen) and they handled it immediately and really listened to us. We did a family style meal and everyone loved it ! The manager of the wait staff was phenomenal! I believe his name was Ralph. And Donald, the owner and coordinator literally handled everything for us! -
![Haley]()
Haley C. Sent on 09/11/2022The Conner Team is a Dream!
The Conner Team was great! Don worked with us from the very beginning to capture the vibe we wanted for our wedding. Don was so easy to work with, and obviously knew what he was doing. He was able to talk us through all the little things you might not think about with planning, but also really listened to what we wanted and helped us make it all possible. The behind the scenes team was great with quick email responses and INCREDIBLE food!!!! I would recommend Conner Catering (and the Old Mill) to anyone! -
-
![Tina]()
Tina H. Sent on 05/04/2022Dream wedding!
When I was searching for venues for my wedding I came across The Old Mill, Rose Valley. My husband and I instantly fell in love with it and met with Conner Catering to start planning! Donald met with me multiple times to go over what we wanted for our wedding as far as food, setup, drinks, and timeline. They are very responsive, accommodating, and flexible. They handled everything perfectly after giving them my vision. The food was AMAZING! We loved how fun and unique the cocktail hour hors d'oeuvres were and they were so delicious! The desserts were also amazing and set up so nicely! Our guests raved about the food to us! I would highly recommend hiring Conner Catering to cater your wedding! Especially at The Old Mill, Rose Valley! -
![Ashley]()
Ashley M. Sent on 11/23/2021The food and service were impeccable. Everyone loved everything!!
Don and his team were professional and accommodating. There was more food than we could have eaten at 2 weddings!! And it was all more than fantastic!! We would highly recommend Conner Catering for any event!! -
![Clay]()
Clay H. Sent on 12/05/2021Conner Catering is amazing and very professional
From the very start, Donald and Conner Catering were very professional. The Old Mill provides a rustic, natural wedding space and Conner Catering was there for us every step of the way. We can’t thank them enough for all of the quick communication and answers when needed. Whenever we wanted to meet with Conner Catering, they made themselves readily available. Conner Catering knows their venue and this business inside and out and pays particular attention to all details. They were more than willing to work with us on our specific requests and needs to make the day great for ourselves, friends and family! The kitchen, serving staff, and bar tenders were all so kind to our guests and went out of their way to help us celebrate on our day. We are still hearing from friends and family about how beautiful the venue is, how amazing the food was and how kind and professional the staff were. The catering manager, Christine, was amazing as well and made sure everything was perfect. During the week of our wedding, the forecast called for rain on our wedding day. Donald was so responsive and helpful. He guided us through every step even when we had to change plans back and forth a few times to accommodate the weather. It truly was an amazing day and we couldn’t be happier that we chose the Old Mill for our wedding. -
![Marie and Rony]()
Marie Sent on 10/03/2021We loved the Conner Catering team!
The Conner Catering team did an amazing job with our August 2021 wedding at the Old Mill. First, the food was DELICIOUS. We still have family members talking about how delicious the food was at our wedding. Also, both my wife and I are vegetarians, and we really appreciate how accommodating they were to our needs and the dietary restrictions of our guests. Second, Don and his team were smooth to work with and we appreciated their directness and honesty as we planned our wedding. Third, the venue itself was absolutely stunning and everything we could have wished for. Sending our thanks to the Conner Catering team for all their hard work on our wedding day! Definitely recommend them for your catering and wedding needs! -
C. K. Sent on 08/27/2021
Absolutely Incredible at The Old Mill!
There are not enough words to describe how wonderful Connor Catering is. Don and his team went above and beyond to help us with our postponement (due to COVID) and wedding. Don and his team were extremely responsive in always meeting with us to discuss the changing guidelines with COVID. Don and his team created a wonderful array of food items for our wedding.Our guests could not stop raving about the food and presentation of the food. Don and his team truly were incredible and we had the wedding of our dreams at the Old Mill. If you are looking for a unique venue in which you can make your own, then this is the perfect wedding location for you! I would highly recommend this venue and caterer to anyone looking to host a wedding or special event! -
-
![Elyse]()
Elyse J. Sent on 06/28/2021The Perfect Day
Where can I even begin? Conner Catering was amazing from start to finish. Every single detail was exactly as we imagined it, and the food was spectacular. Each appetizer was delicious, and the food at dinner was spectacular. So many guests commented on how good everything was. Even the last table to be served shared that their food was still hot when it came out and that the staff checked in with them multiple times to make sure everything was good. Honestly, I am over the moon thrilled with Conner Catering! Words can’t do the experience justice! -
![Chastity]()
Chastity Sent on 12/01/2020The Best Wedding Dinner Ever
The food for the event was PHENOMENAL. Everything from the appetizers to the main course to the desserts were so delicious. Everyone could not stop complimenting the food. We were so happy with our choice. The wedding cake was gorgeous and actually tasted good! -
-
![Paige]()
Paige D. Sent on 11/12/2020Dream Wedding - COVID changes and all!
The Old Mill and the Conner Catering Team were a dream to work with. When we originally booked with them two years prior, we had anticipated a larger wedding with nearly 250 guest. As COVID hit, they did everything in their power and within safety to ensure we were still able to have our special day. Although we cut our guest list back, made multiple changes to ensure our guests were safe, the team at the Old Mill were very responsive, flexible and quick to make sure we could have the wedding we dreamed of. The day of events went beautifully and smoothly, and the food was amazing! Its a night I will never forget.
Leading up to the big day, we did have several meetings with Don, who walked us through all our options and costs to ensure our budget was met. I do wish they had an online payment option, just as we live farther away and I always worry mailing checks- but at the end of the day it was no issue and any worry I had was answered right away with reassure or confirmation of being received! We also were able to stock the bar ourselves, which I personally really liked as we had exactly what we wanted available.
I highly recommend the Old Mill to anyone looking for a wedding venue. The staff were some of the nicest people I have met during a wedding, and they put up with my very loud, enthusiastic family with grace and professionalism. Not to mention the venue itself is nothing short of stunning! Thank you again to the Old Mill and Conner Catering! -
-
Alicia F. Sent on 10/02/2020
The absolute best - & vegan friendly!
My husband and I got married this August (2020) at the Old Mill. I couldn't say enough how amazing our day was. The venue itself is absolutely gorgeous, and has a great alternate plan for inclement weather (the pavilion is GORGEOUS!). The food is just AMAZING -- I am vegan but my husband is not, so we had a mixture. Vegans and non vegans alike said all of the food was amazing! They even had vegan snacks waiting for me in the bridal suite. They definitely make their couples feel special!! The service staff was incredibly friendly and professional! They allow you to supply your own alcohol which helps you save some money too! We communicated mostly with Donald and Taylor. Donald is very detail-oriented and efficient - he made sure everything went smoothly and was great about talking through our options when we had to rework our original 130-guest wedding plan due to the pandemic. Taylor is super responsive and friendly -- I emailed her millions of questions and she was always so great and informative in her responses! Conner Catering put extensive care and effort into making our event safe amidst the pandemic. Our event was held completely outdoors aside from the restrooms (guests had to wear face coverings to go inside for the bathroom), masks and hand sanitizer were stationed throughout, and ceremony and reception seating was spaced at least 6 feet apart. We reduced our guest count to less than 50 people, and Conner was so flexible with all of our changes. I would not change a thing about our wedding experience, and we are so grateful to Conner Catering and the Old Mill for making our day so special! -
-
![Tim]()
Tim Sent on 10/06/2020Second time enjoying their hospitality
After attending my second wedding here, I finally asked the couple about the caterers. I thought they had shopped around forever trying to find the perfect company, but it turns out they come with the venue! The food was out of this world, and the whole night was orchestrated beautifully. I only grabbed a couple photos before I had to start eating stuff -- it was too good to waste time! Chocolate lobster tacos? Hell yeah! -
-
Bridget Sent on 11/01/2020
Beautiful venue and amazing staff
The Old Mill and Conner Catering did an incredible job making our wedding day so special and memorable. After 2 date changes in 2020, they worked so hard to help us have the wedding we always wanted- from extra tents and outdoor dinner, safety protocols, professionalism, and a number of meetings, we had the best day. The Old Mill is a beautiful space and we can't say enough good things about Conner Catering's team and staff. Recommend 10/10 ! -
-
Featured
![Magdalena]()
Magdalena Sent on 06/22/2020Amazing Experience
I cannot say enough good things about Conner Catering. Without a doubt, this was the best choice we made. During the entire process, Don and Taylor were amazing. When we first toured the Old Mill and met with Don, he was very helpful. My family has very little experience planning weddings, so he helped guide us. After we booked, Taylor and Don were great with details and giving us suggestions. Without their expertise, the wedding would not have gone as well as it did.
The day of the wedding, things got a little messed up because 95 was shut down-- delaying the wedding party 1.5 hours. Don was very flexible and made sure everything was okay to extend an hour.
The food was AMAZING. We received so many compliments about the food. During the process, we were worried about staying under budget for food, but still having a tasty meal. Don was very aware of our budget and made sure we got the best possible meal. Everything is very customizable, so you do not sacrifice quality at all.
Without a doubt, this was the best choice we made and are so grateful to Conner Catering! Amazing food and an amazing team! -
![Germaine]()
Germaine Sent on 08/28/2019What A Day!!
When I tell you that Donald and his team did everything they possibly could to make our wedding day perfect, I am not exaggerating! He patiently answered my questions (all 3,000 of them) during the whole process. He was very hands on with tons of helpful advice! He really knows his stuff and his suggestions helped to make our day amazing!!
The venue at the Old Mill is just beautiful!! Donald got new pieces for the center of our stationary hors'd' oeuvres, the floor was freshly painted, and the inside reception area came to life once the place settings were put in place!!
Since we made the centerpieces and all the decorations ourselves, Donald was very accommodating, allowing us to enter early and set up. It was so hot that day, that he even moved one bar inside to help our guests feel comfortable and beat the heat. His staff was on the ball and very kind, pleasant, and helpful to all of our guests.
In addition to the above, the review wouldn't be complete if I didn't mention the food. Oh my gosh!!! Mouthwatering deliciousness!!! We had filet and chicken oscar and our guests RAVED about how fantastic that food was!! The meat was so tender, the crab delicious, and the plates of our guests
empty! That really topped off the evening before the dancing began!
I cannot thank Donald and his team enough for helping to make our day everything we dreamed of and more! We waited a long time for this day to become a reality and I couldn't have picked a better venue or caterer to make that happen!
With much gratitude,
Joe and Germaine DePiano
8-17-19
-
-
![Alyssa]()
Alyssa Sent on 05/14/2019Everything we could have ever asked for!!
The food was delicious, their team was professional and so friendly and helpful the whole evening, without being in the way!! I would recommend them to anyone!! -
![Shellycherea]()
Michelle Sent on 01/05/2019Excellent Service!
Overall, we were pleased with Don and his team as they helped me put on my dream wedding at the stunning Old Mill in Rose Valley. Taylor was also extremely responsive throughout my year of planning, which I genuinely appreciated.
On the day, our guests enjoyed everything: the food, service and venue. Originally we planned to have our ceremony outside but the weather was poor so Don help us move everything to the Pavilion which worked out even better. And if there was ever a problem, a solution was quickly proposed by Don. Thank you so much for your excellent service and sense of humor.
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message