12 User photos
Josh · Married on 10/03/2014
The cheesecakes were delicious. We opted to do several retail cheesecake and sampler cheesecakes instead of an actual wedding cake. It allowed people flexibility to choose the piece of cake they would like.Sent on 10/20/2014
Our cake was the four-piece Peanut butter cup cheesecake and it looked and tasted great. We even had a few cakes without crust to accommodate those who couldn't eat the gluten.
If you are looking for a great value, look no further. Cheesy Eddie's is a great alternative to pricey traditional cakes.
Nuwangi · Married on 08/30/2014
My husband and I had a wonderful experience working with Cheesy Eddie's not only was their cake phenomenal but their service was wonderful! They were very flexible in terms of what we wanted for our design, we wanted something simple and elegant and they definitely provided that for us. We also had a dessert table that they created a beautiful spread for. All our guests shared how delectable everything was. Their service was professional and personal. We would definitely recommend it to anyone!!Sent on 09/05/2014
Nam · Married on 08/30/2014
Cheesy Eddie's is one of the best bakeries in Rochester NY.Sent on 09/07/2014
All of their cake flavors are delicious and can accommodate any cake size (those who don't typically like carrot cake, will be able to enjoy their carrot cake!). Their other specialty is cheesecake, which is also glorious.
Aside from having great cakes and service, they also have affordable secondary options for those who don't want to spend a ton of money on their wedding cake.
We will continue to purchase cakes from them purely to enjoy (not just for an event), and we would completely recommend this bakery to anyone who wants good cake.
Liz · Married on 10/13/2013
My now husband, and I were very undecided on our cake for the longest time. When we talked with Cheesy Eddie's they helped us pick the most perfect cake for our October wedding. Everyone at the reception was impressed and loved the cake. The cheesecake was gone in a flash! We only brought home a tiny portion of our wedding cake, topper not included, so I know people went back for seconds :-). The frosting to say the least is to die for and the chocolate cake, the one I really liked, is amazing. My husband would say the carrot cake is the best..so at least that is all we fought over ;-)Sent on 10/30/2013
User3791912 · 2+ years ago
Awesome Cake!! My wedding cake was gorgeous looking and was delicious! Thank you!Sent on 01/07/2014
Christine · Married on 09/06/2011
Miriam did an amazing job helping with the planning process. The designers were ambitious and willing to try anything! I was always recognized by the staff, which was amazing feeling for this out of town bride! The entire staff was outstanding! Oh...and the cake was out of this world too!!!!Sent on 10/11/2011
Kelly · Married on 09/02/2011
We loved the Carrot Cake they made for us. Simple and beautiful and most importantly, DELICIOUS. We didn't even wait a year to eat the top tier. We had it after the honeymoon and simply buy a new cake for ourselves each year! They were great to work with and I would recommend them to everyone to use. So delicious, can't say it enough.Sent on 08/12/2015
Courtney · Married on 07/08/2011
I cannot say enough about how happy we were about our cake. Colleen and her staff did a wonderful job!Sent on 08/02/2011
claire · Married on 11/04/2010
Excellent service, Colleen could not have been more helpful. The cake(and the Jillain's) were out of this world good - I wish I lived close by so i could visit all the time! Really delicious :)Sent on 01/09/2012
Leah · Married on 09/18/2010
We absolutely loved our wedding cheesecakes by Cheesy Eddie's!! By far the most delicious cheesecake we've ever had - and cheesecake is our favorite! Also, the custom stand provides a unique display for the cheesecakes, which we left unfrosted to show off the yummy crust! It'll be the most memorable wedding cake you and your guests have ever experienced - and by far the most delicious! There was not a single piece left - my husband and I even had the last tier delivered to our room that night - we couldn't resist having more (we plan to order another one for our one year anniversary)!Sent on 02/18/2011
Nicole · Married on 09/05/2010
Cheesy Eddie's was wonderful to work with, and Colleen made the process so easy. We were looking for something different for our wedding cake, and the cheesecake display from Cheesy Eddie's was a perfect fit. They have so many different flavors (not to mention other types of dessert) that it's almost impossible to choose. We ended up with three flavors, and it's a good thing we ordered enough for twenty extra people because every piece was eaten by the end of the night!Sent on 09/22/2010
Katharine · Married on 08/14/2010
Everyone LOVED the cheesecake at our wedding. We had white chocolate raspberry swirl with raspberry sauce and it was a hit!Sent on 08/24/2010
The owners are so great!! Everyone in the bakery was so helpful every time I called or needed to stop by for something.
Deidre · Married on 02/06/2009
Cheesy Eddie's was fantastic! I was contacted almost immediately after submitting an inquiry. The saleswoman was very polite and friendly. She was also very patient with me and helpful in getting me the most for my money. The cakes were beyond delicious! I never liked carrot cake until I had their carrot cake! I liked it so much that we got a combination of cheesecakes (which are also amazing) and carrot cake instead of just cheesecake as we originally planned. They are also very willing to make it work. They let us borrow their one of a kind cake stand from Rochester to Syracuse FREE OF CHARGE! They were awesome and I very highly recommend them.Sent on 07/07/2009
Oreshya · Married on 08/16/2008
My husband and I love variety so we had a difficult time choosing just one cake for our wedding. That's why we chose Cheesy Eddie's, at their bakery we chose 3 different cakes for our wedding. We chose their classic cheesecake, a carrot cake and their very chocolate cake. They decorated them just as we liked, they delivered them even before go to to the venue...just so we would be at ease. Then they provided a display stand so that all 3 of the cakes could be seen and so they guests could choose which cake they would like to eat. Colleen Baker is VERY easy to work with, she has a great personality, she was wonderful at the tasting and she was always flexible. We loved our cake and so did our guests!Sent on 02/17/2009
Kathleen · Married on 12/06/2014
When we met with Cheesy Eddie's, I wasn't expecting to be able to afford their wedding cake. I was pleasantly surprised to find that we could. We did a three tier display cake and 6 kitchen cakes. We were able to do different flavors for every cake. We did two types of cake and the rest were different flavors of cheesecake. It was divine. They also decorated my cake exactly like the picture I gave them. I expect delivery went well since it was in place at our reception venue when we arrived.Sent on 12/16/2014
If you are planning a December wedding like we did, get your cake order in ASAP. They only take one wedding order in December.