Carolina Sugar Fairy Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Featured
![Lauren]()
Lauren Sent on 07/14/2021Beautiful & Delicious Wedding Cake!
Working with Jen was a breeze! From scheduling our tasting a year before our wedding, to finalizing our details, & to her setting everything up at our venue- it was all perfect! Our wedding cake and cupcakes were beautiful and delicious, my husband and I could not stop eating our cake after we cut it. I highly recommend having Jen be your cake vendor :) -
-
![Justine]()
Justine Sent on 05/19/2025the most gorgeous cake I've ever seen!
Exceeded all of my expectations! The cake was delicious and equally as beautiful. -
-
![Kristin]()
Kristin Sent on 04/15/2025Jen is so sweet!
Jen was super helpful in helping me decide on a large cake or small bite and cupcakes. We went with a 2 tier, 120 of her cookie bars, and 14 dozen mini cupcakes. We didn’t cut the top of the cake and we had maybe 30 cupcakes left. Everything was delicious and beautiful! -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 01/18/2025Amazing Wedding Cake!
Jen was a pleasure to work with! She made an amazing cake (and cookies!) for our wedding. It was delicious! We appreciated that she listened to what we wanted, but also offered her professional experience so that we had the best cake. We would recommend Carolina Sugary Fairy and would absolutely hire her again! -
-
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 05/30/2024Wedding 4/27/24
The cake I asked for was absolutely stunning and everything I imagined. Jennifer was so pleasant to work with and very talented! She even made tiny desserts along with the cake. All of it was delicious! -
-
![Erica]()
Erica Sent on 05/16/2024Too GOOD to be true!
Make this your choice! You won’t regret it!
We met with Jen the first time, and she had a box of different flavor cupcakes for us to try……. It ended up being a box of crumbs by the time we left!
Jen is amazing and will work with you no matter what you need. We had 4 different flavor cupcakes with 4 different flavor icing’s, plus our wedding cake! And she knocked them all out of the park!
Flavor and consistency of the cakes and icing was second to none! And we gave Jen our idea for our wedding cake design, and she did a fantastic job, it was gorgeous!
We highly recommend you use Jen for your wedding! -
-
![Tyreshia]()
Tyreshia Sent on 05/22/2023My wedding
Our wedding cake was red velvet and it was amazing!!! -
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 05/08/2023Beautiful and delicious wedding cake and cupcakes!!
I highly recommend Carolina Sugar Fairy as my wedding cakes and cupcakes were beautiful and tasted amazing!! When I saw Jen (the owners) work on Instagram, I knew I had to book her right away! Not only are her desserts works of art, but Jen is extremely professional and so much fun to work with. Our wedding cake (red velvet) and cupcakes (key lime, lemon blueberry, tipsy fairy, vanilla and red velvet) were delicious and we loved having the different flavors for both!! (Tipsy fairy is mocha and bourbon!). I highly recommend Carolina Sugar Fairy for amazing wedding desserts - thank you Jen for making the best wedding desserts!! -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 07/13/2022Wonderful cupcakes!
Jen made amazing cupcakes for our wedding; our guests loved them. She was also extremely easy to work with, and I cannot recommend her highly enough! -
![Renae]()
Renae Sent on 07/04/2022Absolutely outstanding!!!
Jen is amazing. She offers a tasting and the cakes and bite size options were great. We went with lemon blueberry and vanilla with chocolate chip filling. Mini cheesecakes and Boston cream bites. Amazing I was able to eat some of each after all food I had. Highly recommend her for your wedding or just simply needing a cake or desserts. I’m from out of town so I’m lucky to have found her on here. Even though I had a beach wedding I chose something simple and it was perfect. -
-
![Lucas]()
Lucas Sent on 06/11/2022Our dream wedding
We were lucky to be able to book Carolina Sugar fairy, they were exceptional. Jen was very easy to work with. She made it very easy with the tasting, her cakes and frostings were all fresh and very tasty. She was very artistic with our cake and helped us with the vision of how our cake would look like. Everyone was talking about the carrot cake and the cupcakes, they were a total hit. -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 12/14/2021Non-stop with the compliments!
EVERYONE kept going on about how great the cupcakes and cake were! The design and detail went perfect with our beach theme. Super friendly, great service and always answered any questions/concerns in a timely manner. Only disappointment was that we didn’t order enough cake! We never got to enjoy a slice of our own cake! (Forgot to save the top.) Definitely recommended and will be placing an order for our one year anniversary in June! -
-
![William]()
William Sent on 10/13/2021Delicious!
We were beyond pleased with Jen’s cakes and cupcakes. We had a white cake with peanut butter frosting. We also went with cupcakes (red velvet, strawberries and cream, and chocolate with salted caramel frosting). All were delicious… moist and flavorful without being overly sweet. Jen was also an absolute pleasure to deal with. -
-
![Allison]()
Allison Sent on 09/27/2021Exactly what we wanted
Our cake was beautiful and delicious! Jen was super nice and extremely helpful even through the busiest part of wedding season! -
![Elizabeth]()
Elizabeth Sent on 09/15/2021Loved Our Cake!
Jen was so sweet throughout the process! I love that she lets you try the different combinations of icing and cake. She set everything up perfectly and the cake was divineeee. My new favorite cake is Tipsy Fairy with peanut butter icing- to die for (pumpkin spice with cream cheese icing is a close second). The cake looked exactly as I had hoped and the cupcakes were a big success! Jen was super flexible with the details. Thank you so much, Carolina Sugar Fairy! -
-
![Alexa]()
Alexa Sent on 05/28/2021So amazing, definitely recommend!
Planning an out of state wedding can be hard. Planning an out of state wedding during COVID can be even harder! Luckily I had great vendors who were flexible and easy to work with and Jenn was one of them! After having to postpone our wedding, we decided to elope and plan it within a month and Jenn made it stress-free for our cake! We got the vanilla cake with vanilla icing and raspberry curd and it was so delicious! Hands down, best cake we have ever had! And it was simple yet elegant and beautiful just like we had wanted.
I would definitely recommend Carolina Sugar Fairy to anyone! -
-
![Jess]()
Jess Sent on 05/27/2021Beautiful cake display!
Carolina Sugar Fairy was AMAZING at helping us design our perfect cake display! We didn't want a traditional cake and opted for cupcakes, mini cupcakes and cake pops and they were an absolute hit!! They were so accommodating at letting us choose multiple flavors and designing our display! They also helped us through our tasting during COVID and allowed us to try as many flavors as possible to choose the best combination. At the end of the night, there were no desserts left. Would highly recommend! -
-
![Jacob]()
Jacob Sent on 03/16/2021Top notch quality and service
When deciding who to hire, during covid mind you, she met us with a prepared box of different flavors of cake. It came with a sheet of paper explaining the flavors as well. They were all delicious and we had a hard time deciding which flavors. We settled on a cupcake display with a small round cake on top. Our cupcake flavors were lemon raspberry, carrot cake, and chocolate with peanut butter creme icing. Our wedding was Buckeye themed as I am an alumnus of Ohio State so the cake was made with chocolate and peanut butter creme as well and she decorated it with candy buckeyes and red icing that looked like it was dripping off the top of the cake. It was absolutely perfect!!! It looked just like we imagined and everything tasted better than we imagined. The cupcakes were moist and full of flavor and the icing was light, fluffy and delicious. Absolutely recommend Carolina Sugar Fairy! Thank you so much! -
![Madeleine]()
Madeleine Sent on 11/22/2020Delicious and Delectable
Carolina Sugar Fairy is so sweetly perfect! Our cake was exactly what we wanted, and Jen made dessert tasting and creating our menu so fun. She was flexible, kind, and on top of her came. If you want a cake you'll dream about after, go with Carolina Sugar Fairy! -
-
![Paige]()
Paige Sent on 11/01/2020Just As Delicious As It Was Pretty
Jen from Carolina Sugar Fairy is nothing but phenomenal. Not only are her many options of cake flavors and fillings delicious but she is willing to create whatever you wish. For our big day we selected cupcakes which were the perfect option for all our guests and super affordable. We wanted different flavors so everyone could pick their favorite but the pumpkin spice was the biggest hit and was perfect for the time of year. We also had a small one tier cake for cutting which was just as delicious. We even added a grooms cake for a surprise and it could not have turned out any better! 10/10 recommend to anyone getting married on the Eastern Shore!!! -
-
![Bethany]()
Bethany Sent on 10/29/2020Perfect cake!
Jen was great to work with! I sent her picture and pictures on what I wanted my cake to look exaclty like and it was perfect. Exactly what I picture and the taste omg, so many flavors. Basically anything you would ever want and oh so yummmm. Thank you Jen. -
-
![Eddie]()
Eddie Sent on 10/29/2019A Beautiful and Delicious Cake!
From the time we met Jen, we knew we had picked the right person to make our wedding cake...and her tasting samples solidified our decision. She made us a beautiful 3 tier white cake with a butter cream frosting that looked and tasted incredible! The bottom layer was covered with soft pink roses made from the same buttercream, while textured lines circled the top 2 layers. We also had a portion of key lime cake, for variety. All beautifully accented with a few flowers from our floral director at Baywood Greens Clubhouse. Exactly what we wanted! We are happy to say that we ate the whole thing!
Thank you Carolina Sugar Fairy!
Gratefully,
Eddie & Angi
9/20/2019 -
![Elisha]()
Elisha Sent on 09/05/2019Best Cake Ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I really only wanted a wedding cake to take pictures and for my husband and daughter. So whatever my husband wanted I was going to roll with but after tasting her cake I was excited to eat cake. My guest were literally ready to fight each other for the cake lol. I can't wait to get cake from her for our anniversary -
![Danielle]()
Danielle Sent on 08/31/2019Delicious & Beautiful!
I would highly recommend Carolina Sugar Fairy for any event! Jen did such an amazing job designing my cake. The best part was, she was excited about it! She truly understood what I wanted & made it a reality. Everyone could not stop talking about how amazing our cake was. Wish I had a better picture. Thank you Jen! -
-
![Heather]()
Heather Sent on 06/22/2019Beautiful cake!
Jen was great to work with for our wedding cake! It was really reassuring that she helped us make the right decisions for the amount of cake and type of cake to suit our needs, rather than recommending we spend more unneeded money! The whole experience was easy and enjoyable. She even met up with us a second time to make sure we could try all the flavors we were interested in! On our wedding day, our cake was beautiful and exactly as we discussed! We were very happy with everything and how it turned out, so thank you so much to Jen for all her hard work!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?