Brooklyn Girl Bakery Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
![WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2024 Winner]()
5.0 out of 5 rating
125 Reviews
99% recommend it
Awards
-
![Natasha]()
Natasha H. Sent on 07/06/2024Highly recommend Brooklyn Girl Bakery!
Peri, the owner of Brooklyn Girl Bakery, is a true professional! We had the amazing opportunity to work with Peri through our caterer, Williamson, who had a special package through our venue (Brandywine Manor House). From the very first meeting with Peri, she took my vision and made it a reality. I wanted a cake with specific details - white marbling, textured tiers and gold accents. Peri immediately sent me different pictures with options to choose from and she nailed it!! As for the cake flavors - these were just WOW! We were able to select 4 different flavors for each tier (banana cake with salted caramel cream, peanut butter cake with Nutella cream, strawberry cake with cream cheese, and raspberry cake with lemon). We also received a 1-year anniversary cake to take home with us and I asked Peri to surprise us with the flavor - Can’t wait to dig back into her amazing cake on our first anniversary. I highly recommend Brooklyn Girl Bakery for your wedding cake! -
-
![Kari]()
Kari V. Sent on 05/14/2024Excellent!
Peri was so easy and awesome to work with. She gave her expertise suggestions and in the end it was perfect! -
![Julia]()
Julia L. Sent on 11/07/2023Best wedding cake ever!
Our venue provided the cake through Peri and we couldn’t have been happier! We got three different flavor combos for our three tier cake and all three were fantastic! Peri was awesome to work with and made the process so easy! -
![Fenrir]()
Fenrir Sent on 10/30/2023Amazing night
Peri did such an amazing job!! she was so responsive when emailing or messaging, she was incredibly easy to speak to and captured our cake image exactly how we wanted it for our wedding. A Viking/fantasy wedding can be hard to find for and Peri knocked it out of the park with it! her Flavors were to die for and someone I will for sure keep in mind for future events -
Julie B. Sent on 10/31/2023
Highly recommend
I highly recommend Brooklyn girl bakery! Peri was excellent to work with. She was an excellent communicator and responded in a timely manner. She was honest and very helpful in helping me get the cake I wanted. She offers a variety of cake flavors and icings that were absolutely delicious. The chocolate cake with the raspberry filling was a hit with my wedding guests!! -
-
![Becky]()
Becky Sent on 10/01/2023LOVED Peri and our almond funfetti wedding cake
We absolutely LOVED working with Peri at Brooklyn Girl Bakery! Our tasting and cake were one of the highlights of the wedding planning process and we cannot recommend her enough. Peri was kind enough to add an almond flavor to her set of six tasting cakes, and it blew us away. She also accommodated the request for almond funfetti, which was a fun, personal twist that helped set our cake apart. The decorations were simple and gorgeous, and Peri was fantastic with helping us design the perfect cake for our day. We were lucky to take home some leftovers from the venue and spent the rest of the weekend eating tons of cake, and loved every bite! -
-
![Julie]()
Julie S. Sent on 04/18/2023Beautiful and Delicious Bridal Shower Cake
Peri designed a fabulous Alice in Wonderland Themed Cake for my daughter's bridal shower. It was both delicious and beautiful! I would highly recommend Peri and will be using her again in the future! Julie Shaffer -
-
Shannon D. Sent on 05/18/2023
Just amazing!
Peri did an amazing job with our wedding cake! She was very quick to respond to all of my questions and helped me finalize my design. I highly recommend her to everyone!Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you, Shannon! You were a pleasure to work with and I'm so glad you loved the cake as much as I did! Congratulations! -
-
Jill Sent on 04/05/2023
Absolutely perfect experience and cake!
Everything was perfect! Peri was great to work with and the cakes are delicious! We had a 4 tier cake for our St. Patrick’s Day wedding and the cake was even better than what we had imagined! -
-
Gina F. Sent on 11/21/2022
Gina(bride)
Peri was absolutely fantastic from the beginning. She was included in our venue package. She provide various flavors to try and the samples were very flavorful and moist. As most ideas come from Pinterest We provided Peri with an inspiration picture and made our vision come to life. All three tiers were made Of different flavors and cake and tasting them were amazing. It was definitely a highlight of our wedding and couldn’t of been any happier!Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you, Gina! I’m so glad you loved it and I am grateful to have been part of your special day. Best of luck! -
-
![Tara]()
Tara B. Sent on 12/15/2022Peri makes delicious, beautiful cakes
Peri created our dream wedding cake. She took our vision and ran with it, graciously drawing a sketch when we had trouble visualizing it, and accepting input . She was sensible and helped us keep additional cost down by only making 1 tier have fondant and having suggestions for the other tiers. The cake flavors and icings were so tasty and we cannot wait to get another cake from her!Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you, Tara! It was so much fun creating your cake and I'm so glad you loved it! Wishing you both all the happiness in the world! -
Jessica Sent on 10/07/2022
Peri and her cakes are absolutely amazing!
We had the best experience with Peri at Brooklyn Girl Bakery! She was very professional, responsive, and so easy to work with! She took the time to respond to countless emails regarding our many tasting options as well as our final choices! She absolutely killed it when it came to bringing our vision to life when it came to the design of the cake. Everyone raved about the flavors! You will not regret choosing Peri for your big day!Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you so much, Jessica! I'm so glad you and your guests enjoyed the cake. It was one of my favorited to make! Congratulations! -
-
![Robin]()
Robin B. Sent on 04/23/2023Wedding cake
We were super happy with our cake only wish we would have gotten to enjoy it more. Thank youBrooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you, Robin! I'm so glad you were happy with your cake. I hope the whole day was everything you hoped it would be! -
![COLLEEN]()
Colleen B. Sent on 06/22/2022Stop looking for a baker(y)- you found the best- brookly girl bakery
NOT a run of the mill bakery!! We used Brooklyn Girl Bakery for my daughter's wedding. In addition to a cake we got cookies and cupcakes - THERE WAS NOT A CRUMB LEFT! The presentation was exquisite, the flavor EXCEEDED exquisite! Peri is a pleasure to work with - so flexible, so accommodating, so reasonable! HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend Brooklyn Girl Bakery!Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you so much, Colleen! I was honored to be part of such a special day. Congratulations to you and your family! -
Antonella H. Sent on 06/13/2022
Amazing and delicious
Peri at Brooklyn Girl Bakery was absolutely fabulous! She totally listened to everything we wanted and made it happen! The cake tasted delicious and we had everyone asking who made it!! Her design was spot on and when we saw the cake we were so excited at how perfect it looked compared to what we envisioned! Thank you so much!! 10/10Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you, Antonella! I'm so glad you and your guests loved the cake! You were a pleasure to work with and I wish you all the best in the future! -
-
![Cody]()
Cody O. Sent on 06/26/2022Pleasant Interactions and Perfect Cake
Peri was wonderful to work with. The tasting process was so much fun and so easy to set up. After a few virtual consultations, we were all set. Everything was so easy with Peri, and her clear and consistent communication made us feel great about hiring her. The cake was beautiful, and she was able to work with our florist to incorporate flowers into the design. More than that, the cake was delicious. People are still talking about how much they loved the lemon cake with raspberry jam. If you have the chance to work with Peri, we definitely think you should.Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Thank you so much for your kind review! I'm so glad you and your guests enjoyed the cake. It was a pleasure working with you and Rachel! Best of luck in the future! -
![Ryan]()
Ryan L. Sent on 05/19/2022Easiest and Tastiest Decision
Peri, like her cakes, is equal parts sweet and delightful. Our venue has a contract with two different bakeries and we had the luxury of trying both. While both bakeries had delicious cakes, Brooklyn Girl could not be beat. Not only were her cakes, frosting, and fillings delicious, but her enthusiasm for good service has no match. She let us do two tastings so we could try as many flavors as possible and even let us sample her fondant (which is remarkably delicious). She has such stellar creative ability and one look at her instagram makes that most evident. She took our ideas and created a true masterpiece. Having worked with the venue many times in the past, she was able to make us a cake that not only fit our style but meshed immaculately with the style of our unconventional venue. The final product looked amazing, and tasted even better. We went with three different flavors for our three-tier cake: chocolate with pastry cream filling, lemon with raspberry jam, and banana with cinnamon cream cheese filling. Our guests raved about the cakes and we were fortunate enough to be have quite a bit to bring back home with us. Peri did such an amazing job and she was an absolute pleasure to work with, her performance on our wedding day clearly makes her victory on Netflix's Sugar Rush well-deserved.Brooklyn Girl Bakery's reply:
Ryan- Thank you so much for such a kind review! I'm thrilled you loved the cake and am so grateful you took the time so write such thoughtful words. If you ever need anything in the future, please let me know. Best of luck to you and Will! -
-
Megan M. Sent on 02/02/2022
Amazing Cakes and Cupcakes!
Peri did such an amazing job! We used her for our wedding in October, and she absolutely killed it! She's very professional and detail oriented.
All her cakes look and taste absolutely amazing! We had a small two tier cake and a bunch of halloween cupcakes, and she made our vision exactly what
we hoped for. She's amazing, and I would 10/10 recomend her for any event!
-
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message