Bakers Cottage Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Featured
![Madeline]()
Madeline Sent on 05/23/2023Changed my thoughts and expectations of cake!
Baker's Cottage will make you rethink what you think about cakes! Originally, I didn't want a cake because it is no where near my favorite dessert. My mom insisted and so we went with Baker's cottage because of their excellent reputation in the industry. At our tasting I was blow away with all the different options and selections. I can say I LOVE their cake, and no other cake will compare. We also got many other desserts that were amazing too. We enjoyed some left overs at the end of the night in our hotel room, it was a great end to a great day :) -
-
![J. S.]()
Jannell Sent on 11/17/2022Wonderful Experience
Eloise made sure our overall experience was stress-free and easy to handle. All questions, and communication were quickly addressed. She and the team made sure everything was taken care of. My cake was designed exactly how I envisioned it to be. Our cake was also super delicious. Appreciate everything to make my day so special. -
![Monique]()
Monique Sent on 08/11/2022Best Cake Ever!!
The design of my cake still blows my mind, they sketch out your dream cake and the results will blow your mind! The sketch does not and will not do justice for the amazing job these lovely people do and all the hard work they put into it! Thank y’all again so much! -
-
![Annalisa]()
Annalisa Sent on 04/14/2022Stunning Work of Art
All of Bakers Cottages cakes are works of art. My cake was so stunning and delicious. I was seriously so upset when I finished the last of my leftovers! I had a vague idea of what we wanted as far as a design, and they were able to perfectly combine my ideas to create a BEAUTIFULLY crafted cake. There was a tiny scare about a month before the wedding when I realized I mistyped the date of my wedding, but the team quickly adapted and assured me that there would be no issue and my cake would be there on my wedding day. The cake was so delicious and they offered so many options it was hard to choose. I’m so happy they gave us an anniversary cake for us to enjoy in a year!! Their service and professionalism is unmatched! -
-
![Cathlene]()
Cathlene Sent on 04/11/2022Best Cake I’ve Ever Tasted
Best experience ever. Not only beautiful but tastes amazing as well -
-
Victoria Sent on 01/23/2022
Absolutely Devine
From the initial messages, cake tasting and all the way to the actual wedding date; I cannot begin to describe how amazing this team has been and how absolutely incredible their creations are. My fiancé who personally does not like cake, eat every single piece of cake and icing in fillings that were on our trees to try during our cake tasting. Their creations are absolutely divine. Any And all the cake that was left over from her wedding day has already been eaten and we just got married last week!
I will forever recommend these incredible cakes and this wonder company! -
-
![Michael]()
Michael Sent on 11/22/2021Awesome team to work with!
Michelle and her team were a pleasure to work with and were a great help to making our wedding day unforgettable. They offer a range of cakes for any budget and are very talented. I would definitely recommend working with them if you're looking for a baker in Orlando. -
![Marissa]()
Marissa Sent on 11/19/2021Delicious Cakes, Beautiful Designs, Great People!
Michelle and her team are absolutely fantastic to work with! She provided a really in-depth tasting, and really listened to what we had to say, and even created a new combination based on my fiancé's favorite flavors! Michelle was super flexible and allowed us to choose a different flavor combination for each tier of our cake. She was so down to earth and easy to work with. The final design was so beautiful, and the cakes were delicious! We are so so happy that we went with Bakers Cottage for our wedding cake. Thank you ladies! -
![Ruth]()
Ruth Sent on 09/15/2021Wedding Cake of our dreams
Bakers Cottage Cakes definitely hit the ball out of the park with our 4-Tiered wedding cake! The cake not only tasted really good but aesthetically was better than we planned or dreamed of. It was the perfect design and the creativity was right on! Our guests are still raving on how good the flavors were! We discovered this vendor through our wedding venue and so glad we booked them! We would highly recommend Michelle for any couple who wants a wedding cake they will never forget about! -
![Olivia]()
Olivia Sent on 03/18/2021Beautiful Cake
Our cake was perfect! Amazing taste and a beautiful look! It was so yummy, we ended up choosing two flavors for our guests to enjoy and everyone loved it. We especially loved the little cake they gifted us to enjoy on our honeymoon, thank you! -
-
![Brianna]()
Brianna Sent on 12/31/2019The most BEAUTIFUL cake I have ever seen!!!
My husband and I went to 6+ tastings, wedding shows/everything to see what baker we would use for our wedding. Michelle is so warm and personable and does hands down the most beautiful cakes in Orlando!!! Our wedding cake was absolutely STUNNING and tasted AMAZING!!! She went above and beyond what we expected! I am so grateful for her being one of the few bakers in Orlando to be able to accommodate a dairy allergy with such success! She is a true artist and puts passion into every cake!!! We already can’t wait to get into our anniversary cake next year! -
![Ilene]()
Ilene Sent on 08/25/2019Perfect alternative to cake
We’re one of those seemingly rare people who don’t love cake, so we had Baker’s Cottage make us a pie and cookie bar instead! Her cakes may be gorgeous, but her mini pies and cookies were not to be missed!! We ordered extra and we still didn’t have any leftovers. No matter what type of dessert you’re looking for, I’d definitely recommend Baker’s Cottage!! -
-
![Chelsea]()
Chelsea Sent on 05/19/2019Baked to Perfection!
My mother always says that cake is the most important part of a wedding, and going with Michelle from Baker’s Cottage Cakes ensured that our cake was more than memorable. From our first meeting with Michelle, my now-husband and I knew she was the perfect vendor to bring our vision to life. We had a rather unique and different theme, and finding vendors who truly understood that theme was a bit challenging. Michelle knew exactly what style we were going for and executed that style beautifully. It was as though she could read my mind on exactly what I was hoping for, and brought that dream to life. I knew we were kindred spirits during our first meeting Michelle, as she presented the flavor samples on vintage china plates with real silverware. While this detail may seem small, it meant a lot to me, as our wedding had many vintage-inspired elements.
Our cake truly stood out during our reception and our guests couldn’t stop talking about how beautiful it was. Aside from being visually stunning, our cake was also delicious! We opted for a three-tier cake, with Berry Delicious, Vanilla Coffee with Kahlua and Caramel with Nutella flavors. All three were absolutely out of this world, and we had trouble narrowing the flavors Michelle presented to us in our initial meeting down to these three! We would recommend Michelle to anyone looking for their wedding cake!
-
-
![Victoria]()
Victoria Sent on 04/28/2019We got so many compliments on our Stained Glass Cake!
We are absolutely in love with our cake! Not only was she able to pull off an incredible gluten free tier, but exceeded our expectations for our dream Stained Glass Cake!! Our venue had big stained glass windows so we had our heart set on a cake to play off of the window designed. She was up for the challenge and did an incredible job. In fact, she did such a fantastic job that we had numerous people tell us they didn't even realize the third tier was cake! It looks like an antique cake stand! Flavors were incredible! Chocolate chip cookie dough?? I've never had a wedding cake like that!! Michelle was professional, artistic and blew us away with her creation! -
-
![Kirsten]()
Kirsten Sent on 03/08/2019Delicious desserts that are pretty to look at!
My husband and I decided to go the non-traditional route and instead of cake, we had cupcakes and mini-pies as our wedding desserts. We ordered an extra 2 dozen of each and neither my husband nor I got any dessert! They were all gone!! Everyone LOVED the desserts! Also, my husband's mother ended up in the hospital the week before our wedding and was unable to attend the wedding. Michelle baked her an extra mini pie so that she could enjoy! It was so sweet and thoughtful! Not only are their desserts gorgeous to look at and delicious to eat, Bakers Cottage Cakes really care about their customers! We highly recommend them for ANY dessert occasions! -
![Heather]()
Heather Sent on 01/13/2019Cake was wonderful
Michelle was great to work with! The look was everything we ever wanted. Simple yet Elegant. The flavors were superb! We would 100% recommend her to others! -
![Melissa]()
Melissa Sent on 12/03/2018A must have vendor
Best vendor EVER. Gorgeous and delicious. Exceeded all of my expectations! -
![Dennis]()
Dennis Sent on 03/14/2018Michelle was wonderful and very patient during our planning stages. She designed a perfect cake for our wedding and it looked just beautiful on display. I was just a bit surprised the cake was missing some very important "bling" that we wanted on the cake, however this was due to my cutting the cake budget during the last month. Also I was surprised with the icing on the cake, I believe that I chose the wrong kind. This was not the fault of Michelle's but of mine. A misunderstanding on my part. In the future I know that this type of fondant icing is necessary on many cakes depending on the design which is much different than a butter cream icing as I am accustomed to. There were wonderful flavors to choose from, and the final finished product was just what we had expected. However, we did have to cut our budget for the cake and perhaps she had to cut some corners to meet our budget needs which I wish now that I did not do. My recommendation to others is to be sure not to cut the cake budget if this is very important to you. Overall, we were very pleased with the beauty and design of our cake as it sparkled on the stand and looked just like the elegant castle cake we had designed. I hope others see our cake pictures and have the same "wow" that our guests did as they saw the cake for the first time.
Michelle is very nice to work with and is very professional. She did a beautiful job with the budget I gave her to work with. Thank you Michelle for giving us the "wow" we needed on our wedding night. -
Kayley Sent on 11/24/2017Michelle is an absolute artist! She was so pleasant at our first meeting and her cakes are AH-MAZING! We had 3 different flavors on different tiers and they were all delicious. She even custom made a keepsake cake topper based on our theme, and she decorated it beautifully with buttercream icing. Definitely going back to her for my anniversary cake and will be using her for many more events!
-
-
Dana Sent on 10/26/2017Michelle worked closely with us from the very beginning to make the most delightfully delicious cakes for our wedding! She went out of her way to accommodate us for our tasting (as we were coming to the area from out of town and had limited time) and then helped us bring our vision of multiple cakes of different sizes and flavors into reality. She also created a special gluten free cake and vegan cake for a few of our guests. The outcome was truly out-of-this-world beautiful and so delicious - flavorful and complex, not too sugary (but definitely sweet and dessert-worthy!) They continue to be a highlight our friends and family rave about when reminiscing about our fabulous wedding weekend!
-
-
![Andrea]()
Andrea Sent on 01/25/2019Delicious cakes and beautiful design
It was love at first bite when we met Michelle for a tasting of her incredible cakes. Her flavors are imaginative and her buttercream is the best I have ever tasted. We genuinely had a hard time deciding on only 2 flavors for our cake, and I have one regret about having a small (micro) wedding, it's that we couldn't have every cake flavor Michelle offers. Unfortunately, the cake arrived at the venue before we did with the cake flowers, but our venue (a restaurant) was able to use the flowers we provided to put the finishing touches on and it turned out perfectly. I wish we could get married every week to have this cake over and over and over again and we're very much looking forward to our first anniversary so we can enjoy the beautiful complimentary anniversary cake Michelle included. On a personal side note, we enjoyed getting to know Michelle so much and my now husband brought up our conversation for months after our meeting. We can't wait to have another reason for a delicious cake so we can have more lemon poppyseed with blueberry cream cheese buttercream (drool). My husband's caramel cake with nutella filling was also very popular with our guests. Thank you again Michelle! -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?