The Peanut Butter Sucker is a professional bakery creating jaw-dropping wedding cakes in Russellville, Kentucky. The business was founded with a family-centric ethos, and owner Shawn relishes creating cakes for those celebrating new familial bonds. The company’s artistic designs show a flair for creative thinking and bold use of color and texture. With over a decade of experience, the team has baked cakes that have been featured in national publications and even for the Whitehouse.
The Peanut Butter Sucker work to make planning your wedding a smooth-sailing affair. Shawn works with couples to create personalized cakes that showcase their tastes and personalities. They also offer custom cookies, cake pops, cupcakes, and pastries. The team can deliver to your venue of choice, and propose tastings for couples to decide on their cake’s flavor.
33 Reviews for The Peanut Butter Sucker
Recommended by 99% of couples
25 User photos
Kait Barker · Married on 10/05/2019
The cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing! The team made everything easy and did everything to make our special day perfect!Sent on 10/24/2019
The Peanut Butter Sucker's reply:It was a please to work with you. Thank you for allowing us to be a part of this chapter in your life. Stay blessed! ThePBS
Cecilia Teichert · Married on 08/01/2020
Responsive team and Delicious Cake!
Planning (and re-planning) so much of our wedding during COVID, we forgot about the cake until a short 3 weeks before the wedding. We took our planner's recommendations and went with PBS and let me tell you, tasting that cake on our wedding day did NOT disappoint - it was absolutely delicious. I have a dairy intolerance so they made a special cake just for me - it was by far the best dairy free cake I've ever had! I got a lot of compliments from happy cake-lovers. A flexible team and a beautiful, tasty, and affordable cake - would highly recommend!Sent on 08/11/2020
The Peanut Butter Sucker's reply:Thank you Cecilia for trusting us to be a part of such an important first day to your new chapter. We are thrilled that it was enjoyed and added a nice sweet touch to your event. May you and yours be forever blessed. Shawn and Q
Emilie Polley · Married on 07/10/2020
Amazing & Perfect Experience
They were both so amazing throughout the whole experience. They made us our own little website that had a mockup of the cake which was adorable. They also, listen to us and made changes with no complaints or hesitations. Lastly, the cake tasted AMAZING!! So many of our guests complemented both the appearance and taste.Sent on 10/25/2019
Emilie & Ryan Doane
The Peanut Butter Sucker's reply:Thank you for your kind words. It was our honor to be a part of such an amazing day in your life. We look forward to working with you again in the future. Stay blessed