My favorite part of the wedding planning: the cake tasting at the Pennsylvania Bakery. It was nearly impossible to select a flavor because EVERYTHING was amazing. I ended up choosing a peanut butter based cake, and even guests at the wedding that did not like peanut butter loved this cake.

We ordered a small, two tier, wedding cake. It was a very simply cake. We had a smooth fondant over the icing, a ribbon wrapped around the bottom of both tiers, and simple piping in front of both ribbons. The rest of the decoration was fresh flowers.

My husband told them he would be there at 6am the day of to pick up the cake. When he arrived, the cake was ready, but none of the piping was done. When we ordered the cake, we had given them a picture that they could recreate from. He said they had the picture there, and it was written in the contract to have the piping. We're not sure what happened, but it was somehow overlooked. Luckily, we were there so early that there was time to add it.

The bakery didn't have any of there really good decorators there, so they offered to correct the problem and deliver the cake to the church. They arrived on time, and the cake was how we ordered it.

I have ordered from PA Bakery a lot of times, and this was the first time we had any issues. They remedied the mistake, and it tasted great!

We had carmel apples made for my wedding favors. They were not CHEAP. They were more expensive then my wedding cake, but they were the biggest apples I have ever seen. And we did get 80 of them indiviual wrapped. I will have to say these were worth every penny. I am still have my guest talk about them apples, "I was going to eat one or two pieces and then I ate the whole apple" lol

The cake was delicious! I can't wait for our 1st anniversary just so that I can eat more cake! :) The design was simple and elegant. There were a few details that weren't quite right, like the foil color under the cake (gold - eeck!) and the finish of the icing (it had sparkles in it and that isn't what I asked for). I would just recommend that when you have your consult, that you make sure to cover all of your bases.

The professionalism at this vendor was not great. We had a very difficult time choosing an icing as each time we went in they told us a different story. We did not talk with the lady that handles most weddings until our third visit by which we were already frustrated. The cake was beautiful and delicious, but the process leading up to it was not.

The PA Bakery was one of the best parts of the wedding. They were able to take our vision of having whoopie pies, rather than a cake, and developed a beautiful arrangement for us. They were also able to make a fun groom's cake as well. My husband and I always wanted whoopie pies but found that other vendors were pricey when it came to this delicacy. We thought we weren't going to be able to have them until we went to the PA Bakery, who was very accommodating and wrapped the whoopie pies in saran wrap and then put them individually into bags tied with ribbons. We were worried about it looking tacky, but it was the exact opposite. Our guests loved them because they were absolutely delicious--one cousin ate four of them! We would highly recommend PA Bakery for its reasonable prices and excellent service.

PA Bakery made us the most delicious cake I've had in my whole life! We had a three tier cake: butter cream frosting with vanilla cake and cannoli filing. Our guests definitely loved the cake! We ordered enough cake for 225 and only had 150 at our wedding, and all the cake was gone by the end! They did a beautiful job decorating the cake, and I was thrilled with how it looked. They are expensive but it's definitely worth the money.

Absolutely delicious but I wish they would work on being less "short" with clients.

My husband and I had a very clear idea of what we were wanting for our wedding cake when we walked into the Pennsylvania Bakery but were disappointed with the end result. The cake flavors and icing were absolutely delicious, however the service was less than desireable and I was heartbroken when I saw the cake on our wedding day. We were going with a "sports themes" cake and I specifically said I did not want the logos done in rice paper but that's exactly what they did. I would recommend the to anyone looking for a good cup of coffee and a cookie but not for something as important as a wedding cake.

Great job cake showed up on time and was really good and fresh

Our guests couldn't rave enough about how delicious our cake was! We ordered the carrot cake and the strawberry torte. Both flavors were absolutely out of this world! The only reason we didn't give 5 stars for professionalism was that we were initially over charged for our three simple cakes (not a traditional wedding cake) and there was some confusion as to when we needed to order since we had a tasting so far in advance of the wedding. However, the staff at the bakery caught the error and fixed it for us immediately. I would HIGHLY recommend them!

My cake was beautiful, as far as getting the colors right. It was also very delicious. I thought it was a little pricey for the size cake we got, but it was still cheaper than other vendors in our area. It was an overall good experience.

We ordered a yellow cake with Cream Cheese Icing and Raspberry Filling form PA Bakery, with a branch style design with vines and leaves, and custom Dogwood flowers. It was GORGEOUS and they did an excellent job of smoothing out a volatile icing into crisp edges. Staff were friendly and kind. The parlor where you sit to look at cake books is charming and sweet. My only complaint would be that the specialty icings are so expensive: an extra $100 on top of the standard butter-cream, although I could be ignorant on the subject, as I am not a baker. Additionally, be aware that they will only do fillings on the top layer of the cake, as it is more apt to slide during delivery and smash the cake. It's a good reason, but I was a little sad as the raspberry was DELICIOUS beyond belief.
Overall, we were incredibly happy with the cake and the staff and the price, icing forgiven.

Cake was delicious. Their prices did go up after we ordered our cake and we were told we would have to put together a new order if we wanted to downsize our cake. We stayed with the larger cake and just had leftovers. The flowers and desgins on the cake was lovely.

The cake looked just like the picture I gave them and it was absolutely beautiful!!! Tasted wonderful, like all their cakes do. Highly recommend it!

Their cake was to die for!! my cake was so spectacular!! highly reccomend!