Islamorada Fish Company Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
Weddingwire
115 reviews
Google
5929 reviews
-
Featured
![Lydia]()
Lydia Sent on 04/16/2026IFC Wedding 3.14.26
My husband and I got married at IFC on 3.14.26 and we can not recommend them enough! Jill, Marissa, and the entire IFC team were so accommodating throughout the entire planning process and answered every question we had. We have had several guests contact us in the weeks following the wedding to let us know how wonderful the venue, food, and entire experience was and we attribute that entirely to IFC! We definitely recommend using their day of coordinator service- Marissa took all of my decor inspo and made it come to life. We were truly thrilled with how our day turned out. -
-
Sara Sent on 04/09/2026
Jill and lexie the best staff and wedding of my life
JILL AND LEXIE THE WEDDING STAFF IN THE ENTIRE WORLD!! THEY MADE MY DAY A DREAM COME TRUE! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!! We truly cannot say enough amazing things about Isla Morada Fish Company and the incredible experience they gave us for our wedding. From the moment we started planning to the very last detail on our special day, everything was handled with so much care, professionalism, and genuine kindness.
The setting itself is absolutely breathtaking — the perfect mix of coastal charm and elegance. It created such a beautiful, relaxed atmosphere that made our wedding feel intimate, romantic, and unforgettable. Our guests are still talking about how stunning the location was and how it felt like something straight out of a dream.
The food… WOW. Every single dish was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. You can truly taste the quality, and it elevated the entire experience. So many of our guests told us it was some of the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding — which says everything.
But what really stood out the most was the team. They went above and beyond in every way possible. They made the entire process feel easy and stress-free, which is priceless when you’re planning a wedding. Every detail was executed flawlessly, and they made sure we were taken care of the entire time. We genuinely felt so supported and celebrated.
Our wedding day was everything we dreamed of and more, and a huge part of that is thanks to Isla Morada Fish Company. If you are considering this venue for your wedding or any special event — do it. You will not regret it.
Thank you for making one of the most important days of our lives so perfect 🤍 -
-
![Mary]()
Mary Sent on 03/28/2026Wedding in Paradise
Our wedding was on 3/22/26. Islamorada Fish Company (IFC) is truly a perfect place to have a wedding. Our wedding was of 50 guest out in the beach area and when I say it was a perfect day, it was a perfect day in paradise.
Jill the banquet manager and her team worked effortlessly together to create our vision and follow out our detailed wedding plans. Our theme was to have an island style wedding with a Mediterranean themed reception with coastal blue vibes and sunflowers centerpieces. Our vows took place privately, and then we celebrated our reception in the beach area. The sunset on our wedding day was breathtaking. Jill worked with our wedding planner who just happened to be our mom to create a fairytale wedding for us. From the appetizers during our cocktail hour full service dinner & bar. The food was excellent warm plated beautifully. Our cake was done by Publix and the delivery was done seamlessly. Jill handled all wedding details. She has many years of experience, and from day one we felt so comfortable with her . Also, IFC has a beautiful bride and groom wedding suite that’s just recently been remodeled and is beautiful. If you were looking for a place to have a special experience, even if you have small number people to larger wedding, IFC is the best kept secret in Islamorada for a wedding venue. We truly felt like we were family. They truly care about having a meaningful experience on your wedding day. Thank you Jill and your team, and IFC for an amazing wedding day! 🌻 The Medina’s -
-
Pam Sent on 03/08/2026
A Wedding experience
I really can’t say enough about this venue, Jill was incredibly easy to work with and was able to work around our budget. Lexi the day of coordinator was super sweet and made sure we were attended to with a huge smile on her face . Together they made sure my daughter’s wedding was everything we wanted and more .. The venue exceeded our expectations. I as well as my guests felt like we were at a tropical oasis from the tiki torches to the water and sunset natural backdrop as well as the decor ,Everything was perfect !
-
-
![Barbara]()
Barbara Sent on 11/03/2025Everything & More!! 💕
Jill and her staff go above and beyond to make your Wedding day perfect!! They are so very sweet and are there every step of the way! The Bridal Suite is AWSOME and you can be there all day with your girls getting ready. DO NOT hesitate if you are thinking of an Islamorada wedding.
PS. BOOK THE FIRE DANCER!!! Our guests LOVED his performance and couldn’t stop taking about the experience! 🔥🕺🏽 -
-
![Dezareigh]()
Dezareigh Sent on 09/10/2025They made my dream wedding come true!
Islamorada Fish Company was absolutely amazing! From the very first time we met Marissa and she gave us a tour, to the moment I walked down the aisle, all the way to her seeing us off at the end of the night—it was perfection. The entire staff was so kind, helpful, and professional, and I truly couldn’t recommend them more.
The ease of having everything taken care of—from set-up to clean-up, on-site coordination, and even beautiful decorations ready to use—made planning a destination wedding so much less stressful. Marissa, in particular, deserves the biggest thank you! My wedding wouldn’t have been what it was without her and her team. She went above and beyond, from making sure I had the perfect arch for my aisle to tracking down a working microphone at the last minute.
If you’re looking for a gorgeous venue with an incredible team that truly cares about making your day perfect, Islamorada Fish Company is the place.
-The Hendersons
-
-
![Haley]()
Haley Sent on 01/13/2025Brought my dream wedding to life
I am so beyond happy that I booked my wedding event here. I chose to do a destination wedding, and picked this place based off the positive reviews. I worked with Jill and IFC's wedding decor vendor wishes to weddings to achieve the vision I had in my mind. Jill was incredibly accommodating and would go out of her way to help answer any of the questions I had.
She walked us through the menu / food tasting, which was fantastic and very delicious. This venue has some of the best quality food I have ever eaten. For the price point per plate / person, you get such an incredible value. I had a strict budget and IFC was able to help me get what I wanted out of my wedding without exceeding my financial max.
Our bridal party absolutely enjoyed the bartender Gladys, who was also a lovely addition to the day. She went above and beyond for our guests and for us.
I also cannot say enough about the wedding coordinator that the venue offers. Marissa was the real MVP. She was so incredibly helpful the entire day of the wedding! Any needs that either I or my husband could've had, she was always quick to try and meet them the best way that she could. She also guided our photographer around the venue and recommended spots and poses that actually gave us gorgeous photos!
Before the big day, I questioned whether or not getting a coordinator was worth it. I can now say she was absolutely worth what we paid for her services. She helped reduce my stress and worry and that is invaluable.
I am so grateful to this venue for helping me get the wedding of my dreams. We 100% plan to go back here food, when we return to the keys for our anniversary.
-
-
Michelle Sent on 12/23/2024
The best of the best!!!!
Where to begin… IFC absolutely killed it with our wedding. The whole team was amazing. Their attention to detail, flexibility, communication style, openness and ability to put us at ease was outstanding. Jill and Marissa are literally the best and we honestly consider them friends now. We couldn’t have asked for a better evening, it exceeded our expectations. Thank you for helping make our wedding day one we will never forget! If you are debating on using IFC for any event, DO IT… you won’t regret it. ❤️❤️ -
-
![Aliese]()
Aliese Sent on 04/05/2024Best day ever!
We got married on March 23, 2024 at Islamorada Fish Company and it was magical. There are no words to describe how amazing Jill Stewart is. She listened to all my wants, visions and dreams and was very helpful and patient during the whole planning process. I did not know until later on that I accidentally ordered my wedding cake for pick up instead of delivery and Jill without saying anything to me left, picked up my cake and had it back at the reception in perfect time. Everything was perfect. Transitions from ceremony to cocktail to reception went flawlessly. I also recommend using their day of coordinator if you book (which you should) she is so sweet, helpful and has a great eye for detail and a very fun yet calming demeanor. The food was outstanding, all the staff was so kind and the venue is breathtaking. There are truly no words to describe how amazing March 23, 2024 was. Thanks to Jill and the staff of IFC it was truly the best day ever!
-
Beatriz Sent on 04/05/2024
Phenomenal night
First of all... I want to say thank you to Jill and her team for making my wedding such a phenomenal night. All the details that I wanted, they made it come true! The day coordinator was worth every dollar! She helped me with the table settings and everything else that was needed. I would recommend this venue to anyone who is looking to get married in paradise, while not breaking your wallet! -
-
![Krissy]()
Krissy Sent on 03/09/2024Absolutely get married at IFC!
My husband and I got married at IFC on March 1st and are absolutely in awe of the team, especially Jill Stewart and our day-of coordinator, Marissa. They kept me updated throughout the day as the team set up the decor and truly went above and beyond to make our day absolutely perfect.
As an event planner myself, I knew we were in good hands the minute I met Jill. Throughout the planning process, she was attentive, helpful, and so respectful of our budget.
When childcare for one our attendants' fell through at the last minute, her lovely daughter Lexie stepped in as their babysitter.
Not all heroes wear capes, but Jill, Marissa, and the IFC staff were the absolute heroes of our special day. If you are considering IFC for your wedding location, you should absolutely book with them today! -
-
![Guillermo]()
Guillermo Sent on 01/19/2024Worth Looking into it
Amazing venue, amazing staff. Granted we had a small wedding but nevertheless everything went very smoothly. From the bridal suite to the ceremony to the dinner to the after party.
I would highly recommend. -
Ashley Sent on 01/13/2024
Breathtaking wedding
What an amazing wedding day! I got married at the Islamorada Fish Company on Dec 2 2023 from beginning to the very end Jill and her staff were absolutely amazing. Every detail to every aspect of our wedding was covered and didn’t have to worry about anything. Let me tell you about the food, so delicious and yummy. Every guest enjoyed their meal and mentioned how it was the best wedding food they had. My husband and I are very happy with our event and memories we made. Thank you Jill and her team to our wonderful day! -
-
Barbara Sent on 01/04/2024
Awesome venue and location!!
Where do I start? From the first phone call with Jill, EVERYTHING went sooooo smoothly!!!! Location, location, location- can’t beat it, especially with the beautiful sunset we had!!!! Food was AMAZING and Marissa (Coordinator) was FANTASTIC!! IT WAS AN AWESOME WEDDING for my daughter!!! -
-
![Tracey]()
Tracey Sent on 01/02/2024Jill Stewart and her Fabulous Team went Above and Beyond to make our Wedding Day perfect!
I have to say, I don't think I could've planned a wedding from our home town in Colorado to the Florida Keys without the extraordinary help from Jill Stewart and her wonderful team from the Islamorada Fish Company! Jill was extremely supportive, patient, kind, fun and just a "gem" to work with! She made it seamless for us right from the start and kept in touch with me so I didn't have to worry about anything. Our reception was amazing!! The hors d'oeuvres, the salads, dinners and the unbelievable cake from Maggie's Bakery, Key Largo, was by far the best food I've ever had! Her team was so great and they were all so HAPPY to be there! If you are looking for a Top Notch team, who will go above and beyond to make your wedding/reception the best ever, the Islamorada Fish Company is the place to choose! Thank you Jill and your WONDERFUL staff for all you did to make our night so special! ~ Tracey and Roland -
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 12/29/2023The most amazing wedding!
We got married on October 28th 2023 and it could not have been more incredible! The venue was able to make accommodations for us to make the day more than perfect! -
-
![Katy]()
Katy Sent on 10/13/2023The most special place :)
Islamorada Fish Company will forever hold the most special place in our hearts. The venue is absolutely stunning, the bridal suite is perfect, but most of all, Jill and the rest of the IFC team are incredible to work with. Fantastic communication and organization, budget friendly, GREAT food and drinks, but above all, the staff really cares about making your day the best it can be... and ours was! They went to SO many extra lengths to make us feel special and loved, and we will never forget it. BOOK THIS VENUE! You will not regret it. -
-
![Bailey]()
Bailey Sent on 06/05/2023Most Amazing Venue 🤩🌴
First off, all the props need to go to Jill and her staff. These people are remarkable. From communication to decorating, bartending, serving delicious food..this venue has it all. The sunset that we got was amazing!! You can’t beat the views of the ocean and palm trees. Jill put out all my decor and decorated my cake with what I had brought and what she had on hand. I truly didn’t lift a finger that day. You can tell everyone there loves what they do. Jill is so good at her job and I am so thankful for her and all she did to make our day so special. Also a major plus is the bridal suite. It’s stunning. You can eat lunch up there and have drinks. It’s an awesome set up. All these other venues want an arm and a leg and it was so hard finding something within budget but this place fell right into my lap. It’s affordable and the most perfect place for a destination wedding. Look no further because the Islamorada Fish Company is the place. ❤️ -
-
![Ariel]()
Ariel Sent on 05/03/2023The absolute best day ever!!!!
My husband and I just got married at the Islamorada fish company April 21, 2023 and they surpassed all of our expectations with flying colors. We are from Ohio, so having a destination wedding I was extremely nervous. From wanting to have certain decorations brought in and certain accommodations made, I felt this would be impossible. Jill made each and every want possible. Her attention to detail and more importantly the love for her job made everything so effortlessly incredible. The day of the wedding was breath taking and an absolute dream. The entire staff made my husband and I feel like we didn't even have to lift a finger. There was no stress about anything because they handled everything so flawlessly. We also hired the day of coordinator and her assistant, and I highly recommend as they added so much ease to the entire process. From setting up decorations, ensuring all of our needs were met, to even following us around during our pictures to ensure everyone's belongings were safe! They literally thought of every single detail and everything was perfect. My husband and I could not thank them enough. Each and every single one of their staff members were so pleasant and enjoyed what they did so much, it honestly felt like a big family coming together to throw an amazing party. So if you are thinking about having your wedding at this venue.. DO IT!!!!!!!!! because they strive for perfection and they will not disappoint you. -
![Paul]()
Paul Sent on 05/03/2023Best Day or our LIVES!!!
I would like to just say first and foremost how thankful my wife and I are for the amazing staff that worked so hard to make our day perfect. Islamorada Fish Company was the perfect venue for our wedding with around 70-75 guests. Jill, the wedding planner is easy to get ahold of and always quick with a solution when problems arise. My family was lucky enough to have both our rehearsal dinner as well as our wedding there and it was superb. First off, the staff is incredible. It is nice to surround yourself with hard working people that also seem genuinely happy for you. Special thanks to Jamie the bartender, she was amazing and always charming and made amazing drinks. The day of coordinator is a must! There was no stress on the wedding day. Jill was quick to answer any questions as well as offer advice for decorations, vendors, food choices etc. It has been 2 weeks since our wedding and looking at just normal pictures taken the venue is beautiful, and it blows everyone away that I show here in Ohio. We did some light planning and knew a couple specific things that we wanted and the day of the wedding was seamless, non stressful and amazing. When you are there all you have to do is follow the lead of Jill and her staff, they do something like 100 weddings a year at that venue so trust me, they know 100% what they are doing. While we were taking pictures somewhere else on the property they have a young lady watching us to ensure we didn’t forget anything such as phones, jackets, glasses etc. which we did and thank goodness for her. The Fish Company has every angle covered. To summarize, we could not be more happy with this venue. All the food was hot, tasty and fresh, the price was reasonable and the staff truly makes it a wonderful experience. Oh, also the natural beauty of the water, trees, sand and amazing sunset. To the entire staff at the Islamorada Fish Company, we thank you so much for your hard work, professionalism and amazing service that gave us the wedding of our dreams! -
![Sam]()
Sam E. Sent on 04/25/2023The best venue ever!
The most incredible venue we could've asked for! We planned a destination wedding here for March 2023. Jill (and Brad) were so helpful the whole time and made destination planning so easy. When we got to town, everyone on the venue property was so helpful and kind. The day of the wedding was just perfect! The bridal suite was wonderful. Drinks, food, and decorations were amazing. Also the views here are just beautiful! Cannot recommend this venue enough! -
-
![Emma]()
Emma Sent on 04/23/2023Best Day Ever!
We already knew Islamorada Fish Company for their restaurant; One of our favorite spots when we are in the Keys. When we discovered they offered a wedding venue we were afraid it was too good to be true. It was every bit as amazing as we thought it would be! Jill Stewart, the coordinator at IFC, was so knowledgable and so supportive from the start. She walked us through the whole process from our first call to our last. She made planning a wedding long distance as painless as anyone could ever hope for. IFC offered many options when it came to the decor, colors, layout, seating...every aspect. Jill never made us feel like what we wanted on our day was too much or not attainable. All of that was before the wedding day. We were so sure that we would need to be there for set up and coordination. No. Jill and her crew were ABOVE AND BEYOND!! They were all attentive and professional. The ceremony and reception spaces looked gorgeous, they ensured we were settled and comfortable, all set up was completed well before the necessary time and all of our guests were taken care of from the moment they arrived.
There are so many moving parts that go in to a wedding, and the staff at IFC manages them without batting an eye; from the largest to the smallest. My wife and I were talking, recapping our separate experiences the day of the wedding, and realized the person that did the most to calm us before the ceremony, was one of our assigned IFC staff members. Leslie was the last person I talked to before I walked down the aisle and she honestly, gave me peace and perspective. Throughout getting ready, walking down the aisle, more pictures than I care to recount, Jill was there all along with a reassuring smile and a cool drink. That experience and patience is worth every penny a person could spend and IFC was still so affordable; the most affordable of the places that we looked throughout the Keys. Looking back, even for more money, I would not have picked another venue. When I see pictures of our sunset ceremony and our families dancing under the stars...Would. Not. Trade. It!! Thank you, Islamorada Fish Company for the truly unforgettable day!! All our IFC staff were VIPs, special shoutouts to Leslie, Jamie, and Jill..saved the day. -
![Courtney]()
Courtney Sent on 04/09/2023Best Wedding Venue Ever
I'm so glad I picked Islamorada Fish Company as the venue for our destination wedding on April 3rd 2023 in Islamorada, FL. It was so beautiful there and Jill was amazing to work with. She made sure everything was perfect for that day and any questions I had over the course of planning, she would answer right away, or schedule calls if she was busy, and helped to make the entire process as stress free as possible.
The staff went above and beyond for our wedding day by always checking to see that we were taken care of and making sure the decorations looked beautiful. Even after four events they had over that weekend, they were still friendly, energetic and ready to help with anything. The bridal suite was amazing to get ready in and I was able to watch everything being set up from the balcony.
Islamorada Fish Company made sure that my wedding was as stress free as possible and all I can remember was how perfect that day was. The location was gorgeous, the food was absolutely delicious, everyone was helpful and you could tell that they knew what they were doing, and the atmosphere had the Keys vibe of taking your worries away.
I would highly recommend this venue to anyone wanting an amazing, stress-free destination wedding down in the Florida Keys. It was worth every penny and I wouldn't change a thing about my wedding there. -
-
![Jocelyn]()
Jocelyn Sent on 03/14/2023Amazing!
JILL STEWART!!!! Wow.wow.wow. My dream was to get married in Islamorada!!! I found this venue by chance through another brides post on Facebook…. And WOW am I so glad I took her advice! This venue is unbelievable!!! The first time I met Jill (the wedding coordinator) she makes you feel SO at ease with all the wedding details and planning! Literally I only had to tell her my ideas on how I wanted things to go and look on our day and she literally did even BETTER!!! She literally took my ideas and went above and BEYOND! When I saw everything decorated for the first time I lost it! She is so amazing I can not say enough on how outstanding her and her staff are!!! The organization was absolutely incredible!! I got to enjoy every single moment and not have to worry about a SINGLE thing!!!! Because I knew Jill had it all taken care of!!!! It’s truly a breath of fresh air! Not only is she literally the sweetest person and so so easy to talk and coordinate with she’s literally the best in this business hands down. Our entire wedding party said they’ve been to SOO many weddings and our wedding was literally the BEST wedding they’ve ever attended!! We can’t recommend this venue ENOUGH!!!! If your dream is to get married in the keys like mine was…. Stop looking anywhere else. THIS IS THE VENUE!!! You will thank me later!!! Thank you Jill & Marissa, and all your top notch staff. You guys are absolutely amazing and we can’t thank you all enough!!! 10000000 stars!!!! -
-
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 03/13/2023Sunset Paradise Venue
Hands down the best place to have your wedding in the Florida Keys! Jill and her team know exactly what they're doing at Islamorada Fish Company. My husband and I planned our entire wedding from PA through emails and phone calls and we never had to worry about things not getting done or questions not being answered. We had so many guests compliment how delicious the food during cocktail hour and dinner was. The bar service was amazing! The selection of beers, wines, and spirits was more than we've ever seen at any other wedding we've attended. The sunset was absolutely breathtaking and will always be one of the best highlights of our special day. We have no regrets booking our wedding at IFC and would do it all over again!! -
Abbie Sent on 01/05/2023
12.30.22 The BEST day and the BEST venue.
We got married on 12/30 and had a plated dinner. We could not have asked for a better night! It was everything we had hoped for. The staff made it that much better. They were AMAZING! Our whole family kept complimenting on how well put on the wedding was but it couldn’t have been done without Jill! She went above and beyond on our night and so did the bartenders. They were out there dancing and having fun with us! I cannot recommend this place enough. -
-
![Paula]()
Paula Sent on 01/01/2023Took the guesswork out of wedding planning.
Everything was exactly what expected plus 10x better!!! Best day ever! -
-
Charles Sent on 12/04/2022
Superb Service and Venue!
We highly recommend Islamorada Fish Company as wedding venue. Jill is fantastic, the staff are amazing. We a had a memorable/wonderful wedding at sunset and would highly recommend! -
-
![Ralph]()
Ralph Sent on 11/30/2022Our Special Day..!!
First Class from start to finish.. It was a pleasure working with Islamorada Fish Company crew.. Jill Stewart helped us from the first day with all aspects needed for our special day.. The event turned out perfect and we could not have been any happier. I would highly recommend Islamorada Fish Company for your special day.. -
-
Matthew Sent on 11/20/2022
Best venue staff on earth
Jill and her staff at IFC were hands down the difference. They were constantly going out of their way to make our day special. The back up plan for the rain was amazing and their organization to quickly change everything from outside to inside was smooth and easy. I highly recommended a wedding here. Food was great and not a take home box in sight because every plate was finished. Our bartender was fabulous and never had a guest waiting for a drink. -
-
Jorden Sent on 10/10/2022
Unforgettable!
I cant even begin to explain my experience with Islamorada Fish Company for my wedding. Start to finish Jill made the entire process easy and seamless! Choosing a venue site unseen solely based on reviews and research was probably insane but I wouldnt have changed a thing! Jill was beyond responsive and attentive to all my questions, offered so many ideas and recommendations and made the day of my wedding so easy and laid back. The two lovely ladies who also helped, Jaimie and Leslie, will forever be in my gratitude for their helpfulness and being so down to earth and fun to celebrate with! The venue itself was GORGEOUS! The bridal suite accommodations were fantastic and OMG the food, unreal! You normally hear and experience not so great food at weddings but that was not the case here! Between the appetizers to the meal to the drink options, everything was phenomenal! Anyone considering this venue, don't hesitate!! There isnt a single detail of the day I would have changed and that is all because of Jill! Thank you soo soo much for making my dreams come true and more! -
-
Jen N. Sent on 10/04/2022
Dream wedding
If I could give this venue 10 stars I would!! Jill went above and beyond to make our dream wedding come true. Her team was absolutely amazing on the wedding day even when it rained unexpectedly. They helped keep all the seats dry and made sure we were comfortable. Decor was everything we wanted. Food was great!! I cannot thank Jill enough for being so sweet and calming. I wish we could do it all over again! -
-
Ashley Sent on 09/27/2022
Perfect Night!
Everything that involved this venue was a dream! It was the most beautiful, magical night! They had everything we needed and more! All of the staff was so sweet, kind and so helpful!! I would 100000% choose this venue and staff again in a heartbeat! -
-
Melissa Sent on 09/27/2022
Perfect in every way
Jill and the amazing team members were very accommodating. Extremely professional, detailed oriented, knowledgeable, understanding and personable.
There wasn't a detail left uncovered. The bridal suite was very cute and clean. It had everything we needed. They went above and beyond to make our day perfect. Location is beautiful and venue is very affordable. If you're looking for a destination wedding this is the place!
-
-
![Leanibet]()
Leanibet Sent on 09/26/2022Best wedding venue in the florida keys
Islamorada fish company was the best decision my husband and I have ever made. They made our dream come true. Jill (the coordinator) was fantastic and walked us through the whole process the entire time. It was the happiest day of our life and we are so grateful. We loved it!!!!!! Totally recommend it!!!! -
![Tabitha]()
Tabitha Sent on 08/09/2022Jill was fantastic!! Everything turned out perfect!!
Everything being planned via email and few phone calls was nerve wracking, that being said Jill was always available for all my questions and requests! Wouldn’t have changed a thing!!! -
Janet Sent on 06/14/2022
Beautiful!
Everything was perfect for our wedding at Islamorada Fish Co. Jill and her staff took care of every detail for us! The sunset views are breathtaking!! Food and drinks were amazing - I can't give it 10 stars or I would! -
-
Skyler Sent on 04/18/2022
Taylor Wedding
Literally my dream wedding come true!!!! I couldn’t say enough good things about this venue. From the people, to the view, it’s everything you could dream of. Jill is the greatest forreal! She took such a big weight off of my shoulders during this process and we are so grateful for her. All of our family and friends, along with us, had such an amazing time. We are so thankful for this group of people for making our big day so special. -
-
![Jacob]()
Jacob Sent on 04/06/2022Love the Venue and the photos!
Hi! We chose Islamorada Fish Company for our wedding and rehearsal dinner. It was an EXCELLENT choice! If you want a wonderful, Keys wedding with the views and excellent food, that's still affordable, this is maybe the best and only spot to do it! It. Was. Perfect. We planned this from several states away and it went off without a hitch. Jill, the event coordinator, was a godsend, helping our vision come to life and being patient and wonderful every step of the way. In fact, I kept apologizing for being difficult and she assured me I was not. The food, organization, and events were awesome. But the best part of this spot is the view. You will LOVE your pictures, I promise. I'm not a picture person and I LOVE LOVE LOVE them, and can't get enough. Also, we had guests posting pictures of the venue all over, it was exactly the reaction we wanted, especially with a lot of guests coming from out of town. On the day of, the other staff go Jamie, Shawn and Leslie were awesome too. So many people complemented the service at the tables and bartenders (we had a plated dinner and open bar). Also, the day of coordinator Lilly was a HUGE help and worked great with Jill to make the day perfect. This is the perfect spot to start your life together, and don't forget, YOU'LL LOVE THE PICTURES AT SUNSET! -
-
Jess Sent on 03/16/2022
Sunset Rehearsal Dinner Fl Keys
Islamorada Fish Company holds a very special place in my son and new daughter. It was there spot in the Keys. We rented the upstairs room with balcony overlooking the water for the rehearsal dinner. It has breathtaking views perfect at Sunset. We were from out of town and had to do most of our communication with the restaurant via Text and phone calls. I truly can't say enough good things about Jill Stewart She was amazing and helped me with anything and everything that I needed. Jill made everything so easy. The food was ready on time, hot, and delicious. It was the very best experience that I could have hoped for. Thank you, Jill and Islamorada Fish Co. for making their rehearsal dinner memorable and outstanding!
-
-
Jenny Sent on 03/06/2022
Incredible
Absolutely couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Everything was perfect, Jill is an actual godsend! She made everything so easy and talked me off the ledge more than once during the planning process. To say she went above and beyond for us is an understatement. It was awesome to work with a venue that didn’t upcharge us but instead did what they could to help us save money. I couldn’t recommend it highly enough! I wouldn’t change a single thing if I could do it again! -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 11/20/2021Fairytale dream come true only way to describe it
I blinked and my wedding day was here and gone but let me just tell you it was everything I had dreamed of but BETTER!! The entire staff at Islamorada Fish Company was incredible. From the moment we spoke on the phone to the day after my wedding was perfectly planned and executed. Jill Stewart and Ani-Marie Rico did it all flawlessly! Jill couldn’t be there the day of but she still checked in on my special day and the day after!! They were so easy to work with and let me come in and look through all of the decor for the tables and knew exactly the style I was going for. They even saved the top of my cake and labeled it so I could freeze it and take it home! Ani took care of everything the day of and was so helpful if we needed any tiny little thing. Her upbeat positive attitude made me laugh and smile and not stress a single moment! I didn’t hire a coordinator bc we only had 25 people but I didn’t even need to!! The food from chef Izzy was so good! He even came out and helped served it! My party cleaned their plates! The raw bar was incredible and so were the butler passed crab cakes and fish tacos! The plated grouper portifino and the shrimp was some of the best I’ve had in Islamorada. Leslie was also helping serve everything with a smile on her face and was so helpful and quick with getting people anything they needed. Ashtyen jumped in to help serve cake and finished cutting it for us and the bartender Kevin was so so GREAT! They were all so friendly and my guests were chatting with all of them throughout the night like old friends! Jack Hinson was the in house musician that night and he NAILED it! I didn’t think my guests were dancers but they had the time of their lives on November 12th, 2021! I honestly wish we could live it all over. Maybe we will renew our vows here! Can not say enough awesome things. Oh the bridal suite was so spacious and beautiful and all of the men had their pics taken in the Zane Grey room and loved it!!! Thank you all again everyone at ISLAMORADA FISH COMPANY!!! -
-
![Nathaniel]()
Nathaniel Sent on 10/14/2021The most beautiful day of our lives
Islamorada fish company is the way to go! Trust me Jill, and her amazing team are pros at this and Sabrina from the Florida Keys Wedding Center did an amazing job decorating!! Me and my wife couldn’t have ask for a better location and team to help pull of the best day of our lives!! Thank you guys so much -
-
![Amber]()
Amber Sent on 08/15/2021Gorgeous, Affordable, Delicious!!
Islamorada Fish Company is a phenomenal venue!! Hidden treasure as they don’t advertise much! Bridal suite is beautiful and comfortable with amazing views! You have access to so much real estate on their property to really customize your event! Multiple gorgeous ceremony site options with indoor backup options! Indoor reception option if you want to retreat to the AC in summer months! Sunsets are on the gulf side making this venue the PERFECT location. Food is delicious, if you’ve been to the restaurant before, you already know that! AND Jill, the day of coordinator, comes included with the price! Shes worth the whole venue site fee alone! She really knows how to decorate for a wedding and make things run super smooth! Seriously so much value for the amount they charge! You wont find a better bang for your buck than here. Cant brag in this place enough! Stop venue searching, you have found the place! -
-
Sandra Sent on 07/02/2021
Amazing views and amazing food!
Jill and the event team at Islamorada Fish House were exceptional. The food, service and attention to detail were amazing. Many guests reached out and said it was the best wedding they ever have been to! Our day was perfect! Easy to work with, beautiful bridal suite and accommodating. Most of all they went above and beyond to make our day special. -
-
Tina Sent on 06/08/2021
So Thankful To The Islamorada Fish Company!
Our wedding was only a month ago, and deciding to have it at The Islamorada Fish Company in Islamorada was one of our best decisions we ever made! It is located on the bay side where you can see the most beautiful sunsets. Our outdoor ceremony and reception was set in an area that almost looked like our own private peninsula and was sectioned off so no restaurant guests can enter. The food was absolutely fresh and delicious, as promised, as well as the professionalism of all the servers and bartenders. Our event coordinator, and manager of the venue, Jill Stewart, promised us from day one of meeting her that she would do everything in her power to make our wedding spectacular, and boy, did she come through!! From day one of planning, she was always on top of things, always listened attentively to every single question and request that we had, and ALWAYS came through. In her mind, your wedding day is as if you were family to her and she treats you like that. With the stress and nervousness that comes to planning the day, she ALWAYS was there for us whether it was by phone, emails, or texts reassuring us that everything was being taken care of and that it would be beautiful. At this venue, the bridal suite was absolutely gorgeous in a second-story building overlooking the ceremony and reception area, the gorgeous bay and palm trees. The day of the wedding while I was in the bridal suite getting ready, no matter what I needed, she was there in a heartbeat! She is like Wonder Woman when it comes to making your wedding day everything you dreamed of. My husband and I grew to love Jill through this whole process, and Jill now has a very special place in our hearts and lives. Thank you, Jill a/k/a Wonder Woman, and everyone at the Islamorada Fish Company for making our wedding day absolutely extraordinary in every way!!
Tina and Michael G. -
-
Melanie Sent on 06/05/2021
Beautiful Venue
I have to give so much credit to Jill the event coordinator! She is absolutely amazing and made our special day perfect! The venue was absolutely beautiful and the atmosphere was magical. -
-
Alex Sent on 02/08/2021
The BEST sunset wedding pictures in the Keys are taken here at IFC
You don't need to go to mile marker 0 for the best wedding sunset pictures, they are absolutely in Islamorada at Islamorada Fish Company. I can't tell you how many of my guests (many of us who live in Florida) asked me how I found this perfect venue or how I knew that the sunsets were this breathtaking in Islamorada, or just plain said "this is the most beautiful wedding venue I have ever been to." I truly felt blessed with the views, the weather, and the amazing staff at IFC. Jill, IFC's wedding coordinator, is patient, organized and everything a bride tends to NOT be on her wedding day (thank you Jill!). She is compassionate and level headed, when your nerves get the best of you on your big day. Ani and Leslie were our servers, our bartender was Jamie - sweet and quick to help! Dinner was a big hit (try the grouper!) and the coconut shrimp and conch fritters are a MUST for passed Hors d'oeuvres. Highly recommend ceremony, reception, or any event here at IFC - there is honestly no price tag you can put on our wedding ceremony backdrop :-) I was told that a mama and baby dolphin popped up out of the water during my vows, and during Hors d'oeuvres, my guests saw a manatee. Truly magical! -
-
![Megan]()
Megan Sent on 02/07/2021Staff went above and beyond our expectations.
My husband and I cannot say enough good things about Islamorada Fish Company and the wonderful staff here. We got married this past week on 2/1/21 and had such a pleasant experience. We have been dealing with Jill since very early of last year before choosing this as our venue. Throughout the entire process, Jill was over the top helpful to my mom and I with every question we had. She pays very close attention to the small details to ensure everything goes according to plan. We are forever grateful to her. Even on vacations and days off, she was always responsive and always willing to help. She is the absolute best of the best. Did I mention the bridal suite? Absolute heaven and SO convenient for the day of the wedding. We literally got ready in the bridal suite from 9am up until it was time to walk down the aisle. It's a dream. So clean, spacious, and beautiful.
We had our rehearsal dinner here the night prior to our wedding as well and it was set up beautifully. Our bartender and server for the rehearsal dinner, Shawn, was exceptional. Whenever someones drink was gone, he was right there with another in hand. The food was delicious. Shawn was so very friendly and our guests were very impressed with his service from beginning to end.
Our wedding day was slightly disrupted by crazy winds which was beyond the control of anyone. Jill ensured us that they could make it work if we wanted the wedding to remain outdoors. We had a destination wedding so of course we wanted to keep it outside if we could. I am so glad we did. Despite the winds, it was everything we could have imagined and more. The staff did their very best with our decorations and flower arrangements to work with the wind. They were all so friendly and helpful.
Jamie was our bartender, and Leslie and Shawn were our servers. We have nothing but good things to say about both the rehearsal dinner and wedding day, from beginning to end. My family has a very strong connection to Islamorada, as my poppy lived here the majority of his lifetime. My mom spent a lot of her childhood and adult years here. He introduced us to this restaurant, and I knew having our wedding here would make it that much more special. We cannot wait to continue coming back for the delicious key lime pie and extraordinary service that the staff provides. Islamorada Fish Company staff, thank you from the bottom of our hearts for the greatest experience for such a special occasion that we will always remember. I am so glad we chose you! -
-
![Bethanne]()
Bethanne Sent on 02/05/2021Amazing experience
This was the best wedding I have ever been to. Jill was hands down the best coordinator you can have. Everything I ever dreamed of for my wedding came true all thanks to Jill.. She is so accommodating and even went out of her way to make sure I could eat a special diet.. The best experience I could ever ask for.. Thank you so much for making my day special.. -
-
Daniela Sent on 08/23/2020
Beyond amazing!
WOW! Our wedding was better than I could have ever imagined. IFC is a beautiful venue looked like a magazine cover. Jill was so helpful from the beginning. I was coming from out of state and never saw the venue prior or tasted the food but Jill helped us. She was responsive with emails, phone calls, and texts. The day of the wedding the forecast predicted possible rain, Jill called me to discuss options incase of rain in such a calming manner which really makes a huge difference but thank God the weather was perfect! Jill was so flexible and willing to help out in so many ways. I can’t thank her enough! Leslie and Ani were our servers and so sweet and kind! They had a smile on their faces all night and even took the initiative to make a separate plate for us while we were taking pictures which was so thoughtful! Jamie was our bartender and was wonderful, all the drinks were great, A+ service. Thank you for making our wedding so magical, a dream come true. If you are thinking of having a wedding at IFC don’t even think about it just do it! Jill and the staff will not disappoint they go above and beyond!!! Thank you Jill, Ani, Leslie, and Jamie we are forever grateful!!! -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 08/02/2020Our Wedding Day
Only positive things to say about this venue! Jill the banquet manager goes above and beyond for her clients. From being an excellent day of coordinator handling every aspect to make the day stress free so you can really enjoy it and be in the moment. Their bridal suite on-site is beautiful overlooking the water really creates a stunning setting to get ready. Ample space for your makeup artists, bridesmaids and family. Everything on-site is easily accessible. Plenty of options to do ceremony and reception and easy set up for your vendors to bring in what they need. The area outside by the sand where we hosted our wedding was an open format for us to decorate it as we pleased. Amazing photo opportunities and a beautiful sunset in your background. The staff is very friendly and the food is delicious. The space creates a beautiful keys wedding ambiance. Highly recommend for a tropical wedding escape! Thank you Jill for everything you did for me, my now husband and my family. We will never forget you and the Islamorada Fish Company! -
-
![Billie]()
Billie Sent on 02/04/2020Perfect for our Welcome Reception!
We hosted our welcome party on the beach of the Islamorada Fish Company the day before our wedding and it was such a great party! All of the guests that were attending our wedding came to our welcome party, which essentially made it another wedding as well, in size and scope. The event was organized with Jill from IFC, and she was easy to work with, answering multiple emails and calls as we planned our affair from another state. We hosted the party on the beach on Saturday and the set up was lovely. They catered to our specifications with regards to set up and tables. The biggest hit was definitely the raw bar and those tasty coconut shrimp, our guests loved it. Since the party was on a Saturday, there was live music and a fire dancer. Our guests all had a wonderful time and it was a great place to host our party. I imagine that they would be incredible if this was for a wedding as well. Thanks Jill and IFC! -
Alina Sent on 01/30/2020
Perfect intimate wedding venue!
We had such a beautiful wedding here!! It exceeded our expectations! Jill Stewart, the banquet manager, went above and beyond as did all the staff that we encountered! She helped make the whole beach/dock area more beautiful than it already was, and even decorated the tables. Jamie was an awesome bartender and Leslie was a wonderful server. They both made sure my guests were well taken care of. The guitar player was incredible too! Thank you to everyone who helped make our wedding better than we imagined! -
-
![Kenny]()
Kenny Sent on 11/17/2019Amazing Sunsets
The fish company has one of the best sunsets you can find in the keys. The beach area provided an amazing backdrop to our ceremony. The team is great to work with and we received numerous compliments about the food (the grouper was fantastic). With this being a destination wedding for us, it was easy working with them on the details. Their bridal suite is very nice and super convenient for any bride looking to get ready on-site. We would highly recommend booking your wedding & reception at this location. -
-
![Kim]()
Kim M. Sent on 08/01/2019Amazing Venue, Excellent Staff, Perfect Wedding Day 7/11/19
If I could give the Islamorada Fish Company venue 10 stars, I would. If I could give Jill and the staff there 10, it still wouldn't be enough. We had a destination wedding there on July 10th of 2019. We are an older couple having a second marriage and we originally planned a courthouse visit and a trip by ourselves. Plans changed so family could celebrate with us but I was still a very reluctant bride (not wife - but bride).
My sister-in-law found the Fish Company and now I wouldn't go back and change one thing about our wedding. It was a perfect day from start to finish and even the rehearsal dinner the night before was incredible.
The best thing about the Fish Company is the people. I can't even describe how helpful Jill was during the whole process but she went above and beyond the day before and day of our wedding. She rearranged her days off just to be available to help us on our wedding day and even showed up the day before (even though she was not working) for rehearsal to go over everything, assist with any needs we had, and give us access to places to store decorations. When she left, her daughter took over and was there for anything we needed. She is just as amazing as Jill.
Jill was in contact all day on our wedding date and appeared regularly to ask if she could help or if we needed anything. Any request we made was met with a smile and done quickly - from vases for the bridal suite, additional ice, questions about ceiling fan operation, placement of decorations, cake delivery, and everything in between. Every single person at this venue was happy and friendly and seemed genuinely eager to help make our day special. I was able to enjoy the day stress free and just celebrate the moment.
The food is very good and the wait staff is just as wonderful as the people I described above. They went above and beyond to take good care of us all and felt like part of the celebration when all was said and done. ***At the end of the wedding the staff packed all our left over food, cake, decorations at the ceremony and reception site and packaged everything so nice to leave in the bridal suite so we could pick it up the next day. We were able to stay to the end of our event and didn't have a single worry about gathering or packing one thing. We were able to go back the next morning to pick up all our neatly arranged and packaged items.
Finally, the PRICE and LOCATION are phenomenal. The Islamorada Fish Company was by the far the most affordable venue we found and the service provided by Jill and the company employees was worth every penny on their own. The venue is beautiful and was the perfect backdrop for our wedding. They take such care in excellent service and I just can't say thank you enough.
-
-
Rachel Sent on 06/06/2019
Wedding May 16,2019
Can’t recommend Islamorada Fish Co. enough! Jill was utterly fantastic in every way from beginning planning stages till the very end and the venue was just gorgeous for our simple sunset wedding. Everyone was friendly, accommodating, and made our special day so memorable. -
-
28F345486E77D89Adc0Cf9Da908F46417C8C0Ef9 Sent on 03/04/2019
Tropical paradise!
I live in homestead fl. my husband & I love going to the keys every weekend. I search north-south of the Florida keys looking for the perfect wedding venues. But one stood out the most to me which was Islamorada fish and company. Islamorada fish & co have a beautiful out door and indoor venue and they even have a room where the bride and bridesmaids can get ready on site overlooking the water it’s a spectacular view. Now let’s talk about their amazing sunset beautiful blue,purple, and pink sky is what makes this venue so unique. Jill the banquet manager is the best ! My wedding was postponed twice due to covid and with each time Jill was able to accommodate me with my new dates and always stayed positive to keep my spirits up each time. Jill explained the different options I had depending on the weather they have a indoor or out door area which is great you don’t usually get those options at different venues. My wedding was beautiful thanks to the beautiful view. For days my guest have been calling telling me how beautiful my venue site was. I am forever grateful for Jill and their amazing staff that made my wedding day so special. I wish I could relive my wedding day again. 01/11/2021 -
-
![Caitlin and Alex]()
Caitlin Sent on 01/26/2017There are no words to express our sincerest gratitude and happiness with our experience at Islamorada Fish company for our wedding on January 7, 2017. While the weather was out of our control, the staff including event coordinator, Andrea Creary, were professional, flexible, organized, and helpful. A small break in the rainy and windy weather allowed for the outdoor ceremony we dreamed of, while moving the reception indoors to Zane Grey provided a warm and intimate coverage from the storm. The food was hot and delicious and the servers and bartenders were smiling, courteous, and clean. Andrea was not only directing the staff to make sure every detail was perfect, but she was also working equally as hard to clean, organize, and help make the whole day less stressful. We felt comforted and confident that Andrea, the staff, and the setting at IFC would provide us the perfect wedding, and in the end, it was undoubtedly the best day of our lives!!! We cannot thank you enough, Andrea and the staff at IFC!! We appreciate everything you did for us and our family and friends to celebrate our love and marriage!! -
![Ryan]()
Ryan Sent on 02/25/2025Dream wedding at Islamorada Fish Company!
My wife and I are so incredibly lucky to have found Islamorada Fish Company as our wedding venue! We began the process by researching venue options from West Palm Beach to the Florida Keys. We found this beautiful venue on Wedding Wire and other wedding sites and noticed all of the amazing reviews!
We reached out to Jill (Islamorada Fish Company Event Coordinator) and took a trip down to Islamorada to meet her/tour the venue. There, we met with Jill and Marissa (Day of Coordinator) who were absolutely amazing. They spent over an hour with us answering all of our questions (we had ALOT) and showing us all around the property (beach venue, bridal suite, Zane Gray lounge, etc). This was the most flexible wedding venue I have heard of. They worked with ALL of our requests without any pushback at all.
We ended up touring a couple other venues during this trip and it was without a doubt obvious that Islamorada Fish Company was the winner (they’re also much much cheaper than any other venue we toured - and I’m bias but still the best). We ended up putting down a deposit with our wedding date and began planning the wedding.
Over the months leading up to our wedding date we reached out to Jill and Marissa multiple times to answer some questions/clarification on certain things. They were able to assist us in the months prior to our wedding with all of our needs.
About two week prior to the wedding we had a long hour + call with Jill and Marissa where we discussed everything in fine detail to make sure everyone was on the same page with decorations, food selections, timeline, etc.
We had our rehearsal dinner at the venue in the Corner Bar and it was absolutely perfect. The staff/food/service was amazing!
The day of the wedding was incredible. Marissa was completely attentive to the bride and bridesmaids the entire day - getting them everything they needed while they were getting ready in the bridal suite. Marissa met with all of the vendors (bakery, florist, DJ, etc) who dropped items off throughout the day, so there was no pressure on the bride/groom or family. Marissa did an amazing job decorating - it was incredibly beautiful. The groom/groomsmen got ready at their hotel and stood by for the ceremony to start in the Zane Gray lounge. It was awesome they offered this to us!
Once again, the food/service was perfect. Jill and Marissa were so attentive to us on the wedding day and made sure it was absolutely perfect. We are forever grateful to Jill, Marissa and all the staff. This was the best day of our lives and we will never forget it.
If you’re looking for the most beautiful Keys venue at a reasonable price point with the most flexible, kind, attentive staff - this is the place for you.
-
![Christina]()
Christina Sent on 11/19/2024Perfect Intimate Wedding
We had such an amazing time at our reception. I come from the event industry and I know how strict and expensive some venue are, I also have high expectations of service and I can tell you that IFC really came through in the end! I really had my heart set on having my wedding reception in the keys and it was so important for me to find a space that had comparable backup space because Florida weather is unpredictable and IFC was just that! Although we didn't need to use the backup space thankfully, IFC offered beautiful options for both! Initially, I did have some a little trouble with responsiveness in the beginning but I will say I am very type A and got engaged in the busiest wedding season and with team work from Jill and Marissa, they made the dream come true! The onsite professionalism, flexibility and attentiveness was incredible. The day of coordinator is worth every penny (Marissa is AMAZING). The bridal suite is beautiful and was helpful for the night of the wedding because we had my baby niece who needed a few breaks. Lastly, the food blew everyone away! Looking forward to visiting in years to come. Tip: Time your first dance with the sunset :) -
-
![Melissa]()
Melissa Sent on 01/18/2024Lovely and fun at the same time
Our January 5 ceremony couldn’t have been sweeter with the wonderful staff of Jill, Jamie, and Ani!! They made everything relaxed and easy and fun from the preparations to the execution, and even the mid dinner rain shower!
Their experience yields a confidence in themselves and in the bride and groom that is imperative for a wedding! They are an A-Team for sure! -
Somer Sent on 04/23/2022
Loved Islamorada Fish company!
This is an amazing wedding venue! The scenery is beautiful and the service was great. Jill is everything you need during your wedding planning process. Highly recommend! -
-
![Leah]()
Leah Sent on 03/16/2022Jill was great
We had a storm roll in right at our ceremony time and Jill did a great job problem solving for us. We still had our ceremony outside on the beach (delayed of course) and moved the reception inside. Everyone had an amazing time! -
Sarah Sent on 05/29/2021
GREAT experience!!!
I cannot say enough good things about the staff and especially Jill who pulls this whole thing together. She was very responsive, helpful and all around wonderful. The staff, waiters and bartenders were great. I love this venue and would recommend to anyone. I was an out of state bride and they made it easy. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?