Magnolia Bakery Reviews
Reviews
4.7 out of 5 rating
4.7 out of 5 rating
39 Reviews
94% recommend it
Awards
-
![Rylie]()
Rylie Sent on 05/25/2022Best banana pudding around
We ordered 60 banana puddings in mason jars with our custom monogram on the lid for our wedding reception.
The ordering process was so simple, everything was delivered on time and all our guests were absolutely obsessed with them.
We’ve love Magnolia’s banana pudding for years!Magnolia Bakery's reply:
Riley, we're so glad to know you had a great experience ordering from us. Thank you for making us a part of your special day!
Jose & The Magnolia Bakery Team -
![Kathleen]()
Kathleen M. Sent on 04/02/2020Tasted as good as it looked!!
The cake looked beautiful and tasted amazing! Their customer service was outstanding and we felt really special throughout the entire process from tasting to the wedding day. Pricing was pretty competitive too! -
-
![Cori]()
Cori H. Sent on 04/16/2020You Cannot Beat Classic Magnolia Bakery Cupcakes for Your Wedding!
I LOVE cupcakes. So it only made sense to have a cupcake tower instead of a classic cake for our wedding. Our wedding venue actually included a cake or cupcakes in the wedding package- but come the tasting, all of us there were in agreement that the house made ones were pretty awful! Luckily we still had about 2 months until our wedding so after a bit of back and forth trying to find the correct Magnolia bakery (only some of them handle wedding orders) and manager to speak with (Shenequa helped us out and she was amazing), we placed our Magnolia cupcake order. We were able to choose the flavors we wanted, customize the icing colors and decorations to match our theme, and they were even able to include some gluten-free cupcakes for our gluten free guests! Although I did not personally receive the order day-of, our venue did, everything appeared to arrive on time and in good condition. New Yorkers know and love Magnolia Bakery (full disclosure: especially me) so you really can't go wrong! -
-
User2518789 Sent on 01/26/2016Beautiful, delicious, reasonably priced wedding cake! The guests loved it. Victoria was so easy to work with throughout planning. -
User2419790 Sent on 11/10/2015Magnolia Bakery provided the perfect three tier wedding cake for our celebration dinner. Everyone was super helpful, particularly Ben, who arranged our last minute cake stand hire and confirmed all the day-of plans! There were no issues with delivery at all - perfect and professional! The cake itself was absolutely delicious, particularly the red velvet tier! I have to mention that our cake tasting was one of the best experiences during our wedding planning - we met with Kerry, and were given four sample cakes to try, plenty of iced tea and the little "Mr & Mrs" embossed forks just added a lovely touch! Kerry answered all our questions, gave us plenty of inspiration and ideas, and sent us away after the tasting with the remainder of our cakes and a few other sweet treats -- if there was no question we wanted a Magnolia Bakery before the tasting, it was a done deal after! -
User2004174 Sent on 01/10/2015We travelled to New York from Scotland and arranged to have our wedding cake supplied by Magnolia Bakery. It was easy to organise and the correspondence by email was timely and helpful in terms of working out what would be most suitable for us on the day. The cake was beautiful and delicious and we thoroughly enjoyed it! -
![Lindsay]()
Lindsay Sent on 07/31/2014People are still talking about our wedding cake! So... wedding cakes are WAY more expensive than I ever imagined. That being said, if I'm going to pay that kind of money, I want it to not only look good, but taste amazing! That's what you get with Magnolia. We had a New York wedding, so it seemed the obvious choice, and we weren't disappointed! It was beautiful- just what we had asked for, and tasted awesome! As far as using Magnolia as a vendor, I'd HIGHLY recommend them! -
User1468264 Sent on 12/09/2013Fantastic. Went out of their way to make a color they don't normally make. All for a small cake they didn't really make much margin on. -
User1240520 Sent on 07/14/2013From the get-go I knew I wanted to have Magnolia as my wedding cake vendor as it is my Husband and my favorite bakery in New York City. I worked with Katie out of the Columbus Circle location and she was such a sweetie pie. We met for a tasting (even though I knew what everything tasted like already because I practically go there weekly) and she was so receptive to my ideas and helped with inspiration. She kept my budget in mind and really worked with me to make everything beautiful. We paid a little extra to have them decorate everything and put monograms on the cupcakes but it was totally worth it.
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message