Amazing Cakes and Creations Reviews
Reviews
5.0 out of 5 rating
5.0 out of 5 rating
31 Reviews
99% recommend it
Awards
-
![Mandee]()
Mandee Sent on 03/20/2020The best cake in key west
The best cake we have ever had. Please don’t be blinded by the more popular/prominent bakeries in Key West. We tried them all (and not just their wedding cakes) and Paola’s tasting alone blew them out of the water. The white cake with strawberries and mousseline is to die for. Key lime with key lime filling is soooo good but the white cake stole the show for us. Guests were raving about both flavors. We ordered enough so we would have plenty of leftovers and people were stopping by the next morning to take some home and began eating a slice right in our condo. We did a small cutting cake with 2 sheet cakes served to guests, price was reasonable, decor was beautiful, flavor was fantastic. We will be ordering one to celebrate our anniversary when we are back next year. -
-
Krista Sent on 03/19/2019
Beautiful and exactly what I wanted
Beautiful three tiers of coconut rum cake with fondant! -
-
![Cathy]()
Cathy Sent on 08/29/2017Gave them my idea and they created the perfect cake in both taste and appearance!!! -
![Brittney]()
Brittney Sent on 03/09/2017This was honestly one of the best cakes I've ever seen and ever eaten! Amazing cakes truly live up to their name, they gave me exactly what I was looking for (they also worked with my florist to add matching flowers all over my cake). Their prices were way under the competition and the quality was perfection. We went in without a taste test since this was a destination wedding and I still think this was the best cake I've ever had. -
![Amy]()
Amy Sent on 04/20/2016So, I was that bride that asked for a wedding cake 4 days before the wedding. They mentioned in all of their years in business, I was the first bride to order a cake so late in the "wedding game" and we laughed about it. They accommodated us above and beyond. Beautiful cake, friendly and on-time Service. I'm still getting compliments about how delicious and gorgeous our cake was, THANK YOU!!! -
User2174587 Sent on 06/11/2015The lived up to their name!! The cakes were truly amazing!!!!
-
User2089371 Sent on 04/06/2015Amazing cakes was simply one word...AMAZING! We ordered 2 cakes: a 3 tiered wedding cake and a grooms cake. The wedding cake was perfect!!! I showed them a few pictures from Pinterest and it was more amazing than the ideas I sent them. For the grooms cake, we sent them a couple pictures of our french bulldog. I knew their work was great, but I had no idea they would be able to construct a life size replica of our dog in the form of a cake! Amazing!!! They are very affordable, responsive to emails, creative and the cake even tastes delicious! I can't say enough about how great of an experience we had! -
User1528609 Sent on 02/06/2014Just eloped in KW last weekend...WOW Rick made our cake look even better than in the photos! He even came after hours to deliver it; we saw him sneak into the restaurant. He was proactive and always available to help - another bride I met complained 2 bakeries never called back - our cake looked 10x better - was so glad I went with Amazing..the man works 24/7. Cake was incredible, delicious and gorgeous---we shared with the couple next to us who were wowed as well. Thanks Amazing Cakes!
-
User1165007 Sent on 05/16/2013We love Amazing Cakes! They made the tasting easy and fun! I told them what I wanted and they made it exactly! It was perfect! -
User1124227 Sent on 04/02/2013Not only was it a beautiful cake & look better than I can imagine, it actually was delicious! other bakers in town were super expensive and their cakes had funky fake after tastes, BUT not this place! I was amazed at how gorgeous our cake turned out!
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message