Market Street Diner offers an extensive catering menu with selections for everything from an intimate sit down dinner for 20 to your dream buffet for 300 of your closest friends and family. Market Street Diner also offers a private dining room which can seat up to 30 people.
Carl's Cakes was founded by Carl Loeffel in 1985. In February 2009, Carl and his team relocated and became part of Market Street Diner and Bakery. Same great cakes, same talented staff, just a new, bigger location to provide even more cakes. Carl and his staff bring over 30 years of baking experience to the table when helping you plan your special cake, no matter your style of budget. Our exceptional cakes and buttercreams have made Carl's Cakes the most recommended cakes in the Madison area.
Other couples have also viewed:
Recommended by 95% of couples
1 User photo
Shontae · Married on 08/25/2018
Chef Josie did an excellent job with our cake! We went their classic vanilla, raspberry purée, with vanilla buttercream, it was to die for! All of our guests raves about how good it was, we got tons of “this is best wedding cake” compliments, and trust me our people are HONEST. We kept the design simple, but it still had wow factor. I wouldn’t go to anyone else for cake about such a great experience!Sent on 09/10/2018
Louis · Married on 03/10/2018
The new catering manager provided some fresh ideas to some of the things were had discussed with the previous manager. It was a pleasure working with her.Sent on 12/30/2017
Chelly · Married on 09/16/2017
When planning our Madison wedding, we had many recommendations from family and friends. When it came to cake, the only recommendation we received (from multiple people) was Carl’s Cakes. About a year before our wedding, we had breakfast at the Market Street Diner on a morning when Carl was working and didn’t happen to be overly busy. We told him we were interested in having him bake our cake and he provided us with an unscheduled tasting on the spot, during which he also showed us photos of cake designs and explained his process. Needless to say, we went with Carl’s Cakes and they didn’t let us down! Our mothers also ordered a groom’s cake from Carl decorated with the groom’s favorite hobbies for the rehearsal dinner.Sent on 11/11/2017
Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes Price Rates