About I Do Now I Don't

The Website Jewelers Don't Want You To Know About

I Do Now I Don't is an online consumer-to-consumer marketplace for diamonds and jewelry. With a dedication to simplicity, security and safety, the company allows people to buy secondhand, discounted jewelry. Each diamond sold on the website is inspected by a trained GIA gemologist. Co-founded by Josh Opperman and his sister Mara Opperman in 2007, I Do Now I Don’t is a platform designed with both buyers and sellers in mind, allowing buyers to purchase their dream jewelry at lower prices. Josh has over 10 years of experience in research, marketing, sales and distribution, while Mara brings her background in marketing and public relations to the company. Mara also works as a retail adviser, providing guidance to couples as they prepare for their big day.

Services Offered
In addition to offering rings and other jewelry at a discounted price, I Do Now I Don’t offers various other services to help you prepare for your wedding. These services include:

  • Appraisal
  • Cleaning
  • Diamond certification
  • Insurance
  • Ring sizing
  • Shipping
  • Stone upgrades

Categories: Wedding Jeweler

Regions serviced: New York City, Orlando, Los Angeles, Houston + 2 Additional Regions

Follow I Do Now I Don't on

34 Reviews for I Do Now I Don't

out of 5.0
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Custom Engag. Rings (1)
Designer Engag. Rings (1)
Sort by:


I know this is a wedding site and all, but I want to share my review of this company as far as selling my old wedding and engagement rings on this site.
I'd followed the steps for the immediate offer, and heard back within a business day from Kristen. She outlined the process for me, and I followed it. They emailed me a shipping label, I boxed up my rings and completed paperwork, and shipped the package the following day. I kept track of my tracking number, and confirmed with Kristen when the package arrived to them. The very next night, I had an offer. $700 for a 17 year old ring set. I was really happy with that offer and took it. All I had to do then was sign a sales slip for them. They mailed my check the next day, and sent me a tracking number for the check as well. The check arrived on Monday (3 business days after they mailed it), and I'm happy to report that it cleared my bank account with no troubles. I would definitely recommend this company!

Profile Picture Jen, 3/31/27, 1 Review
Category: Jewelry

So happy to find this site and find an amazing ring. I bought a ring from another site (therealreal) and it was not what I expected it to be. So I searched on I do now I don't and found an amazing ring and was able to negotiate a better price. It came with a laminated certificate for free. I highly recommend this site to buy and sell jewelry.

Profile Picture Tanya, 7/1/18, 1 Review
Category: Jewelry

I Do Now I Don't FAQ

Diamond Certif.
Payment Plans
Ring Sizing
Stone Upgrades
Antique Accessories
Antique Engag. Rings
Antique Wed. Bands
Custom Engag. Rings
Custom Wed. Bands
Designer Accessories
Designer Engag. Rings
Designer Wed. Bands
Loose Diamonds
Ring Setting
Costume Accessories
Custom Accessories
Fair Trade
1-2 weeks
3-4 weeks
5-6 weeks
7+ weeks


14 Photos


14 Photos
220x220 sq 1509562572317 screen shot 2016 08 08 at 5.42.38 pm
220x220 sq 1510763053330 img4087
220x220 sq 1510763037370 img4089
220x220 sq 1510763128820 img4043
220x220 sq 1510763016163 img5334
220x220 sq 1510763016141 img5289
220x220 sq 1510763162166 img3996
220x220 sq 1510763110347 img4044
220x220 sq 1510763178648 img3963
220x220 sq 1510763145668 img3998
220x220 sq 1510763193700 img3839
220x220 sq 1510763214007 img3837
220x220 sq 1510763229672 img3813
220x220 sq 1510763247414 img3805


16 E. 52nd Street, Suite 702, New York, NY 10022   See On Map
800-991-3706 (phone)
I Do Now I Don't is a wedding jewelry, engagement rings from New York servicing weddings throughout the local area, including United States, California, and Texas. I Do Now I Don't is a professional Jewelry, Diamonds, Engagement Rings that has been part of the United States wedding industry since 2007 specializing in diamonds, diamond jewelry, diamond rings, wedding bands, engagement rings, watches, necklaces, bracelets, rings.